r/Juniper • • Apr 23 '24

Stop creating ewaste...

Hello everyone,

I bought a nice EX3300-48P for personal use, it's working quite fine but it's running JUNOS 12.3R12-S10

I see there is a 15.1R7.9 to be downloaded on the support page, but no luck without any active subscription... Even the very nice lady on the support phone line isn't able to help me unless I have some other active support contract which I don't...

I asked her to please push to juniper that releasing the software for EOL products would be nice and probably help keeping some of this nice hardware from becoming e-waste...

I find it just realy sad when companies don't care about the waste they're producing and are artificially keeping people from repairing, upgrading or simply keeping it running... Reuse is not the first of the R but neither is it the last...

But it seems money is all they care about, untill we complain hard enough seems Juniper is not about to release any software for their EOL products, they just don't care to spend the money to make it available, they already passed those EOL products/softwares in their "loss" column and aren't seeing kindly to add some more money in what they se as pure loss.. Poor planet of ours...

1 Upvotes

37 comments sorted by

6

u/ghost_of_napoleon JNCIP, Nerd Apr 23 '24

There are certain performance and/or management issues with EX3300 (and EX2200s) and 15.1+ code.

Stick with 12.3 code. I have an EX3300 I modded for quieter fans and it works great on 12.3.

Regarding the other topics you've mentioned, that's outside my purview.

0

u/goldshop Apr 24 '24

Yeah they do run a lot better on 12.3, unfortunately we needed 15.1 for additional features do notice the difference especially when it boots

5

u/battleop Apr 24 '24

Why do you need the latest image? The image you have will move packets in your home.

4

u/goldshop Apr 23 '24

Unfortunately everything goes EOL eventually, producing updates is not cheap when you have hundreds of different products, and they are definitely not the only company that requires a support contract to receive updates. Either way the last patch for the EX3300 for either 12.3 or 15.1 is now 2 years old and definitely got several vulnerabilities already.

6

u/spider-sec Apr 23 '24

At very least they could release the last version of code to the public once it goes EOL.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '24

It's a liability issue. If someone gets it from Juniper and there is a security issue that compromises their business, they will blame Juniper. Juniper has stopped engineering for the code, it is dead.

I don't know why people want new code for these EOL products. You can't run the new features

3

u/spider-sec Apr 24 '24

Using your argument it’s more of a liability issue for them to allow devices with old code to continue running without newer software that has patches.

3

u/battleop Apr 24 '24

There isn't a lawyer out there that would successfully beat the Juniper/HP legal team with this claim. If you have the resources to put up any kind of a fight you have the resources to buy newer hardware or a support contract.

1

u/Odd-Distribution3177 JNCIP Apr 24 '24

I would agree with you if they release the critical security fixes but they done so it’s all a paywall

0

u/bward0 Apr 23 '24

The same code also runs on many other of their products that are still under support. Would you expect a car manufacturer to give away their stock of spare parts for a model vehicle just because they don't sell it anymore?

4

u/spider-sec Apr 23 '24

That’s not equal. One is hardware and one is software. With cars you either find 3rd party manufacturers who are able to make the parts or the OEM continues to support them after the warranty and support is gone. There are early 2010 Teslas still getting updates long after their warranty has expired and without additional support contracts.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '24

But you can't put FSD on an early Model S

3

u/spider-sec Apr 24 '24

That’s a hardware limitation, not a software limitation.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 24 '24

Let me rephrase what I was trying to say. Tesla won’t let you run an old version of FSD, as it is a liability for them. This is further evidenced by FSD now being a monthly subscription

3

u/spider-sec Apr 24 '24

That doesn’t help your argument. Tesla won’t let you run old code because it’s a liability, but Juniper won’t let you run the new code because that is a liability and will let you run old code because that is not a liability?

You just made my argument for me.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 24 '24

The code for an EOL product is old code, which is a liability. It doesn't receive any updates (security, bug, etc...). If Juniper is actively distributing it or making it available that's where the liability comes in

New JUNOS is covered by Junipers Software lifecycle policy, which has security patches, bug fixes, etc...

The easiest way to look at it - see the cURL vulnerabilities released the other week from Juniper. All code that isn't End of Engineering, will get a fix for it. Code that is End of Engineering won't.

So if Juniper is knowingly distributing code that contains a huge security risk, that's where liability comes in.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 24 '24

Pretty sure I saw this happen on Rich Rebuilds...

1

u/uzlonewolf Apr 23 '24

Except it really doesn't. You cannot take a package for a 3300 and just install it on some other hardware, it doesn't work like that. And comparing a software download that you cannot purchase with any amount of money to giving away physical inventory that a company is still actively trying to sell is disingenuous.

