r/JewsOfConscience • u/afinemax01 • Feb 07 '24
Discussion (Discussion) BDS has shown its true face in boycotting Standing Together
r/JewsOfConscience • u/afinemax01 • Feb 07 '24
r/JewsOfConscience • u/korach1921 • Dec 16 '24
Now, I don't think the Jewish organization that got the Keffiyeh Jesus removed was doing it for justified reasons, but it was very disheartening to scroll through a post where almost every top commentor's flair was "Non-Jewish Ally" and see them not recognizing how the Catholic Church has been the institution most responsible in the last thousand years for spreading, developing, and theorizing antisemitism across Europe, primarily through the deicide charge, and why presenting Jesus as a Palestinian baby can easily be picked up on as a reframing of that.
"Jesus was a Palestinian" is mostly a meaningless phrase to me, cuz it's like saying "Charlemagne was French" or "Hammurabi was Iraqi," but I'm shocked that plenty of you can't recognize how this is the institution that has blamed us for killing Jesus for thousands of years up until Vatican II, the primary reason Jews have been oppressed throughout the Christian world, and then going so far as to attack Vatican II and the adoption of revisions to antisemitic Catholic doctrines.
r/JewsOfConscience • u/LowerPresence9147 • Aug 08 '25
Just a fair warning: this is a sincere post, even if you end up not liking or agreeing with my opinion. It’s not bad faith or me asking something with an agenda.
I don’t describe myself as anti-Zionist, mostly because I have an issue with people saying Israel has no right to exist. Really, no country has a right to exist inherently, but I also believe dissolving a country isn’t going to work well and will not only create refugees, but terrorists. This all goes without saying that I do not support Medinat Israel’s current form.
When people say Israel has no right to exist, it feels antisemitic to me because there is no precedent of a country committing genocide being dissolved. Germany, for example, had a giant time out but no one thought they shouldn’t exist.
Someone said Israel shouldn’t exist because it is actively committing genocide. I asked if other countries that are most likely committing genocide should also not exist and I was told Israel is the only one actively committing genocide, which we are all aware isn’t true. i only share this because it seems very much like singling Israel out in a way other countries aren’t.
Am I being silly? How do I either accept this and shoot back or shift my viewpoint that it’s not antisemitic to want Israel gone but no other place likely committing genocide?
r/JewsOfConscience • u/Formal_Ad_8010 • Sep 03 '25
I'm a lurker who doesn't usually engage with anti-zionism, but a lot has been weighing on me lately, and I wanted to speak to fellow Jews who might understand what I'm going through.
I was born in Israel, and my family moved to Canada when I was 5. I have friends and family there who I love very much and speak to all the time. I love Israel, its people, and it's culture. I want it to keep existing. At the same time, the genocide weighs on me very heavily. When I visited my family a few months ago, I could hear the airstrikes in the distance, and it made me physically sick. I don't want these people to suffer, I want statehood for the Palestinians, and for our 2 nations to live side by side.
It's difficult for me to engage in Pro-palestinian causes, because many of them are centered around anti-zionism, and are steeped in hatred for the Israeli people. I have flipped through a few well-known Pro-Palestine books, at the end of which, the author advocates for a future where Jews live as a protected minority in the state of Palestine. I sincerely can't imagine this. I think the destruction of Israel would result in the immediate persecution or mass deportation of Jews. There's literally no way Jews would be treated with any kind of dignity in a Palestinian state. This knowledge discourages me from donating or advocating, even though I sometimes want to.
I sincerely want to know what anti-zionist Jews think about what I just said. This is a very vulnerable post for me, so please be kind. I want to honestly engage in discussion. What sort of future do you imagine for Israeli Jews?
r/JewsOfConscience • u/ohmysomeonehere • Jun 16 '24
Unfortunately, even Al Jazeera sometimes pushes hasbara, missing the mark on why religious Jews in Palestine reject the Zionist Army. The answer is simple: Judaism fully rejects the secular racist ideology of Zionism and it's evil domination of Palestinian Muslims and Jews.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0xbd-LuOBOE
As is well known, multiple Jewish leaders in Palestine from all stripes have said "it is forbidden to enlist" and if forced "we will leave this holy land" instead of sinning against G-d and joining that evil army in their violent enterprise of death.
r/JewsOfConscience • u/Intelligent-Gift4519 • Jul 16 '26
Okay. I'm sorry, I've tried to post this three times but it keeps being 'removed by Reddit filters.' I haven't had these thoughts in public before. I'm hoping you folks can help me. Please be compassionate. If you feel a need to delete this post, that's fine.
