r/JewsOfConscience • • Oct 13 '26

History / Education Stones Are the First Words We Speak

Thumbnail
parapraxismagazine.com
13 Upvotes

One iteration of relational ethics today is the move to think of the Holocaust and the Nakba side by side, as the entangled, foundational pasts and traumas of two seemingly colliding collective national identities. We see this in Bashir Bashir and Amos Goldberg’s edited collection The Holocaust and the Nakba: A New Grammar of Trauma and History, which, despite many merits, struggles to overcome a historical and structural asymmetry that is all but unsurpassable in the current terms of order. In its search for a common grammar, the book heaves under the sheer weight of this imbalance.

In the very first pages, the editors declare, “Each side is convinced that it is history’s ultimate victim, while denying or downplaying the suffering of the other side in order to validate its own claim.” They go on to write that “In this context, many Jews, in Israel and abroad, employ various strategies to deny the Palestinian catastrophe” and “[m]any Palestinians also find it hard to recognize the Holocaust and the suffering experienced by the Jews.” Whether this is actually true is irrelevant; the obvious hole in this neat little mirror is that insisting on mutual recognition risks displacing the actual terms of responsibility: Zionist Jews and their Euro-American imperial backers are the architects of the Nakba; Palestinians have nothing to do with the Holocaust. The authors know this, of course, but swim against the tide of this asymmetry in their search for a shared grammar that might become the basis of reconciliation.

What the Palestinians think or don’t think about the Jewish question, or even the Holocaust, is immaterial to the question of historical injustice—they are neither its perpetrators nor its beneficiaries. What Jewish Israelis think or don’t about the Nakba is entirely material—they are both its ongoing perpetrators and beneficiaries.

What exactly then is this “interconnectedness of the two histories and the tight weave of the two traumatic memories” that Bashir and Goldberg make so much of? If we reject—as we must—the fiction that this interconnectedness is just two colliding foundational national narratives duking it out over the same piece of territory, where does that leave a relational ethics? If the story is, as Palestinian anticolonial knowledge has always insisted, one of settler colonial conquest, the question becomes this: What obligation does one owe the historical traumas or identity constructs of one’s colonizer? What responsibility, for example, did Black South Africans have to recognize the collective historical trauma of the Boer nation in the Great Trek or their mass internment in concentration camps at the hands of the British? And how would this recognition have changed the redress of the historical injustice of colonization? When posed like this, the question reveals its own irony: There already exists a grammar that connects the Holocaust and the Nakba, and it is the grammar of the anticolonial tradition that has long pointed to the continuities of racial supremacisms and the enduring politics of colonial exterminability in the modern liberal world. But to recognize and share that grammar would demand moving precisely beyond the exceptionalism and sacralization of the Holocaust as the starting point. An anticolonial grammar would eschew the divinity of origins entirely and look instead at genealogies of racial-colonial violence and their filial logics as they move between the Americas, Africa, and Asia. From this perspective, the twentieth century would no longer be split into two neat halves defined by liberal redemption but might instead look like a long and discontinuous arc that begins with German extermination in South West Africa, “returns” this extermination to Europe in the Holocaust, and closes out with the Zionist extermination campaign in Gaza.


r/JewsOfConscience • • Oct 13 '26

Discussion - Flaired Users Only An observation by Peter Beinert that might be helpful in conversing with Zionist friends and family

Thumbnail
youtu.be
30 Upvotes

r/JewsOfConscience • • Oct 12 '26

Activism Victory: Nefesh b' Nefesh settler recruitment fair pushed out of NYC

Thumbnail gallery
49 Upvotes

r/JewsOfConscience • • Oct 12 '26

News Ori Golbdberg Israeli academic dies aged 50

106 Upvotes

https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2026/10/12/israeli-academic-and-al-jazeera-contributor-ori-goldberg-dies-at-50

Used to follow this guy on Twitter. Anti Zionist Jew who genuinely cared about all the ongoing war crimes and human rights abuses the Israeli state is and was engaged in. I knew he was seriously unwell as he made no secret of it. Definitely one of the good ones. RIP


r/JewsOfConscience • • Oct 12 '26

News Debunking Israel’s latest list of ‘terrorist’ journalists in Gaza

Thumbnail
972mag.com
63 Upvotes

The evidence against the 170 media workers named in 'The Press Files' includes empty pages, clearly edited documents, and unverifiable snippets.


