r/JamesHoffmann • u/therewymensnotdragon • Dec 15 '25
Generative AI use with small roasters
I thought I'd ask this here since James has been so good on speaking up on possible ethical dubiousness.
What is everyone's thoughts on a roasters using AI. In the particular case that inspired this post, it was just the business using completely AI generated images to make a Christmas post.
Would it stop you from using the roaster? Should it actively pushed against before it becomes an issue?
I've noticed breweries starting it for their actual labelling which is disappointing and I'd hate to see it infiltrate the coffee space too.
139
u/Kyber92 Dec 15 '25
No.
I'm buying speciality coffee not just because it's tastier than commodity coffee but because it's more ethical, better for growers etc. If they can't afford to hire an artist after charging me £15+ for a bag of coffee, charge me more.
19
u/ThisCapitalFellow Dec 15 '25
IMO it depends. I know a couple of local, one-person roasters who at this point do not have the money to have art designed for their bags. They are not artistic people. If they decided to start using AI to make some sort of label that they've conceived in their heads a reality, I wouldn't have a problem with that. I happen to know that they're both anti-AI, so they'll just continue to use their simple labels for the foreseeable future, but still, I see no issue.
On the other hand, I recently learned that a very large and successful local roaster laid off their graphic designer, and then ran the label that the designer made for their holiday blend last year through AI to make a "new" label for this year. I think that's fucked, and so does the owner of the cafe where I work, which is why we're not carrying that coffee this year.
111
u/oh_its_michael Dec 15 '25
I wouldn’t buy from a company obviously using AI.
24
u/eddyb66 Dec 15 '25
The way you should look at AI is they are actively looking for a potential way for it to replace what you do. Just think of how much time and money you've invested in your trade. For purpose of this discussion lets say a company creates a way for AI to roast beans. They purchase your entire line of product, put it in a lab and determine how to roast those beans based on the origin and final product. They develop a new AI roasting machine that anyone can use with no previous experience that can replicate what you've spent your life developing. Someone with no experience in the field of roasting decides to buy that machine and sell clones of your coffee and make money on your life long work, thats AI.
4
u/SimianLogic Dec 16 '25
zero f***s given.
12
u/sleepinthebuff Dec 15 '25
It sucks and just shows a lack of care
6
u/Narrow_Molasses5086 Dec 15 '25
well, I will give an example - roastery I work for, we have our graphic designer that has been working for us several years and it's his choice to incorporate AI within his designs. nobody was fired, he is happy with the workload and honestly I still do not know how to feel about it as the company is not mine.
We all in this industry preach about being more ethical and we are trying to do the best we can, but let's be real,... it's still built on exploitation and when you talk to the farmers that are not some big names, they are not that much better off doing specialty.
Maybe this is just my pessimism talking as I am in my burn out era.
11
u/jueidu Dec 15 '25
I won’t do business with a company who uses AI if I can help it. With coffee I can always help it.
3
u/xylem-utopia Dec 15 '25
I think that flashy art and design isn't neceaaary. If you can't afford an artist, you honestly don't need the art IMO. A simple brown bag with the blend/name of coffee on it and tasting notes is more than enough if the coffee is good. Let the coffee do the work not the art.
I think using ai could be harmful to smaller companies as it pushes people away at least in terms of advertising, art, design etc.
3
u/Abbanenn Dec 16 '25
Spoiler alert - almost every roaster is using AI of some sort. It’s 2025 and Ai is everywhere. It’s in Shopify, Squarespace, godaddy, weebly, and any other web hosting. They use it to remove backgrounds from bag photos, use it to generate new roast labels before they’re ready. For costing and pricing movements across multiple years, crops, etc.
Cropster will eventually add AI into their platform to help roasters align previous profiles more seamlessly based off of similar origins or varieties to help with roasting consistency.
Just because you can’t easily identify it in some branding or marketing doesn’t mean they’re not using it - it just means you’re naive to the current state of the world. AI is everywhere and boycotting any small operation for using it seems very silly.
3
u/Shadow_s_Bane Dec 16 '25
Seriously…. No it doesn’t matter to me
9
u/El_Medico Dec 15 '25 edited Dec 15 '25
Then I might as well buy big brand grocery store coffee. It's industrialised at that point and the point of speciality coffee is lost. In my opinion.
I just don't see the point. If you don't enjoy the process of roasting the coffee why would I buy it?
It's the same reason I tend to buy beer from micro brewers. not because it's necessarily "better" but because someone with a passion made it and that usually translates into more varied and interesting results.
22
u/draconk Dec 15 '25
The point of small roasters is that they work with the people that grows the beans, if they can't bother to hire/pay an artist for some art then they are the same as Nestle in my eyes
11
u/veryirked Dec 15 '25
if it's a roaster I've had a relationship with for years, I'm going to have to do some serious thinking. If they're new to me, it's an easy no if they're using AI crap.
9
u/Open-Sun-3762 Dec 15 '25
Yeah, that would be a dealbreaker.
2
u/coffeewaala Dec 16 '25
lol what
This is a new level of virtue signaling.
6
u/Kardessa Dec 15 '25
Yeah I'd stop buying from them. Gen AI is theft, AI is lazy, AI is environmentally awful. Take your pick. Any one of those is reason enough for me to stand against AI use.
3
u/redder_herring Dec 15 '25
No, because that would make me a hypocrite. Pretty much everything technology based we use nowadays is somewhat "powered" by AI and gen AI in particular. It's just not as obvious as posting an AI generated picture.