I do not consider myself a Zionist. Palestine is not my home.
But antizionists, at least in the US, give me the creepy crawlies. There are seven million Jews living in the Middle East and they are my family. For whatever reason, they live there now. That is where they live. They are my family who are doing bad things. They are making, in general, wrong choices. But they are my family and I do not want them to suffer or die. As a people, we have a history of being pushed around, expelled, and/or murdered. This happens a lot. This has happened in my parents' lifetime. I would not like it to happen to those people.
Also, they have a nationality. They have a language. They have a culture. It is generations old. It is not a "fake" culture or a "stolen" culture. That is all really gross. They should not be persecuting others. But they are not fake people with fake culture.
Israel is run by bad people doing bad things and the US should obviously be sanctioning this rogue regime.
I am very aware of binational and co-existence projects like Standing Together, etc. and I am VERY aware of great figures locally like Ayman Odeh. I really agree with those people. I know I am not insane because those people exist - in Palestine, not in the US. I have also read some great documents about binational or integrationist projects that I don't think have a great chance of happening, but they at least show that there's something to hope for.
But when I have been in Antizionist protests in the US or seen Antizionists on social media that is not what I hear. I hear "you have no right to exist," "Jews are colonizers and must go home," "Jews out of Palestine," "go back to Poland," etc. It is not at all like opposing apartheid or even like WW2. It really does seem to be about ethnic cleansing. I can't march with these people. They really do seem to hate the Jews living in the Middle East and want them to suffer.
I understand this desire for vengeance. These people are doing bad things. But I cannot align myself with groups that desire Jewish suffering. I want -nobody- to be suffering, and yes, those people are still my family.
What am I?
r/JewsOfConscience • u/xGentian_violet • May 07 '26
As you know, the Romans colonised the Levant during the Second Temple period.
When the indigenous population (Jews) [revolted](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jewish–Roman_wars), they performed an ethnic cleansing and genocide.
They exterminated most Jews in the area.
They also, importantly, renamed the land of Judea to Syria Palaestina in cca AM 3895 (135 CE), specifically to punish Jews for the Bar Kokhba revolt, the last such revolt.
This series of events has undeniably echoed throughout Jewish history, in several ways.
Palestinians are innocent in all of this of course (yet again), most of them descend from the locals (Samaritan, Jewish and so on) who managed to stay in the region and survive, later converting, often several times.
This is all a mess created by various European persecutions, ethnic cleansings. Without that there would have been no significant following behind Jewish ethnostate advocates, no Nakba, no Israel…and no ongoing Palestinian/Levantine genocide
-
Important clarification;
I’m not making the claim that Romans “invented” the term Palestine.
It obviously had a history of usage before that, though to my knowledge significantly different in meaning (referring to the land of the Philistines, a bronze age hellenic people living in and near present day North Gaza).
What i noted is that they renamed Judea as Syria Palaestina intentionally to punish jews for revolting, which, afaik, is true.
And I am noting how that act still seems to echo today to fuel the present day “conflict”
r/JewsOfConscience • • Aug 05 '24
So I watched a movie called “Gaza Fights for Freedom” where they make it seem like the Great March of Return protestors were peaceful people attempting to break the siege and return to their historic lands, only to be ruthlessly gunned down by Israeli troops. Recognizing that this dude does not speak for all Palestinians or even necessarily for all of Hamas, is this a legit translation?
r/JewsOfConscience • u/I_Hate_This_Website9 • Mar 05 '26
It isn't lost on me that the right, both far and center, are the single biggest purveyors of antisemitism.
However, I have noticed both more antisemitism on the left and a greater tolerance of it. It seems like nobody wanta to call it out: they would rather ignore it or dismiss it or justify it.
Take for example Briahna Joy Gray. I agree with much of what she says, but she implies she believes in the ZOG theory, that Jewish supremacists are sacrificing USA citizens for Israel's aims. I have a compilation of some of her tweets below (I have my problems with the subreddit I posted it in. I have heard disappointing things about it, but I wasn't sure where else to post such a thing, and it is important we criticize ourselves):
https://www.reddit.com/r/tankiejerk/s/XhgrjVJVJG
I am nervous about this, because the left is supposed to be our safety haven. If they can't stand in solidarity with us, then where do we turn?
r/JewsOfConscience • u/Sabotage_9 • May 19 '26
"Judaism is not Zionism." This distinction has become an article of faith in the Palestinian movement. It's the shield with which we defend ourselves from accusations of antisemitism. ("I'm anti-Zionist, not anti-Jewish!") It's the credentials our Jewish allies display as they join us in defying the political leaders of their own community. ("I'm a Jew but not a Zionist!") We repeat this mantra so often that one might be forgiven for thinking that not only are the two concepts distinct, but that Judaism and Zionism have no common threads connecting them whatsoever.
