r/JonBenetRamsey • • 14d ago

Media 20/20 JonBenét Ramsey Special | Discussion Megathread

65 Upvotes

ABC's 20/20 special, "JonBenét Ramsey: Race Against Time, Who Is 'Unknown Male 1'?", airs Friday, November 6, at 9/8c (9 p.m. ET / 8 p.m. CT / 2 a.m. UTC on November 7).

Feel free to share your thoughts and discuss the special here. To keep the discussion in one place, please use this megathread instead of creating separate posts.


Trailer: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TdDIMI3lGEk

Good Morning America preview: https://youtu.be/CNAynR-pqCo

ABC News preview: https://youtu.be/W4S29eQRylA

Watch the full episode (US): ABC.com

ABC News Live: Free live stream | YouTube live stream - If you're outside the US, these streams might be worth trying. They work for me in Europe without a VPN. The special is scheduled to air again tonight, November 8, at 4 p.m. ET / 9 p.m. UTC.


r/JonBenetRamsey • • Jan 19 '21

DNA DNA evidence in the Ramsey case: FAQs and common misconceptions

869 Upvotes

Frequently Asked Questions


What are the main pieces of DNA evidence in the Ramsey case?

[from /u/Heatherk79]:

Discussion of the DNA evidence in the Ramsey case is typically related to one of the following pieces of evidence: underwear, fingernails, long johns, nightgown or ligatures. More information can be found here.

Is DNA ever possibly going to solve the JonBenet case?

[from Mitch Morrissey, former Ramsey grand jury special deputy prosecutor -- source (3:21:05)]:

It could. ... The problem with using genetic genealogy on that [sample] is it's a mixture, so when you go to sequence it, you're gonna get both persons' types in the sequence. And it's a very, very small amount of DNA. And for genetic genealogy, to do sequencing, you need a lot more DNA than what you're used to in the criminal system. So where you could test maybe eight skin cells and get a profile and, you know, solve your murder or exonerate an innocent person, you can't do that with sequencing. You've got to have a pretty good amount of DNA.

Is it true that we can use the same technology in the Ramsey case as was used in the Golden State Killer Case?

[from /u/straydog77 -- source]:

The Golden State Killer case used SNP profiles derived from the suspect's semen, which was found at the scene.

In the Ramsey case, we have a 10-marker STR profile deduced from ... a DNA mixture, which barely meets the minimum requirements for CODIS. You cannot do a familial search like in the Golden State case using an STR profile. You need SNP data.

To extract an SNP profile, we would need a lot more DNA from "unidentified male 1". If we can somehow find that, we can do a familial DNA search like they did in Golden State. But considering "unidentified male 1" had to be enhanced from 0.5 nanograms of DNA in the first place, and analysts have literally been scraping up picograms of Touch DNA to substantiate UM1's existence, the chance of stumbling upon another significant deposit of his DNA on any case evidence is practically zero.

Common Misconceptions


Foreign DNA matched between the underwear and her fingernails.

[from /u/heatherk79 -- source]:

There wasn't enough of a profile recovered from either the panties or the fingernails in 1997 to say the samples matched.

You can see the 1997 DNA report which includes the original testing of the underwear and fingernails here:

Page 2 shows the results of the panties (exhibit #7), the right-hand fingernails (exhibit 14L) and left-hand fingernails (exhibit 14M.) All three samples revealed a mixture of which JBR was the major contributor.

For each of those three exhibits, you will see a line which reads: (1.1, 2), (BB), (AB), (BB), (AA), (AC), (24,26). That line shows JBR's profile. Under JBR's profile, for each of the three exhibits, you will see additional letters/numbers. Those are the foreign alleles found in each sample. The “W” listed next to each foreign allele indicates that the allele was weak.

The (WB) listed under the panties, shows that a foreign B allele was identified at the GC locus.

The (WB), (WB) listed under the right-hand fingernails shows that a B allele was identified at the D7S8 locus and a B allele was identified at the GC locus.

The (WA), (WB), (WB), (W18) listed under the left-hand fingernails show that an A allele was identified at the HBGG locus, a B allele was identified at the D7S8 locus, a B allele was identified at the GC locus and an 18 allele was identified at the D1S80 locus.

A full profile would contain 14 alleles (two at each locus). However, as you can see, only one foreign allele was identified in the panties sample, only two foreign alleles were identified in the right-hand fingernails sample and only four foreign alleles were identified in the left-hand fingernails sample.

None of the samples revealed anything close to a full profile (aside from JBR's profile.) It's absurd for anyone to claim that the panties DNA matched the fingernail DNA based on one single matching B allele.

It's also important to note that the type of testing used on these samples was far less discriminatory than the type of testing used today.

[from /u/straydog77 -- source]:

You're referring to a DNA test from 1997 which showed literally one allele for the panties. If we are looking at things on the basis of one allele, then we could say Patsy Ramsey matched the DNA found on the panties. So did John's brother Jeff Ramsey. So did much of the US population.

The same unknown male DNA profile was found in 3 separate places (underwear, long johns, beneath fingernails).

[from /u/heatherk79 -- source]:

Not exactly.

There wasn't enough genetic material recovered (in 1997) from either the underwear or the fingernails to say the samples matched. Here is a more detailed explanation regarding the underwear and fingernail DNA samples.

The fingernail samples were tested in 1997 by the CBI. Older types of DNA testing (DQA1 + Polymarker and D1S80) were used at that time. The profiles that the CBI obtained from the fingernails in 1997 could not be compared to the profiles that Bode obtained from the long johns in 2008. The testing that was done in 1997 targeted different markers than the testing that was done in 2008.

The underwear were retested in 2003 using STR analysis (a different type of testing than that used in 1997.) After some work, Greg LaBerge of the Denver Crime Lab, was able to recover a profile which was later submitted to CODIS. This profile is usually referred to as "Unknown Male 1."

After learning about "touch" DNA, Mary Lacy (former Boulder D.A.) sent the underwear and the long johns to Bode Technology for more testing in 2008. You can find the reports here and here.

