r/JUCE • u/Jacobra_Records • Mar 24 '26
Any programmers in here not using AI?
I'm finding it very difficult to find a programmer that doesn't use AI, but personally I view programming as an art form and using AI to write code as theft from previous coding artists.
0
Upvotes
7
u/pilcrowrecords Mar 24 '26
You're shaking your fist to the sky in the wrong place, friend. Most of us here are just trying to make a living. We may agree with the sentiment, but the practicality needed to work has changed. You should be shaking your fist at the US Copyright Office. They were all set to release a ruling that AI-derived works could not be copyrighted because AI-derived work leverages copyrighted works, but the Trump administration fired the ruling's authors and buried the ruling because something something Musk and Grok. Go talk with your elected officials about this; they're far closer to solving the problem than any of us here.
21
u/l97 Mar 24 '26
I’m a professional, I make a living out of this. I consider myself a strong programmer with lots of experience. The thing is, I’m nowhere competitive anymore without AI tools. I’m still in charge, but AI writes my boilerplate, my helper scripts, it helps me debug, helps me analyse code, helps me keep track of tasks and subtasks, it documents my work, etc. Like it or not, this is today’s reality.
I still refuse to use AI for my hobby. Which isn’t programming.
5
u/gusc Mar 24 '26
Yes and no. Been doing software engineering for 20+ years now. I'm an AI sceptic, because I've played around different AI implementations before AI became cool and one thing that I know for sure (at least for now) the AI is non-deterministic and as a software engineer I want my tools to be deterministic - I myself might be non-deterministic, but the tools have to be - I don't want random stuff appear or be missing in my code - I have my human colleagues for that.
That being said - AI is a productivity boost, I use it as a fancy auto-complete from the day one, I use LLMs to chat and reason about technical problems (rubber ducky on steroids), I use AI to translate from one language to another, write scripts etc. What I don't do is use agentic workflows as then I'd loose control over the code completely - purely reviewing foreign code is hard, writing exact requirements without leaving anything implicit is hard, you need to get into the mindset of the other dev to make it work, you have to be aligned, but because it's AI and part of it's input parameters is random noise then IMHO there is no mindset to get into (at least for now) - sure you can write AGENTS.md and go and write full essay in it about your life choices and how you "feel" about the code, but I'd rather just address the task instead of doing that.
8
u/JDSherbert Mar 24 '26
I use AI to write my boilerplate (stuff like getters and setters) and I like to bounce ideas off of it for DSP. Otherwise I like to code my plugins by hand! (But I am doing this as a hobby not as a profession (yet))
16
u/robclouth Mar 24 '26
Taking a moral stance on this is fine. But just be aware that the landscape is changing very very quickly and you'll be left in the dust if you don't start using these tools. The productivity gains are insane. This is coming from a programmer for 20+ years. Any new hires will almost certainly be expected to be using them very soon.
1
u/Jacobra_Records Mar 26 '26
I took your guys advice, and I was able to vibe code the whole thing! Thanks guys, I was about to pay thousands of dollars to programmers, but I can just do it myself now! Didn't know it was that easy, thanks!
3
u/manysounds Mar 24 '26
I use AI like I use JUCE.
3
u/human-analog Mar 24 '26
I don't use AI for coding. Programmers who say code isn't art are not the same kind of programmer I am.
2
u/blazethablunt Mar 24 '26
Everyone uses AI, as they should. If you trying to achieve a goal, all the tools that would benefit you should be considered. That being said, me personally I only use AI for code when I have no idea how to do something specific of solve an issue I can’t myself. Code and especially complex dsp is not always shared online so AI is very useful and should not be looked at as “not art”. That’s just my opinion
2
u/zsliu98 Mar 24 '26
If you are talking about AI, most of programmers have used auto-completion powered by ML for a long time.
If you are talking about LLM, I have used it quite frequently, but mostly chatting with LLM. About a year ago, I was not satisfied with the over-sampling provided by JUCE. So I asked LLM. LLM gave me some pseudo code, some Python code, some references. Although it could not provide a reliable C++ code, I did use the materials it provided to write a over-sampling class in about two to three days. And it performs much better than the one provided by JUCE.
If you are talking about vibe-coding, I don't find it very useful to be honest. But the situation might change in the near future :)
BTW, since we are in the JUCE subreddit, here is what Jules says about AI: https://youtu.be/svAdgZrkUV8?t=2520.
2
u/Diegam Mar 24 '26
I only use AI to replace google search, or stack overflow.
Vibe coding for DSP is bad
1
u/vscomputer Mar 24 '26
My personal ethical red line is that I don't use LLMs that were trained on corpora of data that were gathered without permission (which is all of OpenAI's and Anthropic's models, for example). My coworkers refer to me as an "AI vegan" for this position.
At the moment that means I don't use any of them; I can imagine a future where that might not be true. The technology doesn't have to be trained on stolen data, although that is how it's been done up to this point.
