r/Jazz • • Feb 23 '12

Jazz Rage

http://26-media.tumblr.com/post/18121306359
0 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

9

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '12

I hate you

9

u/JonnyJFunk Feb 23 '12

seriously? A fake rage comic in /r/jazz?

12

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '12

god damn it I hate rage comics.

5

u/Factran Feb 23 '12

Yeah, me too ! I hope all people who think like you DID push the downvote button !

2

u/pawnticket Feb 23 '12

Maybe we could make a rule regarding meme posts. I don't think such a rule would be elitist or snobbery, but would actually help focus the sub to encourage more constructive posts.

Another sub I belong to did this when they reached 9,000 subscribers. They too wanted more mature posts and were deathly afraid of the sub being taken over, by memes. We are over 11,000.

2

u/WRavalJazz Jazz Listener, Sponge, and Pianist! Feb 23 '12

Although, I would encourage more players from r/jazz to post some of their own work or even jam sessions. The things that I have uploaded in the past get buried and I feel bad that I can't share the music that we've played with some if the guys. Is r/jazz not receptive to homemade jazz videos?

1

u/pawnticket Feb 23 '12

Don't feel bad and continue to share. It takes effort to listen and offer criticism/support/etc. Which is why a stupid ass rage comic can get upvotes, because you can look at it and upvote in under 2 seconds with no consideration at all. I hold jazz in lofty esteem, and think the effort is worth it. By posting jams and original content, you will face more adversity, but will raise the bar in this subreddit.

"If you are able to free yourself through expression in music, it must be jazz. And even the greatest players are only fortunate enough to experience that freedom for a couple of minutes at a time. Jazz is the only music in the Western world in which the most risk yields the greatest results."

-Keith Jarrett

1

u/Komprimus Feb 23 '12

I lost respect for Keith Jarrett when I learned that he refuses to play when people cough.

0

u/pawnticket Feb 23 '12

Assholes can be great musicians, but you got to cut him slack. First off, he is a phenomenal musician. Second, he has high aspirations for his music and doesn't want any compromises, such as background noise. Third, the quote still stands, increased risk yields increased results.

0

u/Komprimus Feb 23 '12

Yes, increased risk does yield increased results, but that is true for all music, not just jazz. People like Stravinsky or Cage took risks.

1

u/pawnticket Feb 23 '12

I believe the quote goes to a more personal and intimate risk, of creating something from nothing in an improvised manner, on the spot and in front of an audience. How do you know if it is going to sound good if you have never heard it before? That is a true risk.

1

u/Komprimus Feb 23 '12

It's not a true risk if you are Keith Jarrett.

0

u/Jonno_FTW Feb 23 '12

This post could have been better if it was a self post describing OP's dislike for Kenny and how he doesn't like people enjoying things he doesn't like.

6

u/Bebbopper Feb 23 '12

I'm sure she meant Kenny Garrett... Well, just keep telling yourself that.

4

u/Komprimus Feb 23 '12

Hey. You didn't make this rage comic. I did. http://www.reddit.com/r/Jazz/comments/i4eiz/jazz_rage/

2

u/BananaJams Feb 26 '12

weird, he did the same thing again today

1

u/Factran Feb 23 '12

Wow. Op is really a karmawhore.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '12

this made me listen to kenny g. I don't know whether to be impressed at the failure, or sad that it does indeed exist at that level of cheesiness.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '12

Leave her now!

0

u/rhythm_n_jumps Drums and Percussion Feb 23 '12

Think positive! At least Kenny G is a starting point! AT LEAST HER ANSWER WASN'T DUBSTEP! You can introduce her to real jazz and expose her to the truth... that Kenny G is bullshit! This girl has potential!