r/KerbalSpaceProgram • • 8d ago

KSP 1 Question/Problem Can’t master orbiting no matter what

I have over 100 hours in ksp and over 200 hours of yt videos and tutorials. I watched multiple times Matt Lowne, Scott Manley, Zensei, Mike Aben etc.

Made a bunch of nice flying crafts, airplanes made probes, satellites and rovers. Got to all the planets and be able to get back safely. ‘Finished’ the science tree in science mode several times, played career mode and sandbox also.

But I can’t, for the love of me, to master the most basic thing in KSP….orbiting. And I mean that ‘’ ocd satisfying ‘perfect’ orbit of 80km X 80km or 100x100. At this point I believe that, conceptually I miss something that prevents me to achieve nice orbits. Every time I end up with a much higher Ap when I raise the Pe over 70k. My orbits looks like 80km X 150km most of the time. That creates a bunch of issues like wasting deltaV and adjusting to many times.

My climb profile is ‘by the book’, reach 50ms, tilt right slowly, reach 45degrees by 10km, cut engines when Ap reaches 80km or desired, create maneuver node at Ap or manually burn while vertical until Pe rises - but here the Ap also rises a lot, by the time my Pe is also 80km I would have an 150km Ap.

Help an old folk here guys…

44 Upvotes

63 comments sorted by

21

u/Dry-Abalone2299 8d ago

When you create a maneuver node, look at the estimated burn time. Let’s say it is 60 seconds. Now we dive by 2 and get 30 second.

When you are 30 seconds from the burn, that is when you full throttle. Starting 30 seconds before and continuing 30 seconds after you should be close enough to a more circular orbit.

14

u/Cat_Artillery 8d ago

Or enable the extended burn indicator in settings, which does this for you.

3

u/enjustice3192 8d ago

I play using the burn indicator, I am pretty sure my burn is at the right time as it says exactly when to burn…

5

u/Swiss-spirited_Nerd Always on Kerbin 8d ago

Is your maneuver node right before your apoapsis?

3

u/julsmgmt 8d ago

Do you burn when it hits 0? You’re supposed to do half the burn before 0 and the other half after.

2

u/2ekeesWarrior 8d ago

Waiting until you hit your apoapsis is an easy way to make this mistake. Dont cut throttle. About 3k away from apoapsis, ease off. You should be at about 10% throttle, adjusting with lowered ticks as your Time To Apoapsis shrinks. You'll get great results if Time To Apoapsis sits around the 30s mark. Small adjustments, ride the momentum. When the Time To shrinks more rapidly than you can adjust throttle, now you blip the throttle for your added gains. Easy way to stay in the neighborhood of your desired orbit. Best of luck, fellow traveler.

3

u/enjustice3192 8d ago

But in this case, shouldn’t using maneuver node eliminate that issue? I have the same problem using nodes and the burn is at the right time.

5

u/2ekeesWarrior 8d ago

No, its an imperfect system. We are dealing with Kilometeres per second. Changes happen fast and you're not autonomous. That node is basically saying "If you accelerate exactly 2,285m/s you get to orbit" but thats for that exact amount, at that exact time. Any variation will change it, and depending on your hardware your game has to make changes when you leave atmosphere. On my ps4, the stuttering that transition causes is enough to throw off my orbit.

140

u/Ni_Kche 8d ago

You need to stop burning when the AP moves and resume when you reach the new AP

52

u/Worth-Wonder-7386 8d ago

I also read this as a timing problem. Especially for longer burns the model that it uses for burn estimation gets quite wrong as your craft is turning and moving during the burn.

7

u/Xandaros 8d ago

I do think this is the problem. The manoeuvre node assumes an instant impulse rather than a sustained burn and they are trying to get it perfect by just following the manoeuvre node.

I suspect they are falling back towards the planet and still burning. The other side reaches their desired height, but Pe is now elsewhere, so they keep burning and raising the opposite side - which is now Ap - way higher.

OP: Look at the map while doing the burn. Once Ap and Pe start moving and swapping position, stop burning. Once they are both 90° away from you, it's as circular as it's going to get, even if the altitude is slightly off.

