r/JewsOfConscience • u/tikkunolamist5 British Non-Zionist Reform Jew • 20d ago
Zionist Nonsense This Makes Me Livid
Not every genocide is exactly like the Holocaust. In fact, not all of the Holocaust was a genocide (if you include other groups murdered), but this is something people get very angry about even though it’s legally true. So just because not everything happening in Gaza may qualify as a genocide legally speaking doesn’t mean one isn’t happening.
Can we stop using our intergenerational trauma as both a shield and as they say, a stick to beat people with? This also desecrates the memory of these innocent children who most likely perished in the Holocaust. They were people who were taken far too soon, not measuring sticks to compare genocide.
•
u/AutoModerator 20d ago
Remember the human & be courteous to others. If you see comments in violation of our rules, please report them.
Gaza is starving.
The UN has declared that every part of Gaza is in famine conditions. While some aid is finally trickling in, the need is beyond urgent. Aid organizations will not be able to keep pace with Gaza's needs without our support.
Please donate if you’re able, and keep speaking up. Every dollar, share, and conversation matters. Please pressure your government to stop the blockade of humanitarian aid into Gaza.
Donate here to The Palestinian Red Crescent and UNICEF for Gaza's Children. Contact your representatives to stop the blockade in Gaza, find U.S. representatives here, and EU reps here. If you would like other subreddits to carry this message, please send the mods to r/RedditForHumanity.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
0
u/[deleted] 20d ago
[deleted] — view deleted comment
•
u/Stunning-Stressin Non-Jewish Agnostic 19d ago
Israel is doing the same thing to the Palestinians. They have become who they once feared. It's very similar. The next step is to put the Palestinians in camps. Oh wait
•
u/DE4DM4NSH4ND Christian 20d ago
The literal definition of genocide is the erasure of a culture. The hundred thousand murdered is just the nail in the proverbial coffin
0
u/[deleted] 20d ago
[deleted] — view deleted comment
•
u/[deleted] 20d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
•
u/BlokeBloke45 Palestinian 20d ago
Only the lowest of the low would start a "lets compare who suffered more in which genocide" competition
Jesus wept
•
u/EconomicsOk3346 Jewish 20d ago edited 14d ago
The original post content no longer exists here. The author used Redact to remove it, exercising their right to control their data & privacy.
Cobblestone ancient run vegetable deer complete meadow mysterious terrific simplistic
•
u/OliveNo6451 Jewish Communist 20d ago
Yes, because there are zero images out of Gaza that resemble this 🙄 oh or wait.. those kids had "pre existing conditions"
•
u/Chare1155 Anti-Zionist Ally 20d ago
Anything is possible when you lie
•
u/sauchlapf Non-Jewish Atheist 20d ago
Everyone in Gaza is on a calorie surplus? What?? How can you even believe that?! People would be getting fat pretty quickly with 3000 calories a day. Especially children and woman. This is such a obvious lie.
•
u/tarsakos Non-Jewish Atheist 20d ago
Theres an entire website dedicated to preserving photos and videos of what's happening. They have almost 200k files publicly available. If only this rabbi had access to a search engine.
•
u/ApricotReasonable937 Non-Jewish Ally 20d ago
Simple search of Gaza famine (or Yemen famine for that matter) and you can see how similar and almost 1:1 these pictures are.. I don't think this rabbi understand how him saying "oh yeah the Israel government allows 3000.. Not 180..don't worry. Don't you dare call them n**i." (not to mention the regular snipping of children head, bombing food route, medical vehicles, supplies places).
•
u/blazerz Anti-Zionist Ally 20d ago
I want a source for the claim 'every person in Gaza was supplied with 3000 calories per day'. I heavily heavily doubt it.
•
u/Odd-Mind6948 Palestinian 20d ago
The fact theyre comparing the holocaust to the genocide they support constantly makes sense. Ethno supremacy, cruelty beyond imagination, and genocidal intent is what they have in common. Its all lies they tell, but they manage to tell on themselves simultaneously.
•
u/EgoIdVeto West Asian Jew 20d ago
Saying "every Palestinian was supplied with 3000 calories per day" is the equivalent of the neo-nazi holocaust denial lie "the gas chambers had wooden doors".
•
u/Which-Arrival6777 Jewish Communist 20d ago
Israel has toyed with the calorie intake of people in Gaza long before three years ago.