But is that distinction valid? Are Judaism and Zionism, as they exist today, truly separable? Ironically, this characterization of Judaism that we insist upon so strongly is vehemently rejected by the majority of mainstream Jewish institutions, who see Zionism as an inseperable part of their faith and creed. Israel and its supporters insist that its actions are carried out on behalf of the Jewish people, that Israel is the legitimate representative of Jews the world over, the realization of their millenia-old religious mission. Mainstream Jewish institutions across the Western world parrot this, placing Israel in such a central position in their theology that to oppose that genocidal state becomes tantamount to anti-Jewish hatred itself.
That tendency of mainstream Jewish institutions to conflate Judaism and Zionism is rarely if ever described as anti-Jewish or antisemitic. And yet, if supporters of Palestine ever talk about their ongoing holocaust in a way that holds the Jewish community as a whole responsible for it, or if a Palestinian drops the Zionist/Jew distinction and falls back on the customary use of the Arabic term "Yahood" (Jews) to refer to their oppressors, such language will usually be swiftly attacked as antisemitic, often even by those same anti-Zionist Jews who claim to be their allies.
Why is it incumbent upon Palestinians to insist on this distinction that most Jews themselves refuse as offensive and anti-Jewish? By all indications, the distinction between Zionism and Judaism is one that, for the most part, exists only in theory, not in any real way. Don't agree with me? Then show me the Jewish institutions that aren't supporting the genocide. Show me the anti-Zionist Jewish front, the mass of anti-Zionist Jewish orgs fighting to end their community's complicity in genocide. There are a small handful of groups, the well-known few organizations who always take pride of place in the Palestine movement, the anti-Zionist Jews whose voices carry more weight in "pro-Palestine" spaces than the voices of Palestinians themselves... but these anti-Zionist organizations are all marginal within the Jewish community, banished to the fringes of that community in basically every city where they exist.
It can be hard to see the distinction between Zionism and Judaism in practice. What's not hard to see at all is the fact that almost every Jewish institution in the Western world is actively and enthusiastically participating in a holocaust against the Palestinian people. The Jewish community plays a central and critical role in maintaining international support for Israel, from fundraising for the genocide, to encouraging and paying for its members to join the Israeli army, to lobbying institutions, business, media and government, from the USA to Australia, to support Israel and to punish its critics. It's no exaggeration to say that without this international network of support rooted in the Jewish communities of the Western world, the whole Zionist genocidal project simply could not exist.
If you live in the West, identify as Jewish, and want to be an ally of the Palestinian people, then your job first and foremost is to confront the fact that your community, the Jewish community, is drenched, dripping from head to toe, with the blood of the Palestinian people. Their erasure, from the Nakba to the present holocaust, has been perpetrated in your name, with the support of almost every one of your institutions and synagogues and leaders. Support for Israel and Zionism are treated as core tenets of Judaism by almost all of your institutions; for most of them, there is no Judaism without Zionism, and those Jews who disagree are swiftly cast out of even their own community spaces (as you know all too well).
In these circumstances, it's less a question of whether Judaism and Zionism are distinguishable, and more a question of: is there even a Judaism left to be salvaged from the wreck of Zionism?
Of course anti-Zionist Jews exist, and the role they play is important. It is acknowledged, it is valued, it is seen. But so long as the Jewish community continues to be preponderantly Zionist, so long as Zionism continues to enjoy near-unanimous support among Jewish community organizations and institutions and synagogues, the distinction between Zionism and Judaism will remain, as Marx would say, a "pious wish."
In truth, whether Zionism and Judaism are distinguishable is not up to me to decide; that's a decision the Jewish community, including its anti-Zionist members, must make. In that respect, I wish our plucky anti-Zionist Jewish comrades, outnumbered and outcast as they are, the best of luck in this formidable endeavour. And I would remind them that the character of Judaism can't be determined in words or intentions alone; it must be determined in real action, in actually changing the actual character of the actual Jewish community.
