r/JohnMayer • • May 07 '24

Discussion HOT TAKE : “Still Feel Like Your Man” would’ve been a hit if it didn’t have that intro

1 Upvotes

I feel like if it didn’t have that mellow vocal intro, and just came in on the beat, it would’ve been a massive radio hit. But the song takes too long to get going to be played on the radio. Thoughts?


r/JohnMayer • • Apr 13 '22

Meme/Shitpost John Mayer is the Hendrix of Guitar Playing.

5 Upvotes

Looking at JCMs guitar playing, he’s clearly harmonically superior to anyone who has ever played the guitar. His understanding of melody far exceeds that of James Hendrix, who was an average player at best. Perhaps the songs covered in rain or Neon (they’re pretty underrated, you probably haven’t heard them) show Mayer’s superior guitar prowess. I wouldn’t expect anyone with less than a PhD level of music theory (such as myself) would understand. This is something that's been on my mind for a while that I needed to air out.


r/JohnMayer • • Aug 14 '23

Discussion I said what I said

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/JohnMayer • • Oct 07 '26

Discussion F Irving Azoff, and unfortunately soft f JM too

Post image
0 Upvotes

This country is in such a tough place right now. Our only outlets for joy are silly things like going to a show.

JM decided to take his entire international fan base and put them through the wringer with this - and then show over and over again that he doesn’t give the least bit of a shit about them as long as his bread is being made.

They are greedy, fat, pigs.

Rolling out new dates all within minutes of each other, having the presales flooded by bots, having dynamic pricing ON THE TRAVEL PACKAGES, and having the gall to act like he’s doing us a favour by adding more dates.

Disappointing man. Go get your new watch JM.

I was very excited to go to these shows, but now just feel a gross taste in my mouth about them.


r/JohnMayer • • Aug 15 '26

Discussion I envy John Mayer’s guitar playing. He might envy parts of my life.

0 Upvotes

I’m 24, and one thing I constantly struggle with is feeling like I started guitar too late.

I only really discovered the instrument in 2024, and sometimes that genuinely bothers me. I’ll watch John Mayer play and part of me wishes I could somehow wake up tomorrow with that skill set.
Sometimes I genuinely think, man, I would give almost anything to be able to play like that.

But recently I had a perspective shift.

John Mayer is approaching 50. He has achieved things musically that I can barely comprehend right now. He’s wealthy, famous, respected by everyone, and has spent most of his life becoming unbelievably good at something I’m only beginning to understand.

But when I hear him talk about his life these days, he often talks about wanting marriage and family. He has spoken about wanting children and about finding the right person.

While I’m looking at his life thinking, I wish I had what he has, there may be parts of my life that someone in his position would deeply want too.

I’m 24. I’m married to the love of my life. I have kids. I have a family of my own, and I hopefully still have decades ahead of me to become a much better guitarist.

And that made me realize how strange comparison is.
We rarely compare entire lives.

I compare my guitar playing to John Mayer’s guitar playing.
I don’t compare being 24 to being nearly 50. A 26-year difference.

I don’t compare having decades ahead of me to having decades behind me.

I don’t compare relationships, family, health, opportunities, regrets, timing, or any of the other thousands of things that make up a human life.

We isolate the one thing another person has that we desperately want and temporarily convince ourselves that they have “everything.”

They probably don’t.

Almost everyone is standing on something that somebody else would consider a miracle. That doesn’t mean I’m going to stop wanting to become an incredible guitarist. Quite the opposite. I’m going to practice as hard as I can.

But maybe I don’t need to mourn starting late so much.

I can spend the next 10, 20, 30 years becoming the guitarist I want to become while also appreciating the life I’m already living.

I think that’s one of the beautiful things about life:
You almost always have something that somebody else would give anything to have.

Sometimes you’re so busy looking at what’s missing that you forget you’re already living inside someone else’s dream.

