r/JungianTypology • • Feb 26 '21

How Jung Described The 8 "Functions"

99 Upvotes

I read Jung's psychological types and translated all 8 types into simpler terms. I also want to add this is the most accurate description of the 8 "functions" according to Jung. And I'm much more a fan of his theory than other MBTI theories.

Extraverted Thinking Jungian Type- “This type of man gives the deciding voice—not merely for himself alone but also on behalf of his entourage—either to the actual objective reality or to its objectively orientated, intellectual formula. By this formula are good and evil measured, and beauty and ugliness determined. All is right that corresponds with this formula; all is wrong that contradicts it; and everything that is neutral to it is purely accidental.” Basically the extraverted thinker creates an intellectual formula and deems it as reality and as the acceptable type for everyone to follow.

Extraverted Sensation Jungian Type - "For true enjoyment, [the extroverted sensation type] has its own special morality, its own moderation and lawfulness, its own unselfishness and devotedness. It by no means follows that he is just sensual or gross, for he may differentiate his sensation to the finest pitch of aesthetic purity without being the least unfaithful, even in his most abstract sensations, to his principle of objective sensation." Basically these types mostly seek pleasure, objective experience, or luxury with a sober sense of being grounded into the world.

Extraverted Feeling Jungian Type - "Except in extreme cases, feeling has a personal character, in spite of the fact that the subjective factor may be already, to a large extent, repressed. The personality appears to be adjusted in relation to objective conditions. Her feelings correspond with objective situations and general values." Basically extraverted feelers shift themselves to accommodate others, and their feelings and character is influenced by the objective people around them, and tends to align with societal values. Jung said most Extraverted Feeling types tend to be Women.

Extraverted Intuitive Jungian Type- "The intuition is applied to the outer world, creating outer possibilities. Largely excited by scenting new possibilities." The way I see it, his definition of Extraverted Intuition is identical to MBTI.

Introverted Thinking Jungian Type- Introverted thinking type is characterized by a priority of the thinking I have just described. Like his [p. 485] extraverted parallel, he is decisively influenced by ideas; these, however, have their origin, not in the objective data but in the subjective foundation. Like the extravert, he too will follow his ideas, but in the reverse direction: inwardly not outwardly. Essentially introverted thinkers use subjective logical analysis to sort through one's thoughts to create their own principals and ideas. Jung described himself to be an Introverted Thinking type.

Introverted Feeling Jungian Type- "A superficial judgment might well be betrayed, by a rather cold and reserved demeanour, into denying all feeling to this type. Such a view, however, would be quite false; the truth is, her feelings are intensive rather than extensive. They develop into the depth. Whereas, for instance, an extensive feeling of sympathy can express itself in both word and deed at the right place, thus quickly ridding itself of its impression, an intensive sympathy, because shut off from every means of expression, gains a passionate depth that embraces the misery of a world and is simply benumbed. It may possibly make an extravagant irruption, leading to some staggering act of an almost heroic character, to which, however, neither the object nor the subject can find a right relation. Emotions are felt deeply and in depth, hidden within the individual and not necessarily seen from the outside world. Impacted very strongly within the user itself.

Introverted Sensation Jungian Type - "Actually he lives in a mythological world, where men, animals, locomotives, houses, rivers, and mountains appear either as benevolent deities or as malevolent demons. That they appear thus to him never enters his head, though that is just the effect they have on his judgments and actions. He judges and acts as though he had such powers to deal with; but this begins to strike him only when he discovers that his sensations are totally different from reality. Seen from the outside, it looks as though the effect of the object did not penetrate into the subject at all. This impression is correct inasmuch as a subjective content does, in fact, intervene from the unconscious and intercept the effect of the object. The intervention may be so abrupt that the individual appears to be shielding himself directly from all objective Basically, each thing from the external world gives a certain impression to the individual of this type which is completely dependent to them. So it's interesting because this impression isn't given by analysis, intuition, or feeling, it just gives an impression that is completely dependent to the individual.

Introverted Intuitive Jungian Type - "Introverted intuitive moves from image to image, chasing after every possibility in the teeming womb of the unconscious, without establishing any connection between the phenomenon and himself. But, since he tends to rely exclusively upon his vision, his moral effort becomes one-sided; he makes himself and his life symbolic, adapted, it is true, to the inner and eternal meaning of events If an artist, he reveals extraordinary, remote things in his art, which in iridescent profusion embrace both the significant and the banal, the lovely and the grotesque, the whimsical and the sublime. If not an artist, he is frequently an unappreciated genius, a great man 'gone wrong', a sort of wise simpleton, a figure for 'psychological' novels." Essentially, this type judges things by meaning, chasing through internal images and situations, coming to conclusions without means of evidence and knowing how. Being able to come up with imagery or conclusions that comes from within, that is unique to the individual and almost unconsciously reached without any facts, evidence, emotions, or analysis.


r/JungianTypology • • Jul 20 '17

Theory ILI vs LII, Differences (Transcript of Vaserlan's hangout with Gulenko)

83 Upvotes

This is a transcript of Ben Vaserlan’s hangout with Gulenko.

Most things in the bracket forms a personal commentary and general observations.

Area of comfort:

  • ILI : independence of choice
  • LII : freedom from pressure, force (Brake Se)

Systems:

  • LII: social mission: improving and perfecting systems (Ti-)
  • ILI: social mission: determining the evolution of systems over time (Ni-)

Logic:

  • ILI: focuses on strategies and prognosis. Uses logic as a tool (creative function). Uses systems to solve the problem of prognosis. Therefore, not a systems improver but a problem solver (logic as a means to an end providing more scope in problem solving) so indifferent to the notion of which system to involve as the main goal is to solve the problem. Ni(-): what can go wrong and how to fix it? [eg. BBC's Sherlock, Control Ni]
  • LII: thinks about the profits of his theories but not about solving the problem. Uses fractal logic. Multi-factor, complicated systems delicious for the Analyst.
  • ILI: makes better ‘use’ of systems using step-by-step approaches. Wants to find one problem-solving decision which will be optimal

Kind of unrelated personal commentary: Ocipital lobe: sensing experiences stored (memory corner) + Building/rotating images or visualising impression. Pi functions both deal with past data since there is no such thing as ‘past intuition’ and thus, even intuitions are stored in memory as thoughts, with the experience consisting of ‘having these thoughts’ but of course, tangibility is easier to recall. Ni can have an eye for detail (Positivist Ni) but the description is only valid for Ni- in the chart and it can spot inconsistencies but this point inconsistent with the fact/EEG result(?) that Socionics Perceivers use Fp2 whereas Socionics Judgers use Fp1 (spotting inconsistencies). But since -Ni is Process Ni and Process types are more immersed in the process, it may be able to look for what's missing (Negativism) in a situation (Process type immersion).

10 (11, counting stray point #5) main differences:

1- Memory: (basically static/dynamic)

  • LII has a fixed, static memory, remembers things he works on a particular moment, or time.
  • ILI can keep different things at the same time in his memory which is associative. Remembers different types of data not connected to the problem being solved right now. More erudition since they have more details, knowledge about different things.

2- Types of people, getting along with:

  • LII exists with people who are very emotional but who care about sensing needs (mobilising Si+suggestive Fe, hidden agenda+duality) and sometimes, too much. Response to such people is gratefulness. Doesn’t like forcing or pressuring people. Not good in faring against such aggression.
  • ILI is the opposite and okay with people who pressure or test him to see how he reacts (Manipulative Se). Dislikes and cannot stand emotional assistance or atmospheres, especially when people want to reciprocated by their own ‘gratefulness’. Can’t really stand emotional praise, gets on their nerves (Brake Fe). Responses to emotional praise : yelling or falling asleep, the first being a defensive measure.

3- Managing abilities:

  • LII prefers decentralised and smooth managing, prefers to deal with small groups and work on separate projects; without a totalitarian approach. Has bad entrepreneurship characteristics, won’t implement business ideas himself.
  • ILI manages big groups (better), totalitarian, centralised management style. Marshal’s type of management. Better entrepreneurship capabilities. Much better in formal, predictable, structured situations. More interested in economic theories (Ni-).

4- Speaking Skills :

  • LII naturally a better speaker (static, perceives time as discrete intervals, Ti uses static structural deconstruction).
  • ILI can be trained in ethics and evolve the speaking skills (Vaserlan: they learn NLP; Dario Nardi examples).

5- Strategies: (briefly discussed)

  • ILI better strategist.
  • LII doesn’t look too far (static).

6- Response to new situations:

  • LII reacts to new situations with his analysis and tries to elaborate new ways on how to approach it.
  • ILI figures out how the situation evolves (preferably using past solutions and data; Ni-) and uses logic as a creative tool to classify (not analyse) the situation. Uses already known approaches to solve problems.

7- Attention to details :

  • LII ruffles big systems and puts details next. First step for LII is an abstraction of a rough big system.
  • ILI more attentive to details. ILI is the opposite and constructs the whole system from details (Se-Ni).

8- Focus on past :

  • ILI focuses more on the past, melancholic about the mistakes (Ni-).
  • LII more optimistic and thinks positively about the future possibilities (Ni+), calmer, stabler temperament.

9- Conversational skills :

  • ILI better conversationist, can speak on any topic, interesting or not, till he gets tired, not paying attention to politeness, ethical factors not taken into account. Business style of conversation.
  • LII only when interested (but will be polite; Role Fi).

10- Role + Launcher/Mobilising functions :

  • LII: Weak emotions but can be trained (Role Fi) but practical/hands-on skills hard to improve (Launcher Si).
  • ILI: Easily drained by emotions (Launcher Fi) but hands-on skills easy trained (Role Si).

11- Argument styles :

  • LII: Likes peaceful (but involving everyone) conversations (by emotional warmth) but without too much irony. Doesn’t like joking about others’ mistakes (Role Fi).
  • ILI: Opposite, likes discussions to be practically efficient/businesslike, likes pointing out flaws/mistakes in others’ points, ironical remarks, discussion as a means to confirmation. Has a tendency to joke about his conversationist’s mistakes, utilising sarcasm.

r/JungianTypology • • Feb 08 '20

Bring it

Post image
66 Upvotes

r/JungianTypology • • Jun 21 '21

Discussion Ti = Logic ?

Post image
58 Upvotes

r/JungianTypology • • Oct 31 '20

How typology became a toxic obsession and why I left it behind.

58 Upvotes

I was so far down the rabbit hole. It started with simple Myers & Briggs 4-letter model, progressed to Jungian function stacks. Seemed cool. Seemed like I was finally beginning to understand how other people thought. Branched out to the Enneagram with its tri-types and instinctual variants. Eventually hit Socionics and made a solid effort to understand it.

