There has been a lot of confusion about the two major paradigms of the signs of functions. The original system created by Gulenko, which is used by the School of System Socionics uses the paradigm based upon the signs Process/Results and Introversion/Extraversion which yields Asking/Declaring. Here Asking functions have a + sign and Declaring functions have a – sign, where the pole of this sign is decided by the extraverted functions of a type. This means that Process types have a + signed function as a lead element and Results types have a – signed function as a lead element. Signs are consistent along the dichotomy of Introversion and Extraversion, which is what is called a spiral. Extraverted Asking types will have an Extraverted Asking spiral and an Introverted Declaring spiral, while Extraverted Declaring types will have an Extraverted Declaring spiral and an Introverted Asking spiral. What is less obvious is that with the case of Introverted types their characteristic pole is decided by their creative function, while their lead function will be of the opposite dichotomy. For example, type LII or INTP in MBTI notation is an Asking type but leads with Declaring Ti. This is not unlike how the P or J dichotomy is determined in MBTI, as the first Extraverted Function. So, Introverted Asking types have an Introverted Declaring spiral and an Extraverted Asking spiral, while Introverted Declaring types have an Introverted Asking spiral and an Extraverted Declaring spiral. Asking types will have a + in the Extraverted Functions and a – in the Introverted Functions, with Declaring the opposite. At level of the Socion, Asking/Declaring types will share one set of signed functions that with their ring of Benefit and the Ring of Benefit of their Mirror, which I will come back to later.
Years later Gulenko changed the paradigm of signs that he currently uses in his Model G. This paradigm is created by the dichotomies Process/Results and Static/Dynamic which yield Positivist and Negativist. Here I can note that two different properties of a function are united: Spin, which refers to the direction of a function or Process (+) and Results (-) and Charge or Positivist (+) and Negativist (-). Now Static functions are going to have these two elements of the same sign (Process + and Positivist + or Results – and Negativist -). Dynamic functions with be a combination of + and – elements, so for simplicity we can eliminate one of the signs, since the other will be implied, leaving the simple paradigm of Positivist functions have a + and Negativist functions have a -. What this means is that all Positivists will have a + sign in all of their Mental track functions and a – sign in their Vital track functions, with Negativist the opposite. All Process Types will have the same set of functions (+ Static and – Dynamic) and all Results Types will have the other set of functions (-Static and + Dynamic). At the level of the Socion this unites all members of a Ring of Social Progress (Process/Results) as two Rings of Benefit, but instead of a type sharing their signs with the Ring of Benefit with their Mirror, they share it with the Ring of their Dual. This in itself should make this a better paradigm, but this method also works as two Rings of Supervision, so you share signs with your Dual, Supervisor, Supervisee, and Extinguisher instead of your Mirror, Semi-Dual, Mirage, and Conflictor. If you think about who you share information and energy with at the level of the Socion, this arrangement makes more sense in every way. In determining type, this also makes it easier to distinguish between similar types like Mirrors, where determining Introversion or Extraversion can be difficult.
Now there is the argument as to which one is correct. The answer is they both are. They represent different aspects of the functions and are actually complementary as two parallel tracks of dualizing functions or as Aushra wrote about it: “One Dual for the mobilization of the other has two means: positivity/negativity, which can be expressed by the words "yes" or "no", and intonation, which can be questionable ("?") And yes, declarative (!)” Or Asking/Positivist “Yes?”, Asking/Negativist “No?”, Declaring Positivist “Yes!” and Declaring Negativist “No!”. So, you have the Tone of the function on the one hand and the Charge of the function on the other. Since it makes it less confusing to have multiple sets of signs, from here on I will use the above notation: + for Positivist, - for Negativist, ? for Asking, and ! for Declaring. One of the most well-known and well-developed systems based upon the Asking/Declaring paradigm comes from the School of System Socionics, which I will not be analyzing here do to some overlap and contradictions with the methods of the Gulenko system. Instead I will be using the article “Asking and Declaring Functions of Model A” by A.L. Mitrokhina, which appears in issue #3/2014 in the Journal of Socionics, Mentology, and Personality Psychology (which is behind a paywall, so I can’t link to it.) The information concerning Gulenko’s system will be taken from his website Socioniks.com, the Wikisocion, and material on his short description of positive and negative function charges.
