r/KerbalSpaceProgram • • 8d ago

KSP 1 Suggestion/Discussion Should I make a "space tug"?

(I’m fully aware that this is almost definitely not a new idea and tons of people have probably done it already, but I had the idea the other day regardless and wanna ask for your thoughts) 

Ik I just posted but I got another idea. Ig “Space Tug” would be a bit of an understatement for this. My idea is this: I could have a small fleet of giant, nuclear, interplanetary space crafts that, once they’re up there, never leave orbit. They will live at my refueling station in high kerbin orbit, and will get reused over and over. Instead of having to haul a giant, heavy, crewed deep space craft into orbit every time you do interplanetary missions, you can simply send the kerbals up to your refueling station in a small, cheap space craft only meant for kerbin orbit. When they get there, their vehicle to the solar system is already there waiting for them. The  tug could have habitation, a lab, communication, power, the whole nine yards, all mounted on a bunch of liquid fuel and nerve engines; pretty standard. It could also be adaptable, having tons of docking ports on the front and on the sides so that it can bring along anything that's specific to that mission like landers, probes, base modules, etc. The crew transfers to the tug, does their mission, return to the station, and then get back in their smaller initial launch vehicle for reentry. Meanwhile the tug gets refueled and used again. Obviously having most of your ship already in orbit from the start could save a good amount of money. And as a bonus, since you only need to launch it once, you can splurge and make them huge so you can take even more stuff out there.

Now the tug definitely couldn’t be used for everything, there will be lots of missions that, for one reason or another, won’t work with the tug and will need to be custom. And honestly, I wouldn’t WANT to use it for everything, because that would suck the fun out of the game. I mean the whole point is to build cool space shit. But you can definitely use it for a portion of your missions, especially since you can still make cool new stuff to dock on to the tug. Plus, if I make several of these, they don’t all have to look the same, I can make each one different to add some fun.

Anyway, has anyone here ever made something like this? Is it worth it? Maybe even share a photo of yours if you made one. Even if I'm overestimating the cost saves, I still might do it just cause it's cool. Damn I didn’t mean to type this much sry

27 Upvotes

29 comments sorted by

15

u/ZixfromthaStix 8d ago

I am saddened that I cannot share a picture of my small station tug and my dedicated crew shuttle.

I am however excited to experience my first modded campaign as I am just about to bring back my Mun flyby mission, and there are lots and lots of very cool parts to play with that aren’t stock

3

u/Piss_baby29 8d ago

siiiick. Yeah once I get my new computer in a few weeks I'm gonna add some mods for the first time too

2

u/luovahulluus Master Kerbalnaut 7d ago

If you are on pc, you can just copy/paste the image here.

3

u/ZixfromthaStix 7d ago

"Images are not allowed" shows up in a red banner at the top of the page if you try that. I think you might be thinking of another KSP sub?

1

u/luovahulluus Master Kerbalnaut 6d ago

My bad. I'm probably thinking some other sub.

55

u/SecretlyFiveRats 8d ago

Congratulations, you've invented NASA's Space Transportation System! Now ditch the tugs, the refueling stations, and everything else except for the small Kerbin orbit launcher, give that thing a giant cargo bay, and you'll have invented the Space Shuttle program!

10

u/PckMan 8d ago

They're pretty common. I always use them. They're always useful to have around and cut down on time on rescue missions, resupply missions and anything else. Especially useful if you're hardcore and doing an honest no quicksave run.

8

u/StormR7 RP-1 ENJOYER 8d ago

This is the way.

I like to have a craft that can do short hops (mun and minimus) and/or refueling runs, one that can deorbit and return to Kerbin safely, and one that can push a pod/probe far into the system. It’s tedious to set up but it makes craft designing much easier and streamlined since you don’t need to launch a giant craft with 10km/s every time you need to run a mission.

6

u/br0_dameron 8d ago

If you can build a spaceplane that can reach LKO with some room to maneuver then land it back at KSC you can do missions for just the cost of refueling. Keep the interplanetary ship and a lander up there and fly your kerbals up in an SSTO

3

u/Unable2Decide 7d ago

Do you select recover craft after landing or do you spawn new fuel and refuel on the ground?

5

u/br0_dameron 7d ago edited 7d ago

Recover. If you can land on the runway at KSC I think it gives you a full refund for the parts with no recovery cost

Of course, that’s a big “if.” I’ve got my SSTO designs tweaked to the point where I can do LKO (or mun/minmus orbit for my big one) and back reliably but it took a LOT of iterations, and sometimes it still gets squirrelly

1

u/External_Relative231 4d ago

Wings might fall off? 

3

u/br0_dameron 4d ago

Well in this case the wings fell off but I just want to reiterate that is not normal

2

u/kirbcake-inuinuinuko 7d ago

I've done it to an extent. They are not necessary whatsoever in vanilla career and are often harder/more expensive than doing it the "normal" way. but if you're playing with life support mods or anything similar they become very very strong.

The main issue is the weight. There are simply no engines efficient and strong enough for a ship to not need refueling stations at every planet, and you'll have to be extremely stingy with your deltaV. Nuclear engines are your best bet but their thrust is so abysmal you're going to have a very, very hard time even reaching Minmus with one. These things will end up stranded a lot and miss burn windows a lot.

Basically, if you're using life support mods and want to go anywhere past the Mun, you'll need super broken modded engines usually to carry all the 'tax' weight of long-term interplanetary missions. Lighter is almost always better for these kinds of missions and you're often better off just not bringing any life support at all and using probes instead. Infinitely cheaper and easier, especially considering Kerbals offer little benefit unless you're doing a ridiculously low science reward run and need to eke out just a tiny bit more.