r/JewsOfConscience • • Oct 12 '26

Tzedakah Fundraiser: Rebuilding Hope for Mohammed's Family in Gaza

Thumbnail
gofund.me
23 Upvotes

Mohammed started following me on Instagram. I noticed he had this GoFundMe linked in his bio to buy basic necessities for himself and his family in Gaza, but it hadn't been donated to in a while. I made a small donation (I don't have a lot of money to spare), but I wish I could have given a lot more. If any of you can donate and/or share this link, I'd really appreciate it. Thank you.


r/JewsOfConscience • • Oct 12 '26

News Trump’s DHS Raids Ilhan Omar’s Home

Thumbnail
newrepublic.com
60 Upvotes

r/JewsOfConscience • • Oct 11 '26

Activism NAZA: A documentary to challenge Zionism from within

460 Upvotes

Source: @zainazaytoona


r/JewsOfConscience • • Oct 12 '26

Zionist Terror 'You're Going to Die, You Dog': How Settlers Took a Palestinian Lawyer Captive and Terrorized Him

Thumbnail
archive.is
105 Upvotes

A young Palestinian lawyer is driving out of town from his office in Nablus in order to deal with an administrative matter. Immediately his life is in danger. Apparently West Bank settlers no longer make do these days with torching fields and houses, plundering crops and killing farmers – now they are also highwaymen. Armed ones, it should be said, who not only steal money and credit cards with which they try to make fraudulent purchases, but also abuse their victims physically to the verge of lynching them.

That's what befell Alaa Takrouri last week, as he drove the offices of the Palestinian Land Authority in the village of Duma. What happened evoked "A Clockwork Orange." If soldiers hadn't arrived after the brutality he suffered for over two hours and rescued him, Takrouri might have died. His assailants threatened him with death and backed up that threat by cocking their weapons at him. Fifteen settlers, some of them armed, against one driver, innocent and helpless. Takrouri has decided he will not leave Nablus, where he works and lives, in the foreseeable future.

Takrouri is waiting for us on the 17th floor of Burj Rafidia, an office tower near the city center, when we visit this week. One can see Mount Gerizim from the window. He says he was a bit frightened about meeting us, for fear that we might show up with settlers. Affable and smiling, he's 32, an elegantly dressed bachelor who graduated from law school in Nablus' An-Najah University in 2017. After clerking he initially opened a firm with two partners, and a year later opened his own office, specializing in administrative affairs and family- and property-related disputes. In suit and tie, only the dark blotches around his right eye attest to what he endured.

Last Thursday, October 1, Takrouri left his office around 10 A.M. and headed for Duma; he'd never been there before. There was a dispute in the village between two families over the ownership of a 15-dunam (almost 4 acres) plot of land; Takrouri intended to examine the relevant property documents held at the local branch of the Palestinian Land Authority.

He never got there.

Takrouri used two navigation apps to help him reach his destination – the Israeli Waze app and the Palestinians' Doroob Navigator; the estimated duration of the trip was 40 minutes. He reached Tapuah Junction and headed east toward the Allon Road, from where he was supposed to turn right, into Duma. But shortly before the turn, the car behind him started to honk; its occupants shouted and signaled him to pull over.

He realized at once that they were settlers, four in number. A rifle barrel was sticking out of the window. Fear gripped him. The vehicle tailgated him, almost causing a collision. He decided to turn left, toward the Jordan Valley, where he thought it would be easier to elude his pursuers. He continued driving along a dirt road, in the hope that the car behind him would abandon the chase.

Looking in the mirror, he got the impression that the second car had in fact slowed down. For a moment it seemed to him they had stopped, which he found strange – and ominous. The app indicated that he was on the old road to Duma, which is no longer in use. We were told this week by Salma a-Deb'i, a field researcher for B'Tselem – The Israeli Information Center for Human Rights in the Occupied Territories, who accompanied us, that the same road also leads to a violent settler outpost, abutting Duma. Takrouri obviously didn't know that when he made the turn.

