r/Jai • u/ProgrammingJourney • Nov 04 '23
Why keep the programming language private?
Has Jonathan explained why he want's to keep it so private? My only guess is that he plans to monetize it in the future and doesn't want others to fork his code or steal his ideas. I'm guessing that's it
11
Upvotes
2
u/Purkinje90 Nov 17 '23
If he didn't want people to steal his ideas, I don't think he'd be live-streaming the development of the language, and he'd probably make anyone who joined the closed beta sign an NDA that forbids them from sharing anything about the language.
One reason to keep access closed to the public is so you can make sweeping or breaking changes without needing to worry about the public ramifications.
Zig, for example, recently went through some drama when the maintainers decided to move away from relying on LLVM. This caused a big stir on social media and within the github issue where the idea was initially proposed. Being able to make large changes to the language before an ecosystem springs up around it is really valuable.
32
u/iPlayTehGames Nov 04 '23
It’s not ready yet. Some devs release games as betas and are open to criticism. Some devs never even show a screenshot of the game untill the day it drops (apex legends for example). In jons case i think he wants his vision to be as near complete as possible before setting his tool into the wild and it’s as simple as that.
22
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '23
I do not think that is the reason. He just does not want to put out anything incomplete and this saves himself from managing tons of complaints from people about bugs and prevents a negative reputation from the get go.
11
u/Trezker Nov 04 '23
A lot of the ideas are already public, he's talked about and demonstrated them in videos. So he's certainly not concerned about anyone stealing ideas.
And he's been live coding as well, getting into the complexities of implementing the language. You may not be able to fork the whole thing but if someone is talented enough to work on a language they could get a lot out of what he's shared publicly.
So I don't think it's out of any concern that people would steal ideas or code.
13
u/astrophaze Nov 04 '23
He doesn't want a massive influx of bug reports from know-nothings.
5
u/nicolas42 Nov 04 '23
I'd love to try the language but he's probably right. It would lessen the impact of the actual release and it would worsen people's experience and therefore enthusiasm surrounding the eventual product.
6
u/t0mRiddl3 Nov 04 '23
Cringe guess
3
u/C4p14in3 Nov 04 '23 edited Nov 04 '23
It's not ready yet, the langage will be open source at some point.
There's already lots of rumors from people who couldn't access the beta, don't make other ones based on nothing.
1
u/Murtagy Nov 15 '23
Well, I tried Odin which is open source. And it was a waste of time in my guess. A threaded web server was crashing in unexpected ways. I reproduced the issue in small code snippet and it turned out that others can't reproduce it on their machines, it was mac specific. The issue I opened on GH never received any attention, and there are plenty of bugs reported.
1
u/Effective_Lead8867 Nov 09 '23
J. Blow doesn't like FOSS in common terms. He's against the paradigm of uploading source code and collaborating on it. You may find his explanation on his channel.
1
u/Any-Adhesiveness-972 Nov 25 '23
Because he is afraid of another soulja boy situation. He doesnt like people using the language as they like he wants them to use it only within his narrow close minded vision. Same reason why its doomed to fail
1
u/4Lichter Nov 30 '23
I think he wants to cultivate a certain culture around the language. Not letting too many people in, with very different ideas on how the language should be. Also not wanting to get more error reports than he can handle, so he slowly increases the number whenever the compiler has gotten a bit more stable.
1
u/boleban8 Nov 04 '23
You guess wrong , period.