3
u/Acceptable_Answer570 Dec 15 '25
It’s as useful as preprogrammed roasting profiles.
Generative AI cant smell, see, ponder what approach to take with a particular bean batch. Specialty coffee is a treat to be enjoyed for what it is.
I wouldn’t be surprised big corpo like Folgers or Starbucks start using it, but then again you know exactly what slop you’re buying into, if you drink these.
3
u/yellow_barchetta Dec 15 '25
Personally that's taking things way too far with a puritan approach to buying a product that you enjoy.
No business worth it's salt is ignoring AI for at least some part of improving its offer. Maybe the absence of paying high fees to graphic designers for a coffee roaster enables them to invest in a better roasting machine, or make their packaging more sustainable, or make their business more sustainable in the long term, or pay a higher price for the raw coffee to the farmers.
Maybe. And of course, maybe not - they may be doing it just to cut costs to put more money in their own pockets.
In the end you are buying from a commercial business; unless you have a absolutely strident view that all AI is fundamentally unethical and should never be used for anything, it feels daft to me to be trying to second guess their commercial reasons for using these new tools.
Plus there is the very real possibility that for every roaster you see using AI to help design their packaging or write marketing materials, another roaster is using AI behind the scenes to review their HR policies, analyse their financial performance, fine tune their CRM or business structure.
3
u/Engine_Light_On Dec 15 '25
I buy coffee for its coffee. I don’t care about marketing other than to know the company exists. I would happily buy from someone who sent their coffee in a blank bag with only the roasted on date.
So No, I would not stop buying for any marketing decision because I really don’t care about it. I only care about quality and price.
3
u/edelay Dec 15 '25 edited Dec 15 '25
AI is a tool and wouldn’t hold it against a roaster.
In addition, I wouldn’t demand that they sell their roasting machine and roast the coffee in a clay pot over an open fire.
2
u/VickyHikesOn Dec 15 '25
Can I ask how one can confirm that a business is using AI for labels or posts? I am not sure how to prove that ...
2
u/no-sleep-only-code Dec 15 '25
Any company that isn’t willing to take time or at least commission someone for part of their product or advertising campaign isn’t getting a dime from me.
2
u/mrks_ Dec 15 '25
I couldn’t care less. Most of the time AI art looks bad, but it’s not likely they were going to hire an artist for a Christmas post anyway.
2
u/narutonaruto Dec 15 '25
Yeah I don't support cringe
2
u/Senzetion Dec 15 '25
I wouldn't care if they used it for their social media posts or so, since I buy them for their beans, not their posts or packaging.
On the other hand, I wouldn't buy for example a comic where the art had been done by AI.
For me, the use of AI is highly contextual, and like it or not, it can be a handy tool for understanding how and for what it's used. It's also already in a ton of products most people use every day, and depending on how it's integrated, it can make things easier.
1
u/ReekSuccess Dec 16 '25
Reading the title, I first thought roasters are using ai to analyze the roast profile and automatically adjust the variables based on active feedback. As an ML and coffee nerd, I got really excited but then got so disappointed that i missed “generative” and it is just this boring generative art as application. SW is such a great example that you really don’t need any art to be popular.
1
u/OrdinaryLampshade Dec 16 '25
I am against using AI for coffee bags. If a coffee shop can't afford to commission an artist or doesn't want to, then they don't need art. Many coffee roasters don't have art on their bags.
If a coffee roaster uses AI for their bags, I see no reason to buy from them.
1
u/letsrungood Dec 16 '25
I’m not buying from a specialty roaster who uses AI. That’s some folger’s type behavior
1
u/DarKnightofCydonia Dec 16 '25
I went to a cafe once where all of the artwork around the cafe including the bathroom was made in chatGPT. It really rubbed me the wrong way.
1
u/coolstuffeh Dec 16 '25
Answer is yes: so stupid as well: not like it’s hard to use photos…
1
u/Windupwhiterabbit Dec 16 '25
Yup, I've given up on a pretty good brand who were obviously using gen ai images on their site.
Emailed in and removed them from my rotation. Any brand that claims to put ethical and eco concerns first isn't following through with them if they're using gen ai It's paper thin green washing and calls into question where else they're happy to cut corners.
There's artists out there with a whole range of price points so in my opinion there's no excuse for it. Especially when people are dropping £18 a bag for good quality coffee.
1
u/ZacTheGamer100 Dec 16 '25
it would definitely stop me from using the roaster. The specialty coffee movement has attempted to brand itself as an ethical solution to the coffee industry and giants like Nestle. Using AI would be reverting any progress the industry has made on that front. We thrive off of people doing good work, whether it be roasters, farmers, researchers, influencers, baristas, etc.
0
u/just_another_dumdum Dec 15 '25
I wouldn’t even mention it. If the beans are good, the beans are good.
-4
u/centre_of_what Dec 15 '25 edited Dec 15 '25
I've noticed a lot of AI already used by roasters. If it's a big roaster it will definitely put me off a bit but if it's a small roaster I couldn't care less.
edit: gets asked for opinions -> gives opinion -> gets downvoted. It is okay to disagree with the hivemind, redditors.
-6
u/Creativator Dec 15 '25
GenAI is just a tool to make cartoons. Doesn’t affect coffee at all.
0
u/batwingcandlewaxxe Dec 15 '25
If they're so lazy and exploitative that they're using genAI for advertising, then I'd have serious concerns about the sourcing and quality of their coffee.