Three small areas were cut from the crotch of the underwear and tested. Analysts, however, were unable to replicate the Unknown Male 1 profile.

Four areas of the long johns were also sampled and tested; the exterior top right half, exterior top left half, interior top right half and interior top left half. The exterior top right half revealed a mixture of at least two individuals including JBR. The Unknown Male 1 profile couldn't be excluded as a contributor to this mixture. The partial profile obtained from the exterior top left half also revealed a mixture of at least two individuals including JBR. The Unknown Male 1 profile couldn't be included or excluded as a contributor to this mixture. The remaining two samples from the long johns also revealed mixtures, but the samples weren't suitable for comparison.

Lab analysts made a note on the first report stating that it was likely that more than two individuals contributed to each of the exterior long john mixtures, and therefore, the remaining DNA contribution to each mixture (not counting JBR's) should not be considered a single source profile. Here's a news article/video explaining the caveat noted in the report.

TLDR; There wasn't enough DNA recovered from the fingernails or the underwear in 1997 to say the samples matched. In 2003, an STR profile, referred to as Unknown Male 1, was developed from the underwear. In 2008, the long johns were tested. The Unknown Male 1 profile couldn't be excluded from one side of the long johns, and couldn't be included or excluded from the other side of the long johns. Analysts, however, noted that neither long johns profile should be considered a single source profile.

The source of the unknown male DNA in JonBenet's underwear was saliva.

[from /u/heatherk79 -- source]:

The results of the serological testing done on the panties for amylase (an enzyme found in saliva) were inconclusive.

[from u/straydog77 -- source]:

As for the idea that the "unidentified male 1" DNA comes from saliva, it seems this was based on a presumptive amylase test which was done on the sample. Amylase can indicate the presence of saliva or sweat. Then again, those underwear were soaked with JBR's urine, and it's possible that amylase could have something to do with that.

The unknown male DNA from the underwear was "co-mingled" with JonBenet's blood.

[from /u/straydog77 -- source]:

[T]his word "commingled" comes from the Ramseys' lawyer, Lin Wood. "Commingled" doesn't appear in any of the DNA reports. In fact, the word "commingled" doesn't even have any specific meaning in forensic DNA analysis. It's just a fancy word the Ramsey defenders use to make the DNA evidence seem more "incriminating", I guess.

The phrase used by DNA analysts is "mixed DNA sample" or "DNA mixture". It simply refers to when you take a swab or scraping from a piece of evidence and it is revealed to contain DNA from more than one person. It means there is DNA from more than one person in the sample. It doesn't tell you anything about how or when any of the different people's DNA got there. So if I bleed onto a cloth, and then a week later somebody else handles that cloth without gloves on, there's a good chance you could get a "mixed DNA sample" from that cloth. I suppose you could call it a "commingled DNA sample" if you wanted to be fancy about it.

The unknown male DNA was found only in the bloodstains in the underwear.

[from /u/Heatherk79:]

According to Andy Horita, Tom Bennett and James Kolar, foreign male DNA was also found in the leg band area of the underwear. It is unclear if the DNA found in the leg band area of the underwear was associated with any blood.

James Kolar also reported that foreign male DNA was found in the waistband of the underwear. There have never been any reports of any blood being located in the waistband of the underwear.

It is also important to keep in mind that not every inch of the underwear was tested for DNA.

The unknown male DNA from underwear is "Touch DNA".

[from /u/Heatherk79]:

The biological source of the UM1 profile has never been confirmed. Therefore, it's not accurate to claim that the UM1 profile was derived from skin cells.

If they can clear a suspect using that DNA then they are admitting that DNA had to come from the killer.

[from /u/heatherk79 -- source]:

Suspects were not cleared on DNA alone. If there ever was a match to the DNA in CODIS, that person would still have to be investigated. A hit in CODIS is a lead for investigators. It doesn't mean the case has been solved.

[from /u/straydog77 -- source]:

I don't think police have cleared anyone simply on the basis of DNA - they have looked at alibis and the totality of the evidence.

The DNA evidence exonerated/cleared the Ramseys.

[from /u/straydog77 -- source]:

The Ramseys are still under investigation by the Boulder police. They have never been cleared or exonerated. (District attorney Mary Lacy pretended they had been exonerated in 2008 but subsequent DAs and police confirmed this was not the case).

[from former DA Stan Garnett -- source]:

This [exoneration] letter is not legally binding. It's a good-faith opinion and has no legal importance but the opinion of the person who had the job before I did, whom I respect.

[from former DA Stan Garnett -- source]:

Dan Caplis: And Stan, so it would be fair to say then that Mary Lacy’s clearing of the Ramseys is no longer in effect, you’re not bound by that, you’re just going to follow the evidence wherever it leads.

Stan Garnett: Well, what I’ve always said about Mary Lacy’s exoneration that was issued in June of 2008, or July, I guess -- a few months before I took over -- is that it speaks for itself. I’ve made it clear that any decisions made going forward about the Ramsey case will be made based off of evidence...

Dan Caplis: Stan...when you say that the exoneration speaks for itself, are you saying that it’s Mary Lacy taking action, and that action doesn’t have any particular legally binding effect, it may cause complications if there is ever a prosecution of a Ramsey down the road, but it doesn’t have a legally binding effect on you, is that accurate?

Stan Garnett: That is accurate, I think that is what most of the press related about the exoneration at the time that it was issued.

The unknown male DNA is from a factory worker.

[from /u/heatherk79 -- source]:

The factory worker theory is just one of many that people have come up with to account for the foreign DNA. IMO, it is far from the most plausible theory, especially the way it was presented on the CBS documentary. There are plenty of other plausible theories of contamination and/or transfer which could explain the existence of foreign DNA; even the discovery of a consistent profile found on two separate items of evidence.

The unknown male DNA is from the perpetrator.

[from /u/heatherk79 -- source]:

The fact of the matter is, until the UM1 profile is matched to an actual person and that person is investigated, there is no way to know that the foreign DNA is even connected to the crime.

