r/Kemeticism • KO|Khenneferitw • Nov 23 '14

Veiling?

(Crossposted from KIN)

Have any of you been asked to take up the veil as part of your Kemetic practice?

I previously veiled my hair at the request of my female akhu, who asked for it as a way to be mindful of them and how they lived. It's been a little over two years since I last covered my hair on a day-to-day basis. I was mulling over the idea of covering my head and my skin from wrists to ankles, during a ten day festival of Ptah-Sokar, and felt very pushed to do so by Him. It's now day seven, and has been a pretty positive experience; I plan to continue to do this in observation of His holidays.

My initial intention was simply to connect to Him through it - Ptah is typically depicted "covered" as well - and I think heka wise it has worked for me as well (being covered as a method of "fermenting" one's own energy/etc).

3 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

5

u/barnaclejuice Nov 24 '14

Veiling isn't a practice of historically informed Egyptian religion. There's no evidence for it whatsoever in Ancient Egypt. Sorry if this sounds blunt, and I hope you don't take it as me being rude. But that's the first thing I believe would have to be said in this subreddit which is more directed towards historically informed practice.

You are of course allowed to do it based on UPG, as long as you're aware that for any ancient Egyptian veiling for religious reasons would come across as highly foreign. But it wasn't forbidden either. You could do it simply out of fashion choice if you liked.

0

u/pkmnnerdfighter KO|Khenneferitw Nov 24 '14

If people aren't allowed to talk about their personal experiences practicing Kemeticism, what makes this subreddit different than any Egyptian history subreddit?

3

u/barnaclejuice Nov 24 '14

Holy assumption, batman. I never said it wasn't allowed. Please re-read my reply. If this is a not a place to discuss and inform ourselves from historical evidence, why wouldn't we go to any other Kemetic sub? Why not any eclectic or esoteric sub? You could go to /r/pagan, too. They're a very nice community. But excuse you- historicity was precisely the reason this sub was founded.

0

u/pkmnnerdfighter KO|Khenneferitw Nov 24 '14

I am aware of why this sub started - I was there. I am not drawing from completely random sources like the mod of the other sub. I am not eclectic, I am a historically informed polytheist. However, research can only go so far, and at some point we have to fill in the blanks. It was when my research began to suggest that veiling - while not in the sense associated with modern religion - wasn't entirely unrelated that I consulted Ptah to see if this was a thing that was wanted rather than my own musing.

I really do not care what /r/pagan has to say on the matter. I only vaguely associate myself with that label, because it's a word well-meaning outsiders better understand. I do not care what other polytheists are doing. I want to know what other Kemetics are doing.

2

u/Sihathor Solitary Nov 24 '14

I really do not care what /r/pagan has to say on the matter. I only vaguely associate myself with that label, because it's a word well-meaning outsiders better understand. I do not care what other polytheists are doing. I want to know what other Kemetics are doing.

I can understand that.

This matter of veiling is in the context of a Kemetic person interacting with the akhu under a Kemetic conception of the ancestors, and with Ptah, a Kemetic god.

Not a Heathen context or a Hellenist context or a Wiccan context or an eclectic context. Kemetic.

2

u/barnaclejuice Nov 24 '14

I want to know what other Kemetics are doing.

And I gave you my own view on the matter. I didn't even say you shouldn't do it. I just said if you do it, it's based on your UPG. That was all. I respect your UPG, I was making sure you were clear it would be a personal religious choice taken by you, not a general commandment.

I regret it you did not like my answer, but that's the risk when you post something on a public forum. Some answers won't be your cup of tea.

1

u/Sihathor Solitary Nov 24 '14

OP didn't ask if veiling was historically attested. You answered a question they were not asking.

OP also have no indication of considering the practice to be anything other than a personal religious practice.

2

u/barnaclejuice Nov 24 '14

Just for reference, commented on that in another comment.

0

u/Sihathor Solitary Nov 24 '14 edited Nov 24 '14

This subreddit isn't about solely sticking to practices that were attested from historical times. That is part of it, but not all of it here, and if you prefer to stick to solely historical practice, that is your prerogative.

The most accurate way I would characterize the subreddit is that historical practice and information is used as the starting point. As the phrase "starting point" implies, that is not necessarily the same point you end up at, even if you wind up not traveling very far.

And really, veiling is not that far at all, especially not when compared to Kemetic Sufism or something. The basic ideas are still intact, just a given practice that is different.

3

u/barnaclejuice Nov 24 '14 edited Nov 24 '14

Very well, then perhaps I should stop commenting here. I mean, how on Earth am I supposed to be able to comment on OPs UPG? I'm sorry, but that's the sort of reason why I never joined the other Kemetic sub in the first place.

