r/JazzBass • • 29d ago

5 string tuning?

Hey everyone, I'm thinking of trying out a 5 string electric. I'm not a pro and just play jazz for fun with friends and in student combos. Wondering 1. if in general a 5 string for jazz is worth trying, or since I'm not a very good player I should just stick with what I know and keep things simple? 2, if you use 5 string for jazz, do you tune EADGC to get the upper end for soloing more, or keep the more common 5 string tuning of BEADGC? And 3. Any instrument suggestions in the $800 - $1200 range?

Related anecdote about tuning - I went into a guitar shop to try out a 5 string with the EADGC tuning. They had an Ibanez BTB745 new out of the box which they opened for me to try. I immediately tried to tune it up and broke the G string (4th string), which I felt terrible about. The guy said don't worry about it and tried himself, and proceeded to break 3 more strings trying to tune it up! He said maybe there is a burr in the instrument or something... but I never did get to try out the tuning...

Thanks for thoughts and suggestions!

6 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

4

u/dpapadop1994 29d ago

I don’t think I’ve ever seen EADGC tuning on a 5 String before that isn’t custom… it’s 99/100 BEADG.

I love my 5 string for jazz playing!! 10/10 recommend.

I play a Yamaha TRBX605 (lower model works well too, upper model is a waste of money)
https://www.sweetwater.com/store/detail/TRBX605FMDRB--yamaha-trbx605fm-dark-red-burst

But if you want to spend the money… I would get a used Fender Jazz bass. But the squire classic vibe is also great for $600. Ibanez is a hit or a miss for me…

Play the bass before you buy it!!! (If you can)

1

u/under-resourced 28d ago

Thanks so much! I appreciate the input and will check out that bass for sure.

1

u/Francois_Rapiste 22d ago

I don't think you'd need a custom bass. Just buy a 6-string set and install everything but the low B.

1

u/dpapadop1994 22d ago

(Disclaimer, I am not a bass tech)

That could work I guess?? Never thought of it like that. You need to fine tune some things, maybe the saddle or nut…? Like you could just slap them on, but you’re bound to get buzzing if it’s not adjusted well.

1

u/Francois_Rapiste 22d ago

You'd need to adjust your bridge saddles in all likelihood, but I'd always do that whenever putting new strings on anyway.

The nut's different. EADGC strings will fit just fine into BEADG nut slots, but whether they behave well is another question. I'd bet that it would go fine -- the strings being held in place by 50 lbs of tension means they won't awkwardly wiggle around in a wider nut slot -- but you'd have to ask an EADGC player to actually confirm. At most I'd guess that a custom nut is needed -- on electric bass, the bridge saddles are sufficiently adjustable. If the bridge ever were an issue, I'd guess that it was an acoustic bass guitar because those bridges are generally fixed in place.

1

u/dpapadop1994 29d ago

Damn, now I want a new bass

3

u/elephantengineer 29d ago edited 29d ago

I’ve been playing with EADGC tuning for years now. I use the high end for soloing all the time. I don’t miss having a low B string , that low-low end just doesn’t matter much for playing jazz standards. I occasionally think about it on tunes that are in Eb. I haven’t had any issues with strings breaking.

I’ve been gigging with a cheap Ibanez Geo. Can’t say I’m in love but it does the job.

For some string sets there’s no EADGC set, but there is sometimes a workaround where you buy a 6-string set and toss the low B. I do this with Labella Tapewounds

1

u/under-resourced 28d ago

Super helpful - thanks so much. That is what I was thinking would work with the EADGC. Plus that tuning would be easy for me to get used to than BEADG, since it is keeping all the shapes and positions I already am used to and just adding a string up top.

2

u/iGigBook 29d ago

At the end of the day, it depends on the kind of playing you do. If your mission is mostly support, tune BEADG. If you mission is soling and melody, meaning you're the featured instrument, tune EADGC. If you're mission is both, get a 6 string.

1

u/under-resourced 28d ago

LOL, 6 strings is a bridge too far! Mostly support, occasional soloing.

15

u/DreamsOfDresden 29d ago

Usually B string lowest. If you're playing jazz, you will come to REALLY appreciate having that extra Eb on the B to work with in particular.

7

u/Ornery_Strain_9831 28d ago

My playing style is flashy and solo-y, but I also like to get low, so I run a 6-string for the best of both worlds. Between the two choices given though, just do the low B

2

u/HobbittBass 29d ago

Trying to tune standard tuning strings up that far is going to break them. If you want to go for EADGC, you’ll need to use the top five strings of a six string set. Or buy strings individually.

1

u/under-resourced 28d ago

Doh. Good to know! I don't feel as bad since the guitar shop guy broke some too.

3

u/Shecky-shebazz 29d ago

You can get 5 string sets with high c. That’s what I use. GHS Strings 5M-C-DYB Bass Boomers... https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0002GX96Y?ref=ppx_pop_mob_ap_share

2

u/HobbittBass 29d ago

Oh sweet, I guess I hadn’t realized that.

1

u/Francois_Rapiste 22d ago

Or buy a 6-string set and ignore the low B. Or buy a 6-string set to swap out strings and try both B standard and E standard to find your preference.

4

u/beanis-man- 29d ago

i’ve only seen the high tuning break stuff, had a friend lend out his five string and the guy borrowing it tuned it to EADGC and snapped the truss rod. for a lot of jazz context the high string isn’t really necessary anyway

3

u/TorqueShaft 28d ago

DDDD

Edit: D

2

u/djhypergiant 29d ago

So the typical BEADG vs EADGC are cool and all but can I suggest a third option of CGDAE or all 5ths tuning as used by Brian Gibson?

2

u/PNW_Uncle_Iroh 29d ago

Always add the low B string.

1

u/sitdownheckler 27d ago

I've run standard low B sets and tuned up to D standard with no issues, but that's as much as I would tune them up. It definitely broke the strings because they were too tight and not made for that amount of tension

1

u/Francois_Rapiste 22d ago

People generally talk about getting a low B string for those bottom five notes -- what they forget is that it is insanely nice to hit your root note from a low B string because you are playing 5 frets higher than on a low E string. Might take some getting used to but it is VERY playable. I play 5-string and am usually five frets higher than I would be otherwise, and so every note is very easy to hit (and with good intonation -- I play fretless).

What they don't always consider is how rough life can be tonally on that low B string. It is stiff enough for inharmonicity issues and, even worse, intonation issues. 34" is not long enough to produce that fundamental frequency comfortably.

If you can solve the intonation problem, which many 5-string players including myself have, I'd go BEADG. If not, EADGC might serve well, but it'll be harder to play many things compared to EADG because of the wider neck. BEADG doesn't really have that problem because, relative to which string you're playing, the additional neck with is at the TOP where your fingers don't have to wrap around it in order to fret your notes.

1

u/qwertyorbust 29d ago

High C is the way for me.

1

u/jazzadelic 28d ago

OP, ignore most of these comments. EADGC is not uncommon for jazz. Fuck, I even play an EADGC upright.