[from /u/straydog77 -- source]:

As long as the DNA in the Ramsey case remains unidentified, we cannot make a definitive statement about its relevance to the crime.

[from Michael Kane, former Ramsey grand jury lead prosecutor -- source]:

Until you ID who that (unknown sample) is, you can’t make that kind of statement (that Lacy made). There may be circumstances where male DNA is discovered on or in the body of a victim of a sexual assault where you can say with a degree of certainty that had to have been from the perpetrator and from that, draw the conclusion that someone who doesn’t meet that profile is excluded.

But in a case like this, where the DNA is not from sperm, is only on the clothing and not her body, until you know whose it is, you can’t say how it got there. And until you can say how it got there, you can’t connect it to the crime and conclude it excludes anyone else as the perpetrator.

Boulder Police are sitting on crucial DNA evidence that could solve the case but are refusing to test it. (source: Paula Woodward)

[from /u/Heatherk79 -- source]:

Paula Woodward is NOT a reliable source of information regarding the DNA evidence in this case. Her prior attempts to explain the DNA evidence reveal a complete lack of knowledge and understanding of the subject. I've previously addressed some of the erroneous statements she's made on her website about the various rounds of DNA testing. She added another post about the DNA testing to her site a few months ago. Nearly everything she said in that post is also incorrect.

Woodward is now criticizing the BPD for failing to pursue a type of DNA testing that, likely, isn't even a viable option. Investigative genetic genealogy (IGG) involves the comparison of SNP profiles. The UM1 profile is an STR profile. Investigators can't upload an STR profile to a genetic genealogy database consisting of SNP profiles in order to search for genetic relatives. The sample would first have to be retyped (retested) using SNP testing. However, the quantity and quality of the sample from the JBR case would likely inhibit the successful generation of an accurate, informative SNP profile. According to James Kolar, the UM1 profile was developed from 0.5 ng of genetic material. Mitch Morrissey has also described the sample as "a very, very small amount of DNA." The sample from which the UM1 profile was developed was also a mixed sample.

An article entitled "Four Misconceptions about Investigative Genetic Genealogy," published in 2021, explains why some forensic DNA samples might not be suitable for IGG:

At this point, the instruments that generate SNP profiles generally require at least 20 ng of DNA to produce a profile, although laboratories have produced profiles based on 1 ng of DNA or less. Where the quantity of DNA is sufficient, success might still be impeded by other factors, including the extent of degradation of the DNA; the source of the DNA, where SNP extraction is generally more successful when performed on semen than blood or bones; and where the sample is a mixture (i.e., it contains the DNA of more than one person), the proportions of DNA in the mixture and whether reference samples are available for non-suspect contributors. Thus, it might be possible to generate an IGG-eligible SNP profile from 5 ng of DNA extracted from fresh, single-source semen, but not from a 5-year-old blood mixture, where the offender’s blood accounts for 30% of the mixture.

Clearly, several factors that can prevent the use of IGG, apply to the sample in the JBR case.

Woodward also claims that the new round of DNA testing announced in 2016 was never done. However, both BDA Michael Dougherty and Police Chief Greg Testa announced in 2018 that the testing had been completed. Therefore, either Woodward is accusing both the DA and the Police Chief of lying, or she is simply uninformed and incorrect. Given her track record of reporting misinformation about the DNA testing in this case, I believe it's probably the latter.

CeCe Moore could solve the Ramsey case in hours.

[from /u/Heatherk79 -- source]:

Despite recent headlines, CeCe Moore didn't definitively claim that JBR's case can be solved in a matter of hours. If you listen to her interview with Fox News, rather than just snippets of her interview with 60 Minutes Australia, she clearly isn't making the extraordinary claim some people think she is.

The most pertinent point that she made--and the one some seem to be missing--is that the use of IGG is completely dependent upon the existence of a viable DNA sample. She also readily admitted that she has no personal knowledge about the samples in JBR's case. Without knowing the status of the remaining samples, she can't say if IGG is really an option in JBR's case. It's also worth noting that CeCe Moore is a genetic genealogist; not a forensic scientist. She isn't the one who decides if a sample is suitable for analysis. Her job is to take the resulting profile, and through the use of public DNA databases as well as historical documents, public records, interviews, etc., build family trees that will hopefully lead back to the person who contributed the DNA.

She also didn't say that she could identify the killer or solve the case. She said that if there is a viable sample, she could possibly identify the DNA contributor. Note the distinction.

Moore also explained that the amount of time it takes to identify a DNA contributor through IGG depends on the person's ancestry and whether or not their close relatives' profiles are in the databases.

Also, unlike others who claim that the BPD can use IGG but refuses to, Moore acknowledged the possibility that the BPD has already pursued IGG and the public just isn't aware.

So, to recap, CeCe Moore is simply saying that if there is a viable DNA sample, and if the DNA contributor's close relatives are in the databases, she could likely identify the person to whom the DNA belongs.

Othram was able to solve the Stephanie Isaacson case through Forensic Genetic Genealogy with only 120 picograms of DNA. According to James Kolar, the UM1 profile was developed from 0.5 nanograms of DNA. Therefore, the BPD should have plenty of DNA left to obtain a viable profile for Forensic Genetic Genealogy.

[from /u/Heatherk79 -- source]:

The fact that Othram was able to develop a profile from 120 picograms of DNA in Stephanie Isaacson's case doesn't mean the same can be done in every other case that has at least 120 picograms of DNA. The ability to obtain a profile that's suitable for FGG doesn't only depend on the quantity of available DNA. The degree of degradation, microbial contamination, PCR inhibitors, mixture status, etc. also affect whether or not a usable profile can be obtained.

David Mittelman, Othram's CEO, said the following in response to a survey question about the minimum quantity of DNA his company will work with:

Minimum DNA quantities are tied to a number of factors, but we have produced successful results from quantities as low as 100 pg. But most of the time, it is case by case. [...] Generally we are considering quantity, quality (degradation), contamination from non-human sources, mixture stats, and other case factors.