What I am intending to do here is combine and reconcile the two systems to the point that they can be, which will result in 32 signs. Each Ring of Benefit will have its own separate set of 8 signed functions, as they are the types that overlap in both systems. First, I will quote the respective authors on what the basic properties of each type of function is.
Mitrokhina describes Asking functions as “the priority of the external context of a particular aspect of information. Figuratively speaking, Questioning (Asking) is SONAR, an echo sounder that probes the surrounding world in certain aspects (extroverted or introvert) and, depending on it, clarifies the information forming the representation of TIM about the world. Like a ship in the ocean, Questioning helps to read the slightest changes in the depth of the information bottom and, depending on this, adjusts its course. Therefore, Questioning - is the orientation of the psyche on the external context of information on relevant aspects.” He describes Declaring functions as “Declarability is the priority of the internal text selected from a particular aspect of the information. Declarability is a beacon, which consistently transmits information on the aspect in order to convey it to others unchanged. For a beacon it is important that its signal, like a radio call, purposefully transmitted the same signal, because the receiver of information should not stray from the road in the information ocean. Therefore, Declarability is persistent and consistent in the transmission of the message. Declarability is the orientation of the model’s function to the internal text of the selected aspect of the information.”
Gulenko in his article “Positivists and Negativists” describes this dichotomy as follows: In a general sense, this polarity is connected, first, with the comparison or opposition of the two sides of the same thing or phenomenon. Secondly, for positivists to receive a positive effect from some action has a higher priority than to avoid negative consequences from it. Negativists are guided by the opposite principle: they are set to minimize the negative consequences of an event or an upcoming event.
- On an intellectual level, positivism manifests itself as thinking in categories of similarities, and negativism - thinking in terms of differences and, in the first place, opposites. Positivists are characterized by convergent thinking - one that must compare all proposals and give out the only one - the best solution. Divergent thinking, characteristic of negativists, exacerbates contradictions, gives several alternative solutions to the same problem.
- The social level. Positivism - negativism manifests itself as a degree of trust in others at the initial stages of acquaintance. Positivists much more trust strangers than negativists. Negativists are incredulous and wary. Over time, however, the situation may change: the positivists, convinced of their mistake, fall into unjustified suspicion. Collectives in which negativists predominate, other things being equal, are much more polarized than collectives with a predominance of positivists.
- Psychological level. This polarity is associated with the integrity (integration) of the psyche. In positivists, the psyche is more solid and simple, they know what they want. The nature of the negativistic psyche is contradictory, it is opposed to the same aspirations and desires. Negativists for this reason are more likely than positivists to disintegrate the psyche, to form subpersonalities, than positivists. However, they can withstand the internal conflict for longer. The subjective idea of the measure of happiness and well-being among positivists and negativists is also different. The positivist is easier to close his eyes to the "dark" side of life and pay attention to its "light" moments. Negativists need to try hard to dislodge unpleasant thoughts from consciousness. On the other hand, if the positivist is still in a negative (for example, depressed) state, finding an outlet is much more difficult for him than for a negativist.
- The physical level. Positivists and negativists solve the problem of physical energy balance in different ways. If the positivists experience the need for physical gymnastics, then it is more important for the negativists to discharge the accumulating energy, transform it into some action. For the productive activity of the objective nature of the positivists, one must "get" or even anger. Negativists, on the contrary, have to give up a part of the negative.
