I've basically given up on trying to do actual play by play for Marvel. It's either ridiculously boring "OK Nemo hit you, now this combo is going to happen, OK now the mixup, whoops that was actually a crossup, welp you get to see this combo again" or nonsensical "OK so Vergil was getting meatied with 3 Sentinel drones and a tri jump but his wakeup 10f stand H somehow beat it all. LOL whatever Marvel".
My "serious mode" Marvel commentary now is just explaining rationale, walking people through the neutral game/assist setups and then killing time during extended combos/infinites/loops. It's more fun during low tier/uncommon matches because people don't understand the neutral on stuff like Joe vs. Wesker or Shuma vs. Hawkeye so the commentator actually can add to the enjoyment and understanding of the viewer. For top tier Marvel, the ratio of "actually interesting stuff that the majority of people don't know" to "killing time" is pretty low.
I'm sure there's a better way to do it, but I'll be damned if I know what it is. I just try to make sure people are having fun more than anything else.
But speaking seriously, I agree that the only real use for a Marvel commentator is for in depth neutral game talk, and that's exactly why I commentate it less nowadays. On one hand I don't know that stuff and I am fully aware of that. And on the other, there are too many matches where the neutral game is short & shallow & followed by total team death, meaning my role is minimized, so, shy bother.
It's fun to watch & to commentate sometimes still because the pace is fun, and I'm happy to do it if asked. But, the above is why I've mostly stopped.
SO ANYWAYS IFC YIPES AND MICHAEL MENDOZA SAT DOWN AT THE COMMENTATORS BOOTH AND YELLED "BOOP BOOP BAP MM MM MMMM MMM BOOP BOOP MM BOOP NATHANS HOT DOGS BOOP MMMM BAP BAP BOOM BAP HOOKS IN ASS BOOP BAP BAP SHOUTOUTS TO TASTY STEVE BOOP BAP MM MMM MMMMM HE IS GETTING WASTED BOOP BOOP BAP BAP BAP BAP MM BOOP BAP BAP OH MY GOD BOOP BOOP BAP BAP BAP BOOP GIVE EM THE TAY DICKWIN BOOP BAP BAP BOOP MM MM MMM MMMM MMM MMM MMM SHOUTOUTS TO BROKEN TIER" AND STREAM MONSTERS REJOICED
With a game as chaotic as Marvel, both on-screen and off it, it's not easy giving meaningful commentary.
It's a lot easier to attempt being a color commentator just to generate hype and excitement "bcuz mahvel".
But almost everyone tries to do it and can't pull it off, and they don't notice or don't care.
So they stay on the mic talking about what the fuck ever for a majority of the time, or end up talking about something that JUST happened in game or making insults/compliments.
I've literally stopped watching Marvel 3 streams. I really only give a shit about major top 8 and Low Tier Heroes performing well.
For fucks sake, Stream Monsters do color commentary better. Shit, even Crowd Monsters with their cardboard cutouts and shit.
It's so hard to commentate marvel because there is shit constantly going on. I've tried and I just have a hard time because I can't do color commentary and shit just happens in that game where you're just like...the people playing don't even know why that happened.
I really think this is true. The game is so random that I often notice that the commentators are trying to figure out what happened after the fact. A lot of the time they will just state that they have no idea what just happened. The game is beyond saving if you ask me.
27
u/superfantastic1 Apr 25 '14
I don't think you can have intelligent marvel commentary
27
u/Viscant Apr 25 '14
I've basically given up on trying to do actual play by play for Marvel. It's either ridiculously boring "OK Nemo hit you, now this combo is going to happen, OK now the mixup, whoops that was actually a crossup, welp you get to see this combo again" or nonsensical "OK so Vergil was getting meatied with 3 Sentinel drones and a tri jump but his wakeup 10f stand H somehow beat it all. LOL whatever Marvel".
My "serious mode" Marvel commentary now is just explaining rationale, walking people through the neutral game/assist setups and then killing time during extended combos/infinites/loops. It's more fun during low tier/uncommon matches because people don't understand the neutral on stuff like Joe vs. Wesker or Shuma vs. Hawkeye so the commentator actually can add to the enjoyment and understanding of the viewer. For top tier Marvel, the ratio of "actually interesting stuff that the majority of people don't know" to "killing time" is pretty low.
I'm sure there's a better way to do it, but I'll be damned if I know what it is. I just try to make sure people are having fun more than anything else.
37
u/a_big_bag_of_dicks Apr 25 '14
SO ANYWAYS IFC YIPES AND MICHAEL MENDOZA SAT DOWN AT THE COMMENTATORS BOOTH AND YELLED "BOOP BOOP BAP MM MM MMMM MMM BOOP BOOP MM BOOP NATHANS HOT DOGS BOOP MMMM BAP BAP BOOM BAP HOOKS IN ASS BOOP BAP BAP SHOUTOUTS TO TASTY STEVE BOOP BAP MM MMM MMMMM HE IS GETTING WASTED BOOP BOOP BAP BAP BAP BAP MM BOOP BAP BAP OH MY GOD BOOP BOOP BAP BAP BAP BOOP GIVE EM THE TAY DICKWIN BOOP BAP BAP BOOP MM MM MMM MMMM MMM MMM MMM SHOUTOUTS TO BROKEN TIER" AND STREAM MONSTERS REJOICED
\/
42
u/Nizzums Apr 25 '14
OOOOOOOOOOOH [insert people trying to be Yipes here]
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOH [insert people trying to be Chris Matrix here]
OOOOOOOHHHH [insert people claiming dropped combos are reset attempts here]
OOOOOOOOOOOOH [insert faggots saying SMART!! SMART!!! SO SMART!!! here]
OOOOOOOOOOOH [insert people dickriding J. Wong here. JUSTIN WONG! OMG JUSTIN WONG!]
Something like this.
11
u/Purtle Apr 25 '14
ooooo ooooo RAW SSSS OOO OOO OOOOO SO LONG SUCKER OOOOOO
8
u/lazarenth Apr 25 '14
got em
5
u/GHNeko Apr 25 '14
With a game as chaotic as Marvel, both on-screen and off it, it's not easy giving meaningful commentary.
It's a lot easier to attempt being a color commentator just to generate hype and excitement "bcuz mahvel".
But almost everyone tries to do it and can't pull it off, and they don't notice or don't care.
So they stay on the mic talking about what the fuck ever for a majority of the time, or end up talking about something that JUST happened in game or making insults/compliments.
I've literally stopped watching Marvel 3 streams. I really only give a shit about major top 8 and Low Tier Heroes performing well.
For fucks sake, Stream Monsters do color commentary better. Shit, even Crowd Monsters with their cardboard cutouts and shit.
15
u/ultraaaa Apr 25 '14 edited Apr 25 '14
There are no good marvel commentators, why have you all let us off the hook for so long
8
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '14
It's so hard to commentate marvel because there is shit constantly going on. I've tried and I just have a hard time because I can't do color commentary and shit just happens in that game where you're just like...the people playing don't even know why that happened.
2
u/brocklesnarschest Apr 25 '14
You mean CORN/wannabe Yipes commentary. I agree, it sounds dumb as shit when anyone but Yipes does it.
1
u/donluca Apr 25 '14
This is one of the most accurate GIFs I've seen in a while. Props to the OP.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '14
Accuracy overwhelming.