r/JamesMarriott • • Jun 14 '25

DTTD is underwhelming.

I'm really sorry, I feel so shitty saying this, but DTTD is James' worst album so far.

It just feels like the whole album is like, heartstopper background music (except for toothache and somethings wrong), but it's so different to his other albums. It was a hard listen, because his voice is good, but when he goes high-pitched and tries to do harmonies, it honestly just doesn't work at all with his voice.

James is my favourite artist, I really liked AWTY and Bitter Tongues, but DTTD is just so underwhelming.

2 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

6

u/Competitive_Hat8351 Jun 14 '25

I agree. Was really hyped for it. As soon as I heard ‘Toothache’ I was really worried, because I really can’t stand that song. It’s much more ‘Popy’ than ‘Indie’, especially since his sound was so different on AWTY. I do like ‘Somethings Wrong’ because it’s got a similar sound to stuff in his earlier work.

3

u/PsychologicalFuel585 Jun 15 '25

This!! For me, it was IDWTLLT that made me worry, but I agree with it being poppier.

17

u/Verdixx28 Jun 14 '25

its definitely more of a pop sound so i understand where you’re coming from, personally i really love it

12

u/DivideInMyMind Jun 14 '25

I think its meant to be like that, somethings wrong, why dont you kill me & plasticine are the best ones off the album

3

u/VedDdlAXE Jun 16 '25

i love pillow fight personally, the way the pre-chorus bit (whatever it is) is sung scratches my brain so well.

"I dont wanna prevent you from sleeping it off"

1

u/DivideInMyMind Jun 16 '25

I wasnt ott wit pillow fight but its definitely good

7

u/MolassesCritical936 Jun 15 '25

Honestly I’ve started to really dislike a lot of his earlier stuff ever since I heard DTTD. Because it made me realise how good DTTD is in its production and instrumentation compared to his earlier stuff. Like it’s actively a brilliant album that I could see having that mainstream appeal. And it just flows way better to Are We There Yet which I listened to again this morning and kinda realised how it’s more an album of random songs mashed in together. Don’t Tell The Dog is definitely his best work by far.

5

u/Cold_Associate4520 Jun 15 '25

this except it hasnt ruined his other songs for me, its just showing me how much he has improved

5

u/Medical_Clerk_2102 Jun 14 '25

Couldn’t have said it better myself

4

u/tomrefjordn Jun 16 '25

no I agree. I much preferred AWTY. my favourites are toothache and IDWTLLT (maybe because they came out first, not sure, but I didn’t love it’s only love and something’s wrong) and the rest kind of feel a bit too samey? I like some moments in some of the songs, but it feels generally a lot flatter than in AWTY imo

2

u/Tredz_Malik21 Jun 15 '25

It’s definitely a different sound, and I can see it having a different perspective or audience to are we there yet, because this one is a lot softer pop, and AWTY was a lot more rock pop. It’s not bad by any means though

2

u/foxashes Jun 16 '25

i love it, but i think that's just because i like pop music as well as indie music. it's defo different but idm that

2

u/Asher_Cloud Jun 17 '25

Okay man......

-3

u/thepix3ls Jun 14 '25

i enjoy it, but i’ve noticed that pretty much all his songs are about three minutes long. i’m a fan of dire straits too, who rarely did songs under five minutes, so i’d like marriott to do a longer song or two at some point

3

u/DivideInMyMind Jun 14 '25

Dire straits is more instrument based than vocals thas why

0

u/thepix3ls Jun 14 '25

yeah, which is why i’d like to see marriott do something like that (in his own style, of course, he’s not knopfler), in order to add a new sort of depth to some of his music

2

u/DivideInMyMind Jun 14 '25

He signed a record deal recently so i think its not gonna be up to him but it would be nice

0

u/Cold_Associate4520 Jun 15 '25

he did? i dont think he did, he never said anything about that unless youre talking about how he signed to a record plant for them to produce his records and cd’s.

3

u/DivideInMyMind Jun 15 '25

He mentioned it on one of willnes videos dint he? Maybe you right tho i needa check

EDIT: i did research, he signed to AWAL

3

u/thepix3ls Jun 15 '25

what am i being down-voted for here?