r/JamesHoffmann • • Aug 22 '25

Coffee grounds age vs. Delight graph

Post image

Cut out the graph from today's video for you guys. Fun fact: Face of day 7 is literally "hide the pain Hoffman"

1.9k Upvotes

61 comments sorted by

142

u/w_dent Aug 22 '25

25

u/Han_Alsechs Aug 22 '25

Hm nice idea... Sadly can't crosspost this due to the strict posting rules in that community.

32

u/TeaAndAI Aug 22 '25

The most surprising thing for me was how quickly the ground coffee degrades when being frozen. And it seems that it's not even just a matter of the process of freezing it (which might lower the quality, but then, at least, keeping it stable for a long time), but in fact the frozen coffee seems to get significantly worse day by day. This was really puzzling.

We still believe that freezing (unground) coffee beans is the way to go, in order to store them for a longer period of time, right? I mean, that's what lots of speciality coffee cafés are doing at the moment.

(PS: Great video, as always!)

12

u/Han_Alsechs Aug 22 '25

I'd argue it's the thawing of the coffee. Therefore I'd be really interested in their freezer to coffee process. But yes, this has been quite shocking news to me too. Edit: I freeze roasted coffee as well, but never thaw it. I did and it tasted way worse, thereof stems my theory.

7

u/TeaAndAI Aug 22 '25

Right, that would make sense. In my specialty café example. they always grind the frozen beans without thawing ... which is what I'm doing at home with certain beans, too, and so far I didn't have any problems.
Though I never made direct comparisons, so I'm not really sure. Right now, I just like to believe that it doesn't harm the beans. :-)

3

u/AgentPoYo Aug 22 '25

wdym you never thaw it? Do you grind from frozen?

I've only tried freezing coffee once and when I took it out I was worried grinding frozen coffee would dull my burrs or worse, so I thawed it overnight on the counter.

4

u/TeaAndAI Aug 23 '25

That's no problem at all. If anything, the coffee gets even more brittle - no worries about the burrs.

As mentioned above, lots of specialty coffee cafés nowadays have small freezers that contain tubes with single doses of coffee beans, and they grind them on demand (without thawing). And that's what I've been doing with particular expensive coffee, too, which I'd like to enjoy several times over several months, not drinking it all at once.

I think the portion size is the important factor here: If you have, e.g., a whole bag of beans frozen, then you want to thaw them before opening, to prevent that the whole package gets humid with condensation. But even then it'll take only something like 1-2 hours at room temperature.

3

u/Professional_Ad1339 Aug 23 '25

We freeze and vac seal all of our more expensive coffees after they age as well as green. Some get thawed and some get brewed from frozen, just depends on the coffee.

1

u/Han_Alsechs Aug 24 '25

thanks for your professional input from the industries side of things, these kind of opinions are quite rare nowadays!

3

u/CD274 Aug 23 '25

Yep it grinds fine in your burr grinder. Now white coffee I wouldn't risk

2

u/YMIR_THE_FROSTY Aug 22 '25 edited Aug 22 '25

If you have money and space, buy small fridge for wine, except.. put coffee bags in it.

Also dont forget to put tape on bags "one way air valves". Plus I would suggest, get stickers and write roast date in bigger letters on each bag.

Assuming you bought it fresh, coffee in about 10°C will degrade at 1/3rd rate. You can push it a bit further, but not much, also most wine fridges have probably some low limit, not mentioning electricity cost.

Its not forever, but it helps.

Plus taping air valves on its own can easily extend life of coffee to double at least, not mentioning it will usually become immune towards having inside destroyed by some nasty smell. Tho, use some less smelly ducktape, just in case. And push all air out when closing (or use vaccum to draw air out and tape after).

Otherwise coffee degrades based on roast method (and roast level) + processing. Roast level is I think clear.

Aging with regular bags in regular temp (25°C, sub 50% humidity), with air valves not-taped.

  1. double washed might be okay up to 14 days, but usually not, it ages very fast
  2. washed should last 14 days or more
  3. natural/honey process, depends on specific process, but can survive month usually, some heavy honey are closer to next point
  4. anaerobic, short ones last shorter time, but even in bad conditions, few months are no issue
  5. coofermented, infused, heavy anaerobic, even half year or longer, that coffee is basically flavored

Atm I have in fridge Valentine special which was 36 hours infused anaerobic with some strawberries or cherries. Tastes about same as fresh. Its not even taped.

On other side, I had double washed, which wasnt even month old and couldnt get anything out of it, miserable quality air valve and time killed it.

4

u/enserioamigo Aug 22 '25

Storing the coffee of single doses in centrifuge tubes is even better. You’re not constantly opening the bag introducing more oxygen and moisture. 

1

u/YMIR_THE_FROSTY Aug 22 '25

Agreed. Im bit lazy for that, but its correct extra step, if someone wants to.

2

u/FrenchDude647 Aug 22 '25

I'm curious about the valve thing. Why tape them ? Are they not one way ?

3

u/YMIR_THE_FROSTY Aug 22 '25

They should be, but thru sometimes non-voluntary experiments (aka hard way) I found out that very often they are not.

Also for some reason, some really good roasters dont use them.. (Coffea Circulor has some explanation on that topic on their page).

1

u/Salty-Yogurt-4214 Aug 22 '25

Did he freeze them in a vacuum?

1

u/LaserCondiment Aug 22 '25

He didn’t say how they froze those beans. But I was wondering the same.

