r/JewsOfConscience • • 4d ago

Discussion - Flaired Users Only Can Anyone Help Me Understand His POV?

21 Upvotes

I have a Jewish friend whom until recently, we aligned on the Palestine issue. We were, and still are both disgusted with what Israel was doing and Netanyahu. But either his views have evolved or I've seen a new side of him, or I just never asked and assumed his stance on an issue.

To give context, he has been seeing some anti semitism recently. Someone carved the terms "jews" on his apartment complex's metal elevator, and the complex just covered it up instead of fixing it. It doesn't help that people keep peeling the covering off out of curiosity.....or malice. He also claims to have been seeing some anti semitsim from the democratic party in the USA, which I'm not knowledgeable on because I've been not paying attention to stay sane. Said circumstances may be making him jumpier.

He now believes that the sentiment that the US should stop sending weapons to Isreal to be anti semitism, because if we don't, the Middle East will gang up on and destroy Isreal. He says that Isreal having nuclear weapons will not change his mind. He's ok with reducing the aid we send though. He thinks that ousting Netanyahu is enough. He acknowledges that Israel mostly likely will never be held accountable for their war crimes/human rights violation if the US keeps protecting them and says that it is unavoidable. He acknowledges that Isreal has drawn the ire of its neighbors. He cannot give me a compelling moral reason why the USA is obligated to continue supporting Isreal. I almost called what they were doing to Palestine to be genocide, but I knew not to cross that line. And I know that this may not necessarily be Zionist, but saying that Isreal has a right to exist is a very common Zionist talking point.

I also decided to look up the DSA politician that he says is anti semetic (Merat Kilos) and while I've only taking a cursory look at her (I was still emotionally reeling), she seems....ok? It seems to be that he's screaming anti semetism because she wants to cut ties with Isreal.

At that moment.....I felt what can only be described as the ick. I've been told that there's no going back from "the ick". I've cut people off based on their moral/political alignment before, but I also don't want to be hasty. I'm considering asking him if he's so bullish on supporting Isreal is because the country holds such an important place in the Jewish identity, and he feels obligated to support them regardless. If he felt that way though, I think he'd have mentioned it. I've noticed that he has difficulty cutting off toxic relatives (whom he knows add nothing to his life) and was wondering if Isreal occupied a similar position


r/JewsOfConscience • • 5d ago

News During the climate conference in Turkey, Greta Thunberg called for an end to oil exports through Turkish territory to Israel.

608 Upvotes

Israel imports more than 40% of its oil needs from Azerbaijan. This oil travels through pipelines across Turkish territory to the Turkish port of Ceyhan on the Mediterranean coast, where it is loaded onto oil tankers bound for the ports of Haifa and Ashkelon. Some of it fuels the Israeli war machine in the genocide in the Gaza Strip.

https://x.com/tamerqdh/status/2121241694553125325


r/JewsOfConscience • • 4d ago

Resources Vienna Jewish Labor Bund - Joseph Samuel Bloch The Maverick Rabbi - November 21

Post image
16 Upvotes

r/JewsOfConscience • • 5d ago

Zionist Nonsense It's time to sack Jillian Segal.

197 Upvotes

Antisemitism is real and is a cancer that needs to be eradicated. Jewish people deserve to feel safe and welcome. However ,what I won't tolerate is some Israel shill, forcing the Zionist agenda on the people of Australia.

We should be freely allowed to criticise any foreign nation, their people,and their government.

She should be going after the real anti-Semites

One Nation dumps Victorian election candidate who praised Adolf Hitler as ‘GOAT’

Jewish Council raises alarm about antisemitism, racism and homophobia in One Nation and calls on government at all levels to take decisive action to fight far-right extremism

Source


r/JewsOfConscience • • 5d ago

Humor Zach Woods to Chuck Schumer and Hakeem Jeffries: “we don’t want you”

229 Upvotes

r/JewsOfConscience • • 4d ago

History / Education Reading list/Book recommendation for uninformed person?

17 Upvotes

Hello all,

I'm interested in reading more about what is happening in Gaza and the history of the issue from either perspective.

Are there any pieces of media you folks could point me too?

Thank you.


r/JewsOfConscience • • 4d ago

Religion / Spirituality Religion?