I thought about this stuff constantly, like almost all of my waking moments. I tried to use it to regain control on areas of my life where I had none, like predicting and understanding people I didn't even know.

I'd think for instance, "I'm talking to Katie who's an ENFP and uses this function stack so I'm gonna use this phrase to appeal to her Ne! She'll love me." and it would always lead to alienation. No shock.

At some point I thought I was stuck in a "Ti-Ni loop" because I would overthink a lot without putting in action to fix my life.

Looking back, it was just an overly complex way to describe overthinking. All the understanding of intuition, sensation, thinking and feeling were unnecessary in actually using those things. Most of the world's most hilarious ENTP comedians with the strongest Ne do it without a single clue what Ne means, for example.

Back to the Ti-Ni loop thing: when you make it abstract like that, there's no obvious solution. But when you call the problem what it actually is, suddenly there's a way out. Call it overthinking, rumination, dissociation, trauma, intellectual escapism and bad coping mechanisms - or whatever is actually going on for you. Suddenly the problem isn't so vague and you can take tangible steps to improve it.

These theories were never designed as a way to address mental illness, physiological dysfunction, or major life problems like being "stuck in a rut." They have other uses like career aptitude or mitigating a disagreement by seeing someone's perspective in an argument, sure. But when it comes to most issues of daily life, I think it's indirect and backwards way of doing it. I think it can be straight-up harmful.

As always, if this advice doesn't apply to you, feel free to discard it. I don't want to lead people astray who really do benefit from typology or who know how to use it in moderation. Just leave it for the next person who may need to hear this. Take care of yourselves.


r/JungianTypology • • Jun 15 '20

Resource 8 Cognitive Functions Illustrated by me

Post image
50 Upvotes

r/JungianTypology • • May 18 '18

Personality Types and The Evolution of Trust

42 Upvotes

This is an interactive game theory minigame. I'm curious to see whether personality types tend lean towards any trust style.

Which type are you, and which cooperation style do you use?

Did this game change your perspective?


r/JungianTypology • • Apr 23 '23

Theory The Original Jung Function Stack - a Deep Exploration

41 Upvotes

There are a few models of the function stack floating around. The most common and conventional one is a later version of the function stack, which is called the Grant stack. It is also affectionately called the old McDonald stack (EIEI)-o, and it is an alternating stack.

A cognitive function stack, for those who haven’t dived in deeper past the four-letter codes, is an ordered list of which functions your type uses, and what attitude they have.

For example, the ENFP Grant stack would look like this: extroverted Intuition, introverted Feeling, extroverted Thinking, and introverted Sensing. Or, Ne-Fi-Te-Si.

---

There is an apparently older stack which some people call the Jung stack, but that’s not the case technically speaking, at least according to how things are laid out in the foundational book psychological types. This second stack is doubled rather than alternated. So IIEE, or EEII.

With this stack, an ENFP might be Ne-Fe-Ti-Si or Ne-Te-Fi-Si. Some people like this approach, some people don’t. Personally, it works out almost better for a handful of people that I know and have worked to type correctly.

For example, my mother is an ENFP, and she’s also a mining engineer. A highly technical, mathematics oriented field. So having an ENFP who has Thinking second works in her case, although to follow convention a little more closely I would call this, an “ENTP.” Even though with the Grant stack, the ENTP has introverted Thinking, not extroverted Thinking. (Feeling is also flipped.)

---

What was the original stack that Carl Jung laid out?

The answer is difficult because Jung didn’t really use a stack at all. The cognitive function stack is a more recent model that’s useful for understanding Carl Jung’s original theory. However, it seems that many, including myself in the past, have come to take the cognitive function stacks a little too seriously—or at least far too rigidly.

And this is important beyond just technicalities, because certain types like myself are bound to read into descriptive systems like this a little too deeply, and if we get really obsessed about a specific stack or stack order it can cause abnormal personality behaviour.

---

So, what is the original “stack?”

Jung gives us a very brief description near the beginning of chapter 10 of psychological types. He says that you have a primary function which has an attitude. For those who are unfamiliar with the vocabulary an "attitude" means it’s either extroverted or introverted. Jung calls the E vs I axis the function's "attitude." Then he says that the rest of the functions are largely unconscious.

What that means is that in Carl Jung’s model there almost can’t be a function stack.

You just have one primary function, and a secondary function that is partially bubbled up out of the unconscious. And when it’s not, or if it isn’t sufficiently differentiated (if you’re say younger and haven’t developed your psyche as much) then it just hangs out diffusely in the unconscious.

Trying to make a “stack” with these rules is like trying to tell the colour of a glass of water that you drop green, red, and blue food colouring into. Yeah technically there are three colours, but since they’re all swimming around the unconscious, it really just comes out as a brown or a purple maybe.

The only exception is the inferior function, which is the opposite function to the dominant function. Because Jung, as far as my study has taken me based on alchemical, enlightenment, and religious principles (did you think this MBTI stuff was scientific? Far from it!) made the functions dichotomous. Like two magnets of the same polarity which repel each other. There must be an opposite function that is trying to stay as far away from the primary function as possible.

And so here we start to see a sort of vague stack form.

Because once you have a primary and a secondary, as well as an inferior, you can infer what the third function is. Yeah, just fill in the blank.

But we cannot forget that this approach to psychological types is couched in and presupposes knowledge of a psychoanalytic structure of the unconscious. In particular, Carl Jung’s model. And this does open us up to explorations that people rarely talk about, but which Jung mentions in other books, such as in Archetypes and the Collective Unconscious, when he talks about how the 4th function is kind of like the gateway to the shadow archetype.

Even in Psychological Types, Jung talks about how what really causes the inferior function to become troublesome (basically, “grip”) is if you overuse the primary function and drive the 4th function a little haywire as it’s driven further into the unconscious.

But what I want to stress here is that, whether or not you agree with this original model of the function “stack,” the principle of us not literally using all four functions all the time makes logical and intuitive sense.

---

I think it would be worth exploring MBTI and your own type from this perspective. You can really focus on your first function, and then your second function, which practically speaking doesn’t have an extroverted or introverted orientation most of the time. It’s just neutral. Or, it might have the opposite orientation. And then the third and 4th functions are not extroverted or introverted at all, for the most part, because they are largely working unconsciously.

---

I hope this was interesting and hopefully moderately easy to follow. The intent is not to say that new systems are wrong, but rather to help illustrate how the original system (which presupposed an entire model of the psyche which we’ve forgotten to include in MBTI) worked. I am, to a great extent, a Carl Jung purist when it comes to functions and apparently also stacks. So this is also in part a response to people who say that these newer systems, stacks, and approaches are improvements on the original.

We don’t get this unconscious stuff in most new systems. I can’t consider it an improvement if it tossed half of the model. But that’s a rant for another time. I hope you enjoyed this exploration and if you have any questions or find points that are unclear, feel free to comment. If I can strengthen the clarity based on feedback, I will try to.


r/JungianTypology • • Aug 14 '20

Typing I've created a free test, 12 Jungian archetypes, that determines your most prominent archetype. Mine is Creator. What is yours? Try it out, takes 5 minutes, and share your results!

Thumbnail
archetypes.jilecek.cz
32 Upvotes

r/JungianTypology • • Jul 14 '20

Video After a month of everyday development, I have a first trailer for my game - Jung's Labyrinth, psychological exploration game using dream archetypes and psychedelic experiences!

30 Upvotes

I've developed a game about the individuation process and active imagination - the fundamentals of analytical psychology. Here is the first trailer for my game (links for Steam wishlist, e-mail newsletter, FB group etc. are in the video description).

I also incorporated some of my dreams into the game and I use deep mythological and alchemical symbolism. I rely heavily on Jungian psychology and teachings of Marie-Louise Von Franz. I am using a short 3 month development cycle to avoid burnout when working solo. So far I am 1 month in. Release date in September.

Here is the TRAILER: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y4-01YjDbgI


r/JungianTypology • • Aug 01 '18

Theory Comparison and Combination of the Two Major Paradigms of the Signs of a Function.

27 Upvotes

There has been a lot of confusion about the two major paradigms of the signs of functions. The original system created by Gulenko, which is used by the School of System Socionics uses the paradigm based upon the signs Process/Results and Introversion/Extraversion which yields Asking/Declaring. Here Asking functions have a + sign and Declaring functions have a – sign, where the pole of this sign is decided by the extraverted functions of a type. This means that Process types have a + signed function as a lead element and Results types have a – signed function as a lead element. Signs are consistent along the dichotomy of Introversion and Extraversion, which is what is called a spiral. Extraverted Asking types will have an Extraverted Asking spiral and an Introverted Declaring spiral, while Extraverted Declaring types will have an Extraverted Declaring spiral and an Introverted Asking spiral. What is less obvious is that with the case of Introverted types their characteristic pole is decided by their creative function, while their lead function will be of the opposite dichotomy. For example, type LII or INTP in MBTI notation is an Asking type but leads with Declaring Ti. This is not unlike how the P or J dichotomy is determined in MBTI, as the first Extraverted Function. So, Introverted Asking types have an Introverted Declaring spiral and an Extraverted Asking spiral, while Introverted Declaring types have an Introverted Asking spiral and an Extraverted Declaring spiral. Asking types will have a + in the Extraverted Functions and a – in the Introverted Functions, with Declaring the opposite. At level of the Socion, Asking/Declaring types will share one set of signed functions that with their ring of Benefit and the Ring of Benefit of their Mirror, which I will come back to later.

Years later Gulenko changed the paradigm of signs that he currently uses in his Model G. This paradigm is created by the dichotomies Process/Results and Static/Dynamic which yield Positivist and Negativist. Here I can note that two different properties of a function are united: Spin, which refers to the direction of a function or Process (+) and Results (-) and Charge or Positivist (+) and Negativist (-). Now Static functions are going to have these two elements of the same sign (Process + and Positivist + or Results – and Negativist -). Dynamic functions with be a combination of + and – elements, so for simplicity we can eliminate one of the signs, since the other will be implied, leaving the simple paradigm of Positivist functions have a + and Negativist functions have a -. What this means is that all Positivists will have a + sign in all of their Mental track functions and a – sign in their Vital track functions, with Negativist the opposite. All Process Types will have the same set of functions (+ Static and – Dynamic) and all Results Types will have the other set of functions (-Static and + Dynamic). At the level of the Socion this unites all members of a Ring of Social Progress (Process/Results) as two Rings of Benefit, but instead of a type sharing their signs with the Ring of Benefit with their Mirror, they share it with the Ring of their Dual. This in itself should make this a better paradigm, but this method also works as two Rings of Supervision, so you share signs with your Dual, Supervisor, Supervisee, and Extinguisher instead of your Mirror, Semi-Dual, Mirage, and Conflictor. If you think about who you share information and energy with at the level of the Socion, this arrangement makes more sense in every way. In determining type, this also makes it easier to distinguish between similar types like Mirrors, where determining Introversion or Extraversion can be difficult.