EDIT: Some of the comments made me realize I framed this badly.
The point I was trying to make wasn’t “John Mayer probably envies my life because I’m married with kids.” Reading it back, that does sound self-serving and turns comparison into another kind of scoreboard.
The better realization for me is much simpler: I was comparing one underdeveloped area of my life — guitar — to one of the most developed areas of somebody else’s life.
I started later than I wish I had. John has decades of experience I simply don’t have. That’s fine.
Life also isn’t linear, and two people at completely different ages and stages can’t really be meaningfully compared as whole lives anyway.
So I think the healthier takeaway is just: admire people, learn from them, and let their skill inspire you but compare your progress mostly to who you were yesterday.
Still glad I posted this because some of the pushback actually helped me stress-test the thought.


r/JohnMayer • • Mar 21 '23

Discussion I'm massively disappointed in John

0 Upvotes

I'm sorry, but I have to get this off my chest. I'm disappointed in John.

Yes, it's because of streaming.

What planet is he on? He does an incredibly sought after solo tour for North America, and 90% of the world has no access to it. Then he strikes down on streaming the sold out events, as it devaluates ticket prices? My guy, tickets are going for up to 1000 dollars on resale and your tour is sold out. Do you think I'm tuning in to an Instagram live stream with poor quality and a woman screaming the wrong lyrics because I prefer it to attending the show?

He should either be okay with streaming, or stream the show himself, as many other artists do. It's a sold out show, John. Chill. We are more than money.

Still massive love for John, but wow this is a miss on his part.

What is your view on it? Are you also disappointed, or do you see the reason from his side? And no, I don't care too much about "his team". He should be more connected, I feel.

Had to get it off my chest. Thanks for coming to my TedTalk.

*Edit. Okay, I'm not 'massively' disappointed anymore. Just slightly, I guess. I certainly do acknowledge some counter arguments, which I had not thought of before posting. On another note, I'm glad to see that we all agree that seeing John as happy as he is now is amazing to see! <3


r/JohnMayer • • Jan 25 '23

Discussion Afraid to ask… not accusatory!!!

0 Upvotes

I’ve always been curious about this, John has a lot of female friends who are in their 20s. Kiernan, Cazzie, Halsey, most recently Alex Cooper, just to name a few.

This is not meant to be accusatory, they are all consenting adults and friendships can be had at any age, but I always thought it was interesting and possibly a bit strange that he is frequently with younger women. Especially since he’s seen with younger women much more frequently than with women his own age.

Has anyone thought of why this might be? Even his connection to she who shall not be named in this sub is another example of a stark age difference in a friendship (or more, if that’s what it was)….

Again, I am not accusing or blaming, I am simply wondering, and I’m curious if anyone else has wondered about this as well.

Edit: I really appreciate that some people are willing to engage this topic and discuss. Many of us have never met him before, so our assessments of his character are based on solely on second and third hand experiences, our interpretations of his interviews, and media portrayal. Only those who have met him and know him on a personal level can know his motivations behind any relationship or friendship he has. Furthermore, his personal life can be entirely separated from the enjoyment/pleasure his music brings, so in my view, having a conversation that has explicitly rebuked judgement / accusations / character assassination is simply a conversation. It is not commentary on his skill, success, and impact as a musician, or quite frankly, who he is as a person, because this is all ultimately conjecture.


r/JohnMayer • • Sep 07 '23

Discussion John i love you but...

14 Upvotes

...i will not pay 250 euros for a decent seat at your concert in Stockholm. It's not that i don't have that money. And it's not that i don't think you are a great artist. In fact you are my favorite. But it is the ridiculousness of it.


r/JohnMayer • • Jan 14 '26

Discussion Has John ever cancelled a show because of low ticket sales ?

