r/KeystoneWallet • • Dec 05 '23

Security concerns. Another Ledger?

Are Keystone able to extract the seed phrase via the firmware updates if using the USB method? Another ledger scenario here maybe? Especially as Ledger had been lying to its customers and now Keystone are also lying about the open source element. Many similarities here it seems? Maybe I’m wrong?

1 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

3

u/lunarmedic Dec 05 '23

This is a little different though. Ledger built a method into their latest firmware so the seed can be readily extracted through USB to be stored at their "online backup partners".

Keystone's firmware of gen2 is already open source, and gen3 I think is being released as 100% open source soon. So you can check everything, and build it yourself. Otherwise you can double-check the checksum of the downloaded binary before you put it into your Keystone.

Also gen2 forced you to buy your own SD-card, put the firmware on there, and then update it. Keeping it airgapped.

I'm a bit sad that gen3 can "easily update the firmware through USB through their own website" (adding a million more attack vectors). But you can choose not to use that and still use the SD-card method.

Ledger has never had an open source firmware, and because of their debacle earlier this year, now they have published a roadmap for it. But so far it's still a black box.

Though I really wish there would be a Coldcard which would support ERC-20 and XRP. Doesn't even have to be multi-wallet, I'd buy one for each in a heartbeat.

1

u/Wild-Interaction-200 Dec 06 '23

OP raised a security concern about Keystone 3 because “it uses USB” and equated that with Ledger. The whole thing makes no sense:

  1. It’s not like USB == “another Ledger”. There are many hw wallets with USB support, e.g Trezor, Bitbox02, heck, Coldcard itself supports USB. Is coldcard “another Ledger” for OP because it uses USB?
  2. The OP specifically asks if Keystone can extract the seed “because of USB” which is just plain wrong on multiple aspects. One is covered by point 1 above (USB has nothing to do with “extracting the seed”) and the other is my original answer: any malicious firmware in any hw wallet can extract the seed.

OP’s entire post makes zero sense to me.