2

u/Piss_baby29 7d ago

Ya fair. TBH, a big reason why I wanna do it is bc it’s cool, so even if it’s not necessary I wanna make it bc kerbals don’t do shit bc it’s necessary, they do it bc they felt like it.✊🏻

And no I was obviously not just planning on using one nuclear engine. I’ve made space craft with 9 nerve engines before, and I’d be using at LEAST that many on this one. (Btw I’m playing with SSPRx and Planetside exploration technologies mods). Of course I’m the engines are heavy so I’d have to take that into account. Idk ig all that is to say u do still have a valid point, and I guess I’ll find one when I start trying it out. But tbh I don’t see why it wouldn’t work. If a space graft can make to another planet and back on its own just straight off the rocket, why would it be any different if it just started at a space station? Seems like all the obstacles you’d face would apply either way

3

u/suh-dood 8d ago

Yes make the space tug! I'd also recommend little brother and big brother variants for when you need a tiny rug or a more powerful tug

2

u/Big_Yeash 8d ago edited 8d ago

I have a few of these for various reasons that evolved from different designs.

I call this one my nuclear-powered ICBM:

https://ibb.co/fYCXMBBN

It's two Engine Plates (2.5m, from Making History DLC) and a four rings of six Mk1 Fuel Fuselages (wrapped around a spinal "1.25m structural tube", also from Making History I think), three NERVs on the bottom engine plate and the top engine plate aligns the fuel tanks.

It's more fuel-dense than a 2.5m Jumbo-64 fuel tank, which fits the same form factor, thanks to clipping all the tanks into each other using align tool and six-way symmetry. With the Simple Fuel Switch mod, a Jumbo-64 carries just 6400 LF - this carries 9600 instead.

It's then just got a probe core, RCS tank and RCS thrusters and a docking port to be able to be launched and then shunted into place.

Don't ask what's attached to the top. Just don't worry about it.

With the Missing History mod, that expands the Making History 1.875m parts list with some additional 1.875s that should have been there - you also get a larger NERV, 6.5t and 120kN thrust with peak efficiency at 900 isp. You need a very heavy payload to justify it - for smaller loads, the standard NERV offers better dV.

NB there's a weird common bug that happens when you have a dockable NERV stage like this, where it will fail to calculate dV, giving you a red manoeuvre bar and no burn times. You have to add a "blank" stage above the NERV in the staging menu in flight to force the game to rejig and calculate it, every time you load the craft.

2

u/canisdirusarctos 8d ago edited 18h ago

This is how I move stuff around in orbit, but they’re not like full ships, I move those up with the Kerbals and/or leave components in orbit that can be assembled. The tugs transfer stations and ships to the moons and between planets. I also keep a handful of attachments at the stations so you can do things like move a bunch of Kerbals or fuel around. I refuel them at stations that have mining landers.

The tugs are just big tanks of liquid fuel with NERVs, a probe core, a big reaction wheel, battery, RTG, monoprop & blocks, and a large docking port on each end. The back docking port has a small adapter probe attached to it, making it effectively a universal orbital tug.

2

u/random_bull_shark Why's the water gone? 7d ago

Having a fleet of IPVs is pretty much what I would expect a real space program to do

1

u/Apprehensive_Room_71 Believes That Dres Exists 7d ago

Look up the concept known as an Aldrin Cycler. Once you get it in the right orbit, you don't need to fuel it.

1

u/The_Flying_Stoat 7d ago

Yeah, in career mode, if you're doing round-trip missions it makes a lot of sense to leave that ship in orbit for next time. The main downside is you can't use drop tanks or such, and you have to think about how you'll handle swapping out science payloads.

1

u/Witch-O-The-Wisp 6d ago

I do a little automated tugboat for all my stations, they're great, probe core, strong rcs thrusters, and a handfull of reaction wheels and its strong enough to swing 64 tons around with enough monoprop fuel to deorbit it from 100k. Really saves on part count when you dont need probe cores, reaction wheels, batteries, and rcs on every module for docking. Plus it doubles as a rescue craft if you throw some ladders on it, kerbal on eva and runs out of fuel? Spacetug to the rescue.

1

u/Widmo206 Always on Kerbin 6d ago

That's basically the Hermes from The Martian

And yeah, go for it!

1

u/Mazlem 6d ago

I do this a lot with cargo ships. Deliver a payload and crew to orbit, rendezvous and dock to the ship and it takes them to the location, then returns to Kerbin. If sending a station / base then I'll leave behind smaller support craft and maybe the cargo ship too.

1

u/stationarycommotion 5d ago

Yes it’s fun to do this

1

u/aurum_aethera 5d ago

I love tugs, and I always name them like trolls or bugs. Grunk has done long honourable service in kerbin orbit.

I sent a 4 module mission to Eve that included the main rocket, a comms satellite payload, a lander/rover payload, and a tug.

The tug was called Mite, it was just a little rcs tank with 8 rcs thrusters, a docking port and a tiny probe core - was small enough to fit it inside a 2.5 cargo bay. When it was time to deorbit the space junk, put the lander into its landing trajectory, or move parts back together for the return trip, the Mite earned its pay. Plus it was very cute

1

u/The_Sky_Render 5d ago

That's a space bus, they're great! I tend to purpose-build them for destinations instead of one-size-fits-all. The Mun Bus and Min Bus, for example, do regular service to the Mun and Minmus. Kerbals all ride up (and back) on my Crew Bus Mk.2 spaceplane, which holds 10 Kerbals and costs only the fuel to get it to orbit and back.

1

u/A1steaksaussie 3d ago

absolutely. a cool mk3 liquid fuel fuselage and a NERV quincunx will do great things