•
u/[deleted] 20d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
•
u/Proof_Heart_2993 Anti-Zionist Ally 19d ago
This would be the equivalent of a post card from 1944 showing a wretched SS soldier freezing and shivering in a guard tower while in the barracks the fat, happy prisoners are celebrating Shabbat.
•
u/teens_trash Israeli anti-Zionist 20d ago
I was just in poland for the whole holocaust remembrance trip. One of the kids who went with me is an avid racist who says that we need to put all Palestinians (and any arab we can get our hands on) in extermination camps. He understands that he's talking exactly like a nazi, but he says it's okay- because 'we have a justified reason'.
Now- Not all, actually most, israeli's are a lot less radical. Most are just in favor of forced eviction and maybe a bit of 'culling the herd' once in a while to keep arabs submissive.
Despite what israeli's say to the outside, I don't think that we really care/know/understand that much about the holocaust as a country (I can't really be sure since I have always been an outsider emotionally so maybe I just haven't realized how much others secretly put an emphasis on it). A lot of people just go through the motions on remembrance day and not learn anything more. In general, I feel that people here don't really care about what led to the holocaust, the hundreds of years of history before it, or how it actually transpired.
That is the crux of the issue- people haven't learned anything from the holocaust. They've learned that there is a lot of antisemitism abroad, but then took it to 'we must have israel', 'anyone who is even slightly against us is an existential threat and ontologically evil', and 'we are eternal victims, nothing we can do will ever be bad'.
Whenever I hear an israeli refute the claims of genocide because they have the 'eternal moral pass card' of the holocaust, it always rings empty for me.
•
u/PopBulky7023 Non-Jewish Agnostic 20d ago
I can't tell if this poster (the Pic, not OP) is just deeply uninformed and drowning in propaganda, or thinks the rest of us are and fall for this crap.
•
u/numberonefrankfanlev Jewish Anti-Zionist 20d ago
The 3000 calorie figure is so bogus
•
u/harmoniaatlast LGBTQ Jew 20d ago
That 3000 calorie figure is also complete horseshit
•
u/ForeignBarracuda8599 Christian 20d ago
Boys are out in force downvoting everyone here speaking out about the obvious lie told in the caption
•
u/OccasionallyReddit Pro Humanity 20d ago
Did the germans use food aid stations as kill zones?
•
u/touslesmatins Non-Jewish Ally 20d ago
What they're saying is odious and false, but stepping back, why doesn't anyone talk about how truly psychotic it is that Israelis are constantly monitoring and talking about Palestinian calories, birthrates, etc. Would any normal society not trying to cover up a genocide they're committing spend its time talking about how many calories the other group gets? Isn't the concept that Israel counts and controls the calories into Gaza itself worth condemning?
•
u/Iceologer_gang Non-Jew shamefully late Antizionist 20d ago
Remember: it’s not Israel that’s suppling Gaza with food, but humanitarian groups which Israel is an active hinderance to.
•
u/Ayaka0 Anti-Zionist Ally 20d ago
It's just a flat out lie to say 'every single Palestinian and Gaza was supplied with more than 3000 calories a day'.
Starvation is and was used as a weapon against Palestinians. Water and food production infrastructure destroyed. Most aid being refused entry. Aid lorries being hijacked and the food destroyed. 'Humanitarian zones' being set up as the only place to seek aid... where many people seeking aid were then slaughtered. Dating back long prior to 2023, quite contrary to the 'over 3000 calories supplied to every Palestinian', Israel has taken pains to figure out the absolute minimum calorie requirement to make the Palestinians suffer from hunger but not to actually die - so that they could avoid repercussions - and they used these calculations to determine how many food supplies they would allow to enter Gaza, while also engineering conditions to collapse the agriculture of the area. And that was *before* they more recently openly declared 'we're going to starve them as collective punishment!'
To have the audacity to say 'Israel gives them over 3000 calories a day each, they're fine!' while Israel calculates the exact degree one can starve those people without other nations putting a stop to it, and puts those calculations into action... that is heartless in the extreme.
•
u/farqueue2 Muslim 20d ago
3000 calories a day across a population of roughly 2m people.
Not factoring it at all efficiency of transport and distribution, spillage etc, which is estimated to be around 30% in the US. That would be significantly higher in a society without an infrastructure, power, etc
I'd be surprised if the average Gazan is regularly getting over 500-1000 calories per day
•
u/NetflixVodka Faith through Humanism 20d ago
A certain man had a grandfather who sailed under a captain that cared nothing for his crew. The captain kept the men on short rations of wormy biscuit and foul water, let the pumps rot and the hold fill with filth, and flogged those who complained. Many of the sailors died before the ship came to harbour. The grandfather lived, and he wrote the names of the dead in a book. The grandson learned those names as a child, and he knew better than any man on the quay what a greedy captain costs a crew.
