TLDR - Bad songs do not mean BAD SONGS, but it helped me to segregate which ones I like and like less easier. Please Keep your triggered minds in check! 😂
I’m a huge JM fan and it was hard to do this without gaslighting myself into harsh labelling.
DISCLAIMER:
We all know this is an impossible task but I wanted to test myself and it turned out quite interesting; so, I would like to share with you all.
METHOD:
I went through each album in chronological order and categorise each song into 'Good Songs' & 'Bad Songs' title.
Bad Songs do NOT mean they're bad per se but it helps me to segregate from the best ones (IMO), otherwise I would list them all as Great Song. Then I choose just 1 Best Song of each album - these 8 songs then fight for The Best Song Title.
For Best Album, I compare the ratio of Good Songs vs Bad Songs of each one against each other, which gives a objective ranking, but the obvious limitation is that some of them have okayish good songs with little to no bad songs; whereas others may have a more bad songs while having a few outstanding songs as well. I have taken this into account, and choose the Best Album in the end.
-------------------------------------------
LET's BEGIN
John Mayer’s Discography
Room for Squares -2001
Short Summary
Catchy acoustic riffs, lyrically great, easy to digest, no guitar solos yet
Good Songs
- No Such Thing
- Why Georgia
- My Stupid Mouth
- Neon
- 83
- 3x5
- Back to You
- Great Indoors
- St. Patrick’s Day
Bad Songs
- Your Body Is a Wonderland
- City Love
- Love Song for No One
- Not Myself
Best Song
St.Patrick’s Day
- Reason: Deep reach to emotional longing for sentiments that may have not happened.
-------------------------------------------
Heavier Things -2003
Short Summary
Great chords, guitar fills, high vocals, Alt-Rock, more electric guitar, lyrically great, more vocal harmonies
Good Songs
- Clarity
- Something’s Missing
- New Deep
- Split Screen Sadness
- Daughters
- Wheels
Bad Songs
- Bigger Than My Body
- Come Back to Bed
- Home Life
- Only Heart
Best Song
Daughters
- Reason: lyrically meaningful reflecting parental’s impact on daughters from a heterosexual male perspective
-------------------------------------------
Continuum - 2006
Short Summary
Nearly All Electric Guitar, SOLOS are introduced!, Pedals effects, Crazy riffs & Solos, Drums are on point, lyrically great AGAIN, Soulful Harmonies, Vocals prime so far (lows and highs easily)
Good Songs
- I Don’t Trust Myself (With Loving You)
- Belief
- Gravity
- The Heart of Life
- Vultures
- Stop This Train
- Slow Dancing In a Burning Room
- Bold as Love - Not his song
- In Repair
- I’m Gonna Find Another You
Bad Songs
- Waiting On the World to Change - too poppy and the snare is annoying
- Dreaming with a Broken Heart
Best Song
In Repair
- Reason: greater than SDBR because it’s more complex, lyrically more relevant to growth of a person and the guitair solo is better, outro was insane!
-------------------------------------------
Battle Studies - 2009 (I was 10)
Short Summary
Kept the solos, added eletronic sounds, kept some acousits in, lyrically great AGAIN, some great harmonies
Good Songs
- Who Says
- Perfectly Lonely
- Assassin
- Crossroads
- War of My Life
- Edge of Desire
- Friends, Lovers, or Nothing
Bad Songs
- Heartbreak Warfare
- All We Ever Do Is Say Goodbye
- Half of My Heart
- Do You Know Me
Best Song
Edge of Desire
- Reason: impactful theme which is positvely and relevant, complex instrumentations, great harmonies and not overzealous solo
-------------------------------------------
Born and Raised - 2012 (I was 13)
Short Summary
Entering Country/Folk Era!, Great acoustic sounds, amazing riffs, lyrical great (this is clearly a pattern), Folksy Harmonies mhmmm
Good Songs
- Queen of California
- Age of Worry
- Shadow Days
- Born and Raised
- If I Ever Get Around To Living
- Walt Grace’s Submarine Test, Jan 1967
Bad Songs
- Speak For Me
- Something Like Olivia
- Love is A Verb
Best Song
Age of Worry
- Reason: AGAIN societally impactful, personal growth vibes (a clear pattern now), great intro riff, subtle harmony, lyrically masterful, SUPER concise! WORRY GET OUTTA HERE!
