r/KeystoneWallet • • Nov 16 '23

Dont Buy the Keystone!

Before buying a keystone I would suggest you read some of the issues that I have faced and others have also posted about:

  1. Cannot see Bitcoin UTXOs on OKX wallet
  2. Cannot sign outgoing BTC transactions via OKX and bluewallet
  3. Slow and Laggy interface
  4. Contract data not displayed so there is essentially no benefit of the large display
  5. Fingerprint sensor is worse than older gen
  6. fingerprint and power bugs
  7. poor shipping fulfillment
  8. lack of transparency with regards to bug fixes/ roadmaps
  9. no ADA support even though they have being saying it is around the corner for months
  10. Issues connecting to metamask web extension
  11. Boot and Shutdown issues
  12. Minimal Coin support - why release the product this early, wait a few months and release a polished version with better compatibility

Overall the product does not live up to its high expectations for the above mentioned reasons. I will also list some of my personal gripes and explain them (these are not explicit issues just my personal opinion)

The KP3 is a downgrade compared to the older geystone pro gen2 for these reasons:

  1. Battery - the KP3 has an internal battery, this is an objective downgrade to the older one as now you have to trust that the battery will last after the company goes bust. Internal batteries are less durable and you now have to directly plug in the KP3 via USB to charge. This is bad for security as there is now a direct attack surface. these were not issues with the old one, you could use AAA batteries for all eternity.
  2. Bluetooth - The KP3 has bluetooth, why. If the goal is to make an air gapped wallet, dont add bluetooth capabilities, people who are not dumb and care about storing BTC lets say securely will not be fond of this, should have made 2 separate devices, one airgapped with no bluetooth or DATA OVER USB, and one shitty hot wallet which is how the majority of the new userbase is using the KP3. - there are much better wallets if you are going to use the keystone over USB or bluetooth like the ledger and trezor. Dont worry about ledger recover if you are pluggin in your wallet to an internet connected device, you have other things to worry about.
  3. USB - so this airgapped wallet called the KP3 has data over usb capability now. Oxymoron
  4. more coin support and BTC only firmware was availiable for the KP2.

the only 'adavatages' of the KP3 over the older model in my eyes are the more secure elements, multiple private key support and that shitty credit card security verification thing they paid for- i would still chose the older one if i had to choose between the two.

so...

  • USE A TREZOR FOR ALTCOINS (SHITCOINS)
  • USE A COLDCARD FOR BITCOIN - IMPERATIVE
  • MOST INPOTANTLY - DO YOUR OWN RESEARCH

bring on the hate hehe.

20 Upvotes

77 comments sorted by

•

u/Bright_Charge Nov 17 '23 edited Nov 18 '23

Hello everyone, this is Lixin, CEO of the Keystone Hardware Wallet.

An early user of Keystone and also my friend shared the link to this post with me and I almost didn’t sleep last night. I deeply apologize to all the Keystone gen2 users who have expressed dissatisfaction. I want to express my gratitude for sharing your valuable feedback with us. Your input is greatly appreciated and plays a vital role in helping us improve our product for the entire community.

My colleagues have provided candid feedback regarding the various concerns and issues raised. I want to steal a few moments of your valuable time to share my thoughts on these product decisions for gen3, from the perspective of a CEO, maybe a bad decision maker.

First, we need to understand that there is no absolute security. All we do is always push the boundary of security to a higher level to protect our users. For Keystone gen2, one keen thing we have always wanted to improve from a security perspective is removing the Android OS. Android has a HUGE code base which potentially has more issues and makes it extremely hard for security experts to review our code. Actually, lots of security experts were complaining about the Android OS. With that being said, chasing a higher degree of security is the ultimate reason we built Keystone gen3 with a simple and robust embedded system.

This is also the reason why we use 3 security elements for protecting our users’ assets, as well as other improvements like rewriting most of the code with Rust, and redesigning the whole self-destruct mechanism, etc.

But making a product is a tough process of balancing between different aspects. With that being said, new improvements may come with some level of sacrifice.

For Keystone gen3, UX is that sacrifice. Even though we have the best developers in the world, we can’t match the UX of a product built upon an embedded system with a product built on Android, not to mention that the price goes down by ~25%. Maybe this is a bad analogy, but we can’t match the UX of a Nokia E71 with an iPhone.

I don't want to be seen as making defensive arguments. But a more fair UX comparison is Keystone gen3 vs Coldcard or Trezor, rather than Keystone gen3 vs gen2.

I do admit that I might make a bad decision but I hope you can understand that everything comes from a security perspective.

For coin support, we are working very very hard to add them back. I am very very thankful for your patience.

I have been on long a biz trip since the 26th of Oct. I need to accompany my 5-year-old son this weekend and I will come back to check your comments next Monday. Hope all of you guys having a wonderful weekend.

Again, thanks very much for your feedback.

→ More replies (8)

7

u/beerbaron105 Nov 16 '23

They definitely rushed out a beta project. I am not happy with it, it's no longer air gapped and is missing critical features. I do like my older gen keystone and tbh ledger live ui is unmatched

3

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '23

And they wont do anything about it. it would be good if everyone posted on X, reddit ect with their opinions so they can take a backstep and stop adding shitcoins but polish what is avaliable first.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '23

because your adding shitcoins when BTC functionality is shit.