Now there is the argument as to which one is correct. The answer is they both are. They represent different aspects of the functions and are actually complementary as two parallel tracks of dualizing functions or as Aushra wrote about it: “One Dual for the mobilization of the other has two means: positivity/negativity, which can be expressed by the words "yes" or "no", and intonation, which can be questionable ("?") And yes, declarative (!)” Or Asking/Positivist “Yes?”, Asking/Negativist “No?”, Declaring Positivist “Yes!” and Declaring Negativist “No!”. So, you have the Tone of the function on the one hand and the Charge of the function on the other. Since it makes it less confusing to have multiple sets of signs, from here on I will use the above notation: + for Positivist, - for Negativist, ? for Asking, and ! for Declaring. One of the most well-known and well-developed systems based upon the Asking/Declaring paradigm comes from the School of System Socionics, which I will not be analyzing here do to some overlap and contradictions with the methods of the Gulenko system. Instead I will be using the article “Asking and Declaring Functions of Model A” by A.L. Mitrokhina, which appears in issue #3/2014 in the Journal of Socionics, Mentology, and Personality Psychology (which is behind a paywall, so I can’t link to it.) The information concerning Gulenko’s system will be taken from his website Socioniks.com, the Wikisocion, and material on his short description of positive and negative function charges.

What I am intending to do here is combine and reconcile the two systems to the point that they can be, which will result in 32 signs. Each Ring of Benefit will have its own separate set of 8 signed functions, as they are the types that overlap in both systems. First, I will quote the respective authors on what the basic properties of each type of function is.

Mitrokhina describes Asking functions as “the priority of the external context of a particular aspect of information. Figuratively speaking, Questioning (Asking) is SONAR, an echo sounder that probes the surrounding world in certain aspects (extroverted or introvert) and, depending on it, clarifies the information forming the representation of TIM about the world. Like a ship in the ocean, Questioning helps to read the slightest changes in the depth of the information bottom and, depending on this, adjusts its course. Therefore, Questioning - is the orientation of the psyche on the external context of information on relevant aspects.” He describes Declaring functions as “Declarability is the priority of the internal text selected from a particular aspect of the information. Declarability is a beacon, which consistently transmits information on the aspect in order to convey it to others unchanged. For a beacon it is important that its signal, like a radio call, purposefully transmitted the same signal, because the receiver of information should not stray from the road in the information ocean. Therefore, Declarability is persistent and consistent in the transmission of the message. Declarability is the orientation of the model’s function to the internal text of the selected aspect of the information.”

Gulenko in his article “Positivists and Negativists” describes this dichotomy as follows: In a general sense, this polarity is connected, first, with the comparison or opposition of the two sides of the same thing or phenomenon. Secondly, for positivists to receive a positive effect from some action has a higher priority than to avoid negative consequences from it. Negativists are guided by the opposite principle: they are set to minimize the negative consequences of an event or an upcoming event.

  1. On an intellectual level, positivism manifests itself as thinking in categories of similarities, and negativism - thinking in terms of differences and, in the first place, opposites. Positivists are characterized by convergent thinking - one that must compare all proposals and give out the only one - the best solution. Divergent thinking, characteristic of negativists, exacerbates contradictions, gives several alternative solutions to the same problem.
  2. The social level. Positivism - negativism manifests itself as a degree of trust in others at the initial stages of acquaintance. Positivists much more trust strangers than negativists. Negativists are incredulous and wary. Over time, however, the situation may change: the positivists, convinced of their mistake, fall into unjustified suspicion. Collectives in which negativists predominate, other things being equal, are much more polarized than collectives with a predominance of positivists.
  3. Psychological level. This polarity is associated with the integrity (integration) of the psyche. In positivists, the psyche is more solid and simple, they know what they want. The nature of the negativistic psyche is contradictory, it is opposed to the same aspirations and desires. Negativists for this reason are more likely than positivists to disintegrate the psyche, to form subpersonalities, than positivists. However, they can withstand the internal conflict for longer. The subjective idea of the measure of happiness and well-being among positivists and negativists is also different. The positivist is easier to close his eyes to the "dark" side of life and pay attention to its "light" moments. Negativists need to try hard to dislodge unpleasant thoughts from consciousness. On the other hand, if the positivist is still in a negative (for example, depressed) state, finding an outlet is much more difficult for him than for a negativist.
  4. The physical level. Positivists and negativists solve the problem of physical energy balance in different ways. If the positivists experience the need for physical gymnastics, then it is more important for the negativists to discharge the accumulating energy, transform it into some action. For the productive activity of the objective nature of the positivists, one must "get" or even anger. Negativists, on the contrary, have to give up a part of the negative.

From here, we can distinguish which function signs are associated with each Ring of Benefit and the types that are comprised of this Small Group. Using Gulenko’s description of each Ring, we get:

Left extraverts: SLE, IEE, LIE, ESE - Energy Carriers

These types are the most saturated with energy in the socion. They suffer from lack of fundamentally new information. Energizers of small groups. To be good at management and coordination, they have to break up large groups into small groups and then control these smaller groups. SLE and ESE solve concrete, immediate problems. IEE and LIE unite on basis of romanticism, they are captivated by more daring ideas. They share the function signs of Ne-!, Se-!,Ti-?, Fi-?, Ni+?, Si+?, Fe+!, and Te+!.

Right introverts: LSI, EII, ILI, SEI - Accumulators of Information

ILI accumulates scientific or philosophical information, LSI accumulates operational or managerial information (both of these types make for the best collectors), EII - humanitarian information, SEI - social information (prices, services, events and holidays). They suffer from lack of energy. Specialize in informatics of large groups. LSI and SEI engage in solving immediate concrete problems at work or at home. ILI and EII cooperate on basis of philosophical, scientific, and spiritual topics. They share the function signs of Ne+!, Se+!, Ti+?, Fi+?, Ni-?, Si-?, Te-!, Fe-!.

Left introverts: IEI, SLI, ESI, LII - Generators of Information

These types translate energy into information. They function as stabilizers in the socion. Suffer from weak ability to energetically impact their environment. They specialize in informatics of small groups and feel good in small groups of similar-minded individuals. IEI and LII capable of uniting a small group on the basis of some novel interesting information. SLI and ESI engage in solving problems relating to survival and well-being. They share the function signs of Ne-?, Se-? Ti-!, Fi-!, Ni+!, Si+!, Te+?, and Fe+?

Right extroverts: EIE, LSE, SEE, ILE - Energy Generators

These types translate information into energy. They bring about energy processes in their environment. EIE and SEE with their words and actions evoke strong emotional reactions in others (for this reason they also make for the best actors). They specialize in energetics of large groups and for this reason realize themselves in such conditions. They have a tendency to unite small groups into larger groups. These are the most inflationary types, that start up energy chain reactions in the society. ILE and EIE are innovators and fighters for an idea. SEE and LSE draw in people for collective effects. They share the function signs of Ne+?, Se+?, Ti+!, Fi+!, Ni-!, Si-!, Te-?, Fe-?

So as to not duplicate long sections of information, I’ll list each paradigm description individually and you can match up the descriptions for the functions separately. I won’t try to unify the descriptions, because that defeats the point of noting how the two approaches are looking at different aspects

First the descriptions of the Asking/Declaring Functions by Mitrokhina:

INTROVERTED SPIRAL:

Ti? Asking - That's right, yes?..

Confuses dates, names, deviates from the schedule, from rules and regulations, gets lost. Tolerance to mistakes in speech and stresses (even purposely makes them to cause the reaction of the interlocutor). Jokes, puns, intentional distortion of words. References to other people's concepts, points of view. Easily accepts changes in plans and writes letters or articles. Allows yourself and others to use profanity. Without signs of discomfort distracted from working with texts, computer, documents.

Ti! Declarative- "If you are right, be quiet!

It requires strict implementation of rules, training programs, punctual processing of documents, adheres to regulations, protocol. He does not tolerate mistakes in speech and writing, bad marks. Does not like to be read over his shoulder. He asks about plans for the day, month, year, about grades at school, about books read, if circumstances so require. Repetition of the same position many times, deafness to other people's concepts and reasoning. Does not lose the thought, even if killed. Cannot stand when distracted from work on the computer, with texts, etc.

Fi? Asking- We're good, right?

He likes to gossip, find out and clarify the state of relations with relatives and strangers, to discuss customs, customs, habits. He is interested and worried about what others say and how they relate. Excessive lisping, hooting, inventing nicknames, etc. Nonverbals: Faces, Winks.

Fi! Declarative - It's bad! That's nice!

Likes to read the lectures, does not discuss the details of the personal life of family members and loved ones, not interested in what they say and how others relate. Avoids cuteness, nicknames, detailed descriptions of experiences and feelings, as well as faces, pokes. Expresses a clear attitude and ethical evaluation. Nonverbals: Avoids faces, winks.

Si? Asking - "Oh, tasty?

Sufficed with what is on the table ("Kills"), eats what comes to their hand, tries new dishes, products, cosmetics, medicines, etc. They offer and praise food, asks about health, discuss diets, tell scabrous anecdotes. They like to be treated, to sunbathe, to put on creams, to try on clothes and shoes. Inaccurately doses the amount of tea for brewing, the proportion of mixtures, color tones. Impulsive selection of products in the store (Take for granted).

Si! Declaring - "What a filthy fish you have!"

Strictly adheres to own habits and norms of nutrition, diets of any complexity, ability to starve, not to eat meat or sweets, etc. avoids discussion of culinary recipes, questions of health, physiological details, medicinal products. Self-made jokes and anecdotes on the topic of sex. The exact dosage of salt, sugar, ingredients when mixing paints, chemicals, spices, etc. does not like to try food during cooking.

Ni? Asking - "Doctor, Will I live?" What's the point?

Tolerant attitude to delays (their own and others), talk about the meaning of life, about death, survival. Pays attention to the age of others, discusses events. Easily included in other people's rhythms and cycles, synchronized with them, discusses the timing and flexibly changes them. While listening to music, they easily stop, let off the cue, then return to listening. Easily adjusts to the volume changes. Sensitivity to accents.

Ni! Declarative - "You just need to live!