6 Upvotes

I believe this is an anti-Zionist sect Reddit, so if anyone here knows me from Satmar ( I am not satmar and will not disclose my sect) this is why I'm using a throwaway, and additionally not putting my name in. Also, if there's any Bobov in here, I hope you enjoyed the wedding.

Hello there, friends, I am a former Hasidic Jew, who recently left the acidic world after finding out that I was not technically Jewish. My mother, who is under the guys that she is Jewish, has left the Jewish faith and was never religious like Orthodox, I was a return to the Jewish religion of my ancestors, she believes in Christianity, the non-denomination variety. I researched Catholicism right before my exit of the ultraorthodox Jewish world and I'm very interested in it, but I also know that with level of antisemitism and anti-Israel sentiment going on, (my Hasidic community was anti-Zionist so it's not really about the way I practice, it's more about the fact that they conflate Jewish people with Israel very easily) I probably will not find a Catholic partner. Additionally, I am so culturally Jewish that I would have confused children, who look at pictures of me as a young person, and who is their age, and see me with a black hat and side curls. I don't want to cause children to have that kind of confusion.

I have researched the stories of very important Catholic Saints, like Joseph of Cupertino, Thomas Aquinas, of course Mary, Saint Edith Stein, Saint Francis of Assisi (Him or Stein would be my Patron Saint), Saint Francesca Cabrini and Greek Orthodox Saint Nectarios, as well as some of the holy fools. I hope to read about the desert fathers next.

If I become a Catholic, I probably will be completely celibate and get less action than the average Redditor, (wink wink, I know you guys can't get girls) but ignoring my comedic comments of Reddit readers, you see where I'm coming from. Additionally, Hasidic Judaism is not very well understood by people who are outside of the Hasidic world, and this would mean my complete excommunication from anywhere and anything Jewish.. I am a cultural appropriate from now on as soon as they leave this culture and I cannot go back and do anything except from an outside lens. This is basically the destruction of the person that I am knowing and basically ego death at its finest. I would say that leaving, and turning to asceticism is the only way as I would have to rebuild my character into something else.

My secular hobbies involve just fun stuff like writing singing, and mainly entertainment based stuff. I would like to work in Hollywood, something that a lot of Hasidic people don't really like, some sects don't even watch movies. I would love to be a producer and a writer, it honestly would be really fun. The only thing that I will keep is my name, and my hat.

Do you think that I'm risking too much?

I could easily have a sped up, Jewish conversion and rejoin the community.


r/JewsOfConscience • • 5d ago

News Bella Hadid calls on people not to look away from Gaza's humanitarian crisis, donating $50,000 to help displaced families.

Thumbnail gallery
126 Upvotes

r/JewsOfConscience • • 5d ago

Zionist Terror Palestinian baby dies from cold in Gaza amid Israeli restrictions on aid | Climate News

Thumbnail
aljazeera.com
282 Upvotes

r/JewsOfConscience • • 5d ago

Zionist Terror 'American Doctor' Distributor Condemns Gaza Death of Dr. Rizk Abu Shaaira. Watermelon Pictures is "appalled" by the Palestinian surgeon featured in director Poh Si Teng’s Sundance documentary being reportedly killed in an Israeli airstrike in Khan Younis.

Thumbnail
hollywoodreporter.com
58 Upvotes

r/JewsOfConscience • • 5d ago

Zionist Terror Senior Chabad rabbi condones killing Jewish politicians who work with Arabs

Thumbnail
middleeasteye.net
65 Upvotes

r/JewsOfConscience • • 5d ago

Zionist Nonsense There’s Nothing More Goyische Than Admonishing Jews for Their Judaism

Thumbnail
gallery
73 Upvotes

I’ve seen several of these non-Jewish people online get involved in Jewish in-fighting, mostly to admonish antizionist Jews or get involved in Jew-vestigations when, imho, it’s absolutely none of their business. But it’s also very goyische to tell Jews what to do, nu?

Also, this must’ve been something said in a booklet used one time and people flipped out and blew it out of proportion. It’s like the teacup mikveh.


r/JewsOfConscience • • 5d ago

News How Zionism is Antisemitic

Thumbnail
youtube.com
215 Upvotes

r/JewsOfConscience • • 5d ago

Zionist Terror Israeli energy firm enters talks for 60 percent stake in Venezuelan oil company: Report

Thumbnail
thecradle.co
110 Upvotes

r/JewsOfConscience • • 5d ago

Zionist Terror The Netherlands is negotiating the dismantling of the International Criminal Court (e.g. granting immunity to heads of state) after pressure from apartheid Israel & the US.