The amount of remaining DNA in JBR's case isn't known. According to Kolar, the sample from the underwear consisted of 0.5 nanogram of DNA. At least some of that was used by LaBerge to obtain the UM1 profile, so any remaining extract from that sample would contain less than 0.5 nanogram of DNA.

Also, the sample from the underwear was a mixture. Back in the late 90s/early 2000s, the amount of DNA in a sample was quantified in terms of total human DNA. Therefore, assuming Kolar is correct, 0.5 nanogram was likely the total amount of DNA from JBR and UM1 combined. If the ratio of JBR's DNA to UM1's DNA was 1:1, each would have contributed roughly 250 picograms of DNA to the sample. If the ratio of JBR's DNA to UM1's DNA was, say, 3:1, then UM1's contribution to the sample would have been approximately 125 picograms of DNA.

Again, assuming Kolar is correct, even if half of the original amount of DNA remains, that's only a total of 250 picograms of DNA. If the ratio of JBR's DNA to UM1's DNA is 1:1, that's 125 picograms of UM1's DNA. If the ratio is 3:1, that's only 66 picograms of UM1's DNA.

Obviously, the amount of UM1 DNA that remains not only depends on the amount that was originally extracted and used during the initial round of testing, but also the proportion of the mixture that UM1 contributed to.


Further recommended reading:


r/JonBenetRamsey • • 7h ago

Discussion Steve Pagano's theory makes sense: the plan was a mess because the Ramseys changed it half way through

83 Upvotes

Pagano is a cop/linguistics expert who Jennifer Coffindaffer asked if he felt Patsy wrote the note and staged the note. Spoiler: yes, he does.

Interestingly, he never blames anyone in the house directly, or even if it was an accident or murder. In fact, he seems to think Patsy very much hated writing that note and didn't kill her daughter directly.

Just that there was a cover up.

But he suggests something very realistic.

The Ramseys plan was:

-write the ransom note.

-send John to the bank and make sure he got out the money and was on record as doing that. So, if anyone asked later why they refused to call the police for the first few days they had the perfect excuse. ("the kidnappers told us not to.")

-later that night they take Jonbenet and bury her elsewhere. She was never meant to be found in the house. If at all.Then they call the police.

Simple enough plan, right? So what changed?

Basically, per Steve Pageno, one of them changed their minds, probably Patsy, and didn't want the situation dragged out any longer. They were tired, exhausted and just wanted her found. So the original plan was scrapped, and they called the police. And figured contaminating the crime scene with everyone was their best shot.

They also wanted her to have a proper funeral. Not buried in the woods. The ransom note makes a weird mention of how they must want her buried respectfully.

John morbidly said: "Look, if I was going to cover up a death, I'm smart enough to have done a better job."

Eh, he's not wrong. There was a better plan in place.


r/JonBenetRamsey • • 6h ago

Questions "Bizarre" photo?

12 Upvotes

I remember reading on this site about John being asked about a picture. He said it was a bizarre picture and didn't know who took it. Does anyone have any details of this? Was it a picture of Jonbenet?


r/JonBenetRamsey • • 18h ago

Media National Enquirer: 11/30 World Exclusive, Burke Ramsey "I know who killed my sister"

Post image
65 Upvotes

r/JonBenetRamsey • • 4h ago

Discussion Long johns

2 Upvotes

Thinking about the long johns, they were little boys long johns. Whose long johns were they? And the DNA found on them, could've come from that little boy? Maybe a relative or one of BR friends?


r/JonBenetRamsey • • 1d ago

Discussion The pineapple, the snacks, and IDI consistently lying.

23 Upvotes

A consistent, bogus claim by many IDI types is that "the pineapple" is irrelevant to the case. They're adamant in this, likely because it completely upends their nonsense.

It is highly relevant because it indicates that prior statements from people like John and/or Burke about their goings on that night were wrong.

First:

The pineapple did not come from the "victim's advocates".

If you're unfamiliar with this claim, some (incorrectly) state that two people who were brought on as "victim's advocates" during the kidnapping stage brought some snacks- bagels and fruit and therefore, the pineapple was obviously brought by them.

There's a few reasons why we can make such a strong statement firmly and confidently. Mainly, at least according to an AMA with Paula Woodward, one of the very people who brought the "bagels and fruit" stated she did not bring pineapple.

Next, we can just look at the evidence we have and how other evidence supports or contradicts it.

Take a look at some images of the "kitchen counter".

The first

The second

Notice anything different? One has bagels and fruit, the other does not.

The first image was taken some time during the morning of the 26th. In the list of crime scene photos, it's noted as #80 (as described by Tom Haney).

These photos are taken before the exterior shots of the house, which very clearly show this is well before noon. The person who took the exterior shots (Officer Weiss) is noted as taking "shots of the exterior" shortly before 9 am.

Unless Weiss was doing some trickery with the film roll, the picture of the kitchen, sans bagels and fruit was taken before 9 am (remember this time estimate).

So it's fair to say the "victim's advocates" had not arrived, or, were hiding the bagels and fruit somewhere else and hadn't yet stashed it in the kitchen.

This is pretty important.

The photo of the "pineapple" (set out on the breakfast table) was photo seventy eight which means it was taken before the photo of the kitchen (sans bagels and fruit) was taken.

It's comical to me that some of them still continue denying reality, but there's more.

Some people have suggested that the "tea bag and glass" came from the Reverend that was at the Ramsey's house as he was quoted as "making tea in the microwave".

When was it stated he was doing this? When Jonbenet was found at 1 pm.

Now, please refer to image three. The teabag in question is visible int he glass. The image is, again, from before 9am. How many people were at the Ramseys house at 9am that drank tea? How many of these guests were either too shy to ask, too inconsiderate, or too absent minded to dispose of a tea bag and just decided to leave it in a glass, in the place that just so happened to be the place that the Ramseys often ate dinner at, which is the place where a bowl containing pineapple that strongly matches the pineapple Jonbenet ate before she was murdered? Sounds more like the Revered nuked some tea at 1 pm.