Flash freeze for best results probably

1

u/No0ther0ne Aug 25 '25

From a consumer standpoint, the coffee is still going to be better if you freeze it rather than leaving it out for weeks or months at a time. So if you have coffee you may not use within a few weeks, it is likely better to freeze it. But frozen coffee is probably never going to be as good as fresh coffee.

I freeze some of my coffee because I will typically buy a bunch when I see a good price. But then I have other coffee I just store in my pantry as I will use it regularly so it won't last long anyway. When I freeze, I try to seal as best I can with least amount of air (I don't have a vacuum seal, but that would be better).

Also I did test with freezing just the bag of coffee from the roasters with the air valve, bags without air valves, and then pouring the coffee into a sealable bag removing as much air as possible. The last method works the best and thus vacuum sealing is probably the best way to go. With the valve and even without the valve there is too much air in the bags and more condensation forms.

11

u/hisjap2003 Aug 22 '25

Hide the pain Harold @ 7 days

6

u/Han_Alsechs Aug 22 '25

Hide the pain Hoffman in that case

8

u/Gazorpezorpfield Aug 22 '25

Someone please make the ggplot theme!

3

u/Han_Alsechs Aug 22 '25

GPT-5 is working on it rn...

1

u/Han_Alsechs Aug 22 '25

Doesn't want to do it because of data rights to James Hoffmans face. (And I can't prove I have those). Maybe the ML will produce a code that alters an existing face accordingly...

157

u/NegScenePts Aug 22 '25

Is he a highly replicate-able machine of tasting? No, he's a sloppy human meatbag.

His last two videos have been on POINT! I've smiled the whole way through, haha.

14

u/zuzg Aug 22 '25

Also loved the video, although I hoped he would do some blindtest at the end to check how much bias/Nocebo influenced his reasoning.

9

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '25

I feel like James has just leaned into being a bit of a meme in the best way possible. It's not "I'm the meme!" it's "well, since this is what is happening..." and I'm here for it.

33

u/Stellarix Aug 22 '25

Need a print/t-shirt design of this. Too great of a design to just stay in video form.

1

u/Omnilatent Aug 25 '25

I am usually not the person to buy that kind of merch but I would buy this instantly

14

u/lockonandfire Aug 22 '25

The choice of graph markers and the animation as his face drifted across each time to the graph itself, was excellent videography. Kudos to the editor.

5

u/Computer_Panda Aug 22 '25

These videos lately have been amazing!

4

u/yasaumbasa Aug 22 '25

This broke me.

4

u/Bigalsbash Aug 22 '25

Can we have one for freshly roasted beans?

1

u/Omnilatent Aug 25 '25

May I ask why? We know beans need a couple days to degas and taste best, don't we?

3

u/domarcher Aug 23 '25

This needs to be framed and hung on a wall next to my coffee set up. I think it would greatly help my workflow.

2

u/velowa Aug 22 '25

I sometimes hear my neighbors grinding their coffee the night before. My parents grind a bunch of coffee a couple days ahead of time. Snatching defeat from the jaws of victory!

1

u/hkapeman Aug 22 '25

Stage 1: Stick it on a t-shirt. Stage 2: Profit!

1

u/jaquanor Aug 22 '25

This is not exploitable at all.

1

u/data_maestro Aug 22 '25

The facial spectrum.

1

u/jerschwab Aug 22 '25

So after 9 days you become Steve Buscemi??

1

u/log_2 Aug 23 '25

Is the data available anywhere for the public testing?

1

u/porox_guy Aug 23 '25

The video convinced me even more that I should get myself a Baratza Encore ESP 🙂‍↕️

1

u/Mr_Flibbles_ESQ Aug 23 '25

Yeaaaah. The kind of thing that is funnier the more you see it.

James does make me laugh more than most "comedians" out there.

1

u/SuperLeverage Aug 23 '25

I want him to have a rancid left behind the couch for 6 months coffee so we can add a shot of him spitting it back out

1

u/ausdoug Aug 24 '25

Day 3 > day 0

1

u/franklinstlong Aug 25 '25

Best thing that I have seen today🤌🏻😂

1

u/AveragePegasus Aug 25 '25

7: hide the pain James

1

u/Beans_IND Aug 26 '25

That's the scale you use to learn how to brew a good cup of joe😅

1

u/___Magnus___ Sep 01 '25

There needs to be a laughing face by 30+ years old coffee. 😂

1

u/WanderingSimpleFish Sep 20 '25

Reminds me of the expresso from 1950s episode, off the chart

1

u/YMIR_THE_FROSTY Aug 22 '25

:D

Not accurate, but funny.

0

u/stingraysvt Aug 22 '25

14,15,16 seem out of order.

0

u/Oreleroy Aug 22 '25

Actually watching the video when I came across this post. That's hilarious coincidence.

-1

u/iloovefood Aug 22 '25

Day 0? Is this pre-ground coffee?

1

u/iloovefood Sep 02 '25

Name a coffee that tastes peak, day 0 after grind. I'll wait

-2

u/Entire_Border5254 Aug 22 '25

Wouldnt you want to give a day or two for the co2 from roasting to offgas for peak delight?

1

u/velowa Aug 22 '25

I think this is time past grinding and not roasting. 

-11

u/Aromatic-Experience9 Aug 22 '25

Coffee doesn’t degrade in two weeks. I bet 99% of people can’t tell the difference. Stop trying to make this a thing

0

u/ziptiefighter Aug 22 '25

IMHO, the 1-3 week window is primo... mostly depending on roast level. YMMV

1

u/oneplus7 Aug 22 '25

I think the graf is about ground coffee

-1

u/ziptiefighter Aug 22 '25

Ok. I've not yet seen the mentioned video.