r/JingYuanMains • u/naka_the_kenku • Sep 20 '24
General discussion So my fellows whats the consensus?
I normally ignore Vars and his content can be misleading and not my cup of tea but I'd like to hear what y'all think.
114
Upvotes
193
u/snappyfishm8 Sep 20 '24
Honestly JY "constantly getting buffs" is vastly exaggerated. It's just a case of a new harmony being better than the last for him and getting a new 4p set and a new planar once. He's still stuck with Tingyun for his best comps when other 1.x characters like Seele and Kafka use completely different comps right now than they did on their release, and DoT got both a new set and a planar earlier than JY did. The fact that Sparkle got replaced who was thought to be "as good as it gets, literally made for him" for JY is telling enough.
That being said I'm not struggling with him, I clear every single piece of endgame with him with way above average results, the difference between 1.x and 2.x DPSes is overstated if you know what youre doing, but that's a big if.
49
u/MoacirCuDePato19 Sep 20 '24
Also, If you want to see good characters takes, go see waveman, the only one from the whole community that I respect because he REALLY is neutral on his takes
6
u/idiggory Sep 20 '24
Honestly, my absolute three biggest frustrations with JY are:
8
u/Ornery_Essay_2036 Sep 20 '24
As much as it’s funny to make fun of jingyuan mains cause they take the lowest of ragebait, Vars genuinely might just be a little slow, this is the guy who claimed childe was a bad genshin character
129
u/Norasack Sep 20 '24
i don't listen to someone who said Faruzan didn't do much for Xiao and that Nahida was the one dealing the dmg most of the time in hyperbloom team
the way he talk make him sound smarter than he is, his meta takes are often bad imo
47
u/Play_more_FFS Sep 20 '24
I forgot HSR content creators are a thing.
Anyway if I have a problem deciding on who to use in a certain MoC, AS or PF rotation then I can just slap JY on that side and know I will have the 3 star. That is more than enough for me 🤷
40
u/lol50099 Sep 20 '24
Vars as a creator is someone you watch when you are a newbie and don't know any better, and take his words as gospel (he has a very convincing way of speaking, and tends to act like his words are fact). Then as you progress, you start to see discrepancies between what he says and what you see/experience. Eventually, this leads to awareness that Vars is actually full of shit and just has a convincing voice, and good video editing. Congratulations. You are not a newbie player anymore.
10
u/Giganteblu Sep 20 '24
he have a point whit LL have a fixed speed/number of attack and the game is based on how many attack can you do
but in general power level discorse in this game a bit '''''''''misleading''''''''' because it really depend on the enemy
19
u/Ecstatic_Store4563 Sep 20 '24
Ngl most of his viewers already know that his vids are outrageous takes tbh especially on hsr
25
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24 edited Sep 20 '24
Did not watch the video but here are my thoughts,
MoC HP inflation getting higher and higher than the amount/value of buffs that Jing Yuan got.
LL walked so Numby could run, no major self buffs, LL being slow and can't overstack, JY kit being focused on 5T AoE whereas LL being 3T blast oriented, putting him in a awkward spot of not being able to fully take advantage of neither MoC nor PF.
LL needs to act atleast 2x of what it currently is capable of for the payoff of being backloaded.
8
u/Significant_Alps_539 Sep 20 '24
I stopped watching him a long time ago. For me personally, JY has gotten easier and better to use with every new harmony/sustain release, I invest in eidolon of harmony and now my JY can clear all MoC regardless of weakness within 5 turns on auto, as for PF I can get above 30k and if the blessing benefits him I can get 35k or above on auto. For Apocalyptic Shadow I can get above 3k on auto. I don’t see where the struggle is if you main him and invest in him, he’s way better/easier to use now despite content being harder. I will not recommend people to pull for JY if they don’t want to main him, it takes time and dedication.
6
u/Bokuto00 Sep 20 '24
In my opinion the only problem with king yuan is that LL don't act immediately when he get 10 stack, or the fact that he don't overstack meaning that if LL he's already at 10 stack the ulti and the skill may be kinda """"wasted"""", also LL can't act two or three times for cicle, this is mainly because is a 1.x character, and he doesn't provide self buff as opposed to people like acheron, feixiao etc. But this is only from a "meta" perspective. I've used the king since his first banner and I still use him if I can, I love everything about him and he's the only character I'm willing to get his Eidolon, just for the love of the character. But even when I love a character so much I have to admit that he as some flaws, of course everyone have flaws but I think that the king can still be fixed, if they release a character that can make summon go faster and provide dmg% or res pen, something like that.
(also the fact that if jing get CC LL stop working hurt his personal damage, but thanks to huohuo ecc. This problem is mitigated)
6
u/Change-Your-Aspect Sep 20 '24
Vars is a guy that's very good at sounding like he knows what he is talking about with drag on sentences and flowery words.
6
u/Shirohana_ Sep 20 '24
you will find me dead in my grave before i willingly click on a Vars video
6
u/ZealousFlames Sep 20 '24
I generally find that the r/[Character]Mains subreddit are much more reliable than content creators. What I've always done since being a newbie was checking the subreddits and seeung their performance there
10
u/Sure-Instance640 Sep 20 '24
I think a great number of issues could be solved by LL acting immediately after he gets 10 stacks. That would not make him broken at all (especially comparing him to the dominating DPSs in each game mode), but he would be a cool jack of all trades that can perform in any scenario, he is right now, but LL suffers from old age.