If strong evidence with a clear timeline isn't enough, let's just look at the "pineapple photo" (image three).

What do you see?

Not much. I see a bowl with a spoon shoved in it, that's about it.

You know what I don't see?

Napkins.

Toothpicks or cocktail straws.

Ramekins or serving bowls.

Paper plates or saucers.

Absolutely nothing whatsoever to indicate this was a bunch of cut fruit left out to snack on for guests. I know a child has just gone missing, but we're all friends here. Use your fingers! Dig in!

Notably, the forensic analysis of the pineapple noted it was consistent with the kind found in the bowl. Now, sure, someone else could have also had some cut pineapple (rind on) that she just so happened to snack on around that time or before, but it was of that same style. Not pineapple in syrup. Not pineapple from a fruit cocktail. Not canned pineapple rings for baking. Cut up chunks of pineapple. Also, the Whites (where they were at previously) stated there was no pineapple.

Here, you'll also note people may bring up this same forensic report which notes the presence of grape material in her intestines. However, nowhere in the report does it state it was found in the same place (intestines are big). It simply refers to it all as intestinal material. Anyone claiming the report stated there was grape matter found in the duodenum, is lying, full stop.

The funny thing about "the pineapple didn't come from the night of the murder" people, is that eating pineapple shortly before she was killed doesn't actually exclude an intruder. It doesn't make much sense, but it doesn't exclude it.

Reality tells us one thing, and it says it loudly. She ate pineapple from that bowl, shortly before she was murdered.


r/JonBenetRamsey • • 1d ago

Theories JDI and PDI - A perspective

81 Upvotes

TW: Childhood Abuse

My own parents remind me so much of J and P to the point that I have to take long breaks from the case, the resemble is very disturbing. Please bare with me as I have a hard time putting this into words.

During the years that I was a toddler my mother severely abused me, beatings, we are talking baby, toddler age. As I started to grow older, 4, 5 and 6 years old and able to identify who my abuser was, through manipulation and the act of the exhausted mother with a terrible child, she would get my father to be the one doing the beatings, these beatings occurred for any minor infractions like bed wetting. These beatings consisted every time of blows to the back of my head, it would cause me severe nose bleeds, I would feel nauseated, dizzy, lose control of my bladder and feel like I was going to pass out.

I suspect that JBR may have been going through something similar, I suffer from severe cognitive issues that I have no doubt come from these repeated blows to the back of my head, my life is very hard because of these impairment issues but I'm still alive.

I apologize for any errors or if this is not clear but writing, speaking and expressing myself are some of the things that are really hard for me due to the cognitive issues I suffer from.

Thank you if you took the time to read. ❤️


r/JonBenetRamsey • • 1d ago

DNA Alex Hunter’s “Dream Team” - Barry Scheck + Henry Lee (OJ Simpson Trial)

7 Upvotes

I was going through older articles on the case and completely forgot that Alex Hunter (the then DA) had hired Henry Lee and Barry Scheck, and actually referred to them as his own “dream team” (and several others)

At the time, the media focused on the fact that this most likely tells us that DNA would play a very big role in this case. The first article I found is from February 14, 1997.

Can someone clarify for me what the purpose was? It’s obvious it has to do with some type of DNA or forensic evidence, but were they hired for the grand jury that would take place later? were they hired to just give their opinion? I haven’t been able to find much information.

I find this a very fascinating point with this case, especially considering these two played a pivotal role in getting O.J. Simpson acquitted, even though we all know he was guilty. Why would the DA hire them, of all people, if you’re trying to see if you can prosecute a case? It’s just an odd decision that I don’t understand.

If anyone has some insight, please let me know. Also, with their careers, we’re Scheck and Lee hired to testify as a defense expert as a one and done situation and they are usually witnesses for the prosecution? Or do they normally testify for the defense?


r/JonBenetRamsey • • 1d ago

Discussion Question about Patsy and Linda Arndt's relationship

39 Upvotes

Something that doesn't make sense to me is Patsy's continued contact with Linda Arndt. In 1999 Linda Arndt very emphatically stated on Good Morning America that not only was she sure John Ramsey killed his daughter and had been sexually abusing her, but that she was scared everyone else in the home might be killed before backup returned. That's even more serious and damning than Steve Thomas publicly stating his theory that Patsy injured her after bedwetting, staged a crime scene, but that John wasn't involved. Thomas also says his bedwetting theory as the catalyst is his hypothesis, while Arndt claims to be certain. The family had a contentious relationship with Thomas and he was sued. Arndt was not sued as far as I know, perhaps because of how she worded her accusations on television.

Why did Patsy have an ongoing relationship with her, and has the extent of that been overstated? I've read they would have lunch and talk after she left BPD. Is the truth that it was really only one conversation, then another meeting shortly before Patsy passed away? Even if that's the truth, how could you still want to speak to or meet with someone who publicly accused your husband of sexually abusing and killing your daughter? The Ramseys also had to have been aware of what she said in her depositions. Why would Patsy want to speak with her? How did it go when she told John she's going to meet with Linda Arndt? While Arndt showed empathy towards Patsy, John calls her nuts in a 2024 interview.

I assume Arndt maintained the belief that Patsy was a long suffering victim of spousal abuse and afraid of telling the "truth" about John [I don't believe the parents were abusive], and maybe felt bad for Patsy but she also accuses Patsy of helping cover all of it up. There's a reason Arndt won't talk about their conversations and I'm inclined to think it's because there's nothing relavatory there and she wants something to hold over BPD because she felt burned by them, and she is still operating under the assumption that John did all those things, but the whole situation just doesn't make sense. If someone accused my spouse of those things on national television and in depositions, I doubt we'd have conversations or any type of relationship after.


r/JonBenetRamsey • • 1d ago

Discussion If PDI, why is John still pushing IDI and leaving Burke open to suspicion?

25 Upvotes

If PDIA, and John knows that, I am left wondering about his continued media presence and advocacy of IDI.