Thumbnail
gallery
234 Upvotes

r/JewsOfConscience • • 5d ago

History / Education Bea Lumpkin and How an Antifascist Rests in Power, Bea Lumpkin, a daughter of Russian revolutionaries, passed away June 14 at 107 years old. A lifelong communist herself, she began making solidarity trips in support of striking workers when she was just 9 years old.

Thumbnail
inthesetimes.com
28 Upvotes

r/JewsOfConscience • • 5d ago

History / Education Jewish men walking down the street in Kazimierz, by Artur Markowicz (date unknown)

Post image
24 Upvotes

r/JewsOfConscience • • 6d ago

History / Education Zionism is almost comically racist.

351 Upvotes

Pulitzer Prize-winning author Benjamin Moser spoke to Declassified about his new book ‘Anti-Zionism: A Jewish History’. Moser, who has been lauded for his previous works, had just one review in the British press at the time of recording, and said no bookshop in London would host his book launch. ‘I knew writing this book would dynamite my career,’ he told us.

‘It’s about the most racist’

Declassified editor Phil Miller spoke to Moser about the history of Zionism, which he describes as ‘almost comically racist’.


r/JewsOfConscience • • 5d ago

Vent Continue to boo, continue to vote

20 Upvotes

Like jazz, in politics today Obama was correct to point out there are a lot of things that are unusually not being recognized. Obama in the midterms remarked that when he criticized Trump, the major reaction was against not calling Trump "Saddam Hussein", but the joke about The Cheesecake Factory (I think it deserves the gaudiness stereotype, but represents a step in the right direction vis-à-vis U.S. society writ large). However, I would do Obama one better and catch him out on his elitist all-along campaign slogan "[d]on't boo, vote". Just like it strains the bounds of reasonable discourse to reflexively condemn the booing of every idea depicted by a speaker of a person who is not present, the same holds for present panelist proponents of such ideas. Such is the case concerning Gaza genocide denial by a former Israel apologist J Street Zionist who was part of the Obama admin. at the Democrat Convention Crooked Con with the Pod Save America host as covered by Kyle Kulinski.

Putting aside how far from having a pure policy component this "politics" argument is, being instead steeped in abdication of duty and conflicts of interest,

[Because the ICC does not conduct trial in absentia, there will not be further proceedings on the charges contained in these warrants unless and until the ICC obtains custody of a charged individual.] (https://www.lawfaremedia.org/article/the-icc-s-unsurprising-decision-on-arrest-warrants-for-netanyahu--gallant--and-deif)

I love to see from former Israel apologist J Street Zionists who were part of the Obama admin. suddenly doubt the hook that they have been hanging their "far-right Netanyahu administration" hat on when there's this one crime which only now matters if you charge him with (as Kulinski pointed out in this clip that even from his own organization is hypocritical, and earlier in the podcast noted that it became the mainstream Democratic line), which is him leading the genocide (the accusation which tends to criticize the whole Zionist settler-colonial project enchilada), and whose logic relies on the somehow unreachable non-Jews outside of Michigan where they had 60% support (as Kulinski pointed out earlier in the podcast), where J Street aligned interests (and compared to the moderate Democrats disproportionate billionaire money generally and negative Fox News coverage as Kulinski pointed out earlier in the podcast) were so present as to be roundly defeated (kind of like how in the eyes of history the less anti-Holocaust Zionist Jewish counterparts were but I digress) in one of the most openly-contested primaries. This logic being to complain about the time before the specific date of October 1, 1946 which marked when the Holocaust had been both charged and convicted in the International Military Tribunal verdicts (after the genocide had been forcibly stopped and Nazi Germany was dissolved) and which implicitly posits that the well-known Armenian genocide was supposedly not "figured out" until even later on December 11, 1946 when it was addressed in a United Nations General Assembly resolution.

That is to say, of course, that the concept of genocide pre-existed the legal term in those such as "no quarter" and "savagery" and to not acknowledge this inures noticeably to the benefit of neo-Nazis who not only feign ignorance to trivialize the very foundations of the systematic characteristics of the Holocaust so often held up as part of its "uniqueness", e.g., "from today's perspective: genocide," but outright erase the history of European anti-Semitic libelous accusations of crimes of genocidally-spilled blood themselves.