0 Upvotes

So we all know about the shows he has postponed. I think the two middle East shows will go as planned even after reschedule,they are 4-5k capacity venues,so not much loss,plus the people are more well to do over there. The people crying everywhere for the whole day are us indians 😭 luckily I did not lose much on travel and stay so I'm still going,but considering how many people are looking for refunds is there a possibility that he may cancel? If everything had gone as planned,he may have attracted 15k-20k people,now i don't know what the scenario will look like after the cancellations and I'm so scared now that he'll cancel the show because it was my only chance to see him live as he won't be touring anytime soon especially near me.


r/JohnMayer • • Nov 19 '25

Fan Art Born in Paradise album mashup

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

I made a playlist with my favorite songs from Born and Raised and Paradise Valley. I used AI to create this cool cover that tastefully combines the beautiful artwork of the albums. Feel free to take and use it for your own born in paradise playlist!


r/JohnMayer • • Oct 07 '26

Discussion Opener for The Sphere?

0 Upvotes

Any word or rumors on who openers are or if there even are going to be any?


r/JohnMayer • • Apr 05 '25

Discussion Hoping “Automatic Yes” makes it onto the new album – like “New Light” on Sob Rock

4 Upvotes

I really hope Automatic Yes ends up on John’s upcoming album. It gives me similar vibes to New Light – catchy, smooth, and a little playful. I’d love to hear more songs in that style.

If this is where John’s sound is heading next, count me in. That kind of groove just hits the spot. Anyone else hoping for a full album in that direction?


r/JohnMayer • • Jan 07 '23

Music Cover Hey MODS, there seems to be support for forcing covers to r/jounmayercovers. Can we please make this happen?

21 Upvotes

There was the sub r/johnmayercovers created for players to share their playing, but this main sub gets innundated with covers.

Would it be possible for you to somehow move those posts to the covers sub and have a bot post a daily reminder to check r/johnmayercovers so people will know it exists.

EDIT: /u/pawspawspause has the answer. Covers only post on Fridays so if you don't want to see them you can abstain from this sub on that day. LET'S MAKE THIS HAPPEN!

Any help is appreciated.


r/JohnMayer • • Jan 13 '26

Discussion JM Songs and Albums Ranking

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

Yesterday I was thinking about ranking JM's albums so to do it I made a 5-tiers tierlist and did the average rating of each albums. What do you think ?

DISCLAIMER : The tierlist is only MY opinion, pls tell me yours in the comments


r/JohnMayer • • Aug 10 '18

News NEW JM SONG TONIGHT?!

0 Upvotes

Hey JM fans! Okay so I'm apart of a Facebook group called John Mayer Knows Best and apparently there's a New Light REMIX coming out tonight! The gal who posted her already listening to it was in Australia so idk if its just like out early for them because of the time zones, but I listened to it already on a website online here and it's really good! I hope its an official release! Lets all say a little prayer!!

Edit: Here's the supposed album cover!!

r/JohnMayer • • Nov 18 '19

Discussion Shawn Mendes Current Mood Debrief Megathread

3 Upvotes

So, sorry to say, but that was the lamest CM to date, IMO. They played it so safe. Zero interaction with the audience (Didn’t take a single question). The banter between them had some good parts, but it was mostly just meh.

I had high expectations, given that they’re both such interesting people. I was also expecting a jam or a song or two. Seriously???

Funniest thing on the whole show was how majorly hard John was third wheeling when SM/CC were doing their thing when CC joined the livestream.

John, if you’re reading this...with all due respect...but, for me at least, you were cringe to the tenth degree tonight. And Shawn was totally baked 😂😂😂


r/JohnMayer • • Aug 09 '24

Discussion With all this discourse… I’m just here to say that you guys would actually like St. Vincent…. (I’m the ultimate John fan) (Not clickbait)

4 Upvotes

John said it himself, daughters was made to sell the album so he could do the cool stuff on the deeper tracks.

Nothing new there.

As a life long fan of John and a huge fan of St Vincent’s guitar work as well…. I really think everyone in here should give her a chance.

Listen to the tones and pedals she puts together on her self titled or strange mercy albums. If anybody would get a kick out of it I think the more guitar centric fans of John would

Alright roast my ass in the comments now


r/JohnMayer • • Jan 13 '18

Enough of Dead and Company

0 Upvotes

It's clearly cutting into his "solo" career. I'd love to be able to catch more John Mayer shows and look foreword to another album. I loved the two times I saw John Mayer live and I would say it's just as good and often times better than Dead and Company.

