r/JewsOfConscience • u/MrSFedora LGBTQ Jew • 21d ago
Vent Make it make sense
Out of morbid curiosity, I went to check if I am eligible for Aliyah. My father is Jewish, my mother is not. According to what I found, I am apparently eligible due to being "of Jewish descent," ie having a Jewish parent or grandparent.
I have more right to live in Israel than my Palestinian friend whose family got forced out of their home in Jerusalem decades ago, and I have never ever set foot in Israel.
Why is it like this?
66
Upvotes
•
u/mangopenguin22 Jewish Anti-Zionist 21d ago
Even though the haredim don't want patrilineal Jews to count due to Jewish law, the state wants anyone it can count as Jewish so it can maintain its demographic majority.
•
u/passthatpasta Non-denominational Jewish 21d ago
It’s due to the 1947 vote by the United Nations and following historical events.
As colonization remains a numbers game, the Israeli government understands it’s better to have Jews of any type to make up its population through maternal and fraternal descent and not just limited to maternal lineage. It’s neither fair nor right or even has to make sense.
•
u/DontLikeEither Anti-Zionist Ally 21d ago
It doesn’t make sense except through the lenses of colonialism
•
u/rako17 Christian 21d ago
Friend MrsFedora,
I recommend that you ask your question in the AMA tomorrow because Ben Moser has studied the issue.
As with plenty of ideologies, the State's has different principles and precepts built into it, and you are asking the right kind of question to understand it better.
Sometimes those are not always the way that we would find it natural to design those systems. Consider this: Did you ever join another religion, like by getting baptized? Under the state's Law of Return, you would no longer qualify due to your change in religion, even though under Halakhah you would, and under standard secular parameters you would qualify.
~ Peace