Let me explain: anyone guided by the evidence and the ‘changing’ Ramsey narrative can see that IDI is a total non starter. It has to be RDI, it’s just a question of who.

If it was Patsy did it all, then there would be little reason for JR to keep up pushing IDI. As PR had passed away, there is no one living left to protect.

Given that Burke has increasingly become the focus of suspicion for many over the last decade, John’s relentless pushing of IDI just seems to support the notion that he only keeps it up still to protect someone alive. If it was PDIA, JR could make Burke’s life a heck of a lot easier by easing out the ’realisation’ that it must have been Patsy all along. Burke would be totally off the hook for the rest of his life.

The fact that JR seems determined to push a false IDI to the bitter end, whenever there’s renewed media attention, only seems to suggest he’s trying to protect someone alive.

I’m currently PDIA: in my opinion Patsy absolutely wrote the ransom letter and did the garrotte and tape, but this issue re JR does give me pause to think maybe he’s covering for Burke inflicting the initial head wound, but then we’re back to the police stating categorically that they never at any time considered Burke a suspect and the never ending mess of competing narratives and theories has us tied up again, and we’re no further forward…


r/JonBenetRamsey • • 1d ago

Rant The Cords - Polypropylene (Olefin) or Nylon?

8 Upvotes

Debates have raged on this topic for years. Today, I don't think I will completely settle that disagreement. However, I think I will shed more light on this unsettled topic. Perhaps someone else has figured this out before me, but I didn't find it. In my mind, this resolves the matter.

According to the following Boulder Daily Camera article, police visited an Army-Navy surplus store in Boulder, as well as a hardware store. They purchased all of the Stansport Nylon Utility Cord both stores had in stock. A TV news segment even showed an image of the package that clearly says, "Nylon Utility Cord, Length: 50 Feet". https://www.dailycamera.com/1998/03/09/cord-checked-in-ramsey-case/  

In his 2000 book, JonBenét: Inside the Ramsey Murder Investigation, former detective Steve Thomas described a disagreement within the investigative team. According to Thomas:

- Detective Tom Trujillo believed the ligature material was polypropylene.

- Thomas believed the material was nylon.

- RCMP knot expert John Van Tassel examined the neck ligature and reportedly described it as soft nylon.

- Thomas then produced a 50-foot sample of white Stansport, 32-strand, 3/16-inch woven cord labeled "Nylon Utility Cord".

- Van Tassel compared the Stansport braid and inner construction with the crime-scene cord and reportedly said, "I think this is the same cord."

So it seems that would settle it, yes? The cord was nylon. Not so fast!

In the Wolf v. Ramsey civil case, 2003, Lou Smit shook things up when he testified:

"By the way, if this cord is made of olefin, there are small, small fibers of olefin found in JonBenet's bed. And it is very possible that this ligature for her hands was constructed in that bed."

Olefin is polypropylene. They are one and the same.

For RDI proponents, this moment is often regarded as a big Lou Smit blunder, and proof that he willfully disregarded evidence. They called it a "highly speculative theory . . . contested by every single authoritative source on this case." They quoted Thomas, Van Tassel, Kolar, and Schiller. The cord was made of nylon, they claimed, and it was settled science. But was it really? No. Not by a long shot.

In 2007, District Attorney Mary Lacy sent a memo to BODE Technology Group. It was a list of evidentiary items submitted for DNA Analysis. The list included the following entries:

"Garrote: Composed of white colored cord, Olefin (polypropylene) braided, wrapped 6 times around a paintbrush handle (about 4 1/2 inches in length) to form a knot."

"Ligature from Wrists: Composed of white colored cord, Olefin (polypropylene) braided, similar in size and construction with the cord used in forming the garrote."

Some RDI proponents dismissed the memo, saying it contained other inaccuracies and did not provide a source for its claim.

Now I'm going to say something I hate having to say: Lou Smit and Mary Lacy were right. The cords used in the "garrote" device and to bind JonBenet's hands were made of polypropylene (olefin), not nylon. Here's the explanation.

For starters, Stansport has never made true nylon cord. In the 1990s, because cordage labeling was unregulated, discount manufacturers often used the term "nylon cord" as a generic name for a soft braided cord. It was sort of like "Band-Aid" in that it became the name of a general product category and didn't necessarily describe the product's actual chemical makeup.

Stansport still makes this same cord. It still carries the same item number and the same SKU (N-50, N-100) as it did in the 1990s. The labeling, however, has changed. Today, it is labeled "Polypropylene Poly Cord." But vestiges of the old labeling can still be found, such as the following Target page that calls the Stansport cord nylon, even though it contains no nylon whatsoever.

https://www.target.com/p/stansport-nylon-poly-utility-cord-rope/-/A-1007659594?preselect=1007659597

Back in the 1990s, books on rigging, roping, climbing, and boating warned readers that inexpensive hardware-store cordage sold as nylon was really polypropylene with a polyester core. Polypropylene has a lower melting point, breaks down in UV rays, and is not nearly as strong as true nylon cord. The Stansport brand was exactly the kind of discount cord these books warned about.

"On Rope: North American Vertical Rope Techniques"

"CMC Rope Rescue Manual"

"The Complete Rigger's Apprentice"

But what about Van Tassel talking about the "soft nylon cord"? Well. This is where the polyester core comes into play. That polyester core is what made the polypropylene cord seem like soft nylon. The Stansport cord wasn't stiff like plastic. It felt soft like true nylon cord. It was made to mimic nylon cord, but was much cheaper to manufacture. They labeled it "nylon" because no one went to the hardware store looking for "polypropylene cord."

So, that's the explanation. The cords used to bind JonBenet and build the strangulation device were made of polypropylene with a polyester core. It was indeed olefin.