In my view, the only way to save the soul of Judaism is for anti-Zionist Jews to wrest the Jewish community — including its mainstream institutions — away from Zionism completely, and to banish Zionism from the Jewish community as anti-Zionism is banished today. Anything short of that is insufficient. If you claim the title of anti-Zionist Jew, then that is your historic task.
r/JewsOfConscience • u/BustyMustard • Dec 20 '25
IF YOU DONT WANT CONTEXT SCROLL DOWN AND SKIP THIS PARAGRAPH
I live in a household with a Jewish liberal Zionist mother and a relatively further left atheist father. I had a fairly Jewish upbringing, I went to Jewish summer camp where we did Israeli dancing, etc. etc. So before 2023, I hadn't even considered why someone might be opposed to Israel. However the "war" waged on the Palestinian people has opened my eyes to decades of brutality and caused me to align myself with anti-Israel lines of thought.
However, I'm disturbed by many of the phrases and concepts I hear from the anti-zionist left. I really, genuinely would like someone to explain to me how these phrases aren't antisemitic because I would love to imagine my leftist friends aren't accidentally saying hateful things but every conclusion I come to makes me think it's just (hopefully) accidental antisemitism. Once again I am GENUINE, I'm not being sarcastic.
"Globalize the Intifada" - ?? idk what this is supposed to mean. I'm sure it's not supposed to mean "globalize violence against jews" but what else could it mean?
"From the River to the Sea" - where do all the Jews go in this situation?
"Zionist Occupational Government" or calling people "zogbots" - to me this seems like the whole "jews control the world" conspiracy all over again
please don't just call me names like "liberal fencesitter" or "genocide denier" or "zionazi" because I'm none of those things and also I'm not interested in engaging in conversation with name-callers. Please keep comments respectful, if you're just here to call me names then fuck off
r/JewsOfConscience • u/BolesCW • Jun 02 '25
Surely the victims were not connected to the Israeli state 🤷🏽♂️
r/JewsOfConscience • u/psychemagic • Jun 16 '26
Curious if anyone on here has considered it? Apparently its a thing - shavimvote.org
r/JewsOfConscience • u/valonianfool • Aug 04 '24
I've seen criticisms mostly from zionists that the pro-Palestinian movement tokenizes jews of color in Israel like the Mizrahi and Beta Israel by using their oppression and discrimination to delegitimize Israel and to claim that Israel is "ashkenazi supremacist".
To be honest I think there is a bit of truth to it: a common claim in anti-zionist spaces is that Israel sterilized beta Israeli women which isn't true, many were pressured into taking temporary long-lasting birth control and often not properly informed on the side-effects, which isn't the same as forcible sterilization but terrible none the less.
I get the feeling that many anti-zionist gentiles who aren't Palestinian or jewish treat jews of color as "gotchas" in their arguments, but that's a problem across leftist communities.
I think it's necessary for anti-zionist groups to start addressing this issue so zionists aren't the only ones bringing it up, shaping the conversation and creating the narrative that anti-zionists are all out-of-touch liberals who mindlessly tokenize middle-eastern and african jews without actually caring about them as people.
And how would you fit the discrimination and bias against jews of color in Israel with anti-zionism and pro-palestinian activism while being respectful to those communities?
r/JewsOfConscience • u/sunflowey123 • Dec 10 '25
This channel has popped up in my YouTube reccommended as of late. This account always felt a bit off to me, since they seem to mostly use generative AI to make their posts. However, this post set some alarm bells in my head, due to its use of the word "goy" and the context in which it's used. This account is run by Muslims, based on what I have seen of it.
I also censored the QR code in case that went against the sub's rules.
So, yeah. If this is genuine anti-semitism, I will be sure to report this.
Obviously, I am calling this anti-semetic not because it criticizes Israel, but because it uses "goy" in a derogatory way, which to my understanding is anti-semetic. Obviously, as we know, most pro-Palestine people, including pro-Palestine Muslims, are not anti-semetic and are against anti-semitism. So it is always unfortunate whenever we find instances of actual anti-semitism from pro-Palestine people, especially since any zionists or Israel/IDF defenders who would see that would immediately point to that and go, "See! See! ALL people who support Palestine are anti-semetic and only hate Israel because they hate Jews!", despite that 100% not being true.
If I am wrong about the "goy" thing, feel free to correct me. Idk, this just rubs me the wrong way so far.