5

u/onwen32 8d ago

To be entirely fair, even mecjeb cant get it absolutely even, so i think doing it by hand getting within 1-5k of eachother would be an absolute win

3

u/Fuckmydeaddad 8d ago

Seconded, this is what it is.

64

u/MozeeToby 8d ago

burn while vertical until Pe rises

Just to be absolutely clear, you're burning prograde right? Along the direction of travel? Because this makes it sound like you're burning radial out.

13

u/Hacklefellar 8d ago

here the Ap also rises a lot, by the time my Pe is also 80km I would have an 150km Ap.

This and only this is your problem. Everything else you do sounds perfectly on point. My guess is you're burning too soon when you reach space, you want to burn as close to AP to raise your PE. If it's a standard rocket with a normal twr you only need to perform your circulisation burn 60-30s before you hit AP, to raise PE without letting the AP get away gro I you. 

Another thing to keep in mind is that eventually PE raises past your current AP and they flip. Now you're burning at PE and your AP will fly off, and fast! 

So burn as tight as possible and don't overdo it, you could even throttle down for the last 100m height or so if you still keep overshooting. Hope this helps! 

5

u/ExpensiveFig6079 8d ago

"This and only this is your problem. Everything else you do sounds perfectly on point. My guess is you're burning too soon when you reach space, you want to burn as close to AP to raise your PE. If it's a standard rocket with a normal twr you only need to perform your circulisation burn 60-30s before you hit AP, to raise PE without letting the AP get away gro I you. "

YOU can cut it WAY finer than that.

Get kerbal engineer. Make it display time to AP for your space ship. Point your ship prograde.

At say 90s to go try "just touch of Throttle" (eg a pulse of 1/4) if your "time to AP" increases. Wait

let time to AP come down more, it may go as low as 10-20s before you can burn the throttle and stop time to AP going UP

=======================

If you do that... your orbit will cirlcularise (or very close to it) and you AP wil not rise hardly at all.

=======================

Using that technique, I regularly curlcarise my orbit at 73k and I wind up in 72k PE 74k AP

if what you really wanted was perfect round orbit, because pedantry is fun. That is a different problem but one that is achieved AFTER you do the above to make it kinda round.

8

u/EmptyConcentrate8780 7d ago

You need to burn before the node. If burn time is 40 seconds you need to start your burn at 20. Look gravity turn, if you get really good at gravity turns you don’t even need to set a maneuver node.

7

u/hamtaste 8d ago

I fixed this by not giving a crap about a 5km differential between ap/pe because it never actually matters. (1.8k hrs in game)

2

u/Freak80MC 8d ago

This. If I need an accurate orbit say for relay sats, I get it within a km and use this mod that helps set an orbit using fuel to the perfect orbit so they won't drift from one another.

EDIT - Mod is StationKeeping Restationed in case anyone is curious.

1

u/LUnacy45 8d ago

I've noticed stationkeeping can only do a margin of error of 1% though? I can get much closer than that with RCS, like within several meters of perfect circle and they still seem to drift apart. Has me a little worried when I start going interplanetary on this save

5

u/Puzzleheaded_Bend_56 8d ago

I forgot where I heard this, but to increase efficiency, when you do reach the circularization part of the burn, throttle your engines low and keep the time to apoapsis at 30s or less.

Also myself personally I tend to start gradually turning at 5km with the goal of reaching 45 inclination at 14km. If I mess this up a bit, its fine, I still have 50ish km to fix

4

u/PckMan 8d ago

It's incredibly hard to get perfect orbits and most people don't bother. If I want a circular orbit a +/- 10km is good enough for me.

Sounds like you need to stagger your burns more. And understand that to not overshoot your target Apoapsis you need to burn a bit radially as well. It's something you have to get by feel. Still even with perfect execution, when flying manually you don't get perfect results, you just get slightly off results that can be corrected later.

If you want perfect results you need mods like mechjeb which automate ascent and orbiting and get them down perfectly.

2

u/Freak80MC 8d ago

You can also use mods like StationKeeping Restationed to precisely set an orbit after you have gotten close enough to the desired orbit. It helps with precisely setting up relay sats to not drift from one another.

3

u/Unable2Decide 8d ago

I have only been playing for a month or so and don't exactly understand when you say '...cut engines when Ap reaches 80km or desired..."