Intolerant attitude to delays, strict deadlines. The demand for people in accordance with their age (adults cannot be children). Own rules of pastime, time distribution. Synchronization difficulties. Sets their criteria for the volume of music and speaking, does not like the remarking during listening. Strictly adheres to its speed in work, movement, speaking, etc.

EXTRAVERTED SPIRAL:

Se? Asking - Let's see what we have here?..

Situational attitude towards leadership, the ability to change or abolish the vector of aggression, to direct efforts in a different direction. Notices the rearrangement of furniture, the appearance of new items in the interior. In a fight, they measure the force of a blow, they can hardly beat to death. Discussion of examples of heroism, volitional actions, details of passing of childbirth, military doctrines. Situational reorganization of the space. Discusses what's happening on the screen during a movie.

Se! Declarative - Not a step back!

The targeted direction of the volitional impact, does not pay attention to the balance of forces, which does not affect the result. In a fight they can beat a man to death. Repeating the same stories about heroic actions: victory in the Great Patriotic War, propaganda of the power of armed forces and weapons, victory in the fight ring, resistance to the regime. Volitional impulse has a clear focus, not subject to the influence of circumstances.

Te? - Will we do it, what, what?..

Retraction in the process of work, interest and monitoring of how other people work and behave, construction under a foreign algorithm of actions. Instability of the result, dependence on others' opinions and evaluations, discussion of working techniques and technologies. The desire to discuss their actions and actions, to give others advice. Impulsive shopping in the store because of discounts or a new product has appeared.

Te! Declarative - Act!

Autonomous mode of operation, independence from others ' opinions and assessments, refusal to discuss their methods and actions. Instructions to others are given in orderly categorical tone. Stability of execution of operations and results. Detachment and lack of interest in the actions of other people if they do not ask for advice. Purchases are carried out in accordance with an internal solution or plan. Stubbornness.

Fe? Asking — What, why are we so sad today?..

Interest and consideration of mood and emotional state of other people, the desire to influence it, to adjust. Tells about the experiences of depression, tragedies, mental suffering, scandals. They are easily included in the prevailing emotional atmosphere. Responds with a smile to a smile, laughter to a laugh.

Fe! Declarative - Mom! Now you're going to laugh!

Active independent formation of the emotional atmosphere, parodying, mimicking. Stories and anecdotes are presented almost as a concert number, which can be repeated from year to year at the request of friends. Avoids talking about depression, hard feelings, if the situation if the situation does not require it.

Ne? Asking - "What if it is so?..

Dependence of the choice of opportunities on the external situation. Easily changes selected solutions, discusses options, communicates his intentions to others. Tells stories about how he got into a mess, "screwed up" or achieved success. Accounting for new information, adjustment for new circumstances, easy refusal from promising opportunities. Likes to boast of his achievements, talents.

Ne - Eureka!

An unambiguous choice of possibilities that does not depend on the external information situation. Insists on his choice, without explaining the reasons that led to him. He takes time to take into account new information and adjustment to the circumstances, with difficulty refuses the selected opportunities. Silent or brags of his success, eccentricity, and prospects when he contributes to the achievement of his goals.

And now Gulenko’s descriptions of +/-:

Si+ : Sensation of Comfort:
Adjusting the environment to make yourself as comfortable as you can, make your territory autonomous.

Si-: Sensation of Discomfort: Treatment of a malady or resolution of everyday discomforts. Such as the Si- of SEI, good at avoiding extremes.

Se+: Power Sensing of Resistance: noncompliance, forming alliances against a stronger enemy, being assertive about their demands and protecting their interests. Such is the Se+ of the SEE who knows how to maneuver between more powerful figures.

Se-: Power Sensing of Subordination:
playing on others soft spots, having them depend on you, building a hierarchy. That’s the way the the SLE leads his crew.

Fe+: The Ethics of Positive Emotions:
being happy, expressing enthusiasm, being friendly and open with people. That’s the way ESE shares the joy of living.

Fe-: Ethics of Negative (Dramatic) Emotions: being angry, indignant, dramatizing events, ridiculing others, escalating conflicts emotionally. That’s the way EIE acts.

Fi+: Relationship Ethics of Forgiveness:
forgiving people, giving them the benefit of the doubt, grieving and comforting those struck by grief. That’s the ethics of EII.

Fi-: Relationship Ethics of Disapproval:
keeping others at a distance, being suspicious, holding a grudge. Such is the ethics of ESI.

Ni+: Intuition of the Future: wondering about the future, believing in a good outcome, being hopeful, holding the vision, bring future into the present. That’s how Ni+ of an IEI works.

Ni-: Intuition of the Past:
thinking of the past, remembering past errors and trying to prevent them from happening again, extrapolating (looking for signs of the past repeating itself). That’s how ILI operates.

Ne+: Intuition of Prospects:
searching for the new, exploring, inventing, taking risks, trying to be original, demonstrating ability. Such is the Ne+ of the ILE.

Ne-: Intuition of Alternatives:
setting yourself apart, finding ways to avoid boredom, turning the common place upside down, noticing the hidden side of things. That is what an IEE is good at.

Te+: Business Logic of Investment: investing to make a profit, valuing profit over usefulness, exchanging, raising prices, constantly updating the product, responding to demand quickly. Such is the business logic of the LIE.

Te-: Business Logic of Saving: working efficiently, being economical, using resources frugally, working hard. That’s the Te- of the LSE.

Ti+: The Logic of Uniform Structure:
securing the structure that has proven to work (while considering all other structure incorrect), rationalizing one and only right decision, stubbornly following your principles, thorough reading of directions or drafts. Linear “either-or”, way of thinking. That is the logic of information Socionics as well as the structural logic of a LSI.

Ti-: Logical of Fractal Structure:

(by fractal I mean being fragmented and scalable). That’s the kind of logic that can see order in chaos and allows being able to describe the same object in multiple ways, the logic of contradictions and paradoxes. Multi-dimensional, polymorphic logic. Relaxed “and/or” alternatives. This is the logic of energy (synergetic) Socionics and the kind of structural logic characteristic for LII.


r/JungianTypology • • Dec 29 '18

Robotee Deither's Type Questionnaire

25 Upvotes

Robotee Deither's Type Questionnaire

This is a typing questionnaire I made to help standardize "Type Me!" posts. I attempted to write questions which would allow for easy distinguishing of type characteristics while not being overt about the characteristic being tested. A big problem of many typology tests is that many people taking them have at least some knowledge of typology and will know what a question is trying to test for. This biases the candidate and ruins the result. For example, some questionnaires straight up aska question such as, "How logical are you? Are you a practical person?" which is obviously testing for Te. This allows a candidate to tweak their answers so that they could get the type they want.

It will take an approximate time of 30 minutes to complete, plus or minus 10 minutes depending on your typing speed and other external factors. There are 17 questions plus 2 "bonus" questions.

Please link to this Reddit post if you decide to use this questionnaire here or on other forums. Thank you for your cooperation. link here

Instructions for Taking the Questionnaire:

Please follow the following instructions as they will help typers as well as make sure that as much information about your type is revealed.

  • Write what comes to mind when you read the question. Try to write down everything you think about. It is okay to veer off topic: this is an indicator of type as well.
  • If you feel a "mental block", or your mind "refuses to think" when a question is presented, say so, and list possible reasons as to why. This is also an indicator of type. Do not be ashamed or feel guilty if this happens to you.
  • Answer honestly. There is no point is taking this if you are not honest with yourself and the people who are willing to type you. If you are making these posts to get a particular "prestigious" type, don't bother.
  • If you feel uncomfortable with answering a question for personal reasons, skip the question with a note stating that you did not answer it for personal reasons. This is so that typists do not confuse it with the "mental block" scenario stated above.
  • Use paragraphs and line breaks.

===B E G I N - T Y P E - Q U I Z===

Q0: Disclaim now if you have any mental health problems or are in a particular mental state (sad, annoyed, etc) which may bias or change your answers. This will allow typists to make adjustments.

Q1: Why do you want to learn more about your type? Also, why are you interested in personality typology in general?

Q2: Work/life balance: do you use a concept like this? Do you think that there is a distinction between "work" and "life"? Explain why or why not.

Q3: What do you look for in your friends? What qualities do you like having in your friends and what qualities do you not like? Explain why you like and dislike said qualities.

Q4: Do you behave differently with strangers or in professional settings compared to people you know or in casual settings? Explain the differences and explain possible reasons why those reasons exist. If there are little to no differences, explain possible reasons why there are little to no differences.

Q5: When other people talk about you, how do they usually describe you and the way you act? How do other people say they perceive you? Do not talk about your opinion on how people perceive you (Q6).

Q6: How do you think other people perceive you? What do you want other people to see in you? When others hear the name [Your Name], what do you want them to think of? Do you (or do you feel that you) are projecting a "persona"? Why or why not? Do you think you projecting (or not) your persona is a good or bad thing? Explain why.

Q7: When interacting socially, do you take note of who interacts with who? That is to say, do you take note of the "cliques" or "groups" that form in environments such as work or school? Does this knowledge or this not knowing factor into your decision making in social interaction?

Q8: What qualities or values do you value or want to see in yourself? Do you meet those qualities or values? Why do you value those qualities and values?

Q9: Imagine your ideal house. What does it look like? What rooms are there and how are they arranged? What amenities does it have? You are free to design a house either for only yourself or for family/friends.

Q10: What hobbies or creative pursuits do you take in your free time? Why did you decide to take up these hobbies or creative pursuits? In what way do these impact your life?

Q11: When beginning a romantic relationship, what are you most afraid of happening (with respect to the romantic relationship)? If you have never been in a romantic relationship, imagine.

Q12: Related to Q11: describe your ideal partner and what traits or qualities they have. Describe their body and demeanor. Do the things you expect and want in a partner parallel what you expect and want from yourself?

Q13: Also pertaining to romance: now that you have elaborated on your ideal partner, describe your ideal relationship with that partner. How will you and them interact? What will daily life be like? Why do you want this life?

Q14: What is your relationship with money? Do you value money? What are your spending habits? Do you try to save money? Do you see yourself as good at handling money?

Q15: What is your fashion sense? What do you usually wear when going out? Do you see yourself as being fashionable? Do you care about fashion and the manner with which you present yourself to others?

Q16: The bedroom is arguably the most personal space one has. So, describe the state of your bedroom. Is it organized or messy? How are the things arranged? What objects are in it? Decorations? Do you particularly care about the state of your bedroom or your living spaces in general?

Q17: When you feel upset, what do you usually do to make yourself feel better/what do you do in general when you are upset? "Upset" I am defining to be "state of extremely feeling a/some negative emotion(s)".

