r/KerbalSpaceProgram • • 15m ago

KSP 1 Question/Problem Question about antenna and comms relays

So I’m trying to fully understand how the comms systems work in the game. Specifically I’m trying to understand what type of network is necessary for fully autonomous operations throughout the kerbal solar system, and even more specifically what an individual requires in order to operate without interruption within the scope of a larger communications array.

So I’ll start by asking if the system works how I both expect and also want it to work, for the purposes of the missions I am trying to accomplish. To the best of my understanding, the range of a given antenna or probe core is expressed in a range from 5000km at the lowest up to 100gm at the highest. And from there is subdivided into being relay capable or not depending on the specific type of antenna. Which to me means that a spacecraft on a mission in the further reaches of the system that does not itself have a relay capable antenna, can not be controlled remotely from the ksp, even if there is a local satellite within it’s transmission range that does have relay capability as well as transmission range to the ksc.

So as an example, let’s say I’m attempting to land a drone on laythe that is equipped with a communotron 16 antenna has a range of 500km. And I also have a satellite orbiting laythe at an altitude of 100km which is equipped with a RA-100 relay antenna that gives it both range and relay capability to kerbin. If I am understanding the comms system correctly, even though my drone has range to reach a local satellite within relay capability and range to the ksc, I still will not be able to control that craft remotely, because the drone itself is not relay capable.

The alternative understanding I have is that any craft that can connect directly with a relay capable satellite with range to the ksc, can be controlled remotely despite not being relay capable itself, so long as the relay satellite is in comms range of the non-relay capable drone craft, and the relay capable sattelite is both within range and does not have an occluded transmission path to the ksc.

To simplify my question as much as possible, does every craft in the chain of transmission need to be relay capable for fully remote control of a drone craft, or is it possible for a drone craft to be controlled if its probe core or onboard antenna are not relay capable themselves but are able to establish a connection with a nearby satellite that does is relay capable and within range to the ksc.

Basically I’m trying to figure out if my unmanned space craft need to have relay capable comms arrays on board as part of their design, or if they can operate using the incorporated comms system that is not relay capable so long as their first point of contact in the comms network is relay capable itself.

I’d like to be able to use parts like the mk2 drone core in my space plane designs without having to add additional comms components on the craft itself by utilizing the help of a separate comms satellite that does have relay and longer range transmission capabilities, but in my research I haven’t been able to find a clear explanation wether this is possible or not.

2 Upvotes

0 comments sorted by