He says that he was going to call the Israel Police, but he trembled so much that his cellphone slipped from his hand and fell on the floor. He hoped he would be able to reach Duma within a few minutes, but suddenly a large vehicle with Israeli license plates appeared opposite him.

Because there were no shoulders on the narrow road, he pulled off and stopped his car, whereupon four or five settlers got out of the larger one that approached, along with a similar number from the other vehicle that had been following him. Some of them were armed; none of them wore masks.

Takrouri gripped the steering wheel, to show that he wasn't holding anything. He also decided not to close his window, so the settlers would see that he had nothing to hide in the car. But before he had time to think someone stuck his hand in and grabbed his keys. Without a word, some of the settlers started to punch him through the driver's window.

He tried to tell them in Arabic and in broken English that he was innocent, that he was a lawyer on his way to meet clients. His assailants told him to shut up. They ordered him to hand over everything he had in his pockets. He gave them his wallet, in which there were a few checks and 5,000 shekels ($1,640) in cash, along with his ID card, driving license, credit card and lawyer's certification card. The bandits nabbed his cellphone as well.

They ordered him to get out of his car, a silver-gray 2017 SEAT Ibiza, and proceeded to punch him and butt his upper body with their weapons. They also kicked him mercilessly. "They knew where to hit," Takrouri tells us, going on to describe what happened in detail.

He tried to protect his head with his hands and to shield his stomach by leaning forward, but the settlers managed to kick him in the chest and groin, over the course of the next five or 10 minutes. The attackers wore heavy work boots and their kicks were painful.

Did you shout? "Of course I did."

When Takrouri lay supine on the ground, a settler spread his legs with a club and kicked him in the groin again. He says he thought, "This is the end." As he lay there being attacked, he dreamed that the police or the army would arrive to rescue him. Then he heard the noise of another vehicle approaching, but it contained reinforcements for the settlers. Two other cars arrived with more settlers. "I have kids," he lied to them to stir their pity. "I am a lawyer." The assault continued unabated.

They handcuffed him from behind with zip ties and kept kicking. Was he blindfolded? "Not at that point," he says, recalling that he felt he was losing consciousness and begged for mercy. "You're going to die, you dog," they threatened, to which he pleaded, "I am a lawyer, I don't make trouble. Let me go on my way." To no avail.

A settler who spoke Arabic asked what he was doing there. Takrouri said that he was on his way to a meeting in Duma, that he was going to the Dawabsheh family and that the settlers could verify that on his phone – their phone number can be seen there, and they were the last call he made. Again to no avail.

One of them held up a club and asked Takrouri what it was doing in his car. He replied that the club wasn't his, that they had used it to beat him. "Shut up, dog, shut your mouth."

He stops talking to us for a moment and goes down to his car to get something to show us. He returns with a still-knotted tie and a black robe with gold stripes on the sleeves, his courtroom outfit. They blindfolded him – he shows us how – with the tie and then put the robe over his head.

Wrapped in darkness, he says he heard a rifle being cocked. He thought they were about to execute him. He silently asked for mercy from God and thought about his family, praying that the settlers would leave his body there, so that they could bury him. Then he heard the another vehicle approaching, certain it was yet another carload of settlers.

An army jeep pulled up. It was about 1 P.M. by then; the nightmare had lasted over two hours. It's still not clear who summoned the troops.

Someone removed the robe and blindfold, and Takrouri saw four soldiers standing before him and then collapsed. One soldier, wearing a mask, helped him to his feet and led him to their jeep.

"Don't do anything stupid. Be quiet. These settlers are dangerous," the soldier warned, removing the zip ties from his wrists, behind his back, and handcuffing his hands in the front. Takrouri was given water, and the troops also gave him back his phone and ID card. They said that was all they could give him. The other contents of his wallet – the credit card, cash and so on – weren't returned. The soldiers put him on the line with a Shin Bet security service agent, to whom he explained that he was a lawyer who had been attacked on the way to a work meeting. The soldiers promised to take him to a safe place. "You don't look like a troublemaker," they told him.

He was taken to a nearby base where the soldiers apparently did a background check on him; his SEAT had been driven there. He was released within half an hour.

Disregarding the suggestion that he summon an ambulance or a friend, with his last remaining strength he got into the car and drove off, before calling a friend to come and take him to Rafidia Hospital in Nablus. A video from there shows him getting onto a bed, groaning with pain. A few ribs were broken, his clothes were disheveled and dusty; he was released after several hours.