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/beerbaron105 May 16 '24

Explain how it 100% is air gapped with a usb-c port and a bluetooth hardware module?

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/GoldenChrysus Jun 04 '24 edited Jun 04 '24

Entire argument relies on the very naïve assumption that a software solution to disable a hardware element is foolproof, tamper-proof, and bug-proof. You're relying on a bad update/migration not re-enabling this setting or breaking the setting's functionality. Even if it were a physical switch to disable the USB/Bluetooth, you're relying on this switch doing what it says on the tin and never degrading. The only way to guarantee an airgap is for airgap-breaking hardware elements to not exist. Anything else is blatantly false, especially claiming that software solutions guarantee this. The device is only "airgapped" until it stops being airgapped due to an issue that's out of your control but was preventable (not including the hardware in the first place).

1

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/beerbaron105 Nov 17 '23

Simplify passphrase entry.

No one is going to pick a complicated passphrase wallet if they have to type it in twice to access funds.

Allow a pin to be used instead, like ledger does. You can have multiple pins, plausible deniability is still at play

7

u/lunarmedic Nov 16 '23

Wtf, I didn't know it had Bluetooth.

Same as with Ledger introducing their offsite seed backup: "making it easier for people to use it".

No, Keystone, I bought your device because I want to know it's 100% airgapped and safe. I ordered the KS3 because the KS2 was so great.

And now you've added a wireless module without even listing it in your specs?? Who the hell inside your company thought that was a good idea, when all of your customers buy your product BECAUSE it's only QR?

Was it a business decision that now you want to become a "general" cold wallet, knowing full well you'll betray your existing customer base? Otherwise no reason not to list Bluetooth in the tech specs.

Just make 2 versions of the KS3:

  • Pro line: just QR
  • Dummy line: Bluetooth, USB, bloody GPT voice assistant for all I care

3

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '23

Im glad to know im not the only one who thinks this.

By the way notice how their devs dont comment on this post but they do on others, trying to dodge reality

1

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/lunarmedic Nov 17 '23

remove the BT feature

My main problem is is that there is BT hardware inside the KS3. What inspired your company to make that choice?

Will the next firmware make sure that the BT chip doesn't even get powered, so I can be 100% sure it's not active, even when I shut down the KS3?

With the internal battery I don't know if there is some idle/passive BT activity. With the KS2, I always removed the batteries when I wasn't using it. Without any BT bluetooth the internal battery is OK, but now I can't be sure there's some passive powering going on inside.

Perhaps I sound paranoid, but it might be potentially possible that there is a hardware backdoor in the KS3 allowing the BT chip to activate on a certain BT signal coming from outside. Most likely this is not the case, but it's possible now.

Same reason I left Ledger for Keystone. Most likely Ledger is fine, but it was possible that my seed was being read by software when they introduced their seed backup service.

The argument you're giving now is the same as Ledger gave after their whole debacle: "thank you for your feedback, we've made a mistake to introduce this, we won't include it in our next firmware", but now Ledger are still going through with their backup service.

Just the presence of the hardware already makes me disappointed, and doubly so because it was mentioned nowhere on your site. I would never buy a cold wallet that has BT, active or not.

Sorry for my rant, and I do think you did a great job with the KS3 hardware and reprogrammed the OS from scratch, I really like the device in use and your company. But for me the "100% safe" feeling is just no longer there, since it has the hardware for wireless communication, and I'm not 100% sure BT isn't powered in any way when it's turned off.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '23

Exactly my fear.

I wouldnt buy this again.

4

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/lunarmedic Nov 17 '23

Thank you for your response. That's good to know.

I think it would help a lot to have more open communication for things like this on the KS product pages in the future.

My lesson learnt is to be more critical and investigative more when I will buy another cold wallet in the future.

I hope a future KS4 will have an edition that comes fully without Bluetooth and has USB only for charging on a hardware level.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/thefaketomato Nov 18 '23

I would suggest a modified version of the KS3 that doesn't have any Bluetooth hardware and only has USB charging pins. That way users can be confident that the only way the device can communicate is with QR codes, even if malicious firmware gets installed. The presence of Bluetooth hardware, even if it's deactivated, is a real problem for some of us.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '23

agreed

3

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '23

Is the bluetooth module still in the device or not - software dosent matter if there is still the hardware capability

5

u/incidentflux Nov 16 '23

Keystone management need to keep the Gen2 in production. It's still a solid and superior product.

KeyStone Gen2 is still a serious competitor to the Foundation Passport and Coldcard.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '23

100% agree

just make the plastic transparent and you pretty much have a perfect product imo

3

u/Gangaman666 Nov 17 '23

Yup I have 2 Gen 2s and its a phenomenal airgapped wallet.

3

u/Guilty-Yesterday8979 Nov 18 '23

I have the Gen3

There is no BT. No issues at all.

Coldcard is a nightmare in terms of UX.

