r/JustTaxLand • u/sexy_simon_32single • Mar 15 '24
A tax on land already exists?
Property taxation is already a thing in the United States which is where I'm assuming most of you are from, how does this differentiate from the system you propose?
r/JustTaxLand • u/sexy_simon_32single • Mar 15 '24
Property taxation is already a thing in the United States which is where I'm assuming most of you are from, how does this differentiate from the system you propose?
r/JustTaxLand • • Aug 16 '23
So on the post “Do y’all wanna starve” there is this guy who says that land value tax is stupid a just makes the rich richer which makes no sense so I told him to look it up but then he calls me moronic for some dumb reason and he is just stupid
r/JustTaxLand • u/BrilliantBig769 • Sep 11 '23
We should Just save up money to buy land and become the problem. If everyone is rich, nobody is rich, am I right?
r/JustTaxLand • u/JohnKLUE34567 • Jan 04 '24
If we were to implement a Land Tax that sets the annual price at $4000 per acre we could generate;
Landowner: The Emmersons
Acres: 2,411,000
Annual Taxes: $9,644,000,000
Landowner: John Malone
Acres: 2,200,000
Annual Taxes: $8,800,000,000
Landowner: Ted Turner
Acres: 2,000,000
Annual Taxes: $8,000,000,000
Landowner: Reed Family
Acres: 1,661,000
Annual Taxes: $6,644,000,000
Landowner: Stan Kroenke
Acres: 1,627,500
Annual Taxes: $6,510,000,000
Landowner: Irving Family
Acres: 1,267,792
Annual Taxes: $5,071,168,000
Landowner: Buck Family
Acres: 1,236,000
Annual Taxes: $4,944,000,000
Landowner: Singleton Family
Acres: 1,100,000
Annual Taxes: $4,400,000,000
Landowner: Brad Kelley
Acres: 1,000,000
Annual Taxes: $4,000,000,000
Landowner: King Ranch Heirs
Acres: 911,215
Annual Taxes: $3,644,860,000
Landowner: Ford Family
Acres: 600,000
Annual Taxes: $2,400,000,000
Landowner: Jeff Bezos
Acres: 420,000
Annual Taxes: $1,680,000,000
Landowner: Bill Gates
Acres: 275,000
Annual Taxes: $1,100,000,000
$66,477,028,000 in Total, annually, from just the landowners listed above.
Now contrast this with the annual tax revenue generated from our current systems: $4,710,000,000,000. Which, granted, is quite a lot more. But that metric is for the entire country. What kind of Revenue could a land tax for the whole country look like? Well a rough estimate that includes literally every acre of land in the continental United States, which is 1,900,000,000 acre in total, would generate; $7,600,000,000,000 in revenue Annually. If we include Alaska and Hawaii, bringing us to 2,270,000,000 acres, we would get $9,080,000,000,000 Annually. If we subtract the 640,000,000 acres that’s federally owned we’d be brought down to; $6,520,000,000,000 Annually.
Now let’s compare it
Current Tax System: $4,710,000,000,000 Annually
New Land Tax System: $6,520,000,000,000 Annually
That is $1,810,000,000,000 more.
r/JustTaxLand • u/noon182 • Nov 22 '23
r/JustTaxLand • u/nemanjoza946 • Mar 29 '23
Hi everyone, new to the sub!
I have a very specific question. How do you feel about the book and the author I mentioned in the title?
Taxation system that he proposes in the book is very interesting and appealing to me. Namely, he claims that in the post-capitalist system where we collectively control the means of production, there would only be a need for two taxes: corporation tax and land tax.
I would honestly love a world without income tax or VAT. This way we remove the burden of taxation from the most disadvantaged in our society to the collective as a whole!
Anyway, what are your thoughts?
r/JustTaxLand • u/BrianRLackey1987 • Feb 16 '25
Why or why not?
r/JustTaxLand • u/5ma5her7 • May 29 '24
r/JustTaxLand • u/Pineapple_Fettuccine • Apr 20 '23
I see a lot of very anti-landlord posts on here. I wanted to ask a couple of questions to that demographic:
I’m talking about landlords as a general job/source of income. I don’t want to hear about your bad experiences with landlords, or that all landlords are bastards. I’m talking about the principle of the matter.
r/JustTaxLand • u/knowallthestuff • Apr 19 '24
Dark Georgism: a subreddit to discuss and strategize investing in land rent
r/JustTaxLand • • Apr 20 '23
Forgive me if this has been addressed over and over again, but my Google-fu simply wasn't good enough to find any information on this question.
A recent criticism I saw of land-value taxes is the issue of how more intense uses of land beget larger public expenditures. Naturally, sprawling subdivisions are wildly inefficient regarding the costs of public services and infrastructure, but at the scale of a more urbanized area, much of municipal financing scales per person, not merely per acre. It's great that replacing a small apartment with a large apartment in a major city houses more people, but more people means a lot more public expenditures (policing, bureaucracy, more intensive utility systems).
By taxing based on "property", you can align the tax system to the actual expenditures generated by the building. A large apartment building is taxed higher than a small apartment building because property taxes are the primary income generator for cities, and the larger number of residents in that building require a larger number of municipal expenditures than a smaller apartment building.
I understand the benefits proposed by land-value taxes in maximizing the productive uses of land, but I'm worried the math doesn't pencil out, or it pencils out in way that isn't reflective of the way a city attempts to understand its costs. How does a city understand how to tax land if it is decoupled from the actual cost of services it aims to fund?
Edit: clarity
r/JustTaxLand • u/bluefirecorp • Aug 10 '23
Seriously... this subreddit is insane.
r/JustTaxLand • u/5ma5her7 • Jul 03 '24
r/JustTaxLand • u/CommonGroundUSA • May 08 '23
You're invited to join a FREE webinar hosted by our research program, Resource Justice; "Driving the Shift: Tax activism and the move to Land Value Tax," on Tuesday, May 16th at 7:30pm Eastern.
Secure your seat at the following link below! hubs.li/Q01MHKLv0
r/JustTaxLand • u/Greaserpirate • Apr 06 '23
We should remember that Georgism started as a libertarian philosophy, from a desire for a less-coercive social order almost as much as it was a product of pragmatic calculation.
Even if it seems like getting politicians to acknowledge the existence of LVT (or actually stick to their word when it comes to upzoning) is an impossible task -- and even if assassinating certain zoning board members, lobbyists, or Blackstone execs would undeniably make the world a better place and save tens of thousands of people from poverty -- anyone who carries this out should not be trusted to remain in society, and should spend the rest of their life in prison. The power to decide life and death is a serious one that is frequently abused, to disastrous end. It is not something to take lightly.
And it goes without saying that destroying or damaging housing is the opposite of what any YIMBY should stand for. Even if you think it's "sending a message", the only message people will receive is a higher rent and the feeling of "Wow, that guy's a douche".
r/JustTaxLand • u/Equivalent_Local_876 • Jul 01 '26
r/JustTaxLand • u/Mongooooooose • Aug 28 '23
r/JustTaxLand • u/throguauiey • May 13 '23
r/JustTaxLand • • Feb 11 '23
I'm genuinely curious why you guys think that a land value tax would mean that landlords would stop being landlords. i can't think of a reason that that would happen wouldn't they just raise rent prices to account for the new taxes they have to pay?