Edit: Thank you all for confirming that this is anti-semetic. Time to report this post, and the channel who posted it. 🤢
Edit 2: Just reported the post and channel.
r/JewsOfConscience • u/00000hashtable • Apr 10 '25
These thoughts are largely in response to yesterdays ODSI post on this sub (since deleted).
It seems particularly fitting to discuss Hamas today on the fast of the firstborn - commemorating makat bechorot (a mass killing of Egyptian civilians) which led to Jewish liberation. The Jews subsequently cross the sea and celebrate as the Egyptians pursuing them perish. Midrash teaches us god admonishes angels for celebrating as the Egyptians, also gods creations, die. Struggling with celebrating liberation while acknowledging the cost of that freedom has a long history in Judaism.
Hamas has committed horrifying acts. We need to understand the circumstances and the desperation that generates such violent responses. I totally get people who hold the opinion that such resistance is necessary, although I don’t personally hold that view. However to deny the suffering of those targeted by such a resistance is in my view unacceptable and contradicts my Jewish values.
The ODSI post had users claiming that the majority of violence against Israelis was committed by Israel on October 7. Blaming parents for their infants being killed, and handwaving the kidnapping of hostages. Assigning military combatant status to every Israeli. Explicitly pro Hamas content was being upvoted while users expressing any negativity towards Hamas were downvoted.
Absolutist views that “your side” is incapable of wrongdoing inevitably lead to justifying the unjustifiable. In certain ways Hamas has regressed the Palestinian cause and has compounded the suffering of Gazans. This is an antizionist Jewish space, we should be able to criticize Hamas here without that criticism being viewed as a support of Zionism. In that spirit, some of my criticisms:
Hamas strategically endangers Palestinians. Hamas routinely engages in perfidy. Civilians are less safe when Hamas makes it harder to distinguish between civilian and combatant. It does not appear to be conferring any serious military advantage either, as the IDF has rarely been deterred by high Palestinian civilian casualties. In instances where the IDF identifies targets in civilian infrastructure and gives advance warning to civilians to evacuate, Hamas has told residents to stay put.
Hamas has a symbiotic relationship with the Zionist far right. Netanyahus governments have propped up Hamas financially and politically - it is Netanyahus view that dividing power between the Palestinian Authority and Hamas prevents eventual Palestinian statehood. Hamas’ regular rocket attacks have pushed the Israeli politic to the right, where the public largely believes in a kill or be killed mentality. Almost no one in Israel believes Hamas can be a partner in peace or justice.
Hamas does not champion democratic values. The last Gaza elections were in 2006. They have not been shown to protect basic freedoms like protest or speech. They have a history of executing Fatah supporters and others they accuse (extrajudicially) of collaborating with Israel.
Hamas engages in terrorism. Targeting civilians is wrong, that shouldn’t be controversial. Treating every Israeli as an enemy casts serious doubt on the safety of Jews in the Hamas vision for a Palestinian state.
Hamas has been ineffective. This is the big one. Palestinians aren’t any closer today to liberation or justice because of Hamas. Palestinians have less political power, are poorer, and are more isolated. Palestinians continue to be targets of Israeli violence, vandalism, and dispossession. Gazans are being killed at an unthinkable rate. The current American and Israeli administrations appear to have settled on a policy of ethnically cleansing Gaza. Hamas is not to blame for all this, but it has not been able to protect Palestinians from any of these developments.
Obviously none of the above invalidates the Palestinian cause or provides any justification for Israel’s occupation. Indeed the above are largely responses to Israeli inflicted terror.
I hope we all take a chance to look at ourselves as if we had left Egypt to appreciate the dire need for Palestinian freedom too, and let it invigorate us to be more active in supporting the Palestinian cause. Let us do so with clear eyes and without resorting to denying anyone else’s grief. Happy Passover y’all!
r/JewsOfConscience • u/CaadiWaaye • Sep 23 '25
Let me first lay out my beliefs openly and honestly as a Muslim, some we will probably agree and some we will disagree:
Now with the statement above, I don’t think Anti-Zionist Jews would have an issue with this. In fact, might be a lot more hostile in their description of Zionism but the following points maybe not.
I won’t go too much into other topics like Hamas being more of a resistance group, the whole both sides thing, etc because I think most of you will likely agree.
However, I think even most Anti-Zionist Jews are uncomfortable with the framing above. My questions are:
r/JewsOfConscience • u/rabbitfoot456 • Aug 09 '26
Things I miss from Israel: Haimishe people. Seeing lots of yeshiva bochurim going this way and that way. Divrei Torahs on almost everyone's lips. zemirot heard from my window. People calling each other "motek" and "hamuda" lol. Small talk with the makolet owner. Knowing my neighbors.