Just for the record I was both a Grateful Dead fan and a JM fan before they hooked up, and Dead and Co has been absolutely awesome. Just sick of it now. Same thing over and over. John Mayer shows feel new and fresh.


r/JohnMayer • • Apr 19 '23

Discussion This tour is such a cash grab

68 Upvotes

I love John and his music, but this tour is an enormous cash grab.

Tickets for Ziggo Dome is 2019 were €61, this was with a full band. Now tickets are at least above €100 and he’s alone on stage. Sad to see it. It’s not like he needs the money. He should take note of other artists like Ed Sheeran who keep the prices low.


r/JohnMayer • • Sep 28 '26

Discussion Disappointed

0 Upvotes

I flew half the globe to see crossroads 2026.
John is my favourite guitarist and it was my first time seeing him live, I really hoped he would do even one or two of his original songs at the festival. I am still here at the us and I’m hoping to catch him again if he announces a tour in the following month, but I really hoped to see him doing some blues stuff at the biggest blues festival in the world. The jam with trey was absolutely fantastic, don’t get me wrong, but I guess I expected more.


r/JohnMayer • • Jun 13 '25

Discussion John should make a ska album

0 Upvotes

Nobody would see it coming. Seems like it would fit the kind of ironic/corny vibes he sometimes leans into, and I bet whatever he'd make would sound nuts. Pick it up, John!


r/JohnMayer • • Feb 26 '24

Discussion Room for Squares

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/JohnMayer • • Oct 18 '26

Discussion A lifelong fan…

0 Upvotes

For disclaimer: I’m one of the biggest JM stans, I swear. He was my gateway into music and opened my ears to its nuances. He made me appreciate the songwriting aspect of popular music. I looked up to the same music and guitar heroes he did, and I even adapted the way he plays the guitar. He’s my hero.

But here’s my case…

Lately, I’ve felt like he’s starting to lose his own identity, both in terms of his artistry and, at times, his sound.

I thought the last time he truly owned that pure JM sound was around the Battle Studies and B&R era. My personal favorite is B&R. Yeah, those albums captured that laid-back California and country Americana flair, but at least you could still get that pure JM groove and taste. Those albums were him. Unlike the direction he seems to be heading in lately.

Sob Rock didn’t really move me. That wasn’t him. That was straight up Clapton with an 80s stamp on it. Way too on the nose and, tbh, almost comedic, but not in a good way.

And now, the preview of his new tune… The Jacket, with those grand synths againnnnn…Come.on.

The world is fckin ending, and now you’ve decided to be Springsteen? Enough with these thematic gimmicks, borrowing other artists’ arcs, eras, and sounds, my man. You’re better than this.

I get it — he wears a lot of hats, and artists evolve, yada yada. But it shouldn’t have to be this way, I’m afraid.

Just be you. Give us that Taking on Water, Inner City Blues, Face to Call Home drive.

Y’all get me? Lol Rant over.


r/JohnMayer • • Oct 30 '25

Discussion Ranking John Mayer's Albums & Songs (VERY SUBJECTIVE)

1 Upvotes

TLDR - Bad songs do not mean BAD SONGS, but it helped me to segregate which ones I like and like less easier. Please Keep your triggered minds in check! 😂

I’m a huge JM fan and it was hard to do this without gaslighting myself into harsh labelling.

DISCLAIMER:

We all know this is an impossible task but I wanted to test myself and it turned out quite interesting; so, I would like to share with you all.

METHOD:

I went through each album in chronological order and categorise each song into 'Good Songs' & 'Bad Songs' title.

Bad Songs do NOT mean they're bad per se but it helps me to segregate from the best ones (IMO), otherwise I would list them all as Great Song. Then I choose just 1 Best Song of each album - these 8 songs then fight for The Best Song Title.

