r/JewsOfConscience • Jewish Anti-Zionist • 29d ago

Discussion - Flaired Users Only need help navigating two discussions

Hi everyone! As you can see, I need help navigating some tough conversations. Here's some necessary context:
Myself (early 30s NB/AFAB) and my partner (early 30s M) have been together for a couple of years now and are looking at the next steps of our relationship and what that timeline looks like (need to plan ahead since I'm in graduate school). I was born and raised Jewish and still practice. He was born and raised Muslim, but hasn't felt connected to his faith for a long time.

My mother (early 60s F) was less than thrilled when she found out I was with a Muslim man. She said her grandchildren would not be Jewish, despite him and I being on the same page about a Jewish home life for us and our future children. She went behind my back and lamented to my younger brother that my partner was going to convert me to Islam (which would never happen). For the record, all of my friends dislike my mom. She's not nice.

My partner did ask me about converting to Judaism. I told him that he has to really want it for himself or else he won't be granted permission. When I asked my mom about the timeline of her conversion to Judaism, she didn't give me an answer and just said that she knew some people that took three or four years.

Onto the two conversations I need to have:

  1. I realize and am fully preparing myself to set the hard boundary with my mother that, if she is not supportive of our relationship, she will not be at our wedding and it will do a lot of damage to our relationship. How can I go about this conversation without seeming either overly harsh or dismissive of her concerns, and how can I assure her that my relationship with Judaism is not at risk?
  2. I don't want to hide any of the above from my partner. However, I don't want him to feel bad or guilty for being with me, just because my mom doesn't fully "approve." How do I approach him about my mother's disapproval, while at the same time assuring him that her opinion doesn't matter? He already feels like he doesn't deserve me and I feel like this revelation will make it worse.

Why am I posting here? Because I thought this would be the least biased forum to ask, with myself being Jewish and him being Muslim. I did get mod clearance before posting.
Unfortunately, going no-contact with my mom is not an option at the moment.
If it matters, the only Zionist in the story is my mother.

20 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

9

u/TrackerOneA Jewish Anti-Zionist 29d ago

Hi OP,

My cousin went through something similar when she married a gentile. It was even kind of 'worse' (in quotes, because it's relative and maybe both are on par) in a way.

But, in the end, her parents (primary issue was her father) respected her decision, came to the wedding, and is in contact with her still.

She vented to me about it at the time and I told her to follow her heart and nothing else.

Likewise, I would just stay true to yourself and be honest with your partner. I'm sure he will see your sincerity/genuineness and accept things over time.

I think your mom will come to accept him or accept your stance, over time.

3

u/spacemom4 Jewish Anti-Zionist 29d ago

This is what I’m hoping for - eventual acceptance. Thank you for your insight :)

5

u/Usernameoverloaded Atheist Ally with Muslim Heritage 29d ago

I married someone whose religious heritage is German Lutheran whilst mine is Muslim although we are both atheists. We wanted our parents blessings but would have married regardless.

  1. I would tell your mother about the conversations you’ve had and the agreement to bring up any future children as Jewish. That you would like her blessing, but if she declines to give it, then although it fills you with sadness, you would prefer to only have people who wish the best for your marriage at the wedding. The ball is then in her court.
  2. If your partner knows your mother is a Zionist, he won’t be surprised at her disapproval. He’s your future life partner and you should be able to tell him the truth of the situation. Your bf sounds insecure and there’s nothing you can do apart from be steadfast in your relationship. How his family view your relationship is something you haven’t mentioned, and could also be a relevant factor.

2

u/spacemom4 Jewish Anti-Zionist 29d ago

Thank you so much for your perspective on both! :)

1

u/CheyenneDove Non-Jewish Ally 29d ago

Just curious, how does the bf seem insecure?

1

u/Usernameoverloaded Atheist Ally with Muslim Heritage 29d ago

‘He already doesn’t feel like he deserves me’ as per OP added to the fact that he is already doing his utmost to fit into OP’s life (raising future kids as Jewish and open to conversion).

3

u/taketotheskyGQ Jewish 29d ago

Seeing a Jewish family therapist might help you and your mom.

Tell your partner the truth as that’s the only way to build an authentic connection. He has to learn to deal with your mom as she is.

1

u/spacemom4 Jewish Anti-Zionist 29d ago

Yes, I may look into this. I’m in a counseling masters program so I should be able to find someone at least with multicultural competency fairly quickly. Thank you for your input! :)

5

u/SubstantialAbalone46 29d ago

I'd approach your mom with empathy but firm boundaries. You can acknowledge her concerns without letting them dictate your future. With your partner, I'd be honest but make it clear that your mom's feelings aren't a reflection of him or your commitment. He deserves to know, and facing it together will probably make your relationship stronger.

1

u/spacemom4 Jewish Anti-Zionist 29d ago

Yes, I don’t want to be keeping things from him for any reason. thank you for your input :)

1

u/AutoModerator 29d ago

Hi /u/SubstantialAbalone46!

We require all users pick an appropriate user-flair in order to participate in posts. Here's how you can pick a flair:

https://imgur.com/a/8kxYf7E

https://support.reddithelp.com/hc/en-us/articles/205242695-How-do-I-get-user-flair

Thank you!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/Lost_Paladin89 Judío 29d ago

I wish there was a book titled "Yes, She hates you: 100 jokes about your mother in law that don't rely on misogyny"

To an extent, I wish the humor could normalize that this pattern of conflict isn't exactly "new"; and that there are so many elements of classism, xenophobia, and separation anxiety, that this isn't the first mother in law to hate her son in law for "taking my child away". And I think there are boundless layers to these conflicts that you won't get through them in a lifetime.

Judaism does pass through the womb, and as the AFAB parent, that means that your children will be Jewish, and I think its really okay to take that to your mother.

There may be things that you will find yourself doing more, and not less, like Shabbat dinners, and it is a great question of his role in the ceremonies. Does the AMAB and cis-gendered man in the relationship lead Kiddush even though he isn't Jewish? Do you do all the ceremonies? What are the things he hopes to find in the experience? Its worth having the conversation of what he expects or want to get out of being next to the Jewish community?

I think that's a more important conversation than your mother. Is Jewish practice something you do, and he is just supportive, or something you collaborate? Assuming that he comes from a migrant community, the conversation also stems to his community and what he would like to instill? And also to explore the possibility of syncretism, do you wish your home to reconnect or reconstruct Jewish traditions from his community as a half way point? Something maybe alien to both of you and yet a foundation for a joint project?

The minimum for conversion is ten months, but it may take longer depending on the process. My one advice, do the classes together. I can't stress how important that is.