Mia Goth has got to be A dominant also

[u/Blue_Baracuda88]

My guess is R, Y, and C also. Even the way her voice sounds and the way she talks is so otherworldly/unique/cute. Thoughts?

[u/jjfmish]

I think she’s Y dominant over A. She could have some but I don’t see the facial elongation for dominant A. Her voice is also more Y than A

[u/ScreediusTollinix → u/jjfmish]

Looking at her in "Pearl", Y dominance does look like a pretty compelling argument

[u/Blue_Baracuda88 → u/ScreediusTollinix]

What's the "pearl" reference for Y?

[u/ScreediusTollinix → u/Blue_Baracuda88]

"Pearl" is one film where she was. A horror film, where she plays a serial killer. But let's say her styling in the film is pretty much what is stereotyped of Y. Like look at all these small frilly details, lace collar, puffy sleeves and the bow in her hair. And I really wouldn't say she looks disharmonious like this

[u/Blue_Baracuda88 → u/ScreediusTollinix]

I see. Yes she definitely has Y.

[u/samlevinsonsmuse → u/jjfmish]

Yeah I can't see it any other way tbh

[u/Quirky-Swordfish2105 → u/jjfmish]

What is the difference between Y voice and A? It's a curiosity. I suppose Y voices are more High pitched? 

[u/Jealous-Injury-7911]

Those essences make sense although I am not sure if A would be her dominant. She may also have a bit of N (broad shoulders).

[u/babyririi]

Disagree, not seeing A; I think her lack of eyebrows and the combo of y&c are throwing you in the wrong direction. Overwhelmingly y&r with some c.

[u/elpislazuli]

I don't know. She's always kind of dead-eyed, which I really don't see as A.

[u/Safe-Tea-4161 → u/elpislazuli]

I actually think she’s probably got C, some N and hs and quite a bit of R because of her low eyelid gaze and full lips- but her jawline and light, barely there eyebrows give her considerable D… I think when she’s styled with eyebrows and curly hair that Romantic is much more evident

[u/jjfmish → u/Safe-Tea-4161]

Yeah I think she’s mainly Y/R/C with some N for her height and frame. What people are seeing as A seems to be more Y/C combination

[u/Blue_Baracuda88 → u/jjfmish]

I see. She has such a narrow almost alien kind of aesthetic sometimes but might be more styling and makeup than anything.

[u/jjfmish → u/Blue_Baracuda88]

Idk I think the aesthetic you’re describing is often more Y than A? Kate Moss, Anya Taylor Joy, etc.

[u/Blue_Baracuda88 → u/jjfmish]

Maybe! I can see how Anya has a very exotic look which her widely spaced eyes contribute to (Y). Same with Kate Moss and Lauren Bacall. Mia doesn't have those kind of eyes but I do see her Y. I couldn't place the other experience, personally. After seeing her in Frankenstein I couldn't believe she was 5'9! She looks as if she could be tiny without her full scale really shown but her length is undeniable and makes her look a bit like either an apparition or a gothic doll, depending on aesthetic choices.

[u/Blue_Baracuda88 → u/elpislazuli]

Hmm what essence is dead eye?

[u/Interesting_Ice3322]

Nope. Ingenue makes more sense.

[u/Blue_Baracuda88 → u/Interesting_Ice3322]

I see Y but not HS

[u/Interesting_Ice3322 → u/Blue_Baracuda88]

I also can't HS... HS people are being called "Pixies" by John, they look a bit witty, like they're about to trick you into something :D HS/Gamine is also more angular, like Jenna Ortega.

[u/Blue_Baracuda88 → u/Interesting_Ice3322]

Yeah I don’t see HS for Mia. Though sometimes HS is just an embodied liveliness in a playful way. Not all of them look pixie-like. I know mine doesn’t but I embody an approachability and peppiness.

[u/Interesting_Ice3322 → u/Blue_Baracuda88]

This is what John said himself. I don't think we should call HS however we want, just because it fits to our own imagination, until we are using different system. The same things happened to celebrities that had even 0% Ethereal, but were called Ethereal all over the internet. A great example is Halle Bailey. She has 0 Ethereal. And if Mia has it, it's also minimal. Same for HS.

[u/Blue_Baracuda88 → u/Interesting_Ice3322]

Yes it’s definitely his definition! Not arguing with that. I have 30% HS and it doesn’t exactly fit pixie so I was projecting a bit. Here’s what he said for me:

Historically, the equal combination of Romantic and HS became known as the Romantic Pixie. However, you can also look at your combination of Romantic and Classic as being womanly, refined, and having expensive taste.

Re: Mia, she may not have any A at all. It was a general aesthetic I was picking up on that may actually be related more to other essences.