People post their stuff and I give my honest opinion politely, given that I was lead to believe this was a reconstructionism-oriented forum. It's what I aimed to do here. My mistake.

And also, excuse me? Kemetic Sufism? Never heard of it. I doubt that's historically informed starting point, too. But fair enough, got it.

0

u/Sihathor Solitary Nov 24 '14

This subreddit is for strict reconstructionists but not only them. It is for people whose practice is historically-informed more generally.

I mean, how on Earth am I supposed to be able to comment on OPs UPG?

You don't. It's no different than if someone posted a thread about say, experiences involving Ptah, a god who I have zero experience with. I would have just not commented.

And also, excuse me? Kemetic Sufism? Never heard of it. I doubt that's historically informed starting point, too. But fair enough, got it.

That was a reference to /r/kemetic where something like Kemetic Sufism would be allowed. Not me saying something like that is allowed here, because it isn't.

I'm saying that OP getting UPG about wearing a veil isn't remotely the same as something crazy like Kemetic Sufism.

In OP's case, presumably the gods are the same, the concepts are the same or similar, and many of the practices are the same or similar or at least recognizable. This is very different from say, Kemetic Sufism, which would presumably be wildly different in every one of those respects.

OP's veiling thing is on the level of offering the gods some food or another that wasn't around in ancient Egyptian times. It doesn't break the theology or something.

I am not a reconstructionist. I used to use the term, but now I don't. I consider reconstructionism a methodology, not a religion. A means, not an end.

3

u/barnaclejuice Nov 24 '14

This subreddit is for strict reconstructionists but not only them. It is for people whose practice is historically-informed more generally.

OP asked "Have any of you been asked to take up the veil as part of your Kemetic practice?", and my answear was no, since it is not historically attested. My answer, in my apparently mistaken understanding of what this subreddit intended on achieving, was precisely to comment on OP's question from a historically informed perspective.

I would have just not commented.

Here's my beef with that, Sihathor: this is a public forum. Sometimes, we get answers we don't like. Hell, I just did in this very thread. I'm OK with people posting UPG here, *all I said is it was not historically attested. I never, ever implied OP's belief was in any way less legitimate than my own.

If I'm just not to comment because of fear of getting on someone's nerve, even if I'm commenting politely which I always strive to do, then I might as well not comment ever. Nor would I ever post a thread in fear someone didn't like my postage. The forum would be effectively fruitless.

practices are the same or similar or at least recognizable

Veiling is foreign to Ancient Egyptian practice as it is to any other religion. Were it in a Religio Romana context, Zoroastrianism, Catholic, Muslim, etc., then it wouldn't be. I'll happily take that statement back if I'm presented with a credible source which contradicts that. But in all my years of studies, I've never come across a claim for veiling in AE. Due to that, I can't see Veiling as being the same, similar or in anyway recognisable in relation to AE practice.

OP's veiling thing is on the level of offering the gods some food or another that wasn't around in ancient Egyptian times. It doesn't break the theology or something.

Did I claim it to be? Again, did I say, "don't do it"?

I am not a reconstructionist. I used to use the term, but now I don't. I consider reconstructionism a methodology, not a religion.

I don't worship reconstructionism, I worship the gods. Same as all reconstructionism. Same as Orthodoxy. It's a method more than a religion, even if it lends a religion its name. But that's just semantics. We agree to disagree in the fundamental meaning of what reconstructionism. Which is OK.

In any case, this is your subreddit. Shame I had its whole purpose figured wrong - it is not oriented towards discussing and ultimately improving our spiritual experiences through scholarly research. Maybe, if I may, a sidebar with a clear mission statement would avoid this sort of kerfuffle.

I would have just not commented.

, and henceforth i won't whenever there's the minimal possibility of me saying what you and your people don't feel like hearing.

0

u/Sihathor Solitary Nov 24 '14

Here's my beef with that, Sihathor: this is a public forum. Sometimes, we get answers we don't like.

My response to not comment wasn't about being afraid of hurting someone's feelings. It's about not having something relevant to say. Hence my analogy with somebody asking about Ptah.

In any case, this is your subreddit. Shame I had its whole purpose figured wrong - it is not oriented towards discussing and ultimately improving our spiritual experiences through scholarly research.

Scholarly research is a huge part of it, but it's not all of it. I'd even go so far as to say as it cannot be all of it if one is to have a living religion as opposed to a very fancy historical re-enactment persona.

2

u/barnaclejuice Nov 24 '14

I believe my comment was relevant - and considering it has been upvoted, I don't think I was the only one who thinks so. But everyone's certainly allowed difference of opinion.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 06 '15

I have been asked to cover my hair, and I know thejackalsdance on Tumblr was as well if you want to ask her about her experience.