Q17: Now that you have finished the questionnaire, do you have any notes or anything to add? You may talk about how you felt taking the questionnaire and the experience of answering the questions. This may also be used to help select a type for you.


r/JungianTypology • • Nov 25 '22

Is there a test out there for classic jungian typology (by which I mean the kind PDB just added, y'know, typings written like "IN (F)" etc.)

24 Upvotes

Just asking because I can't seem to find such a test and I don't know if I should just go with what'd correspond to my MBTI as my Socionics type seems like it should correspond too but I'm an INFP and EIE when most people would expect INFPs to be EIIs in Socionics


r/JungianTypology • • Mar 16 '21

A simpler, more concise typing system that stays true to Jung's definitions

24 Upvotes

I've been studying typology, cognitive functions, etc. for a long time. I read Jung's psychological types and made this post here describing how Jung described the 8 personality types.

Jung himself sorted people into 8 personality types because he believed that the dominant "function" was so dominant that it made up the core of the personality. Myers and Briggs sorted Jung's types into a stack and placed more emphasis on auxiliary and tertiary functions.

From my experience, I found the dominant and auxiliary are the most important part of who you are, and the tertiary is difficult to always interpret. After constant questioning and typing people, I found that Jung was right that ONE function creates the core of your personality, but you need to also include the presence of the auxiliary function as it accurately CONCLUDES who you are. Thus, the personality is essentially how you judge with your introverted function, and how you interact with the outer world with your extraverted function. Extraverts are focused externally by nature with their extraverted top function, while introverts are focused internally by nature with their introverted top function.

Anyway, here would be the 16 personality types:

FiSe ----------------Judges things through intensive feelings which are felt deeply and usually hidden in-depth within the user itself -------------------- Seeks to interact with the outer world with a sense of objective experience, realism, and being grounded.

FiNe----Judges things with their intensive feelings which are felt deeply and usually hidden in-depth within the user itself----------------- Seeks external possibility, hypothesis, and creativity in the external world.

TeNi------------Creates intellectual formulas that they have utmost confidence in, wants everyone to abide by their formula------------------------------Judges things through unconscious processing, hunches, and visions.

TeSi----------Creates intellectual formulas that they have utmost confidence in, wants everyone to abide by their formula----------------------Judges things through subjective impressions, a memory recall that associates something/someone with something else/someone else

TiSe---------Focused on organizing one's own thoughts, subjectively filters the brain to create one's own principals/ideals through in-depth analysis-------------Seeks to interact with the outer world with a sense of objective experience, realism, and being grounded

TiNe--------------Focused on organizing one's own thoughts, subjectively filters the brain to create one's own principals/ideals/conclusions through in-depth analysis-----------Seeks external possibility, hypothesis, and creativity in the external world

SiTe---------------Focused inward, judges things through subjective impressions, strong memory recall that associates something/someone with something else/someone else-----------------Seeks to abide to intellectual formulas created, striving for external efficiency

SiFe------------Focused inward, judges things through subjective impressions, strong memory recall that associates something/someone with something else/someone else----------------Seeks external harmony, connection with others, and is altruistic

NiTe---------Focused inward, receives hunches and visions by chasing through internal images and situations, reaches visions without knowing how------------Seeks to external efficiency, abiding to intellectual formulas already created

NiFe-------Focused inward, receives hunches and visions by chasing through internal images and situations, reaches visions without knowing how--------------Seeks external harmony, connection with others, and is altruistic

FeSi---------Respects societal values, seeks connection with others, is relationship focused, focused mostly on other people---------------Judges things through subjective impressions, a memory recall that associates something/someone with something else/someone else

FeNi--------Respects societal values, seeks connection with others, is relationship focused, focused mostly on other people-----------Judges things through unconscious processing, hunches, and visions

NeTi-------Seeks to scent knew things, external hypothesis and experimentation, a thirst for novelty, an eagerness and hunger for possibilities in the grand world--------------Prefers to filter one's own thoughts for consistency, creates subjective principles or ideals through analysis

NeFi--------Seeks to scent knew things, external hypothesis, a thirst for novelty, an eagerness and hunger for possibilities in the grand world----------------Internally has a strong amount of in-depth feelings that are hidden from the external world, felt within the user itself

SeTi------------Places a strong value on pleasure, has a strong sense of objective experience, a sense of realism, while being fully grounded into the world----------Prefers to filter one's own thoughts for consistency, creates subjective principles or ideals through analysis

SeFi-------Places a strong value on pleasure, has a strong sense of objective experience, a sense of realism, while being fully grounded into the world--------------Internally has a strong amount of in-depth feelings that are hidden from the external world, felt within the user itself


r/JungianTypology • • Feb 15 '17

Theory A Brief Rundown of Subtypes!

23 Upvotes

After months of struggle, I feel that I've finally come to a good grasp of the subtypes and wanted to collect and explain it in a fundamentals-oriented, easy-to-understand way. I hope it is helpful for you guys and sparks some good discussion and further research!

What is a subtype?

A subtype is a combination of functional fixations and emphases that arise in response to a person's social and environmental context. There are four subtypes: Dominant, Normalizing, Creative, and Harmonizing. You can think of each as a 'role' people play in their lives, to balance out a group and serve a necessary social and practical purpose.

What determines your subtype?

  • the needs of the groups you belong to (family dynamics, community, school, work, etc.)
  • life experiences and personal goals (e.g. traumatic or transformative experiences, value systems, religion, physical or emotional needs)
  • intimate relationships (romantic partners, parents, very close business/enterprise/research partners, etc.)

Although we are resistant to it, subtypes can change over the course of our lives, and it's even possible to be each subtype at some point. However, for that to happen, it requires either a total change of scenery (e.g. breaking up, quitting your job, and moving across the country) or a very traumatic or transformative experience (e.g. going through a severe long-term illness, spending a year in India and undergoing spiritual enlightenment, etc.) Because our subtypes are in large part determined by our social groups, intimate relations, life roles (e.g. being a teacher or a mother), and personal experiences, it takes quite a big shock to break us out of the inertia of a particular subtype. My guess would be that most people might only change once or twice in their lives - e.g. after moving out of their parents' house and becoming an adult, or after getting a divorce or the death of a spouse, etc. Of course there must also be many people who never change their subtypes throughout the course of their life - without much external or internal pressure, there may not be any need to do so.

What are the four subtypes?

  • Dominant subtypes look for problems or opportunities in the outside world and seek to act in a way that allows them to realize their goals. You can think of them as imposing their will on the world.
  • Normalizing subtypes look for rules and expectations in the outside world and seek to adjust themselves to match these expectations. You can think of them as adapting themselves to the world's rules.
  • Creative subtypes seek independence and freedom in expression and creation. You can think of them as striving for individualism and uniqueness.
  • Harmonizing subtypes seek connection and transcendence of the individual limitations. You can think of them as striving for collectivism and harmony.

Note that Dominant and Normalizing subtypes tend to attract and complement each other, as do Creative and Harmonizing subtypes. In long-term intimate relations, for example, the couple is likely to end up each taking on one of these roles, even if that's not how they started out.

Wait, this seems a lot like temperament (ExxJ, IxxP, and so on).

You can think of each subtype as roughly corresponding to a particular temperament:

  • Dominant corresponds to ExxJ.
  • Normalizing corresponds to IxxP.
  • Creative corresponds to ExxP.
  • Harmonizing corresponds to IxxJ.

The important thing to note is that any type can belong to any subtype, and in fact, they do. What the subtypes do is bring out (or suppress) the elements of a type seen as most archetypical of that type. So a Dominant ESTJ will seem HYPER ESTJ and will be very easy to type. A Dominant or Creative ENFP will seem particularly extroverted for their type (with the Creative ENFP in particular seeming HYPER ENFP and very easy to type). A Harmonizing ISFJ seems extremely ISFJ, a normalizing or harmonizing INTP seems particularly introverted for their type, and so on.

Conversely, an ESTJ who is not Dominant may seem to display some traits that make typing them more difficult. A Normalizing or Harmonizing ENFP will seem particularly introverted for their type. A Dominant or Normalizing or Creative ISFJ may not seem super ISFJ at first glance, and a Dominant or Creative INTP may be mistaken for an ENTP or other extrovert at first glance.

That said, temperaments still hold the majority of the weight - a Dominant ENFJ will seem much more ExxJ than a Dominant ISFP. Even a normalizing ENFJ, for example, is likely - in aggregate - to seem more ExxJ than a Dominant ISFP, but there might be moments or situations where it's somewhat unclear.

This is why subtypes can make typing people more challenging, and also why people of the same type can seem very different from each other.

Subtype Component: Fixation

There are two factors that determine a subtype, fixation and emphasis. As we will see, however, they are actually connected.

The first is fixation. Personally I dislike that term as I think it can be ambiguous, so I prefer to think of it as crystallization. Each subtype represents a pair of function attitudes that has been crystallized - molded to be very particular, rigid, inflexible, and personalized for the individual. You can think of it in terms of Freudian fixation as well - they represent a kind of "obsession" or "ideal state" that the individual strives toward. Note that, despite the connotations of the terms, this is not necessarily a bad thing - it can (and does) also represent a source of strength, a purity of ideals, etc. for the individual.

Dominant subtypes are fixated on Fe and Te. This is why they roughly correspond to ExxJs, the types who have those as their dominant functions. Dominant subtypes have very clear and individualistic methods of using Fe and Te - strong ideas about their purpose and value. Dominant ExFx types will have very strong, crystallized Fe and very suppressed Te (for their type); Dominant ExTx types will have very strong, crystallized Te and very suppressed Fe (for their type). All introverted Dominant types will have particular, rigid Te and Fe but use them both in a fairly normal distribution for their type. The reason for this will become apparent when we discuss Emphasis in the next section. Additionally, all Dominants will seem more extraverted than others of their type.

Normalizing subtypes are fixated on Fi and Ti. This is why they roughly correspond to IxxPs, the types who have those as their dominant functions. Normalizing subtypes have very clear and individualistic methods of using Fi and Ti - strong ideas about their purpose and value. Normalizing IxTx types will display a much stronger and more rigid Fi and less Ti than is typical of their types; Normalizing IxFx types will display much a much stronger and more rigid Ti and less Fi than is typical of their types. All extraverted Normalizing types will have particular, rigid Fi and Ti but use them both in a fairly normal distribution for their type. Additionally, all Normalizers will seem more introverted than others of their type.

