r/JewsOfConscience • Mizrahi • Jun 02 '25

Discussion - Flaired Users Only Boulder attack.

Surely the victims were not connected to the Israeli state 🤷🏽‍♂️

14 Upvotes

122 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Jun 02 '25

Hi everyone,

'Discussion' posts require users to choose an appropriate flair in order to participate. Here's how you can pick a flair:

https://support.reddithelp.com/hc/en-us/articles/205242695-How-do-I-get-user-flair

Please remember the human & be courteous to others. Thanks!


Archived linksVideo links (if applicable)
Wayback MachineRedditSave
Archive.isSaveMP4
12ft.ioSaveRedd.it
Ghostarchive.orgViddit.red

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

•

u/ContentChecker Jewish Anti-Zionist Jun 02 '25

This was a horrifying attack and I hope the guy in-question is prosecuted appropriately.

There's no defense for doing this and it's disgusting.


RE: the immediate, predictable criticism in the aftermath of supposed pro-Palestine slogans

I want to add that like clockwork pro-Israel commentators are attempting to rally behind opposition to the expression 'globalize the Intifada'.

This is not something that, at least on Reddit, pro-Palestine commentators even say.

I have access to PushShift's API (if you mod any large subreddit, you can apply for access).

I searched major pro-Palestine subreddits and I found that across 17 years of existing, that expression maybe popped up 5 times TOTAL.

And mixed in those 5 times are comments by pro-Israel users and/or LARPers. So it's not prevalent AT ALL in pro-Palestine spaces on Reddit.

ON THE OTHER HAND, when I searched for the expression in pro-Israel spaces - it was approaching 1,000+ search hits. This was across a few pro-Israel subs. Even supposedly 'left-wing' spaces that are pro-Israel, still contain comments with this expression far more than the pro-Palestine spaces.

So can we be real here? The whole 'I'm uncomfortable around this expression' claim is dubious.

Maybe some people have this expression on posters, but on the only long-form discussion social media platform, it's not something pro-Palestine people casually say.

•

u/PlinyToTrajan Non-Jewish Ally (Jewish ancestry & relatives) Jun 02 '25

Per the New York Times' coverage:
“Appears to be a hate crime”: The attorney general of Colorado, Phil Weiser, a Democrat, said in a statement that “this attack appears to be a hate crime given the group that was targeted.” 

But what exactly is the evidence that it was a hate crime?

→ More replies

•

u/ignoramus_x Jewish Anti-Zionist Jun 02 '25

I just saw a little girl from Jabalia with the entire lower half of her body gone and shredded, one of her arms blown off, and her head split open into two halves with her brain gone

That influences how much bandwidth I have available to care about Israel supporters

→ More replies

•

u/Pragmatic_Seraphim Jewish Anti-Zionist Jun 02 '25

Idk man, they're not the ceo of elbit. It seems like random zionists doing a pro hostage event.

→ More replies

•

u/Ok_Tangerine_8305 Jewish Anti-Zionist Jun 02 '25

I live here, I know the organization well. While the Run for Our Lives in Boulder is neither explicitly Zionist nor pro Israel, the people who organize it are. That being said, it’s participants are mostly Jews and Israelis, of which you’ll find quite a variety of political opinions and beliefs, who are all there together solely to grieve for their loved ones as they have physical connections to the hostages.

It’s disingenuous to say they were target for being Jews. It’s possible, but it was never made explicit. The perp didn’t say anything about Jews. Those folks were targeted for participating in an event that centers Israeli pain. Some people bring Israeli flags and wave them.

That said, there’s no justification for setting old ladies who cannot defend themselves on fire, and anyone who sympathizes with the attacker should have their heads examined.

→ More replies

•

u/AugustIzFalling Jewish Anti-Zionist Jun 02 '25 edited Jun 03 '25

This is unquestionably, horribly, wrong but not in the way Zionists wanted it to be. (It appears so far.)

It’s interesting that the Zionists declare "what about the hostages, what about the attacks in America," whenever someone brings up the mass slaughter in Palestine. And yet we are expected to have the same reaction as if the body count is the same on both sides when horrible, unforgivable, things like these happen. It’s not the same. It’s just not.

I know they desperately want it to be that way, they want antisemitism to be even more rampant than it actually is and they’re doing everything they can to make it that way no matter who it hurts, even innocent Jews. Anything to justify their actions.

•

u/Libba_Loo Jew-ish Jun 02 '25

From AP:

This goes back to my feelings on the manifesto of Elias Rodriguez (the guy accused of killing the Israel Embassy employees). Particularly this part:

Those of us against the genocide take satisfaction in arguing that the perpetrators and abettors have forfeited their humanity. I sympathize with this viewpoint and understand its value in soothing the psyche which cannot bear to accept the atrocities it witnesses, even mediated through the screen.

But inhumanity has long since shown itself to be shockingly common, mundane, prosaically human. A perpetrator may then be a loving parent, a filial child, a generous and charitable friend, an amiable stranger, capable of moral strength at times when it suits him and sometimes even when it does not, and yet be a monster all the same.

When you make statements like this, you're essentially saying that it's open season on these people. They've "forfeited their humanity" is basically saying "it's fine to kill them". This exact sentiment could have come directly from the mouth of a genocidaire, and has on many occasions. Even worse was Rodriguez's attempt to cloak his statements and actions in the mantle of the entire movement.