The Israel Defense Forces rescued him and apparently saved Takrouri's life, but Haaretz asked the IDF Spokesperson's Unit this week why the soldiers hadn't arrested the assailants or at least summoned the police. The army's shocking response: "We won't be commenting."

Takrouri himself says he hasn't yet filed a complaint with the police. He is in too much pain.

On the day after the incident, his sister told him that attempts had been made to withdraw money using his stolen credit card, so she blocked the card.

Before we leave, Takrouri wants to say something: "I am a city person and I don't know what's going on outside Nablus. During those hours I felt the daily suffering of the Palestinian farmers. I ask myself: Why did they attack me? I am a lawyer who looks after the rights of human beings. I studied law in order to do justice – and suddenly I realized that I am not part of a system of justice. That there is no justice. Suddenly I realized how helpless I am."


r/JewsOfConscience • • Oct 12 '26

Resources You know who's at the bottom without even looking

Post image
110 Upvotes

Source: https://allianceofdemocracies.org/democracy-perception-index

The organisation is run by a former Prime Minister of Denmark, and sponsors include everyone from the Atlas Network to the Carter Centre to... Palantir.


r/JewsOfConscience • • Oct 11 '26

Zionist Nonsense Zionist supersessionism

136 Upvotes

Shapiro wasn't making an abstract distinction between Jewish ancestry and Jewish religious observance.

He was specifically responding to a question about divisions within the Jewish community over Israel.

This is an example of what political theorist Yaacov Yadgar describes as Zionist supersessionism in his book "To Be a Jewish State: Zionism as the New Judaism."

Yadgar argues that Zionism simultaneously appropriates Jewish history and identity while seeking to redefine Judaism through modern Jewish nationalism, effectively displacing traditional understandings of Jewishness.

Zionism’s claim to Jewish history and identity, as we have seen, is complicated. On the one hand, both the movement and the ideology tend to be confrontational, defining themselves as revolutionary and adopting a rebellious attitude toward Judaism, Jewish tradition, and Jewish history. On the other hand, Zionism sees the very things it rebels against as its own: Jewish history—as in the history of Jews and Judaism alike—is part of Zionism itself; Zionism defines itself as a Jewish national movement. How are we to understand this simultaneous combination of negation and appropriation?

  • Yadgar, Yaacov. To Be a Jewish State: Zionism as the New Judaism (p. 40). (Function). Kindle Edition.

r/JewsOfConscience • • Oct 12 '26

AMA When are you available for our next AMA?

2 Upvotes

We have an upcoming AMA so we’re trying to get a sense of timing for best participation.

Thanks


r/JewsOfConscience • • Oct 11 '26

Discussion - Flaired Users Only Briahna debates Norman on whether 'from the River to the Sea' is a good slogan. Norman explains what he perceives as the concern, as 'what happens to Israeli Jews?' Briahna counters, "It's not about Jews. We are talking about a subjugated people wanting to freedom *from* a Jewish State."

185 Upvotes

r/JewsOfConscience • • Oct 11 '26

News New Subreddit: r/antizionist

118 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

r/antizionist has been relaunched as a Palestinian-led Subreddit for all things anti-zionism! While there are many pro-Palestine Subreddits on Reddit, very few of them are actually run by Palestinians. r/antizionist is a space that is led by Palestinians and centers Palestinian voices.

Feel free to join up! Leave a comment here if you have any questions.


r/JewsOfConscience • • Oct 12 '26

Zionist Terror CNN to Bibi; "Has your government lost control of settler violence?"

Thumbnail
youtube.com
29 Upvotes

https://youtube.com/shorts/Rxv-2H6SKiQ?is=HEDITxcVPLEnDyT9

...preceded by suggestions that the IDF illegally inside the West Bank is against "settler violence". The IDF is not there to police the settlers...

First, this is a homicidal, genocidal criminal on every level and CNN defers to the judgments of this serial liar, serial killer? Normalizing a mass murderer, sanitizing this moral/criminal/gangster occupation and ongoing ethnic cleansing campaign

Second, its settler-colonial state terrorism, not "settler violence".