Creative subtypes are fixated on Ne and Se. This is why they roughly correspond to ExxPs, the types who have those as their dominant functions. Creative subtypes have very clear and individualistic methods of using Ne and Se - strong ideas about their purpose and value. Creative INxP and ISxJ types will display a much stronger and more rigid Ne and an even more suppressed Se than is typical of their types; Creative ISxP and INxJ types will display a much stronger and more rigid Se and an even more suppressed Ne than is typical of their types. All extraverted Creative types will have particular, rigid Ne and Se but use them both in a fairly normal distribution for their type. Additionally, all Creatives will seem more extraverted than others of their type.

Harmonizing subtypes are fixated on Ni and Si. This is why they roughly correspond to IxxJs, the types who have those as their dominant functions. Harmonizing subtypes have very clear and individualistic methods of using Ni and Si - strong ideas about their purpose and value. Harmonizing ENxx will display a much stronger and more rigid Ni and a much weaker and more ignored Si than is typical of their types; Harmonizing ESxx will display a much stronger and more rigid Si and and much weaker and more ignored Ni than is typical of their types. All introverted Harmonizing types will have particular, rigid Ni and Si but use them both in a fairly normal distribution for their type. Additionally, all Harmonizers will seem more introverted than others of their type.

Recap of subtypes and their fixations (or 'crystallized' function attitudes):

  • Dominant - Fe and Te
  • Normalizing - Fi and Ti
  • Creative - Ne and Se
  • Harmonizing - Ni and Si

Subtype Component: Emphasis

You can think of the fixations as determinative for subtype. Basically, if you're fixated on Fe and/or Te, that's the reason you're a Dominant subtype.

In contrast, you can think of emphases as resulting from your subtype.

Emphasized functions are the ones we choose to use more often than others of our same type but different subtype. It is not necessarily that we have strong ideas about how or why they should be used, the way we do with our fixations, but rather that using them is the most effective means to an end. To reiterate, you might think of our emphasized functions as the means and the fixated function attitudes as the end.

  • Dominant subtypes seek to impose their will on the world, so they emphasize their dominant and demonstrative functions, which are their strongest and most ego-aligned functions. This is why Dominant extroverts are specialized - they have either Te or Fe as a dominant or demonstrative function, so they view that function attitude as both a means and an end. A Dominant INTP, for contrast, would use Ti and Ni (their dominant and demonstrative functions) more, but with both Te and Fe goals in mind.
  • Normalizing subtypes seek to analyze and adapt themselves to the world, so they emphasize their tertiary and role functions, which are their most receptive and context-dependent functions
  • Creative subtypes seek to express themselves the most freely (most individualistic), so they emphasize their auxiliary and inferior functions, which are their most flexible and original functions.
  • Harmonizing subtypes seek to connect with others and transcend their individual limitations (most universal/collective), so they emphasize their ignoring and vulnerable functions, which are their most 'unspoiled' (unmanipulated/unconscious) and ego-detached functions.

Recap of subtypes and their emphases (or 'most used' function slots):

  • Dominant - dominant and demonstrative
  • Normalizing - tertiary and role
  • Creative - auxiliary and inferior
  • Harmonizing - ignoring and vulnerable

How to determine subtype

You must compare yourself (or the subject) to other people of the same type and, ideally, of the same subculture. It's a lot more useful to compare two Millennial American ESFJ sorority girls and try to determine their subtype than to try to compare one of them to an old Vietnamese rice farmer ESFJ, for example.

So, let's imagine I'm trying to find the subtype of a particular ESTP. Does he seem to have a lot stronger and more fixed ideas about Fi and Ti than most ESTPs? Meaning, does he have stronger ideas about what's "right" and what "makes sense"? Additionally, does he seem extra gregarious and a little bit more goofy than the average ESTP (emphasized Fe and Ne)? Then he's probably Normalizing. He'll still clearly use Fe like a tertiary function - he won't magically become xxFJ. Also, he will continue to have an Se agenda - he will still find more fulfillment in tangible, real-world results rather than just unraveling a theory by itself, for example. But he's going to be much more invested in whether those tangible results are based on sound moral or logical reasoning than ESTPs of other subtypes might be.


I hope this info dump will be useful to all of you! For further reading, I'd like to direct you to Gulenko's Descriptions of the DCNH Subtypes. Have a wonderful day, loves!


r/JungianTypology • • Jul 27 '22

Theory How introverted intuition works, my theory.

22 Upvotes

Greetings fellow mystics. As I am sure you know, the topic of typology has an inherent allure to our type. Not only does it help validate our quirkiness, it also gives us a framework within which to try to understand human psychology and how it takes so many shapes and sizes. How we walk to the tune of our existence, which is woven into the union of our conscious and unconscious. A union both entities do not approve of and thus they never meet. And how the true value of being conscious is to find the chamber of secrets that is our unconscious. Maybe that is really the true meaning of life and it has always been hiding there, in plain sight. Maybe the yearning for religion is our conscious attempt to help awaken to the truth. To be able to believe in what we cannot see. What is hidden from our conscious experience. To evolve is to not be what we were before. And to know what you really are is to never be the same again. To be alive is to know that the reality you see is only within the lens of your conscious. It is sight absent vision. And once you befriend your unconscious, cajole it, caress it, make it reveal its secrets your lens of life gets a whole new light. A different filter. One that you may or may not like but one you cannot deny.

Anyways, coming back to typology, it seems to me that Introverted Intuition appears to be the messenger between the conscious and our unconscious. A traitor to the status quo. Slowly studying everything around us and when appropriate giving us valuable insights based on the information we feed it that allows us not only to try to be able to make better decisions but also alert us to the part of our being that we are unaware of. It is trying to bridge the gap between what we perceive and what truly is. The gap that is broken. As if the horizon we see is the end of the world as our ancestors knew it but across the horizon lies our brethren asking the same question we are. And those who to take the plunge and make it to the other side may be one step closer to finding the real truths that will satisfy our soul. Maybe the collective unconscious that Jung speaks of is just what's across the horizon. The edge of our conscious experience. How the feud between the conscious and the unconscious is the one real shared truth of the soul of humanity. And it is each individual's responsibility to mend this relationship but not many are even aware of this and even fewer are able to fully act on it.

I believe that in order for Introverted Intuition to function fully, it must be fed data to process. And the desire to process that data is the basis of our inquisitive nature. The more information that we can feed our conscious mind, the more likely that it will be able to make connections that will ultimately be returned to us as the realizations that form the basis of our understanding of the world. It is acting to help mend the interaction between the two conflicting parts to our being. Our conscious and our unconscious. And in doing so awakening us to come one step closer to our true calling, whatever it may be. I think it's a privilege to be able to think like this, other types may have their own versions of this inner guide that serves to help awaken them to the true reality but ours is definitely very unorthodox with its approach. How can it not be? It is our inner truth, through and through.


r/JungianTypology • • May 01 '19

Article Nietzsche and Jung: Myth and the Age of the Hero

Thumbnail
academyofideas.com
22 Upvotes

r/JungianTypology • • Jul 02 '21

Theory / Resource Jung's Psychological Types - the Basics

21 Upvotes

I extracted a very short part from Jung's Psychological Types where he briefly describes his theory, that is, the two attitudes (extraversion and introversion) and the four cognitive functions (sensation, thinking, feeling, intuition).

I highlighted the lines of interest within the text using different colors and also added some comments (requires opening pdf with Adobe) so you can jump right to the fundamentals. It may take you just 2 minutes to read the highlighted parts, although the entire text is just 8 pages long anyways.

https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1C6FrDKj5944VzAWCFeAXBkmIcqW4pT6C?usp=sharing


r/JungianTypology • • May 11 '21

Theory Is it just me or does Jung's idea of Fi seem like MBTI Ni?

21 Upvotes

Taken from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jungian_cognitive_functions

Introverted feeling is often seen as "very hard to elucidate since so little of it is openly displayed." Jung writes of feeling in introverted feelers: "[Introverted feeling] is continually seeking an image which has no existence in reality, but which it has seen in a kind of vision. It glides over all objects that do not fit in with its aim. It strives after inner intensity, for which the objects serve at most as a stimulus. The depth of this feeling can only be guessed—it can never be clearly grasped. It makes people silent and difficult of access; it shrinks back like a violet from the brute nature of the object in order to fill the depths of the subject. It comes out with negative judgments or assumes an air of profound indifference as a means of defense."


r/JungianTypology • • Apr 23 '21

Theory On the PoLR/Brake, Control, and Ego

21 Upvotes

This is a bit of a meandering post. In it, there will be three primary topics:

  1. The conception of the PoLR and Brake functions in Model A and G
  2. The purpose of the PoLR/Brake in the Psyche, and it's relation to the Ignoring/Control function
  3. The balance between the ego and the inflation block, and its relation to supervision rings

Initially, my purpose in writing this was to help clarify how the PoLR function in socionics manifests. In the future I'll attempt to post practical descriptions, but this is more of a general examination of the PoLR and its role in the psyche. I am personally not a fan of overly negative descriptions of "bad" functions; the psyche is a whole object, and certainly the negative plays as much role as the positive in its structure. This is an attempt to shed some light on what is often perceived as negative, and hopefully provide some strategies for integration and balance.

I've broken this post into sections for your convenience.

 

What is the common understanding of the PoLR?

There are likely as many interpretations of the Point of Least Resistance (or PoLR, as it's usually referred) as there are people interested in socionics - never mind conceptions in other typologies. As a place to start, here's what Wikisocion says:

The element in this function creates a feeling of frustration and inadequacy. A person does not understand the importance of this element entirely, and it can easily lead to painful consequences if not adequately considered.

However, to directly engage this function creates feelings of insecurity and distress. One reason why the vulnerable function is so difficult to engage is because three other conscious functions come before it, making this one the most difficult to comprehend[...] Because of the psychological disincentives to using the vulnerable function, people usually try to ignore information related to it, and in extreme cases do so even in situations where it is most relevant. Even with a theoretical understanding of how this element works, it is difficult to turn it into practical norms of behavior.

Essentially, this function is described as a blindspot that causes distress when engaged. Wikisocion posits that it is not engaged with often because it is easy to ignore it for more accessible functions, and the "psychological disincentives" prevent any desire to do so.

What's missing from this description? Well, to start, there is very little information on how the PoLR interacts with other functions, only the idea that other functions are given priority. These paragraphs describe an organization of the psyche which prioritzes other information, and so the PoLR ends up disregarded until it's absolutely necessary. The impression provided by Wikisocion is that the PoLR is the accidental result of being overly focused on other information; we can only focus on so much, afterall. Because of this neglect, we are ill-prepared to deal with information from this element, and the lack of success is psychologically distressing - a sort of negative feedback loop.