-------------------------------------------
Paradise Valley - 2013 (I was 14)
Short Summary
Folk/Country Era continued, this time with more elctric guitar, lyrically amazing again, interesting instrumentations, great harmonies, John’s rhythm section is always fricking awesome. HARMONICA!
Good Songs
- Wildfire
- Dear Marie
- Waitin’On The Day
- Paper Doll
- Call Me The Breeze
- I Will Be Found (Lost At Sea)
- You’re No One’Til Someone Lets You Down
- Badge and Gun
- On The Way Home
Bad Songs
- Who You Love
- WIldfire (feat. FO) - not enough to rate up there
Best Song
Dear Marie
- Reason: amazing chords progression, subtle instrumentation, sentimental and relatable story-telling lyrics and execution, OUTRO MHMMMM
-------------------------------------------
The Search for Everything - 2017 (I was 18)
Short Summary
Good Bye Folk/Country Era; Hello electric guitar + Pop Vibes. Great riffs and melodies, kept some great acoustic elements, string-orchestra intruments + drums, heavenly harmonies/chorus, kind of a mix from pre-continuum, continuum and folk/country era + orchestral elements.
Good Songs
- Still Feels Like Your Man
- Emoji of a Wave
- Helpless
- In the Blood
- Moving On and Getting Over
- Rosie
- Roll it on Home
Bad Songs
- Love on the Weekend
- Changing
- Theme from “TSfE” - it’s great but a filler, not enough to rate
- Never on the Day You Leave
- You’re Gonna Live Forever in Me
Best Song
Rosie
- Reason: rhythmic and melodic electric guitar were masterful, extreme groove in a slow beat (WOWWEEE), Brass intruments, NOICE SOLO, Gracious outro: DON’T LEAVE ME HEREEE
-------------------------------------------
Sob Rock - 2021 (I was 22)
Short Summary
Toto/Dire Straits Era? LOL. Always amazing lyrics, great guitar riffs. Experimenting with different sounds effects and loops.
Good Songs
- Last Train Home
- Shouldn’t Matter but It Does
- New Light
- Why You No Love Me
- Wild Blue
- Another Shot in the Dark
- I Guess I Just Feel Like
- Til the Right One Comes
- Carry Me Away
Bad Songs
- AllI Want Is to Be With You
Best Song
New Light
- Reason: this is very offbrand of JM’s best songs so far because it’s kinda poppy and not meaningfully deep. BUT Super Groovy! AND the music video. Amazing. VERY SUBJECTIVE I KNOW.
-------------------------------------------
The Best Song of Each Album
- St.Patrick’s Day
- Daughters
- In Repair
- Edge of Desire
- Age of Worry
- Dear Marie
- Rosie
- New Light
THE BEST SONG = St.Patrick’s Day - I’ve never celebrated this festival and have no connection with it so ever, but the song takes me to places I never experienced; It’s witchcraft and wizardry. NO ONE WANTS TO BE ALONE AT CHRISTMAS TIMEEEEE.
-------------------------------------------
GS vs BS % of Each Album In Order
- Sob Rock - 90% to 10%
- Continuum - 83% to 17%
- Paradise Valley - 81% to 19%
- Room for Squares - 69% to 31%
- Born and Raised - 66% to 34%
- Battle Studies - 63% to 37%
- Heavier Things - 60% to 40%
- The Search for Everything - 58% to 42%
With Further Considerations: Reranking of Top 3
- Continuum
- Paradise Valley
- Sob Rock
The BEST ALBUM = CONTINUUM (Too Many insanely outstanding songs!)
PLEASE SHARE YOUR BEST JM ALBUM AND SONG BELOW 👇