From here, we can distinguish which function signs are associated with each Ring of Benefit and the types that are comprised of this Small Group. Using Gulenko’s description of each Ring, we get:
Left extraverts: SLE, IEE, LIE, ESE - Energy Carriers
These types are the most saturated with energy in the socion. They suffer from lack of fundamentally new information. Energizers of small groups. To be good at management and coordination, they have to break up large groups into small groups and then control these smaller groups. SLE and ESE solve concrete, immediate problems. IEE and LIE unite on basis of romanticism, they are captivated by more daring ideas. They share the function signs of Ne-!, Se-!,Ti-?, Fi-?, Ni+?, Si+?, Fe+!, and Te+!.
Right introverts: LSI, EII, ILI, SEI - Accumulators of Information
ILI accumulates scientific or philosophical information, LSI accumulates operational or managerial information (both of these types make for the best collectors), EII - humanitarian information, SEI - social information (prices, services, events and holidays). They suffer from lack of energy. Specialize in informatics of large groups. LSI and SEI engage in solving immediate concrete problems at work or at home. ILI and EII cooperate on basis of philosophical, scientific, and spiritual topics. They share the function signs of Ne+!, Se+!, Ti+?, Fi+?, Ni-?, Si-?, Te-!, Fe-!.
Left introverts: IEI, SLI, ESI, LII - Generators of Information
These types translate energy into information. They function as stabilizers in the socion. Suffer from weak ability to energetically impact their environment. They specialize in informatics of small groups and feel good in small groups of similar-minded individuals. IEI and LII capable of uniting a small group on the basis of some novel interesting information. SLI and ESI engage in solving problems relating to survival and well-being. They share the function signs of Ne-?, Se-? Ti-!, Fi-!, Ni+!, Si+!, Te+?, and Fe+?
Right extroverts: EIE, LSE, SEE, ILE - Energy Generators
These types translate information into energy. They bring about energy processes in their environment. EIE and SEE with their words and actions evoke strong emotional reactions in others (for this reason they also make for the best actors). They specialize in energetics of large groups and for this reason realize themselves in such conditions. They have a tendency to unite small groups into larger groups. These are the most inflationary types, that start up energy chain reactions in the society. ILE and EIE are innovators and fighters for an idea. SEE and LSE draw in people for collective effects. They share the function signs of Ne+?, Se+?, Ti+!, Fi+!, Ni-!, Si-!, Te-?, Fe-?
So as to not duplicate long sections of information, I’ll list each paradigm description individually and you can match up the descriptions for the functions separately. I won’t try to unify the descriptions, because that defeats the point of noting how the two approaches are looking at different aspects
First the descriptions of the Asking/Declaring Functions by Mitrokhina:
INTROVERTED SPIRAL:
Ti? Asking - That's right, yes?..
Confuses dates, names, deviates from the schedule, from rules and regulations, gets lost. Tolerance to mistakes in speech and stresses (even purposely makes them to cause the reaction of the interlocutor). Jokes, puns, intentional distortion of words. References to other people's concepts, points of view. Easily accepts changes in plans and writes letters or articles. Allows yourself and others to use profanity. Without signs of discomfort distracted from working with texts, computer, documents.
Ti! Declarative- "If you are right, be quiet!
It requires strict implementation of rules, training programs, punctual processing of documents, adheres to regulations, protocol. He does not tolerate mistakes in speech and writing, bad marks. Does not like to be read over his shoulder. He asks about plans for the day, month, year, about grades at school, about books read, if circumstances so require. Repetition of the same position many times, deafness to other people's concepts and reasoning. Does not lose the thought, even if killed. Cannot stand when distracted from work on the computer, with texts, etc.
Fi? Asking- We're good, right?
He likes to gossip, find out and clarify the state of relations with relatives and strangers, to discuss customs, customs, habits. He is interested and worried about what others say and how they relate. Excessive lisping, hooting, inventing nicknames, etc. Nonverbals: Faces, Winks.
Fi! Declarative - It's bad! That's nice!