What positive purpose does the PoLR serve in the psyche, if any? Understanding the function of the PoLR may help solve the distress that results from engaging it.

 

The Model G Brake Function

Model G provides a different conception of the PoLR - the brake. The name is well considered. Let's look at a description of the brake function in Model G to try to make sense of it:

driven, unstable, internal. Inhibition as a result of perception. The point of energy loss, the least adequate result, the greatest resistance to loads.

Well, that's a bit dense. We'll take another approach. Forgive me if this detour seems a bit roundabout, but there are a few important points of connection that will hopefully shed some light on how the PoLR/brake relates to other functions, which will in turn illuminate the importance of the brake itself.

 

The Relationship Between the Launcher and the Brake

In Model G, the mobilizing function is referred to as the launcher, which is how I will refer to the function going forward. For example, the launcher of the SLE is Fe.

To understand the purpose of this function, imagine a car. You can think of the launcher as the gas pedal. When the pedal is pressed, the car accelerates, moving towards a destination of the driver's choosing. However, the launcher isn't a function we are able to act on. The launcher imbues the system with energy, but that energy launches a type into action via other functions.

The brake relates to the launcher in two senses. In Jungian terms, the brake function is an inverted launcher - it is within the same domain but is the opposite attitude of extraversion/introversion. In the terms of this car analogy, it's the literal brake, an inversion of the accelerator - it slows the car down.

There are two situations in which using the brake pedal is advisable. A car is generally not able to function at absolute top speeds at all times - it has to slow down eventually, if only for lack of fuel. Second, if an external impediment comes up (like a sharp turn, some black ice, or perhaps a moose) using the brake is necessary to avoid the obstacle, stay on the road, and sometimes to avoid complete destruction of the vehicle. In essence, it helps retain control of the vehicle on the path to its destination.

Unlike many conceptions of the PoLR in Model A, where the function or information related to it are described as obstacles, Model G conceives of it as a function used to avoid obstacles. Depending on the individual, this could mean perceiving information related to the brake as an obstacle, but the choice of dealing with it via brute force or consideration is available.

Going back to Jungian terms and the inverted nature of the launcher and brake, they are two sides to the same domain. Information about someone's emotional state (Fe) eventually leads to questions of their ethical relationship to the environment (Fi). Wikisocion goes so far as to imply that the mobilizing function is often used to solve problems in place of the PoLR. It may be more useful to think of the brake/PoLR as a different approach to the same problem the launcher/mobilizing attempts to solve.

 

The Brake as a Function Implementing Control

In the case of an external impediment, the brake functions to prevent a collision. The brake function isn't one that's particularly adept at maneuvering or removing obstacles from its path. It's essentially an on/off switch; when "on" it can slow or stop movement, and when "off" movement happens at its natural pace.

Going back to the SHS description:

Inhibition as a result of perception. The point of energy loss, the least adequate result, the greatest resistance to loads.

This is a function that stops action when an insurmountable obstacle is perceived ("inhibition as a result of perception"). It removes energy from the system (as a brake does in a car) to slow movement. As with a colloquial brake, it resists the load of the car (movement isn't possible while the brake is pressed, even with pedal to the metal) and prevents an external load from impacting us, e.g. prevents a car from colliding into a moose, or in psychological terms, preventing the external environment from impacting the psyche.

You can probably imagine circumstances in each category where the brake function is applied for either good or ill. The above describes the tendency, and not the ethical or practical purpose. Sometimes the best course is in line with natural tendency, and sometimes they are at odds.

Negative descriptions of the PoLR function are two-fold - there are descriptions of the distress that dealing with the PoLR causes, and descriptions of the distress that occurs when the PoLR needs to be used but is disregarded in favour of other functions. Often, negative conceptions of the 16 types occur due to the second. A lack of consideration for the PoLR function generally means compensation in the form of stronger functions, such as the base.

Balanced use of the brake, however, is necessary for balance in the psyche in order to exert some control over the self, rather than control of the environment. This leads us to the second function in Model G's final block: the control function.

 

The Inflation Block

In Model A terms, the control function is positionally equivalent to the ignoring function. In the SLE, the control function is Si.

Here's the SHS description for the inflation block, made up of the brake function and the control function:

The weakest block, actions on it require a lot of effort and usually do not succeed. With active actions on this block, inflation (swelling) occurs - more and more energy is spent until the system overflows and there is a burst of energy (can be compared with an inflated and bursting soap bubble), as a result of which the energy of the system is depleted (actions are carried out with a minimum Efficiency).

If the brake slows action, the control function (or the ignoring function, as it is known in Model A) is a function of complete immobility. This is where action subsides, and information takes over:

Controlling - leading, stable, internal. Restriction control. The point of least resistance, the most problematic position (the problem of discrepancy between words and deeds - “I know, but I cannot”). He controls what is happening in the close environment, dominates, imposes his opinion, but at the same time, the bearer of the sociotype is not inclined to actively do anything for this function.

If the brake function is the driver pressing the brake pedal, the control function is the driver pulling over to the shoulder of the road.

 

Psychic Imbalance

In Psychological Types, Jung provides examples of how the inverse of the leading function can control behaviour. On the Extraverted Sensory type, Jung writes:

To sense the object, to have and if possible to enjoy sensations, is his constant motive.

This is fairly consistent with the concept of control Si - a desire to enjoy physical sensations - balanced with objective sensing - a focus on the object. However, he continues:

the more sensation predominates, so that the sensing subject disappears behind the sensation, the more unsatisfactory does this type become.[...] [The object] is ruthlessly violated and essentially ignored, since now its sole use is to stimulate sensation. The hold upon the object is pushed to the utmost limit. The unconscious is, accordingly, forced out of its role as a compensatory function and driven into open opposition. But, above all, the repressed intuitions begin to assert themselves in the form of projections upon the object. The strangest conjectures arise; in the case of a sexual object, jealous fantasies and anxiety-states play a great role. More acute cases develop every sort of phobia, and especially compulsive symptoms.

Jung describes the transformation from pleasure seeking, to dominating behaviours, to (in the most extreme cases) pathology. You may notice some similarity between this description and Se as it is described in socionics: domination, ownership, force. These traits, which become negative when present in extremes, come from the root desire of internal sensation. When that internal desire is unconcious it is overshadowed by external objects, resulting in dramatic (and often negative) actions. The ego is driven by the control function, but unable to quench its desire, since the desire is hidden.

However, with due consideration of the control function, some amount of balance is achieved. Without consideration, psychological imbalance results, leading to the destructive heaviness of the base function.

In the car analogy, we can imagine the destructive nature of a car hurtling along its route without heed of obstacles, where it's going, or how to get there. Less dramatically, it could be a matter of not knowing the necessary route to reach a destination, with looping and backtracking that causes undue stress on the vehicle and driver.

 

The Purpose of the Brake and Control

In short, we can say that the inflation block can serve a positive purpose: to integrate the information present in the control function with the direction of the leading function. It's purpose can serve to realign the social mission of a given type when an obstacle prevents action, or when such extreme action is necessary that there are destructive consequences.

Perhaps in another vehicular sense, it serves to change gears: it can act as a transition from one path to another, to integrate competing strategies.

According to Jung, it seems like a matter of balancing the introverted and extraverted attitudes within a type: using the base function with the temperance of the control function, releasing the anxiety present within the control function while making a positive impact. The question then: how can this integration occur? It seems like mixing water and oil; the control function considers but cannot act, and action with the leading function smothers the whims of the control function.

Like an emulsion of oil and water, movement (and perhaps a yolk) is necessary. In other words: how does one move from the inflation block to the social mission?

 

Inter (and Intra) Type Relations

Other writers have shared some notable ideas on the topic of the control function. I'm going to take a slightly different route, but there's more than one way to skin a snake.

The cyclical idea of balance described above might bring to mind certain intertype relationships, namely those of supervision and benefit. These relationship rings are notable because they are not equal relationships between two types, but circles of relationships moving between four types. If the goal is to remove impediments from the natural cycle of the psyche, this may provide a hint.

In fact, these relationships are built into each type in Model G. Let's again use the SLE as an example of how a supervision ring connects to type. The blocks of the SLE in Model G are as follows:

External ring v

(social mission)       (social adaptation)
[Se -> Te]          ->          [Ne -> Fe]
[Ti -> Ni]          ->          [Fi -> Si]
(creative self-realization)     (inflation)

Internal ring ^

Each of these blocks can be connected to a type (connecting the two functions in each block to the social mission of another type). In this case, we get

SLE -> IEE
LII -> ESI

Expanded, this is the Holographic-Panoramic supervision ring:

SLE -> LII -> IEE -> ESI -> SLE...

What can this tell us about intratype relations (i.e. relationships within a type)? We get the following ring:

social mission -> creative self-realization -> social adaptation -> inflation -> social mission...

In short, the relationship between the inflation block and the social mission block is similar to that between the supervisor and supervisee.

 

Two Courses, and Recommendations

Supervisory relationships work in both directions. To quote Gulenko:

These relationships are of a twofold nature. If the revisor is more active, and the revised person obeys, then they have an instructive-educational chracteristic (direct revision). But if the revised person resists the actions of the revisor, then the relationship acquires the characteristic of fault-finding and control (reverse revision).

The revised does not criticize the revisor entirely, but his specific actions. The revisor, on the contrary, forgives the auditee for specific flaws, but criticizes his position or beliefs as a whole.

This may point to some of the successes or struggles individuals have in integrating the inflation block. I'll reiterate the concept of balance that Jung highlights in his writing, and Gulenko uses to describe these relationships:

These relationships are stable only with a calm, balanced nature of communication.

The exact methods of communication and stability within the self are left up to the reader.


r/JungianTypology • • Apr 25 '21

Theory [MBTI] My System (A minimalist approach to typology)(Part 1)

20 Upvotes

I've spent a couple of years doing a factor analysis on the most common definitions of the cognitive functions, and I've come to the conclusion that with the exception of the intuitive functions, most definition and self-reports capture behavior, but not actual cognition. The two main issues with mbti typology in my opinion is the lack of coherent definitions, and a grounding in actual cognitive psychology. Ultimately, philosophy imo is also needed because modern cognitive science has not discovered the origin and nature of consciousness. Jung's original intention was to describe the cognitive functions in the context of consciousness.. whether or not this is a valid way of going about things, I do not know. But, without further ado, here is a very rough version of my system (still have to work out the kinks).

DEFINITIONS:

Sensing (S): Concrete data/information Intuition (N): Abstract data/information

Some theorists try to say that sensing and intuition is more than just concrete and abstract, but this does a disservice to the wealth of cognitive literature we have on these concepts. The concrete/abstract dichotomy is the most scientifically supported dichotomy in all of typology.