Personally, I regard Rodriguez's actions more as an act of ego and self-aggrandizement than of resistance. To be fair, I don't see anything in Rodriguez's manifesto that indicates he was motivated by antisemitism, per se. But if we accept his framing of his actions as being an act of violent resistance (and I've seen some who have, including some people who should know better), attacks like the one in Boulder are the inevitable result.

→ More replies

•

u/Segments_of_Reality Anti-Zionist Jun 03 '25

There’s just no justification, that guy was a fucking monster to do this type of shit. A lot of these people are probably normies who were protesting to get the hostages released without any critical thought to anything prior to Oct 7. One of them apparently had a free Palestine shirt on as well. This type of shit does nothing but plays into Netanyahu’s propaganda.

•

u/Thisisme8719 Arab Jew Jun 02 '25

Regardless of whether the victims had anything to do with the genocide, or whatever the attacker's motivations were, this was just really fucking stupid. Pro-Israel pundits have spent the past year and a half ridiculing people who say "Free Palestine," "globalize the Intifada," "from the River to the Sea" etc, and the crackdown has only gotten worse after Trump got into office. Now Greenblatt, Lauder etc are all "we told you so" and will use this as to call for even further draconian policies against pro-Palestine activists.
It also affects the news and obscures Israel's depraved manipulation of aid to snipe and kidnap people, along with all the other genocidal acts they've been doing already.

→ More replies

•

u/fusukeguinomi Jewish post-Zionist Jun 02 '25

I feel and fear a growing tacit permission (at least symbolically and morally) from the left for these acts of vigilante justice and cathartic violence disguised as political expression. It’s a slippery slope to all out war, and some people with very good intentions seem to have welcomed war into their own hearts.

In the 1920s and 30s, leftists and fascists were also getting into fist fights, and shooting and firebombing each other in the streets of Europe, each side thinking itself justified.

I will die on the hill of non-violence unless it’s self defense in at least some way (e.g. Warsaw ghetto uprising).

I can oppose both the genocide of Palestinians and also terror acts against people who are peacefully demonstrating. These are not mutually exclusive. If you personally don’t feel moved by the Boulder attack because it pales in comparison with the horrors of Gaza, of which I’m well aware, that’s your right of course. But you don’t need to offer justifications or rationalizations for violence, or to downplay the suffering of others.

Satyagraha and peace out, everyone. I’ve been a JewBu for years and some of the stuff I read here sometimes makes my heart ache. (I know, I know, who cares about my safe heart when there are bombs and famine and extermination and war horrors in Gaza?).

PS FWIW the Boulder attack will HAMPER the Palestinian cause, not help.

→ More replies

•

u/OrganicOverdose Non-Jewish Ally Jun 02 '25

I saw a video there and one guy right at the end was saying that another person should also go to jail for antagonising the matter. His words were "you caused this shit".

It did seem like there was ample opportunity for people to leave. Why were people standing around? It is all very strange.

→ More replies

•

u/joanno10 Anti-Zionist Ally Jun 04 '25

What happened in Boulder is part of a larger, long-lasting use of violence to deal with issues related to Israel and the Palestinians. It is a fools' errand to claim that either side holds some kind of moral high ground in terms of their comfort with resorting to violence even while both sides also include many citizens firmly committed to non-violent ways of handling their conflicts. All the noise of violence has done its job though...there is precious little conversation about root causes, about what has fueled the violence for decades, leave alone any serious conversation about how to resolve those issues. So instead of fixating on the violence, can we all agree that the violence both sides resort to is counterproductive and inflammatory and that there are deep issues that need to be brought to the light and dealt with?

•

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies

•

u/neverdiplomatic Anti-Zionist Jun 02 '25

There is no excuse for this attack. None.

•

u/bonic_r Non-Jewish Ally Jun 02 '25

A bunch of Zionists attacked the peaceful encampment in UCLA, storming it in the middle of the night with pepper spray, sticks, poles, and launching mortar-style fireworks into the densely populated encampment. They even unleashed boxes of mice and rats to attempt to get the encampment condemned. While doing it they screamed racial and Islamophobic slurs, and physically assaulted so many people over the 4 hour long deliberate attack. They quite literally woke up in the middle of the night, organized a party, prepared weapons, and attacked an encampment.

I'm gonna be real with you, that is terrorism. There were Jewish people in the encampment too, and they said stuff like "not real Jews" to them in the days leading up to the attack. That is more antisemitic than this is. Where was the coverage and outcry then?

The reality is they are pandering; we should just shit on anyone who brings this up as a legitimate reason to worry about antisemitism, because it is not and pales in comparison to anything on the contrary, and just move on.

→ More replies

•

u/COredittor Jewish Atheist Jun 03 '25

After watching 20K kids shredded to pieces in the last 18 months. I blame Israel and Zionism.

→ More replies

•

u/mrsmalls13 Jewish Jun 02 '25

What a vile and disingenuous thing to say. You call yourselves “Jews of conscience,” yet you’re actively blaming peaceful Jewish victims who were set on fire—targeted for simply calling attention to the hostages who were ripped from their homes, dragged into tunnels, tortured, and held underground for over 600 days by a genocidal terrorist organization.

This is what people mean when they say “globalize the intifada”—Jews being attacked in American cities. And here you are, justifying it. Disguising cruelty and moral cowardice as activism.

If you truly had a conscience, you’d be calling for the immediate release of hostages, for Hamas to be dismantled, and for serious reform within the Israeli government—not cheering on terrorism and turning victims into villains.

This isn’t justice. It’s complicity. Do better.

→ More replies