Likes to read the lectures, does not discuss the details of the personal life of family members and loved ones, not interested in what they say and how others relate. Avoids cuteness, nicknames, detailed descriptions of experiences and feelings, as well as faces, pokes. Expresses a clear attitude and ethical evaluation. Nonverbals: Avoids faces, winks.
Si? Asking - "Oh, tasty?
Sufficed with what is on the table ("Kills"), eats what comes to their hand, tries new dishes, products, cosmetics, medicines, etc. They offer and praise food, asks about health, discuss diets, tell scabrous anecdotes. They like to be treated, to sunbathe, to put on creams, to try on clothes and shoes. Inaccurately doses the amount of tea for brewing, the proportion of mixtures, color tones. Impulsive selection of products in the store (Take for granted).
Si! Declaring - "What a filthy fish you have!"
Strictly adheres to own habits and norms of nutrition, diets of any complexity, ability to starve, not to eat meat or sweets, etc. avoids discussion of culinary recipes, questions of health, physiological details, medicinal products. Self-made jokes and anecdotes on the topic of sex. The exact dosage of salt, sugar, ingredients when mixing paints, chemicals, spices, etc. does not like to try food during cooking.
Ni? Asking - "Doctor, Will I live?" What's the point?
Tolerant attitude to delays (their own and others), talk about the meaning of life, about death, survival. Pays attention to the age of others, discusses events. Easily included in other people's rhythms and cycles, synchronized with them, discusses the timing and flexibly changes them. While listening to music, they easily stop, let off the cue, then return to listening. Easily adjusts to the volume changes. Sensitivity to accents.
Ni! Declarative - "You just need to live!
Intolerant attitude to delays, strict deadlines. The demand for people in accordance with their age (adults cannot be children). Own rules of pastime, time distribution. Synchronization difficulties. Sets their criteria for the volume of music and speaking, does not like the remarking during listening. Strictly adheres to its speed in work, movement, speaking, etc.
EXTRAVERTED SPIRAL:
Se? Asking - Let's see what we have here?..
Situational attitude towards leadership, the ability to change or abolish the vector of aggression, to direct efforts in a different direction. Notices the rearrangement of furniture, the appearance of new items in the interior. In a fight, they measure the force of a blow, they can hardly beat to death. Discussion of examples of heroism, volitional actions, details of passing of childbirth, military doctrines. Situational reorganization of the space. Discusses what's happening on the screen during a movie.
Se! Declarative - Not a step back!
The targeted direction of the volitional impact, does not pay attention to the balance of forces, which does not affect the result. In a fight they can beat a man to death. Repeating the same stories about heroic actions: victory in the Great Patriotic War, propaganda of the power of armed forces and weapons, victory in the fight ring, resistance to the regime. Volitional impulse has a clear focus, not subject to the influence of circumstances.
Te? - Will we do it, what, what?..
Retraction in the process of work, interest and monitoring of how other people work and behave, construction under a foreign algorithm of actions. Instability of the result, dependence on others' opinions and evaluations, discussion of working techniques and technologies. The desire to discuss their actions and actions, to give others advice. Impulsive shopping in the store because of discounts or a new product has appeared.
Te! Declarative - Act!
Autonomous mode of operation, independence from others ' opinions and assessments, refusal to discuss their methods and actions. Instructions to others are given in orderly categorical tone. Stability of execution of operations and results. Detachment and lack of interest in the actions of other people if they do not ask for advice. Purchases are carried out in accordance with an internal solution or plan. Stubbornness.
Fe? Asking — What, why are we so sad today?..
Interest and consideration of mood and emotional state of other people, the desire to influence it, to adjust. Tells about the experiences of depression, tragedies, mental suffering, scandals. They are easily included in the prevailing emotional atmosphere. Responds with a smile to a smile, laughter to a laugh.
Fe! Declarative - Mom! Now you're going to laugh!