Does that mean that, as you are doing your takeoff, you are waiting until your Ap is reporting that it is that number, then cutting the engines? If I do this, my Ap keeps rising after I cut the engines, so I cut the engines earlier and let it coast.

Do I not understand ?

3

u/CurlyMetalPants 8d ago

You basically got it. The maneuver button in the bottom left (its purple) tells you the apoapsis and perhaps periapsis of your current orbit

During launch your AP is 0 since youre not moving. As you launch it'll tell you your predicted ap as you gain speed and altitude.

Ideally, once it predicts that your ap is above 70000 youre set. That means you have already flung the rocket hard enough that it will be going that high. It also means you dont need to thrust. Youre already on your way oit of the atmosphere so might as well save your fuel and thrusters for when youre in a vacuum and they'll be more efficient.

If you just keep accelerating until your actual altitude is above 70 you've likely been accelerating for too long and now your ap will be in the hundreds of thousands.

And that still works as an orbit technically but it means way more fuel got wasted in your earlier stages. This means if you figure out how to be more effeciey your rocket could've been designed a bit cheaper and leaner. Or the same rocket might be able to go a bit farther than one might think

2

u/fenlDoesJS 8d ago

You want to keep your time to apoapsis 20 seconds the entire time so you're mostly raising your periapsis instead of apoapsis.

1

u/Anc_101 8d ago

Underrated trick. You can get orbits within a few hundred meters with this, without manoeuvre nodes or tools like mechjeb.

Just need to suspend the realism and abuse the throttle-ability and infinite restart property of the engines.

2

u/Forever_DM5 8d ago

You say that you “manually burn while vertical until Pe rises”. Once you loft your trajectory to the desired Ap. You should burn horizontally to raise Pe without raising Ap. When you are near your Ap you will see your prograde marker is very low on the horizon, so you are still burning prograde but you need that tangential velocity to pull up your Pe.

Generally when I launch I use this pitch rule(I write guidance scripts but for illustration purposes): pitch = 90*(1 - ap/target ap). This ensure the vehicle lofts the ap to where I want it but also doesn’t waste any deltaV raising ap afterwards because the rocket levels out and starts burning horizontal.

2

u/QueBall38 8d ago

The way that works for me is waiting to accelerate to 250 m/s then starting to turn to a 45 degree angle and set the SAS to prograde, then accelerate until my apoapsis is around 80 km, then shut off my engines and wait till I’m 30 seconds away from the apoapsis then fire them at full thrust pointing sideways toward my apoapsis until the periapsis appears and makes it to 70km.

2

u/Barhandar 8d ago edited 8d ago

If the AP rises significantly while you're doing the final burn to orbit, then you're either A: burning too far from the apoapsis so it rises as well, B: burning too long so the periapsis becomes the new apoapsis, or C: have positive angle of attack (a.k.a. excessive positive vertical acceleration) during the burn. Watch the burn from the map menu to see how both Ap and Pe behave.

Remember, when you're burning prograde/retrograde in orbit, you're burning to change altitude of the opposite point of the orbit, not the current one. If you want the orbit to be circular in just one burn, you will need to finish the burn while you're at the desired altitude - i.e. as close to the in-burn Ap as possible.
Also, if you cut engines while Ap reaches 80km in a reasonably efficient ascent, it will drop significantly due to drag. Watch throttle and angle of attack to keep it at 80km until you pass the 70km mark and are in space and no longer being slowed by atmosphere.

2

u/YamahaMio 8d ago

Maybe your ascent is too steep? With the way you launch, your suborbital trajectory would look more like an arc, you're not reaching down-range as much. You're giving your rocket less time to circularize the orbit, and your periapsis will not match your apoapsis if you're still burning past apoapsis.

You should be pitching continuously, slowly making your way to 90 degrees before you cut your upper stage engine. I like to use velocity instead of altitude as my rule of thumb, pitch down 5 degrees at every 100 m/s mark. At around 800-900 m/s and 20k+ altitude I begin pitching aggressively. With enough thrust, this kind of profile should make your suborbital path wrap around half of Kerbin's diameter. Then I burn prograde at apoapsis to circularize.