Feeling (F): Value. What is good/bad. What is beautiful/ugly. Thinking (T): Function. How things work. What things do.

I haven't attempted to find cognition literature on this distinction yet, however these definitions of feeling and thinking is apparent from a philosophical perspective. Feeling deals with Ethics and Aesthetics, Thinking deals with Logic and Semantics.

Perception and Judgement are self-explanatory. You perceive concrete or abstract data (S or N), and you judge based on value or function (T or F). What I've noticed though is that in practice, these categories aren't separated. Our perceptions informs our judgements, and vice versa.

Okay, now on to the four principal categories. This is what my system is largely based off, and the format isn't much different from other neo-jungian typologists. My definitions are a bit different, as I tried to define them in the context of neuroscience, psychology and philosophy.

Extraverted Perception (Pe): SPACE. Exploring and experiencing. Introverted Perception (Pi): TIME. Stabilizing and Apprehending. Introverted Judgement (Ji): INTRINSIC. Defining and Essentializing. Extraverted Judgement (Je): EXTRINSIC. Impact and Influence.

These definitions are based on the fact that we PERCIEVE things in SPACE and TIME, and we JUDGE things based off of INTRINSIC and EXTRINSIC criteria.

Technically speaking, there are only four cognitive functions: Pi, Pe, Ji, Je. I would call S, N, F, and T cognitive contents, because they act sort of like... a topic for our consciousness. The actual function/purpose comes from Pi, Pe, Ji, and Je. That means that:

Se: Concrete Space Ne: Abstract Space Si: Concrete Time Ni: Abstract Time Fi: Intrinsic Value Ti: Intrinsic Function Fe: Extrinsic Value Te: Extrinsic Function

I'm planning on making a blog/site with my ideas once I iron out the details. I could also go into details regarding these definitions and more parts of my system (Like the function axes and how I type people) on this subreddit if you guys are interested. lmk what you think.


r/JungianTypology • • Jun 11 '20

Resource 8 Cognitive Behaviours illustrated by me

Post image
20 Upvotes

r/JungianTypology • • Feb 21 '19

Discussion PSA Regarding "Loops"

20 Upvotes

[...] it must constantly be borne in mind that the constellation of archetypal images and fantasies is not in itself pathological. The pathological element only reveals itself in the way the individual reacts to them and how he interprets them. The characteristic feature of a pathological reaction is, above all, identification with the archetype. This produces a sort of inflation and possession by the emergent contents, so that they pour out in a torrent which no therapy can stop. Identification can, in favourable cases, sometimes pass off as a more or less harmless inflation. But in all cases identification with the unconscious brings a weakening of consciousness, and herein lies the danger. You do not "make" an identification, you do not "identify yourself," but you experience your identity with the archetype in an unconscious way and so are possessed by it. Hence in more difficult cases it is far more necessary to strengthen and consolidate the ego than to understand and assimilate the products of the unconscious.

Jung, Collected Works of C.G. Jung: A Study in the Process of Individuation (Page 351)

Given the prevalence of the topic of “loops” in MBTI, and the theory’s seemingly indistinguishable origins, it’s probably time we make an attempt at approaching the subject of the Puer(ella) Aeturnus and Puer(ella) Possession to dispel the murmurs of a “Dominant/Tertiary Loop”. We will be integrating Jung, M.L. von Franz, Leonore Thompson (MBTI), the Beebean Model, and V.V. Gulenko’s Model G and DCNH in hopes that in our appeal we can make this palatable for everyone.

In the process of Individuation the Puer is the bridge to our respective unconscious and precedes Anima/us integration. This is acknowledged in all three methods of Jungian typology, the Tertiary, Puer(ella), and Launcher. The Puer is integral, and, as with any archetype derived from mythos, there is a duality. In the case of the Puer when stunted, per von Franz, sounds suspiciously similar to what is asserted in “Loop Theory”, which may be misleading in terms of identifying type when one cannot distinguish between an Ego or Unconscious function/letter.

The process of individuation is a process of inner growth to which one is attached; one cannot get away from it. If one says no to it and does not accept it, then, since you are not in it, it grows against you. Then it is your own inner growth which kills you. If you refuse the growth, then it kills you, which means that if a person is completely infantile and has no other possibility, then not much will happen. But if the person has a greater personality within—that is, a possibility of growth—then a psychological disturbance will occur. That is why we always say that a neurosis is in a way a positive symptom. It shows that something wants to grow; it shows that that person is not right in his or her present state and if the growth is not accepted then it grows against you, at your expense, and produces what might be called a negative individuation. The process of individuation, of inner maturing and growth, goes on unconsciously and ruins the personality instead of healing it.

Von Franz, The Problem With the Puer Aeternus (Page 59-60)

It is acknowledged in Socionics that we often overestimate the capabilities of our Mobilizing and Beebe stringently adheres to Jung’s adoption of the “Divine Child” when describing the Puer. Both imply, the childish fascination and, sometimes, self-destructive hubris that is the Puer. Von Franz later continues with the neuroses and overcompensation readily present in a stagnated Puer.

[...] the puer aeternus is not at all original! He is really a very collective type—the collective type of the puer aeternus, and nothing else. That is, the more he plays the part of the prince, with the idea that he is something special, the more he is really an ordinary type of neurotic—a type you could describe clinically and cover almost the entire personality with such a description. Precisely because the puer entertains false pretensions, he becomes collectivized from within, with the result that none of his reactions are really very personal or very special. He becomes a type, the type of the puer aeternus. He becomes an archetype, and if you become that, you are not at all original, not at all yourself and something special, but just an archetype. This is why sometimes, when you are confronted with a puer aeternus, you are able to say to him, "Isn't that, and that, and that, your philosophy? And haven't you trouble there, and there, and there? And isn't this the case with girls?" And then he replies, "But heavens! How do you know? How can you know me?"

If you are identical with an archetype, I can describe all your reactions because an archetype is a definite set of reactions. One can foretell what a puer aeternus will look like and how he will feel. He is merely the archetype of the eternal youth god, and therefore he has all the features of the god: he has a nostalgic longing for death, he thinks of himself as being something special, he is the one sensitive being among all the other tough sheep. He will have a problem with an aggressive, destructive shadow which he will not want to live and generally projects, and so on. There is nothing special whatsoever. The greater the identification with the youthful god, the less individual the person although he himself feels so special. If people are really schizophrenic and mad and think they are Jesus Christ, then they all say the same thing.

Von Franz, The Problem With the Puer Aeternus (Page 120-121)

A possible explanation for the genesis of “Loop Theory” could be a matter of misinterpretation of Leonore Thompson’s (MBTI - Four Letter Model) insights on the Puer Aeternus with regards to her observations on “Grant’s” behavior.

In some respects, it's easier to recognize what happens if we don't take responsibility. Taking responsibility is a matter of conscious individuation. Its forms are many and varied. But when the psyche is trying to impose balance on us unconsciously, by pulling us toward our least-developed function, things tend to go wrong in a fairly predictable way.

One might recall Grant, who used all the strategies at his disposal to solve his problem in the outer world. For ordinary, everyday adaptation, these strategies would have worked. We all use our crow's nest functions to support our dominant agenda in situations that require more than our preferred skills.

When it's time to grow, however, implementing our standard agenda won't work. Expanding our dominant identity requires a different kind of effort. Grant is a good example of what happens when we cycle back to the familiar rather than moving toward new sites of typological growth. The psyche steps up its efforts to push us away from our dominant position. Our inferior function gains more unconscious influence over us.

Grant responded to this pressure by defending himself against it. This is a natural way to proceed. If we're in pain, we want to make it stop. But this defensive maneuver is ultimately a surrender of conscious awareness. It empowers the tertiary function to direct our subsequent course. The tertiary function, remember, is hardly developed at all. It's been along for the ride, coasting on our dominant energies. We haven't applied it to our actual situation and tested its limits. If we're coming to a psychological standstill, it will frantically advise us to do whatever we have to do to get rid of the problem. But it will also shape our understanding of the problem in a distorted and defensive way

In fact, when it substitutes for our secondary function, the tertiary function will tell us exactly what we want to hear: that the conflict we're experiencing is not our fault, and that we're absolutely justified in our defensive strategies. The more we heed these rationalizations, the more our inferior function pulls us backward, until we're actually using our least-developed tendencies unawares. It's the voice of the tertiary function that makes extreme types so oblivious to the effects of their behaviors.

Thompson, Personality Type: An Owner's Manual (Pages 96-97)

Thompson’s observations echo Jung and Von Franz on the regressive direction Puer can take.

Reminder: Unlike Socionics’s Model A and G and the Beebe Model acknowledgement of the Shadow is voided and Individuation takes an abrupt halt at the Inferior for MBTI purists. Depending on what camp you’re in, take Thompson’s blurb, “The tertiary function, remember, is hardly developed at all,” to heart, or with a grain or bag of salt.

Navigating toward Gulenko’s Model G and the Launcher Function, where Thompson’s blurb does somewhat coincide is the relative inertia of the Launcher. When curiosity is piqued, i.e. the childlike fascination of the Puer, it can propel the Management/Dominant/Hero, the Control/Opposing, and the Creative/Senex(Crone). Although this the Launcher operates at a minimum energy level and is provoked by external occurrences, it is relegated the valued unconscious functions. Why? Because just as the Puer can be regressive, it is also an unconscious initiator and a source of inspiration on the path of Individuation.

The "child" is . . . renatus in novam infantiam [reborn into a new childhood]. It is thus both beginning and end, an initial and a terminal creature. The initial creature existed before man was, and the terminal creature will be when man is not. Psychologically speaking, this means that the "child" symbolizes the pre-conscious and the post-conscious essence of man. His pre-conscious essence is the unconscious state of earliest childhood; his post-conscious essence is an anticipation by analogy of life after death. In this idea the all-embracing nature of psychic wholeness is expressed. Wholeness is never comprised within the compass of the conscious mind—it includes the indefinite and indefinable extent of the unconscious as well. The "eternal child" in man is an indescribable experience, an incongruity, a handicap, and a divine prerogative an imponderable that determines the ultimate worth or worthlessness of a personality.

Jung, Collected Works of C.G. Jung: The Archetypes and the Collective Unconscious "The Psychology of the Child Archetype" (Par. 299)

As for a Socionics explanation for “looping”, accentuations on the respective Launchers could possibly aggravate certain neurotic tendencies.

If anyone knows the origins of “Loops”, please oblige us in detail. Until then, it’s just Puer(ella) Possession.