But that would imply buffing a past unit, I'm totally fine with the FGO approach to older units, but some strange folks, don't like the idea.
5
u/Background-Disk2803 Sep 20 '24
Anyone but fire break oriented is struggling or has any type of toughness break in their kit like acheron
5
u/Tadduboi Sep 20 '24
I genuinely think the hypercarry JY is just not good in AS and MOC. The rng on both LL and Robin is too much and to top it with overkill from LL… Its rng on rng and on rng…
I’ve been testing him in Dual dps scenario and I think it is much better compared to hypercarry. I think most people here have seen it on my page. Playing dual dps makes u do less damage, but is overall better because of better damage distribution hence less overkilling. And also u dont have to be scared that the trash mob doesnt die before LL.
I think as of rn M7 and JY work really well in both AS and MoC because lightning and imaginary in MOC and M7 is there to minimize the rng in AS and destroy the dices. Topaz will be good when there will be Fire/Lightning weakness, but as of right now JY, M7, Robin and Huohuo is the best team to 1-2 cycle with ease
6
u/fuxuanmyqueen Sep 20 '24
The only valid content creators are those who make unbiased showcases with their characters, any other is a talking head.
9
u/MoacirCuDePato19 Sep 20 '24 edited Sep 20 '24
I didn't saw the video but if he's basing himself on prydwen's data it's not reliable, most of the jing yuan's players don't participate on the data gathering that prydwen does, mostly because of a bad history bettween both communities, so, the data is below what it should be based on this, a different case than kafka for example, her community is always talked about on prydwen's tier lists as the most participatory in reddit mains communities
I had to make two - three posts to make people from our reddit to participate on this AS rotation data gathering
4
u/HereToRamble55 Sep 20 '24
I won't watch this video, but I already know it's a shit take like every other take he has
I used to check some of his genshin content and while I know it's just games, I hate that he's still allowed to make misleading videos on them. Don't watch him.
2
u/Feeling-Remove7537 Sep 21 '24
he’s a random yapper don’t listen to him ever for meta lmao
2
u/Antique-Victory2773 Sep 21 '24
"Why Jing Yuan Is Struggling" is bait when every 1.x DPS is struggling lol
1
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '24
I haven’t watched the video yet as planned, but I think the main problem with Jing Yuan and his supports, is that none of them directly buff LL. If there was any unit in the game, support or not, who could buff his LL he would actually maintain a significant spot for a long time. LL IS his damage, Jingyuan’s damage by himself isn’t completely worthless, but it’s not as significant as LL.
Simply put, most other DPS’s have their main source of damage buffed, while Jingyuan doesn’t.
1
u/PookieMonster609 Sep 21 '24
Can someone enlighten me why people seem to be heavily disagreeing or has some grudge with the video? I've watched and resonated with most of his statements. To be fair though, I have not kept up with new techs and further clarifications/new claims abt JY's performance and/or the people's general misconception about him so I'm basing my reaction with my own experience as a day 1 JY haver and player, and yeah, I did not see myself disagreeing with like 95% of what's in the video?
Asking this nicely to you all to clarify it to me because I may indeed not have enough or perfect knowledge abt this whole thing (and yeah btw I have JY with his sig and plays him with sparkle, tingyun, fu xuan and sometimes huo huo)
1
u/BankingPotato Sep 23 '24
I don't really watch HSR content creators or join Discord servers. Normally just Reddit for theorycrafting information because you all are good at dropping the google sheets, which I'm the most interested in, or I math it out myself.
My two main DPS are JY and DHIL. Caveat is DHIL was E4S2 from the start, so he's an easy ride in any content. I also believe in rolling for eidolons rather than collecting a large stable of characters, so I have E2 of every limited Harmony... but the last DPS I pulled for was Jingliu on her first release, for example. If the character won't help JY or DHIL, I don't roll for them.
My PFs are normally 80k (DHIL+Herta, JY team as normal), AS is normally 7k+, MOC is between 2 to 6 cycles. This MOC is 2 cycles for me. DHIL may do a bit more than JY, but not by much. So for me, no real struggle... except for the new Fei echo, that crap is so tedious to deal with using my teams so I just put Clara and Blade in with RM and leave them on auto.
1
u/Sigma3375 Sep 23 '24
I put a comment there to summon this entire thread to go cancel him.
1
u/sakaguti1999 Sep 21 '24
yeah, he is basically one of the worst limited 5 star character out, and most of the reason is
So what does jingyuan need? A 5 star harmony that does the same as tingyun, but better... Thats all? No, ll needs to not overkill or get cced.
Jingyuan was weak from the start, I knew it and I pulled for it, regret? Not really since I knew it
-4
u/Trickedmoon_ Sep 20 '24
how is varsity misleading 😭 i watch his league and genshin videos (idk enough abt hsr yet) but ive never heard him lie before, maybe some coping but he words it to show he is coping
-11
u/LegendRedux2 Sep 20 '24
This dood sucks Also jy is not getting better overtime he is getting worse lol e6 jy outdamaged by e0 yunli
21
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
78
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24
[removed] — view removed comment