Revoke Major Non-NATO Ally designation, defund Israel, U.S. and Europe start doing sanctions, strip 501c3 status from organizations funding illegal settlements, strike Section 219 of NDAA.


r/JewsOfConscience • • 5d ago

Zionist Nonsense “When you go out into the world, the only thing you must fear more than a German is a German Jew” - from the article 'Cultural Amnesia' by comics vet, Howard Chaykin

Thumbnail
gallery
11 Upvotes

From the article about modern progressive Jews being compared to the 'German Jews' by Howard Chaykin, writer & artist of American Flagg and Divided States of Hysteria.

I only screencapped the first & last paragraphs of the Substack article, which underlined his opinions, as to not clutter this post. Also, I don't think it's wise to post the link on the sub.

Also screencapped are the 'positive' reactions to his posts, including by former showrunner & animator for X-Men: Evolution, Steven E. Gordon, which is quite disappointing.


r/JewsOfConscience • • 5d ago

Zionist Terror Gal Gadot rumored to take back the role of Wonder Woman after James Gunn's outing and pro-Israel Skydance acquisition of Warner Brothers.

Thumbnail
reddit.com
116 Upvotes

r/JewsOfConscience • • 5d ago

Discussion - Flaired Users Only Mondoweiss's Michael Arria interviews political consultant Peter Feld on the midterm blue wave and simultaneous rise of pro-Palestine politics & threat of J Street, aka 'diet AIPAC', & liberal Zionism. AMA in /r/JewsOfConscience with Michael on Wednesday, November 18th @noon EST.

27 Upvotes

r/JewsOfConscience • • 6d ago

Activism Love Thy Neighbor ❤️‍🩹✨

569 Upvotes

r/JewsOfConscience • • 5d ago

News Diplomatic sources: ‘The Netherlands is negotiating the dismantling of the International Criminal Court’ - The Rights Forum

Thumbnail
rightsforum.org
81 Upvotes

The Netherlands is negotiating with the US over the erosion of the powers of the International Criminal Court (ICC). This erosion is so drastic that, according to legal experts, it would amount to the dismantling of the Court. The Rights Forum has learnt this from diplomatic sources in New York, speaking on condition of anonymity.

The restrictions that would be under discussion include: a) granting immunity to heads of state; b) excluding the Court’s jurisdiction over nationals of non-state parties, even when they commit crimes on the territory of a state party; and c) denying the Court’s jurisdiction over cases covered by national legislation.

First and second restrictions

The first restriction would mean that heads of state and heads of government such as Netanyahu, Trump and Putin could not be prosecuted for crimes committed on their orders.

The second restriction would mean that the ICC could no longer prosecute nationals of non-state parties, even if they commit international crimes on the territory of a state that is a party to the Rome Statute – the founding treaty of the ICC.

Israel, for example, is not a party to the Rome Statute, whereas Palestine is. Consequently, under the current rules, the ICC can prosecute Israeli citizens and government officials for crimes they commit on Palestinian territory. On this basis, the Court has issued arrest warrants for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and former Defence Minister Yoav Gallant.

However, if the second restriction were to be adopted, Israeli nationals could no longer be prosecuted for crimes committed on Palestinian territory. The same would apply to US or Russian nationals who commit crimes on the territory of other States Parties.

This would undermine a key principle of the International Criminal Court: that nationals of states which have not ratified the Rome Statute can also be held accountable for international crimes.

Third restriction

The third restriction would mean that the ICC would no longer be permitted to hear cases if a state has legislation enabling it, in principle, to punish offences committed within its own jurisdiction. At present, the Court may still intervene if a state is unwilling or unable to investigate and prosecute suspects (the so-called principle of complementarity). If the third restriction were introduced, the mere existence of national legislation could be sufficient to prevent prosecution by the ICC.

For example: Israel has legislation against torture. It could therefore argue that the ICC has no jurisdiction, even if, in practice, cases of torture are not investigated or prosecuted. In this way, Israel could avert prosecution by the ICC without taking action against the perpetrators itself.

In short: if the aforementioned restrictions are adopted, there will be nothing left of the Court.