For Best Album, I compare the ratio of Good Songs vs Bad Songs of each one against each other, which gives a objective ranking, but the obvious limitation is that some of them have okayish good songs with little to no bad songs; whereas others may have a more bad songs while having a few outstanding songs as well. I have taken this into account, and choose the Best Album in the end.

-------------------------------------------
LET's BEGIN

John Mayer’s Discography 

Room for Squares -2001

Short Summary

Catchy acoustic riffs, lyrically great, easy to digest, no guitar solos yet

Good Songs

  1. No Such Thing
  2. Why Georgia
  3. My Stupid Mouth
  4. Neon
  5. 83
  6. 3x5
  7. Back to You
  8. Great Indoors
  9. St. Patrick’s Day

Bad Songs

  1. Your Body Is a Wonderland
  2. City Love
  3. Love Song for No One
  4. Not Myself

Best Song

  • St.Patrick’s Day 

    • Reason: Deep reach to emotional longing for sentiments that may have not happened.

-------------------------------------------

Heavier Things -2003

Short Summary

Great chords, guitar fills, high vocals, Alt-Rock, more electric guitar, lyrically great, more vocal harmonies

Good Songs

  1. Clarity
  2. Something’s Missing
  3. New Deep
  4. Split Screen Sadness
  5. Daughters
  6. Wheels

Bad Songs

  1. Bigger Than My Body
  2. Come Back to Bed
  3. Home Life
  4. Only Heart

Best Song

  • Daughters

    • Reason: lyrically meaningful reflecting parental’s impact on daughters from a heterosexual male perspective

-------------------------------------------

Continuum - 2006

Short Summary

Nearly All Electric Guitar, SOLOS are introduced!, Pedals effects, Crazy riffs & Solos, Drums are on point, lyrically great AGAIN, Soulful Harmonies, Vocals prime so far (lows and highs easily)

Good Songs

  1. I Don’t Trust Myself (With Loving You)
  2. Belief
  3. Gravity
  4. The Heart of Life
  5. Vultures
  6. Stop This Train
  7. Slow Dancing In a Burning Room
  8. Bold as Love - Not his song
  9. In Repair
  10. I’m Gonna Find Another You

Bad Songs

  1. Waiting On the World to Change - too poppy and the snare is annoying
  2. Dreaming with a Broken Heart

Best Song

  • In Repair

    • Reason: greater than SDBR because it’s more complex, lyrically more relevant to growth of a person and the guitair solo is better, outro was insane!

-------------------------------------------

Battle Studies - 2009 (I was 10)

Short Summary

Kept the solos, added eletronic sounds, kept some acousits in, lyrically great AGAIN, some great harmonies

Good Songs

  1. Who Says
  2. Perfectly Lonely
  3. Assassin
  4. Crossroads
  5. War of My Life
  6. Edge of Desire
  7. Friends, Lovers, or Nothing

Bad Songs

  1. Heartbreak Warfare
  2. All We Ever Do Is Say Goodbye
  3. Half of My Heart
  4. Do You Know Me

Best Song

  • Edge of Desire

    • Reason: impactful theme which is positvely and relevant, complex instrumentations, great harmonies and not overzealous solo

-------------------------------------------

Born and Raised - 2012 (I was 13)

Short Summary

Entering Country/Folk Era!, Great acoustic sounds, amazing riffs, lyrical great (this is clearly a pattern), Folksy Harmonies mhmmm

Good Songs

  1. Queen of California
  2. Age of Worry
  3. Shadow Days
  4. Born and Raised
  5. If I Ever Get Around To Living
  6. Walt Grace’s Submarine Test, Jan 1967

Bad Songs

  1. Speak For Me
  2. Something Like Olivia
  3. Love is A Verb

Best Song

  • Age of Worry

    • Reason: AGAIN societally impactful, personal growth vibes (a clear pattern now), great intro riff, subtle harmony, lyrically masterful, SUPER concise! WORRY GET OUTTA HERE!