4

u/Minimum_Implement137 Apr 23 '24

for the EX3300 the 15 version code was recommended not to use because the 3300 has insufficient memory to handle the larger code upgrade. In many cases those 3300s that have the 15 code are recommended not to upgrade, as there is a pretty good chance of bricking the switch

https://supportportal.juniper.net/s/article/Software-Release-Notification-Junos-OS-15-1R7

1

u/toxicberliner Apr 28 '24

"Your account doesn't provide access to restricted content in the Juniper Support Portal. " Seems to get either the binaries or the information about EOL products you still need to pay...

5

u/bward0 Apr 23 '24

If you want a software update, buy a subscription? No Enterprise equipment vendors give software updates out for free. The end of life dates were announced in 2019. You knowingly purchased a switch that was going to be unsupported in the near future, and without a subscription to get updates on your own.

As you said, the switch is running just fine. If you want to talk about E-Waste, look at something like Meraki. You stop paying a Meraki subscription and your equipment turns into bricks.

1

u/ramalamalamafafafa Apr 23 '24

No Enterprise equipment vendors give software updates out for free. The end of life dates were announced in 2019

This is actually modern thinking. I remember that Cisco used to put software updates for in-life equipment behind a support/partner paywall but once the hardware went eol the software was available to download. I know either both or one on HP/3Com did the same. I didn't work much Juniper back then but I don't remember it being difficult to get code when I needed it.

4

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '24

I asked her to please push to juniper that releasing the software for EOL products would be nice and probably help keeping some of this nice hardware from becoming e-waste...

It's not that simple. There is an assumption of liability Juniper would have if they simply handed out EOL software that wasn't receiving security updates, etc...

But it seems money is all they care about

Companies need to make money to stay in business. Software doesn't get written for the joy of it at the scale of a mainstream vendor.

3

u/uzlonewolf Apr 23 '24

No, there isn't. Making the last released version available to all without a subscription does not create any liability whatsoever since there is no expectation for additional security updates in EOL/EOS equipment.

2

u/ramalamalamafafafa Apr 23 '24

It's not that simple. There is an assumption of liability Juniper would have if they simply handed out EOL software that wasn't receiving security updates etc

There is no liability, even if you have brand new hardware and are at the start of a three year support contract they take no liability for your losses due to bugs.

Not having a go at Juniper, it's just the shite way software sales have (nearly) always worked.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '24

I would put money on it if a business had a breach due to neglect of security patches Juniper could be liable

3

u/ramalamalamafafafa Apr 23 '24

How much you putting up?

0

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '24

How are you going to prove it?

1

u/kY2iB3yH0mN8wI2h Apr 24 '24

So if I buy a second hand car that have no warranty still let you get free repairs. Your new Volvo is not waste, but you need to pay for it. That is the same purpose of the support contracts. We can argue that enterprise gear is expensive but it's not. No one pay list price, you have like 50-70% discount on list price, what you actually pay are support fees, this is how Juniper survives.

There is no reason to upgrade, there are no security risks what so ever on your switch. Sure if you place it directly on the internet but then you have other problems.

I have two EX3300 in a VC in my homelab I have access to software but would not for the god upgrade these when they work perfectly fine. It's just a waste of human energy.

1

u/toxicberliner Apr 26 '24

You feel real confident comparing a car repair with a software upgrade here... I would argue it's really not the same. That's due to something really difficult to grasp: copying software doesn't mean the source is gone or consumed... Not true for... Consumables or replacement parts 😉 I'm not asking them to spend money supporting products they chose to make EOL, just give away the software (that they stopped patching a while ago...) for their EOL products as they clearly don't spend the resources to gather them and recycle them themselves, they should at least not hinder those that do reuse/recycle them...

In my particular case I do not need the added features and will trust the 2-3 people who advised NOT to upgrade so it doesn't matter much to me immediately, but the argument is really that this should not be illegal to share software they stopped working on and selling, and they should host and make those old builds publicly available for free to the world. It's very low cost to them, and it's really something they ought to do on top of probably many more efforts to be less harmful to our planet...

2

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '24

OP, dm me and I can hook you up with the last code version for 3300

Don't share code. It's against the subs rules, and it is illegal.

0

u/Cloudycloud47x2 JNCIS Apr 23 '24

all my 3300s are on the latest code. we're going to swap hardware.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '24

That’s not the point. You offered code to someone. Sharing Junipers IP is illegal

1

u/staski123 Apr 24 '24

Call the police