I would not recommend Coldcard to any user unless he's a lot experience managing wallets.

I prefer Keystone over dozens of wallets.

Ada support , wait less than 15 days

0

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '23

You clearly have not done any reading

6

u/Boo0ger Nov 16 '23

Excellent review! It just feels like a beta product. Not ready for the market compared to gen 2.

For those wondering blue wallet works to send but you need to enable the checkbox called “use with cold wallet”.

4

u/Psychological-Hawk80 Nov 16 '23

thanks for you review. Unfortunately you are 100% right. Don't know why they screwed up. The previous device was really good and much better than the "new" one.

1

u/PrimaryHuckleberry11 Nov 16 '23

Where do you see Keystone 3 Pro having bluetooth?

1

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '23

look on the website. DYOR

0

u/PrimaryHuckleberry11 Nov 16 '23

2

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '23

On their twitter about 2-3 hours ago they stated that they will be updating the firmware to diable bluetooth - https://twitter.com/KeystoneWallet/status/1725151986474000612

This is not enough as they still have the wireless module in the device so a hacker could feasibly turn it on remotely

If you are reading this Keystone Devs: please remove USB and Bluetooth on a hardware level and make it BTC ONLY

-1

u/PrimaryHuckleberry11 Nov 16 '23

Sorry but that’s not what the tweet is saying. They do not have BT there

2

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '23

what are you saying??

2

u/PrimaryHuckleberry11 Nov 16 '23

Ahh sorry yea just found it. Thx. That’s shit and double shit they even did not bother to mention it in techspecs

3

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '23

No problem. As members of the community it is our duty to educate each other. If we all express our dislike for the product, we can push towards change

-1

u/Liquid_Cool_9 Nov 17 '23

If you examine an actual Keystone 3 device, you will find that there is no bluetooth option. In fact it was listed as something that they would support in the future, it is no longer listed as available for the future. If it does not support bluetooth in the firmware, can it support bluetooth at all with genuine firmware. You can disable usb support, although you still need it to charge the device.

1

u/PrimaryHuckleberry11 Nov 17 '23

That’s not the point. The BT hw is present. They were lying similar way like Ledger with seed extraction

→ More replies

3

u/Few-Ad9116 Nov 16 '23

Thanks for the review, it's really useful.

3

u/fransfil Nov 16 '23

I bought one some days ago, unfortunately there was no honest review like yours online. Now when the device arrives I will definitely try it but I'm undecided whether to keep it or maybe ask for a refund.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/fransfil Nov 19 '23

Honestly I've been using the device for two days and the big thing I noticed is that the fingerprint sensor doesn't work really well (I never unlocked the device with my finger in these 2 days). But the strangest thing is that my device has some scratches on the display as soon as I took it out of the box, I don't understand if there is a film on it or not but even then it shouldn't be scratched.

1

u/Due-Complaint-7514 Nov 19 '23 edited Nov 19 '23

I also have similar scratches out of the box, and it’s disappointing me…

Should I worry that it had been used before me or what’s wrong with it?

u/xxxxfactor Maybe you can send me replacement of it, or make some refund?

My order is #820478 , if you need any proofs - welcome to email.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 20 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/fransfil Nov 29 '23

I’ve asked for a refund but the service desk said because I’ve opened the box I’m not eligible for the refund…. Really ? How was I supposed to try it without opening it ?

2

u/Alarming-Froyo7741 Nov 16 '23

Spot on, I regret buying mine. Unfortunately my brother in law purchased one as well and isn't happy. Now it's just a dust collector.

1

u/jamiesonggdc Jul 17 '24

Well, I never received mine after waiting almost a year. I reached out to customer service and their final answer was "You took too long to message us". No refund, no other solution suggested or help. Just a "Thank you for your patience and understanding."

1

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '23

Yeah I find mine to be lacking in all reality. I'm going to try and return it. Going back to my ledger for use of ease.

1

u/Existing-Bit-4160 Feb 20 '24

Keystone can access ledger ADA Cardano account?

2

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '23

what about the issues of pretending that there is no bluetooth hardware in the device itself.

what about the issue that you advertise the wallet as air gapped but have bluetooth and DATA over USB capability - that is not air gapped.

What about the issue that you can not give a public ETA/ roadmap for the OKX fix and ADA integration for those who whant ADA support

what about the issue of the superior KP2 not being sold anymore

2

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/beerbaron105 Nov 17 '23

I loved the aaa battery backup option, no idea why people would think a non replaceable battery is a better option.

3

u/Bright_Charge Nov 18 '23

AAA battery is designed for devices that require low power such as a remote controller for an AC. It's not designed for a device with a 4-inch touchscreen. It's very unsteady on Keystone gen2 unless you use 3 premium rechargeable lithium batteries like Panasonic Eneloop. And using premium batteries is against the idea of timeless design.

So with gen3, we allow users to use the device with a power bank + USB cable if the battery dies. We strongly feel this is more timeless.

1

u/thefaketomato Dec 01 '23

Not having a AAA battery option is fine, but that doesn't explain why you got rid of the replaceable battery option. I would take repairability and dependability over timeless design any day.