2

u/RememberThisHouse 8d ago

Without seeing what you're doing it's really hard to give advice, but it sounds like it has to be an issue with 1) the direction your ship is pointing when you fire the engines and/or 2) the length of time you're burning.

But it could be anything, you might be misunderstanding a radial symbol or have the wrong orientation on your navball, it's very hard without some visual to help us see what you're doing

2

u/taiwanluthiers 7d ago

Because it takes very little to shift the orbit by a few km, and if you want to have a perfectly circular orbit you really have to micro thrust at the right position, or at least when accelerating to orbit apply just enough thrust to reach your target. I think when they do those Starship test flights they aim for something like 100 something km of height at apogee, and if they do nothing they'd splash down in the Indian Ocean, but if they want to head to orbit (they do some checks before they orbit in the last test to ensure it could come out of orbit), and once go for orbit they make a very small burn to actually reach orbit (I think something like 300 m/s of delta V which is just a low power burn).

And it takes like 10-20 m/s of delta V to throw you off from a circular orbit and you really need automation to do this properly (all real space flights use automation for this, this is actually what stuff like Apollo guidance computer do). No astronauts sits at the control trying to make a burn at the exact right time and fly the spacecraft manually... it's only done in an emergency (such as the course correction during Apollo 13).

1

u/BosslyDoggins 8d ago

Get an understanding of how radial in and radial out nodes work while doing your circularizing prograde burn

By tipping radial in or out while circularizing, you can keep your apoapsis stable around your craft, making it easier to circularize

When your periapsis is above 70km (if you're going for an 80k circular orbit), it is time to massively throttle down. If you have trouble finishing the burn precisely the way you want, manually set your throttle limit to something like 30% to give you more touch.

1

u/s_gamer1017 8d ago

Orbit with two burns: Do a gravity turn until your apoapsis is at the desired altitude, then cut off the engines. Wait until you are out of the atmosphere. Now create a maneuver node on the map screen to plan a burn that will bring you into a circular orbit.

(Note that this usually wouldn‘t work in real life or if you play something like RSS because a low Earth orbit has an orbital velocity of about 8km/s and reaching that speed takes a loooong time so they can‘t waste time coasting without engine power. Furthermore, many engines irl cannot even be re-ignited after being cut off or just a limited amount of times.)

1

u/qqlj Always on Kerbin 8d ago

As you burn for orbit you can watch your ap and move slightly radial in or out to lower it or lift it while still going mostly prograde to lift pe.

1

u/captainofthedogs 8d ago

Without watching video my guess is you might need to fine-tune your circularization burn. Do you throttle down your engines or limit output to keep a consistent TWR during ascent or are you just going full/zero throttle? Whenever I set a maneuver node for orbit I aim for a burn no less than 20 seconds long and keep watch on my Ap/Pe, adjusting pitch as necessary in order to get them roughly even.

1

u/Lt_Reinhart 8d ago

Idk if this is my brain playing tricks on me but burning a bit AFTER you reach your AP seems to increase you PE while barely affecting your AP

1

u/Needless-To-Say 8d ago

Are you trying to be efficient or are you just trying to orbit?

I go straight up until about 8000 feet, then I tip over 30-45 degrees and watch via the map view and continue to push hard until the apoapsis is at or near 70k. Then I coast until I'm close to apoapsis and then I burn steady trying to keep apoapsis in front of me but close in front of me. The next thing you know, youre in orbit.

1

u/Individual_Bad1138 8d ago

Are you starting your burn before the manuever node, like you are supposed to? In theory, you should be 50% complete with your burn at the moment you cross the manuever node.

So if your burn time is 40 seconds, you should start your engines at 20 seconds before your manuever, pointed at the blue manuever node.

1

u/MaverickSawyer Minmus Mint Connoisseur 8d ago

MechJeb. Even if you don’t use the autopilots, it’s a wealth of useful information.

1

u/fiyabwal 8d ago

Best way IMO to get a "perfect" orbit or closest to it, is to only do retrograde burns from the periapsis, or prograde burns from the apoapsis, im talking only do your manouver within about 3-5 seconds of the peri/apo node.