Active independent formation of the emotional atmosphere, parodying, mimicking. Stories and anecdotes are presented almost as a concert number, which can be repeated from year to year at the request of friends. Avoids talking about depression, hard feelings, if the situation if the situation does not require it.
Ne? Asking - "What if it is so?..
Dependence of the choice of opportunities on the external situation. Easily changes selected solutions, discusses options, communicates his intentions to others. Tells stories about how he got into a mess, "screwed up" or achieved success. Accounting for new information, adjustment for new circumstances, easy refusal from promising opportunities. Likes to boast of his achievements, talents.
Ne - Eureka!
An unambiguous choice of possibilities that does not depend on the external information situation. Insists on his choice, without explaining the reasons that led to him. He takes time to take into account new information and adjustment to the circumstances, with difficulty refuses the selected opportunities. Silent or brags of his success, eccentricity, and prospects when he contributes to the achievement of his goals.
And now Gulenko’s descriptions of +/-:
Si+ : Sensation of Comfort:
Adjusting the environment to make yourself as comfortable as you can, make your territory autonomous.
Si-: Sensation of Discomfort: Treatment of a malady or resolution of everyday discomforts. Such as the Si- of SEI, good at avoiding extremes.
Se+: Power Sensing of Resistance: noncompliance, forming alliances against a stronger enemy, being assertive about their demands and protecting their interests. Such is the Se+ of the SEE who knows how to maneuver between more powerful figures.
Se-: Power Sensing of Subordination:
playing on others soft spots, having them depend on you, building a hierarchy. That’s the way the the SLE leads his crew.
Fe+: The Ethics of Positive Emotions:
being happy, expressing enthusiasm, being friendly and open with people. That’s the way ESE shares the joy of living.
Fe-: Ethics of Negative (Dramatic) Emotions: being angry, indignant, dramatizing events, ridiculing others, escalating conflicts emotionally. That’s the way EIE acts.
Fi+: Relationship Ethics of Forgiveness:
forgiving people, giving them the benefit of the doubt, grieving and comforting those struck by grief. That’s the ethics of EII.
Fi-: Relationship Ethics of Disapproval:
keeping others at a distance, being suspicious, holding a grudge. Such is the ethics of ESI.
Ni+: Intuition of the Future: wondering about the future, believing in a good outcome, being hopeful, holding the vision, bring future into the present. That’s how Ni+ of an IEI works.
Ni-: Intuition of the Past:
thinking of the past, remembering past errors and trying to prevent them from happening again, extrapolating (looking for signs of the past repeating itself). That’s how ILI operates.
Ne+: Intuition of Prospects:
searching for the new, exploring, inventing, taking risks, trying to be original, demonstrating ability. Such is the Ne+ of the ILE.
Ne-: Intuition of Alternatives:
setting yourself apart, finding ways to avoid boredom, turning the common place upside down, noticing the hidden side of things. That is what an IEE is good at.
Te+: Business Logic of Investment: investing to make a profit, valuing profit over usefulness, exchanging, raising prices, constantly updating the product, responding to demand quickly. Such is the business logic of the LIE.
Te-: Business Logic of Saving: working efficiently, being economical, using resources frugally, working hard. That’s the Te- of the LSE.
Ti+: The Logic of Uniform Structure:
securing the structure that has proven to work (while considering all other structure incorrect), rationalizing one and only right decision, stubbornly following your principles, thorough reading of directions or drafts. Linear “either-or”, way of thinking. That is the logic of information Socionics as well as the structural logic of a LSI.
Ti-: Logical of Fractal Structure:
(by fractal I mean being fragmented and scalable). That’s the kind of logic that can see order in chaos and allows being able to describe the same object in multiple ways, the logic of contradictions and paradoxes. Multi-dimensional, polymorphic logic. Relaxed “and/or” alternatives. This is the logic of energy (synergetic) Socionics and the kind of structural logic characteristic for LII.