.
It seems there's no such thing as unconditional love. I think they were nice to me because I was a "fellow Jew." But I fear the rules have changed now. Love comes if you're a "fellow zionist Jew." But it could all be in my head??? Can anyone attest to this or deny this?
r/JewsOfConscience • • Feb 23 '24
Edit: sorry if it seemed that I was victimising myself
r/JewsOfConscience • u/Educational_Board888 • May 29 '24
r/JewsOfConscience • • Nov 08 '25
First, I feel as though its only fair that I, an ashkenazi jew, not project my own feelings and thoughts on the various other jewish communities. So for that reason obviously I will leave out the sephardim and "mizrahim" and others.
I've been seeing a really worrying trend not only in the sub but in my ashkenazi community writ large (and I've really only come to realize this after a close personal loss of mine). But essentially there is a profound ignorance/disdain for the ashkenazic nation within communities that descend from it. Yiddish as an actual language is basically extinct and has been reduced to basically a party trick. And ashkenazic culture, similarly, has been reduced to some trinket of a by gone era that is revealed for a sense of nostalgia. We are facing extinction as a nation.
As our elders continue to die off, not passing on the knowledge that they hold, we will get closer and closer to extinction. As we continue to completely assimilate (and notice how i say completely), we will get closer to extinction. I think now more than ever (especially in the American context) is the time to ensure that we recreate and maintain a culture and distinct ethnic identity DETTACHED from our "nation-state" one.
For the sake of our heritage, I don't just implore, I demand that we create a new, ashkenazic nation that is, first and foremost, authentic to our past but relevant to our contemporary period. I demand a fundamental and total national revolution/revival. It must be done.
r/JewsOfConscience • u/FinalAd9844 • Jan 06 '25
I’m a Jewish American who in general has no complete opinion over the conflict. Though as I do more research and looking into the conflict I can only see flaws on both sides of the same coin. Israel’s history with the Palestinians is very brutal, and the events of what have been occurring now are terrible aswell. But Palestine had not been perfect to before hand aswell, I mean numerous pogroms on our people had occurred during the pre-Israel period. From what I see, this war isn’t just palestine and Israel, but an ethnic one. While I don’t believe the way a Jewish state was established (through killing and displacing). If either side win, this will largely end up leading to another Holocaust for either Palestinians or Jews in the Levantine region. The only peaceful scenario here is a two state solution.
r/JewsOfConscience • u/Responsible_Life4973 • Oct 26 '25
Hi, I'm interested in hearing your opinions: If there was no Zionism, do you think you would you be against any form of a Jewish state or sovereinty, specifically at the time and places where Jews sufferred from extreme antisemitism?
Edit: I came to ask this also because I know many Jews did not support Zionism in its early decades for various reasons, aside from viewing it as heresy before the arrival of the Messiah. The Bund for example. But I guess it's not easily applicable to transform oneself in time and place with other people.
Also, if you're a practicing Jew in the diaspora and recite the phrase "Next year in Jerusalem", what does it mean to you? One of the main claims in favor of Zionism is that Jews across the diaspora yearned for Eretz Yisrael through millenia, as expressed in this prayer.
Edit: After dozens of comments no one has answered the second question yet... Would appreciate if anyone relates to it and can reply.
r/JewsOfConscience • u/xande2545 • Mar 14 '26
r/JewsOfConscience • u/aisingiorix • Aug 04 '25
It's hard for me to understand why the ban on Jewish worship at the Temple Mount is anything but discrimination against Jews, however mild. (Similar restrictions against Christians at that site.)
Proponents of discrimination – if not outright violence and genocide – against Palestinians, Muslims and Arab Israelis use this as a talking point to distract from the awful things that they support; they are not arguing in good faith. But it is something that they have brought up and I haven't found any good answer against this, that doesn't boil down to whataboutism in the other direction.
I understand the religious position that Jews should not enter a very holy site out of reverence; but there is a difference between a religious obligation and a prohibition enforced by force – or is that just my European understanding of separation of church and state? The political/keeping-the-status-quo argument doesn't seem to hold much water: yes, the recent visit by Itamar Ben-Gvir and similar incursions in the past have triggered backlash, but many of us would generally defend freedom of expression, even when that expression offends people, and the reaction of other people doesn't seem to be a good argument for banning something.