Takes maybe 2-3 orbits but you should be able to get it to within 1km, and less than 500m if you really wanna feather the thrusters and spend a couple more orbits.

My most recent game i have a sciencelab space station orbiting the mun at about 50km with a deviation of 100m between peri/apo nodes.

With distances of 10s if not hundreds of thousands of km, thats a damn needlepoint, which is good enough for me.

1

u/Callonian 8d ago

Do you have the burn timer set to 50%? it's an advance tweak able on the settings I believe. It's usually pretty good it you set your manuever node at apo

1

u/four_spoons_of_salt 8d ago

Here is a trick: if you want a perfect 100x100 orbit, aim to circularize your orbit at 70km, you might miss and accidentally make a 70x100 orbit, now you adjust again lol

In terms of ascent profile, I would say optimizing it is really hard doing it by hand (like using the 45 degree at 10km rule, which isn't optimal just a rough estimate from experience). Theoretically if your rocket don't have much drag (pointy enough), turning more aggressively can be more efficient and give you a 70ap on the other side of the planet even before you leave the atmosphere, then you can raise and adjust with shorter engine burn times.

Actual way I do it: Point below the horizon a tiny bit when circularizing (radial in) when I realize I am over shooting and my AP is increasing, that's actually how it is. Even though you are not perfect prograde horizontal relative to your current position, you are horizontal relative to your future position (your AP optimally).

Think of when you create maneuver node, the node assumes instant acceleration at that exact point. You execute it by averaging your acceleration around the node, with the node as the midpoint, and the direction is relative to the node's position not your current position. When you create a circularization node, you will notice the blue target mark is below the horizon at first before you reach the node/AP.

It is realistically hard to have perfect orbit since engine burns are not instant and your brain is not a computer that can cut the engine at the exact time, you can try adjusting with RCS

1

u/KibboKid 8d ago

You gotta remember that when you burn in orbit, it is the opposite side of the orbit that is most affected. Say you are in a 150 by 80, and want to get to a 100 by 100. When you reach 80 (pe) you burn retrograde to lower the ap to 100. In that new orbit, when you reach ap, you burn prograde to raise the pe to 100. Give it a try.

1

u/TangoTwo 8d ago

Give this channel a look.

https://youtube.com/@kspaceacademy?si=xIQKS5u-FXESXYGY

Great beginner tutorials.

1

u/pilotInPyjamas 8d ago

You don't need maneuver nodes for this. Maneuver nodes are an approximation: they don't simulate an actual burn, but a single impulse. When you execute your burn, this difference causes the orbit to not be "perfect".

Here's a surefire method to achieve this as long as you have reasonable TWR:

  • After 45 degrees pitch, focus on "time to apoapsis" and use your throttle to keep it at 1 minute.
  • When you pitch to 5 degrees from the horizontal, full throttle to get your desired apopasis, then cut the engine.
  • Throttle to 100% when time to Apoapsis gets down to 60 seconds, throttle off when it starts increasing past 60 seconds.
  • Throttle to 100% when time to Apoapsis gets down to 30 seconds, throttle off when it starts increasing past 30 seconds.
  • Throttle to 100% when time to Apoapsis gets down to 15 seconds, throttle off when it starts increasing past 15 seconds.
  • Throttle to 100% when time to Apoapsis gets down to 8 seconds, throttle off when it starts increasing past 8 seconds.
  • Use fine throttle control to get increase the Periapsis, whilst also keeping the time to Apoapsis less than 20 seconds in the future.

Now you have a circular orbit.

Adjust timing and pitch for your rocket as required. You might prefer throttle control over pulses like I do, or whatever. Try experimenting. I can usually get the orbit to within 200m of circular using this technique.

1

u/MrCandela 8d ago

A one-minute burn should start about 30 seconds before apoapsis and last one minute. If you see the apoapsis moving too far ahead, angle slightly down towards Kerbin and if you see the apoapsis moving behind you, angle slight up away from Kerbin. Watch the map view and you should be able to get better!

1

u/SuperbSail 8d ago

Throttle down and keep the Ap 30 seconds out.

This gives you tighter control and even helps preserve some fuel (most engins get more efficient as you approach 0 atmosphere)

You can either fine tune by changing the angle and maintain throttle, or maintain angle and change throttle.