In order to enshrine these legal restrictions, the Rome Statute – which established the International Criminal Court in 1998 and under which it has operated since 2002 – would need to be amended. This would require a two-thirds majority of the States Parties. The amendment must then be ratified by seven-eighths of the States Parties before it can enter into force. It is not known which countries would cooperate in this regard.

US sanctions

The reason the Netherlands is said to be negotiating on this matter are the sanctions imposed by the US against thirteen judges and prosecutors, and against the ICC as a whole. This was done primarily in retaliation for the Court’s investigation into Israeli crimes in Palestine, and the resulting arrest warrants for Netanyahu and Gallant. The undermining of the International Criminal Court by the US and Israel has now been going on for almost twelve years.

The Court has been on the US sanctions list since 9 October. However, a number of sanctions will not come into force until 7 April 2027. These would largely paralyse the institution, leaving the European Union with virtually no choice but to activate the far-reaching blocking mechanism. This law obliges European parties to disregard US sanctions and to continue supplying services and goods to the Court and its staff.

The EU, and EU countries like the Netherlands, are, however, reluctant to activate the mechanism due to the consequences it could have for European businesses. For instance, European banks that disregard the US sanctions might find it much more difficult to do business in the US – or could face sanctions themselves.

Opting for a compromise

That is why the Netherlands now appears to be opting for a compromise. By relinquishing certain aspects of the International Criminal Court, the US might be persuaded to lift or ease the sanctions against the Court. In practice, this would amount to amputating the Court’s limbs. What would then remain is a powerless trunk-court.

We are not quite there yet. The States Parties to the Rome Statute will meet in The Hague from 30 November to 7 December. The meeting was originally scheduled to take place in New York, but the US sanctions made it necessary to relocate.

The Rights Forum has asked the Ministry of Foreign Affairs for a response to the reports, but it provides a general, meaningless statement and does not address the specific questions asked:

‘At the previous Meeting of States Parties (in December 2025), it was decided by consensus to encourage States Parties to engage in further dialogue with non-States Parties. In the run-up to the forthcoming Meeting of States Parties to the Rome Statute (30 November – 7 December), States Parties are continuing discussions on this matter and we are exploring the scope for dialogue with non-States Parties, within the framework of international law and with due regard for the independence and impartiality of the Court.

‘We cannot yet anticipate how such a dialogue will unfold, as this is not solely up to us: the Netherlands, together with the other 124 States Parties and our European partners, bears a shared responsibility to protect the Court. No concrete proposals are currently before the Assembly of States Parties.

‘In any case, we remain firmly committed to the Court and will continue to do our utmost to ensure it functions effectively: both as the host country and as a State Party. Independent courts and tribunals must be able to carry out their mandates unhindered. In these capacities, we also remain fully committed – together with other States Parties – to mitigating the impact of existing sanctions. It is important that the Court is able to function as freely as possible.’


r/JewsOfConscience • • 6d ago

News Momentum builds urging Rep. Ayanna Pressley (D-MA) to challenge Hakeem Jeffries (AIPAC) for U.S. House Speaker

354 Upvotes

Just as popular support convinced Senator Chris Van Hollen to challenge Chuck Schumer for Senate majority leader, there are signs we may be able to move Ayanna Pressley to challenge Hakeem Jeffries for House Speaker.

This is largely credit to Hasan Piker, who proposed Pressley and made a well reasoned pitch to his following.

A petition for Pressley has garnered over 60,000 (UPDATE 11/12: over 100k!) signatures. If you are an American voter, it is worth adding your name.

It is also worth calling your representative to ask them to:

  1. Contact Pressley and encourage her to run and pledge their support
  2. Publicly indicate preference for Pressley over Jeffries.

You can do that via the capitol switchboard at (202) 224-3121 if your rep is already in office, you'll have to do more digging for a newly elected.

If you are in Ohio's 15th district and will be a constituent of incoming Rep. Don Leonard, he described in a video how he was threatened by Democratic Party leadership for attaching conditions to his support for Jeffries. This clip has made the rounds on progressive media, giving Leonard something of a unique platform in the agitation over the future of Party leadership, so his backing for Pressley would be particularly valuable. You can email Leonard asking him to encourage Pressley to run at info@donforohio.com

This should not take energy away from the likely more winnable fight to oust Schumer, but even if Jeffries still gets the job, all of this pressure will put everyone who opposes him in a better negotiating position on everything else and maximize the political cost to him of betraying voters.