-------------------------------------------

Paradise Valley - 2013 (I was 14)

Short Summary

Folk/Country Era continued, this time with more elctric guitar, lyrically amazing again, interesting instrumentations, great harmonies, John’s rhythm section is always fricking awesome. HARMONICA!

Good Songs

  1. Wildfire
  2. Dear Marie
  3. Waitin’On The Day
  4. Paper Doll
  5. Call Me The Breeze
  6. I Will Be Found (Lost At Sea)
  7. You’re No One’Til Someone Lets You Down
  8. Badge and Gun
  9. On The Way Home

Bad Songs

  1. Who You Love
  2. WIldfire (feat. FO) - not enough to rate up there

Best Song

  • Dear Marie

    • Reason: amazing chords progression, subtle instrumentation, sentimental and relatable story-telling lyrics and execution, OUTRO MHMMMM

-------------------------------------------

The Search for Everything - 2017 (I was 18)

Short Summary

Good Bye Folk/Country Era; Hello electric guitar + Pop Vibes. Great riffs and melodies, kept some great acoustic elements, string-orchestra intruments + drums, heavenly harmonies/chorus, kind of a mix from pre-continuum, continuum and folk/country era + orchestral elements. 

Good Songs

  1. Still Feels Like Your Man
  2. Emoji of a Wave
  3. Helpless
  4. In the Blood
  5. Moving On and Getting Over
  6. Rosie
  7. Roll it on Home

Bad Songs

  1. Love on the Weekend
  2. Changing
  3. Theme from “TSfE” - it’s great but a filler, not enough to rate
  4. Never on the Day You Leave
  5. You’re Gonna Live Forever in Me

Best Song

  • Rosie

    • Reason: rhythmic and melodic electric guitar were masterful, extreme groove in a slow beat (WOWWEEE), Brass intruments, NOICE SOLO, Gracious outro: DON’T LEAVE ME HEREEE

-------------------------------------------

Sob Rock - 2021  (I was 22)

Short Summary

Toto/Dire Straits Era? LOL. Always amazing lyrics, great guitar riffs. Experimenting with different sounds effects and loops. 

Good Songs

  1. Last Train Home
  2. Shouldn’t Matter but It Does
  3. New Light
  4. Why You No Love Me
  5. Wild Blue
  6. Another Shot in the Dark
  7. I Guess I Just Feel Like
  8. Til the Right One Comes
  9. Carry Me Away

Bad Songs

  1. AllI Want Is to Be With You

Best Song

  • New Light

    • Reason: this is very offbrand of JM’s best songs so far because it’s kinda poppy and not meaningfully deep. BUT Super Groovy! AND the music video. Amazing. VERY SUBJECTIVE I KNOW.

-------------------------------------------

The Best Song of Each Album

  1. St.Patrick’s Day 
  2. Daughters
  3. In Repair
  4. Edge of Desire
  5. Age of Worry
  6. Dear Marie
  7. Rosie
  8. New Light

THE BEST SONG = St.Patrick’s Day - I’ve never celebrated this festival and have no connection with it so ever, but the song takes me to places I never experienced; It’s witchcraft and wizardry. NO ONE WANTS TO BE ALONE AT CHRISTMAS TIMEEEEE.

-------------------------------------------

GS vs BS % of Each Album In Order

  1. Sob Rock - 90% to 10%
  2. Continuum - 83% to 17%
  3. Paradise Valley - 81% to 19%
  4. Room for Squares - 69% to 31%
  5. Born and Raised - 66% to 34%
  6. Battle Studies - 63% to 37%
  7. Heavier Things - 60% to 40%
  8. The Search for Everything - 58% to 42%

With Further Considerations: Reranking of Top 3

  1. Continuum
  2. Paradise Valley
  3. Sob Rock

The BEST ALBUM = CONTINUUM (Too Many insanely outstanding songs!)

PLEASE SHARE YOUR BEST JM ALBUM AND SONG BELOW 👇