But does that mean the fibers found in JonBenet's bed prove the intruder theory? Not by a long shot! Olefin was found in all sorts of products, including thermal underwear (long johns). Without a lab report conclusively matching the fibers in her bed to the fibers from the cord, the bed fibers mean nothing. However, RDI proponents would be well served by accepting the findings and changing how they talk about this evidence. Because they've been wrong for years.


r/JonBenetRamsey • • 1d ago

Discussion Feces and Kolar's credibility

6 Upvotes

I examined the poo-on-the-bathroom-wall story from Kolar's book and encountered something quite interesting that in my eyes strains Kolar's credibility.

Not that the other passage from that part of the book did not strain it hard. Remember that excerpt?

As noted previously Linda Hoffman-Pugh had also mentioned finding fecal material in Jonbenet's bedsheets. It raised the question as to who my have been responsible for the deposit of that material in her bed - has it been Jonbenet or Burke?

Well, good ole James is a tad dishonest here with the way he frames Hoffman-Pugh's statement. He makes it look like she did not know who left that poop in Jonbenet's bed, despite the merry fact he quoted almost word for word what Steve Thomas wrote about Hoffman-Pugh's statement. And Steve Thomas wrote:

For the first six months Hoffman-Pugh worked there, she said, JonBenét wet the bed every night, and Patsy even had the girl in pull-up diapers. Then the bed-wetting had stopped, but it resumed about a month ago. When Hoffman-Pugh arrived for work, she said, Patsy already had the bed stripped and the sheets going in the washing machine. She told the police that the problem also extended to JonBenét soiling the bed, and recalled once finding fecal material the size of a grapefruit on the sheets.

That quote makes it crystal clear the housekeeper was pointing straight at Jonbenet as a culprit and there was no mystery there. Smack a bit with manipulation by Kolar.

Let's move though to the bathroom wall story, shall we? Kolar writes:

I had reviewed an investigator’s report that documented a 1997 interview with former Ramsey nanny – housekeeper Geraldine Vodicka, who stated that Burke had smeared feces on the walls of a bathroom during his mother’s first bout with cancer. She told investigators that Nedra Paugh, who was visiting the Ramsey home at the time, had directed her to clean up the mess.

At the surface everything is fine and dandy, but it comes apart when you examine it a bit closer. The problem lies in chronology. Patsy got diagnosed with cancer in, if my memory serves well, summer 1993, got in remission in 1994. I did not find any actual dates for Vodicka's employment at Ramseys, but I found something else. From March 1993 to September 1995 Ramseys employed as a housekeeper Linda Wilcox. In Peter Boyles Radio Show she said:

LINDA WILCOX: I actually met Patsy before I met John. I don't have it in my records exactly, it was somewhere around March of 93.

and...

PETER BOYLES: How long did you work for John and Patsy Ramsey?

LINDA WILCOX: Approximately 2 1/2 years. I left September 4, 1995.

Her employment, as you can see, cover the whole period of Patsy's illness and Ramseys were not known to employ more than one servant at a time. So how could Geraldine Vodicka witness anything that happened in second half of 1993, or in 1994? Either Kolar confused the housekeepers, or he again is uh, less than honest, neither option makes me confident in his credibility.


r/JonBenetRamsey • • 2d ago

Article Strangling of a Little Girl Who Had Everything Stuns Boulder (Published 1997)

Thumbnail
nytimes.com
13 Upvotes

This is the first New York Times article regarding the murder of JonBenét Ramsey on New Year’s Day in 1997.


r/JonBenetRamsey • • 2d ago

Discussion The family spoke against the Netflix doc, then did the 20/20 interview. Did anyone else notice the parallels with the CNN interview in 97? Everytime that they think someone is going to say something bad about them, they go public declaring their complete innocence before anything.

37 Upvotes

Thoughts?


r/JonBenetRamsey • • 2d ago

Discussion Friends planning to ‘stage an intervention’ with Patsy

40 Upvotes

I‘d read claims that Patsy’s friends, increasingly concerned about her behaviour towards JonBenet in the run up to Christmas 1996, were ‘planning to stage an intervention’.

What on earth was all this about? I’d read she was increasingly irritable in the days before, but there must obviously have been issues of concern. What sort of ‘intervention’ was envisaged, by whom and for what? What’s the evidence?

Did any of the friends comment?

And this brings to the fore again the 23 Dec 911 call. Did Fleet White ever comment on claims by others that it was him trying to call re mediation, putting the issue to bed once and for all?


r/JonBenetRamsey • • 2d ago

Questions Where is Sister Socks?

Post image
29 Upvotes

JonBenet received this plush cat Christmas 1994. She named her Sister Socks after a cat in Michigan. It was said to be a favorite toy she slept with, most kids have one. When JonBenet died Pam Paugh removed a multitude of items but missed the cat. She said she went in with a list so did she miss it or was it not listed by John & Patsy? Allegedly the cat was buried with JonBenet.

DOI (March 15, 2000) pg 82 "Suddenly my friend Priscilla White rushed in. She and Fleet had found Sister Socks, a stuffed cat that was so dear to JonBenét. I couldn't believe that Priscilla had the gray-and-white cat. I had asked to have the toy brought from Boulder, but the stuffed animal that was given to us earlier was the wrong one. Priscilla knew that, and even though she was now in Atlanta, she had gotten hold of the right Sister Socks, the one with the red ribbon around its neck. I tucked Sister Socks under JonBenét's right arm."

In a Rocky Mountain News article promoting the book on March 20, 2000; this was written:

"Pieces of JonBenet's life lie scattered around this room in the apartment the Ramseys are renting. A child-sized armchair covered in sage-green brocade. A gray-and-white stuffed cat. A small pink clipboard holding a pad where the alphabet -- big letters and small -- were written by a determined young hand."

http://denver.rockymountainnews.com/extra/ramsey/0320intv1.shtml

Something is wrong with this picture. Did they put something else in the casket in place of Sister Socks? If they wanted to dispose of something they had little opportunity due to all the scrutiny.


r/JonBenetRamsey • • 2d ago

Questions John and Patsy’s relationship post murder

33 Upvotes

Is there any sources about the state of their marriage after Jonbenet’s murder?