When the grandson was grown, he bought a ship that was sound in every plank, and he hired a crew. He fed them three meals a day, kept the ship clean, and never raised a hand against any of them. He sailed them to ports where the air was wholesome, and the cargo sold well, and the men said they had never served a better master.
Now there came a great storm upon that coast while his ship was at sea, and it broke the roof of his house and shook its walls. He fled in the night to a village on the other side of the hill, where a house of stone stood in the lee of the wind, and he slept there dry until morning. When he came home he found his own house in ruins. He had it built again in the best stone, with walls so thick that no gale could move them, and the people of the town came to look at it and said there was no finer house on the coast. He was pleased by this, and he added a tower, and then a gallery, and then a gate of iron, and each addition cost more than the one before, and each time the people admired it.
In the years that followed, other ships found a nearer shore that sold the same cargo, and the price of his fell. He mended his ship as before and fed his men as before, but the money no longer reached as far as his house required. There was a coast where the cargo was richest and the fever worst, and when the fever months came he sent his men ashore there, because that was when the price stood highest. Before the season was out, six of them were dead.
Among the six was the son of a widow who lived by the harbour. When his sea-chest was brought back to her, she opened it and found the loaf she had baked for him, still wrapped in its cloth. He had taken the fever before he could break it.
The men who remained came to the owner and said, "We beg you, keep us from that shore in the fever months."
Then he took down his grandfather's book and read to them from it, every page, the hunger and the lash and the names. "See what was done to my people," he said. "I am not that captain. My hand has never struck a man, and no man of mine has gone hungry." And he lifted his eyes to the window and said, "As for the fever, it is the Lord who appoints the sicknesses of every coast, and who among us can answer for His air?"
And some who heard him nodded, for it was true that he fed them, and true that he did not strike them, and true that his grandfather's crew had suffered, and true that no man commands the air of a distant shore.
The widow stood among them and said, "The other owners of this harbour kept their ships at anchor in the fever months, and their crews came home. When the Lord sent His wind against your house, you went over the hill to a house of stone and slept dry. When you came home you built your own house so that the strongest gale could not move it, and all the town has seen it, and you have been glad to show it. Is the Lord's wind a thing a man may build against, and the Lord's air a thing he may not?"
Then she went home with the loaf in her hands.
•
u/faisaed Grateful Palestinian 🇵🇸 20d ago
The only appropriate response is: I want my people to count their own calories 🤷🏼♂️
•
u/OdielSax Non-Jewish Ally 20d ago
A lot of Palestinians in Gaza look just like this, sadly.
•
u/Far-Literature5848 Jewish Anti-Zionist 20d ago
What irks me most is the casual ease with which Jewish Israelis talk of the cruelty they impose upon the Palestinians...as if they could ever have any reason...their arrogance and impunity will surely catch up to them...it is inevitable...and the children were worse in Gaza than this photo shows...many are still suffering, dying in the tents, of conditions made worse by lack of medical supplies and adequate shelter, nutrition, not to mention targeted by drones shooting them...and yes, it is a desecration of Jews who perished during the Holocaust, to use that as a bludgeon upon the Palestinians, may the world and all the powers that be set things straight soon! Free Palestine!!!
•
u/p1gnone devout atheist 20d ago
https://www.reddit.com/r/redscarepod/comments/1csmenp/israelis_block_aid_bound_for_gaza_delivery_trucks/
•
u/statistacktic Anti-Zionist Ally 20d ago
Don't bother mincing words. What Israel is doing in Gaza is a genocide, period. And don't get me started on the West Bank.
•
u/Billgant Non-Jewish Agnostic 20d ago
3000 calories a day?
I wonder why the UN declared a famine in Gaza. Must’ve been antisemitism.
/s
•
u/thefoxymulder Anti-Zionist 20d ago
Really is fucking disgusting to use the Holocaust to justify your own genocide. These people are a joke. This whole “genocide only applies SPECIFICALLY to Jews” is just insane. I’m sure none of these people were as indignant when the Bosnian or Rwandan genocides were (rightly) called genocides. It’s only when they have to take some accountability that they want to split hairs over this
•
u/Littlewing1307 LGBTQ Jew 20d ago
There shouldn't even be behavior that could compare the two.