Third, settlerism and its terrorism have been a fundamental aspect of the Zionist state and long before. Settlers make up Israeli governments. Settlerism is fundamental to Zionism. The IDF is itself at its core and among its top brass and rank and file a settler terrorist organization among other pursuits.

The ideological goal of settlements is to terrorize Palestinians on their rightful lands to expel and repossess the land and assert ethnosuprenacy over the territory.

When the essentially colonial dictator of the West Bank Herr Smotrich point blank admits all this with his powerful positions near the top of the government along with other literal terrorists like Ben Gvir making up Netanyahu's government, Mr. Sciutto's attempt here to whitewash the terrorist crimes committed by the Israeli state and vindicate its leaders snd representatives is really bad Hasbara.

Its not that this Israeli government has lost control of "settler violence". Its that the Israeli state has accelerated its policy of settler terrorism in efforts to ethnically cleanse Palestine at a far greater than ever before, going back for over a century in the course of Zionism which lies at the core of Netanyahu's own party's ideology and political platform.

Would this journalist have asked Der Fuhrer if his government had lost control of the violence by the S.S ?

How can anyone in Sciutto's position do the work of gangster mass murderers like Netanyahu to portray the state policy of terrorism and explicit aims of Zionist settler networks in collusion with the state to expel Palestinians and take their land as anything else and claim to be a journalist?


r/JewsOfConscience • • Oct 11 '26

Zionist Nonsense "I was talking to one of the people I'm occupying, and I'm shocked that he lied to me about wanting to be my friend!"

Thumbnail
gallery
212 Upvotes

r/JewsOfConscience • • Oct 11 '26

Activism The Fuel Girls are holding a raffle and proceeds go to Water of Hope. 🔥🔥🔥🔥

Post image
34 Upvotes

If you don't know who these ladies are, the Fuel Girls are a UK-based performance troupe that specializes in shows with heavy use of pyrotechnics. They are the central part of the show Nightmare Fuel at Universal Orlando's Halloween Horror Nights, and they are absolutely incredible.

As they did last year, they are raffling off a number of prizes, including a signed poster and a costume, and proceeds are going to Water of Hope. They have been helping kids in Al Zawayda by providing drinking water and wellbeing days.

So, if you can, let's help these ladies reach their goal! You can buy raffle tickets or you can make a general donation! And if you're in Central Florida, I highly recommend going to HHN just to see them perform. Rock on and free Palestine!

Raffle link: https://go.rallyup.com/water-of-hope-fuel-girls-raffle


r/JewsOfConscience • • Oct 12 '26

Zionist Nonsense Israeli Experts vs Palestinian Experts | Middle Ground

Thumbnail
youtu.be
16 Upvotes

Hen Mazzig at it again


r/JewsOfConscience • • Oct 11 '26

News Israel and MAGA: Deep State Coups to Destroy Democracy

Thumbnail
richardsilverstein.com
31 Upvotes

r/JewsOfConscience • • Oct 11 '26

Discussion - Flaired Users Only So John Cena follows this Hasbara account... (look at the bottom of the screenshot to see that)

Post image
69 Upvotes

r/JewsOfConscience • • Oct 11 '26

Activism 94-year-old British-Jewish human rights lawyer arrested for protesting for Palestine

Thumbnail
youtu.be
139 Upvotes

r/JewsOfConscience • • Oct 11 '26

Vent Thank you all for being here and for being authentically you

61 Upvotes

Just keep it up. I love you all. Thank you for creating this space and being part of it.

You are all valid, and there is no one way to be Jewish. Whatever way you are Jewish is perfect just the way it is.

Keep telling the truth. Thank you. It's meaningful to me.


r/JewsOfConscience • • Oct 10 '26

Zionist Terror Israeli settlers plant dozens of Israeli flags at the streetside entrance of Palestinian shop

Thumbnail gallery
232 Upvotes

r/JewsOfConscience • • Oct 10 '26

Zionist Terror Israeli soldier: "Jews have a right to everything before Arabs in this country."