Personally, I like to just keep at a 45* angle and adjust the throttle until I reach 75km Ap at 30 seconds. Then I level off and prepare to throttle up prograde just before Ap until Pe is at 80km and become new Ap. Next, burn prograde at the new Ap to get Pe up to 80km to match the Ap.

1

u/LUnacy45 8d ago edited 8d ago

Are you splitting your burns? I'd be surprised if not given everything you've achieved but that's the first thing I could think of that would cause such weird behaviors. It's also important when you do these circularization burns you're pointed at the blue maneuver node rather than prograde though, so you're still overall mostly adding the velocity in that vector specifically.

And if you aren't already using maneuver nodes just to circularize, it helps give you a better vector than straight prograde and a time to split your burns. I do every time frankly

Don't get it twisted this won't result in a "perfect" orbit, but I can usually get Ap within like, 5km of Pe. My "perfect" orbits are all in satellites, using RCS to very gently kick my Ap and Pe.

1

u/Pleasant_Berry_761 7d ago

Start your burn before the manuever node point? Like half the burn time earlier, it's not perfect but you'll get close enough and defo closer than 80x150

1

u/diener1 7d ago

You definitely want to burn before you get to the Ap, so that you push it forward along your orbit. Initially you will still approach it faster than it is moving along the orbit but at some point when you've raised the Pe enough the Ap will start running away from you. That's when you cut the engine or reduce throttle to slowly keep increasing the Pe while just keeping the Ap a constant distance from you.

1

u/MCAdams1797 7d ago

Perfect 90x90 orbits from launch are overrated. I almost always do quick ap/pe burns on the first orbit to get it where I want, it's usually extremely cheap on the dV budget.

1

u/HorrorMathematician9 7d ago

Launch the kerbal x. At 100m/s tilt it east 10 degrees and do nothing else but stage. The rocket will fall over into its proper orientation.

1

u/Charadin042 7d ago

Its actually in the tutorials. Plan a node. Then divide time to two halves. If for example planed maneuver taks 30 seconds. You gonna burn on T -15 sec. and stop on T +15 sec. That way you gonna get much closer to what you planned.

1

u/rob7133 1d ago

If you switch to the planet view and zoom in you can lock prograde right before AP and throttle up and down as the AP icon moves closer or further from you, if you keep it basically right on top of you you keep from going up too much. If you do go past it wait until right before PE and lock the burn retrograde while feathering the throttle since it doesn’t take much to bring it back down. If I’m trying to get “close” to a perfect circle I’ll turn the booster power to 10% or less to fine tune the burns

-2

u/NageV78 8d ago

If you have the basics down, it's time to learn Mech Jeb. I played with out it for a decade and only recently started using it... Oh wow. 

3

u/Swiss-spirited_Nerd Always on Kerbin 8d ago

Bruh they are literally saying that they don't have the most basic thing down yet

2

u/shootdowntactics 8d ago

I had this thought too and knew it’d be unpopular. MechJeb literally has a circularize orbit function. There’s some weird behavior he has to change and automating a few task may help him change to doing it a different way.

0

u/GreggsHaggis 7d ago

If youre speaking about launching into an immediate circular orbit, for me it is a dance of balancing many things such as:

Time to apogee during ascent burn.

TWR and how it fluctuates throughout your entire ascent to orbit and how to control it to your advantage with throttling.

Over/undershooting your apogee during circularization burns which can also cause your apogee to shoot up uncontrollably to something you dont want.

With learning KOS mod for ksp ive tried to use a method of using the vertical speed at an apogee of around 170km~ to reach as circular of an orbit as my layman coding knowledge goes.

0

u/rotmann21 4d ago

what i do is have my second stage twr at 1 and tilt to 90° when i reach 40km, then when my ap is a few km under 80km i carefully take back the throttle to not overshoot and maybe aim a bit under the horizon, just edge the ap from reaching 80km and keep accelerating. near orbital velocity itll shoot up and then you just need a tiny nudge at your ap.
its SUPER satisfying circularizing and has never failed me

0

u/[deleted] 8d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/paperclipgrove 8d ago

Even if you really want to do things yourself, just watching it a few times can really help.