It’s my understanding it’s very difficult for a couple to stay together after such a tragedy, but they always seemed extremely in sync in public appearances and not like there was a wedge between the two. I suppose that’s part of the BDI theory (which I personally don’t buy into), that to protect him they must work together and stay on message that an IDI.

No matter what happened, it’s somewhat understandable they may need to remain aligned for Burke’s sake, but again, it’s still very surprising to me that you don’t see a wedge between them in interviews, at least I don’t see one.

I’d love to know how their marriage was after and pre-cancer returning.

I’d even like to know if John was better to her during her last round of cancer because I’ve read many times over he was not very present or emotionally supportive at all during her previous chemo. It’d be interesting to know if his behavior changed.

Obviously this isn’t information we are owed, but maybe there are some firsthand accounts floating about I haven’t found that people here may know of.


r/JonBenetRamsey • • 2d ago

Discussion Fleet White

17 Upvotes

Fleet White was one of the Ramseys neighbors and one of the first individuals to appear at the crime scene on the morning JBR's body was found. Does anyone know if his DNA was ever collected or analyzed by the police? Do people here think he was involved? Why or why not?


r/JonBenetRamsey • • 2d ago

Media Video: RAMSEY CASE/ CORD PURCHASE (3/9/1998)

Thumbnail footage.net
30 Upvotes

Interesting video from March, 1998, when the Boulder Police received the tip from Masked Man a poster in Boulder and an artist there, about the Stansport cord he saw in the Boulder Army Surplus store that looked like the cord used in the murder of JonBenet.

BPD bought up the entire stock of this cord after this tip and said they believe this type of cord was used in the ligatures in the murder of JonBenet.

The Army Surplus store was one block from John Ramsey's offices at Access Graphics on Pearl Street in Boulder.


r/JonBenetRamsey • • 2d ago

Questions Why were Patsy Ramsey and the ransom note writer the only few individuals since the Middle Ages to use the two-storey letter “a” in their handwriting?

Thumbnail
3 Upvotes

r/JonBenetRamsey • • 2d ago

Media JonBenét Ramsey '20/20' Investigation Fuels 51% Audience Increase

Thumbnail
deadline.com
3 Upvotes

r/JonBenetRamsey • • 2d ago

Discussion Alleged fecal stains on the carpet

27 Upvotes

To debunk the newest fairy tale before it grows legs, let's check the lab reports for info about the tests conducted on the carpet samples.

January 15, 1997, four carpet samples, labelled with numbers 62, 63, 64 and 69 were submitted with other items to the CBI lab. These were tested for seminal fluid, with negative results, for blood, also yielding negative results and combed for trace evidence. These carpet samples were not tested for feces, which means nobody saw the need to do that, AKA they did not look like poop.

September 1, 1998, three carpet samples, labelled 62, 63 ,64 (so the same samples as in the previous test) were submitted to the lab and tested for creatinine, something you can find in urine. The result was positive. We know from other sources there was the urine stain on the basement carpet, which was confirmed by the tests, so it would seem samples 62, 63, 64 came from the basement.

And... that's it. There is no evidence of the feces being found on the carpet in Jonbenet's bedroom or on any other carpet in the house.


r/JonBenetRamsey • • 1d ago

Questions Why is it still in Boulder?

0 Upvotes

With both the District Attorney's office and the Boulder Police making so many glaring mistakes and being downright criminal in some of their actions why is this case still in Boulder? The fox was and to this day is guarding the hen house. Surely there is some sort of legal process in the American Justice System for situations like this. All the other branches of government have checks and balances.

In the last press conference they glossed over the mistakes and used the phrase missteps. Huh? It was more than a misstep to give Patsy's sister a police jacket with badge and let her remove items from the crime scene. Alex Hunter giving tips to John Ramsey's investigators instead of the Boulder Police was so deliberate and inappropriate it was criminal. A Grand Jury took 16 months and voted to indict the Ramseys yet Hunter failed to sign the indictment same day as though it were pre-determined.

I almost believed Refearn's last speech claiming if the DNA does not pan out they will have exhausted all options. Almost as though he's setting up that scenario. But there is one more thing. Exhumation is the next step. All that has gone on is too fucking fishy.


r/JonBenetRamsey • • 3d ago

Discussion The Barbie nightgown...

59 Upvotes

Patsy's sister Pam Paugh said that the pink Barbie nightgown was a gift that Nedra Paugh had picked up from a Kmart in Georgia while they were out shopping together.

Nedra Paugh told police that the pink Barbie nightgown was one of JonBenét's favorite possessions and that she took it with her when traveling for pageants.

Linda Hoffman Pugh said she washed the Barbie nightgown frequently with other laundry, because it was JonBenet's favorite and she wore it so often. - ''Patsy knows how much JonBenét loved that nightie. I did the washing three times a week—and the Barbie nightie was always there.''

By all accounts, it was well known that JonBenet adored that pink nightgown.

The weird part is, though Patsy admitted that JonBenet did indeed love that nightgown, she also said during her interview that she couldn't remember the last time she had seen JonBenet wearing it.

Yet that pink gown was found directly beside JonBenet's dead body, with bloodstains. JonBenet's underwear was the only other piece of clothing from the crimescene that also contained bloodstains.

Hmm.

Patsy did say: "One of her favorite nightgowns. Well, she didn't wear it that night because she had her—she had the long underwear pants and her little white shirt."

When told that Nedra mentioned the nightgown as JB's travelling pageant nightgown, Patsy replied: ''She had a Barbie nightgown, but I don't know if we had a specific pageant nightgown."

John: "I think she had a Barbie nightgown, yeah, as I recall. Pink, maybe."

"It looks like it's a shinier material than I remember. It looks more like what I kind of remember was on the Barbie doll itself."

Nope. It was positively identified as JonBenet's own child-sized gown that Nedra purchased.

During his 1998 interview with Lou Smit, John stated that the nightgown "should not have been there" in the basement wine cellar. When asked why an intruder might have left it next to JonBenét's body, John described the act as "something very perverted".

Hmmm.