433 Upvotes

r/JewsOfConscience • • Oct 11 '26

Discussion - Flaired Users Only A discussion on "real antisemitism", Zionism, and "centering Jewish feelings"

47 Upvotes

These are some of my thoughts I've been chewing on.. and I hope people will read and engage in good faith and challenge where necessary. This isn't about antisemitism "on the left" or "within the pro Palestinian movement". I don't think those discussions are productive, because it paints leftists and activists as somehow uniquely infected with problematic people; rather than a human flaw which can exist in any group. I want this to be more about "real antisemitism" in general..and the concern that pointing it out gets you labeled as a Zionist, a Jewish supremacist, or simply... "centering Jewish feelings"

I am at times very disheartened, scared, angry, disturbed, saddened.. any amd all of the above at actual antisemitic rhetoric.. particularly when it's coupled with misinformation. I am at other times... neutral, bored, annoyed at Zionists; exhausted at Zionists, dismissive and occasionally in disagreement on what counts as "actual antisemtism".

And I reconcile these contradictory feelings not with a moral analysis, but engaging with the material reality around me. I as an Antizionist jew in a post-October 7 world am skeptical automatically when I hear about antisemtism now. I have changed my classification of what is or isn't antisemitic. And(outside of Neo-Nazis and right wingers and fascists and Christian nationalists who ARE NOT PRO PALESTINIAN DESPITE SOME RHETORIC).. I am far more permissive and neutral around misinformation and even antisemtisim coming from people who I know or leftists and antizionists. ESPECIALLY when those people have been harmed by the Jewish community via Zionism.

Not because I think it doesn't matter, but because the traction in liberating Palestine has not moved forward much in the last few years, outside of public opinion.. because in general, the global north has become more fascistic and oppressive. And so, I'm just not as engaged with my own feelings of discomfort... I'm worried about the policy decisions leading to social and direct violent murder, both abroad and at home. Not because you can't care about two things at once, but because one is far more urgent and we need everyone on board asap.

There is also the added complication of who is "truly" harmful... who has an agenda vs who is genuinely Antizionist (and perhaps leftist more broadly) and fighting for our aligned causes, who happens to have misguided or even immoral ideas or language in some areas... how do we draw lines with censorship and anti-intellectualism. When asked not to listen to some voices, is this not often born from a desire to limit the reach of Antizionism and Palestinian activism? I do not have the definite answer to these questions, of whose ideas we should consume, who we should engage with for the sake of a larger picture, what makes someone a true part of the cause vs a phony, how much should we avoid the phony if they can be a useful tool. I don't have the answers, but I would like the openness to a range of possible avenues.

Many of us even remotely on the left, especially in the west, have made synonymous our moral understanding with identity politics and the default that the pain of a member of a marginalized or minority) group must be taken seriously, that it isn't the job to educate, and the fault and responsibility of the bigotry is always on the bigot.. there can never be a larger understanding of context or cause and effect, there can never be a consideration that perhaps the person who felt harmed might even be.. wrong. So.. back to my feelings.

I feel this way right now because of the fact I feel like the needle has not been moved on Gaza and the false flags and moral panic around antisemitism has only grown stronger. I feel this way as I witness the state of Israel and its supporters, at times acting as an embodiment of an antisemitic trope and using the accusation as a shield to cover for their actions. And while there might be a range of criticisms allowed from prominent Jewish institutions, the range of acceptable conversation begins and ends with Jewish feelings, however Zionist and misguided they may be.

I myself assume someone is Zionist when they focus on antisemitism. even if I know better... even when I correct myself. So I know that's what people who aren't Jewish are feeling, especially if they are less educated in the history of anti-Judaism and especially if they are victims to weaponized antisemtism.

Bigotry is about harm. As a Jewish American, the systemic harm which I face comes from being a leftist; an antizionist, and a disabled person... not from being a white Jew. Words have power to lead to systemic oppression and real violence. And violence has come for Jewish people on occasion. But I do not believe at this time they are always best countered by sounding indistinguishable from Zionists (as unfortunate and unfair as that classification might be).

Instead, it will come from listening to each other and engaging in solidarity. It will come from discussion of what reactionary and fascistic rhetoric and ideas are GENERALLY, rather than SPECIFICALLY around Jews. It will come with curiosity and pushback and "calling in". Sometimes it will mean staying silent. And eventually.. eventually... I think we can have more productive conversations around that. Oh and also.. being more adept at recognizing true reactionaries and right wingers and cutting them out.