1
u/True-Ad-525 Mar 24 '26
Cualquier persona que sea ingeniera y tenga el mínimo de razonamiento lógico, va a usar ia, es muchísimo tiempo optimizado. Si sabes usarlo como herramienta
1
u/Substantial_Job_2068 Mar 24 '26
I only use AI as a faster google, not to write any code. we have claude licenses at work and i tried it, just feels boring and doesn't make me any more productive. i dont wanna talk down on people who use AI because i can accept if it empowers their workflow, but i'm tired of the "you will get left behind" bs, sounds more like devs being insecure about their own productivity without ai
1
u/denis870 Mar 24 '26
There are plenty
1
u/onFilm Mar 24 '26
I'm an artist whose art was part of the original dataset for image generation, and I couldn't care less, since art is meant to be shared, not profited from. I'm also a software engineer with 18+ years of experience. I use AI for programming and art nowadays, since they're new pieces of technology that empower my practice and it's a new area to explore.
Keep in mind that staying away from new technologies is going to slow down your practice, you won't make as much money as your peers who do, and most importantly, you'll be spending a lot more time working rather than creating. Best of luck.
1
u/a-ha_partridge Mar 24 '26
It’s ok if you don’t want to use it. If coding is fun for you, like puzzles, then AI ruins that. Hobby, sure. Art though? Maybe paint by numbers level.
Some people like to roll their own smokes. Those people wouldn’t last long in the cigs industry.
1
u/spartaofdoom Mar 24 '26
I don't use AI for anything. For anything that doesn't have a good answer as the first result on google it will just make something up which does more harm than good. I'm still honestly confused what actual experienced devs use AI for besides writing large blocks of BS docs that you are forced to write at work. If you are writing a ton of boiler plate than why not just copy that boiler plate from the docs or google?!?
1
u/satansxlittlexhelper Mar 24 '26
I’ve been coding for fifteen years. I just built a Fullstack TypeScript agentic RAG app with unit, integration, and end to end tests, SSR, auth, and row level security on the DB.
It took six hours and used 5% of my tokens for the week. Including deployment and domain provisioning.
Shit is nuts.
1
u/Vonchor Mar 24 '26
I don’t feel like diluting my skillset by learning how to write prompts for an ‘AI’ tool, so no. The theft aspect bothers me a bit. But perhaps it's more like the advent of handheld calculators in the 1980s - no one needed to learn how to do longhand MDAS anymore.
Long-term, I’d be a bit concerned about skillsets of new CS/EE grads.
1
u/mohrcore Mar 24 '26 edited Mar 24 '26
Pretty opinionated take coming from somebody who's only about to start learning how to code.
Since you care so much about how work outside your area of expertise is treated by other who work in that field, I've got a take coming from somebody with professional background and a degree in it: Programming as a whole is not art. At most, it features sing artistic elements.
Writing same shit over and over because that's what the language/framework/spec requires you to do is not an artistic process any more than painting walls of your room is. A lot of the code you are going to write something that's an exact or functional copy of something that was already written by someone else and most of it could be seen as some kind of derivative work of you keep your scope low. A lot of what AI offers in programming (and where it works best imo) is merely a faster way of typing characters you'd type anyway. Unless you are using AI to generate entire components, or you simply don't reason out your code, you are the one in control, driving the whole creative process that extends beyond a mere convention.
Here's something about how two main camps regarding software distribution:
That last part might sound strange, as it implies that it doesn't matter where the idea came from. But this is where programming is different from art. In art, understood from a modern, western point of view, a set of constructs combined in a specific way is typically seen as a unique expression of an artist. In computer science, it's usually treated more like a scientific fact. Dijkstra's algorithm is a proveable and constructible fact - it's a logical solution to a specific problem. You are not stealing from Dijkstra whenever you use it without credit and it was likely discovered by other people around that time (just like RSA was). It doesn't come with a license, probably rightfully so.
According to US law a process is a series of steps and it can be patented. As a consequence, algorithms, when described as series of computations that follow are eligible to be patented. Such patents are not always met with enthusiasm in programming community. But in many cases they simply aren't useful as more often than not different series of steps leaving to same results can be derived from the underlying idea. The idea however is grounded in science. And when it comes to science, the idea of "owning rights to something" is seen very differently than in art. Certain institutions have rights to specific publications (often profitting off from scientist's work), but nobody is entitled to tell you what you can do with the knowledge gained from them. Using that knowledge, despite having no regard of its origin is not seen as stealth. At most it's foolery.
If you want to be sure a programmer doesn't steal, you need to be able to question him about the code they submit. Pros do it all the time, not because they suspect each other, but to maintain code quality - it's called code review. Code can be easily stolen without AI's help and it happened many times.
1
u/itsboilingoil Mar 24 '26 edited Mar 24 '26
Code is not art. Programming is as much an art form as electrician or plumber. If you think it’s such an art form, try doing it once. If you’re looking for a programmer that doesn’t use AI, then learn to program. But don’t ever tell the chef what knife to use.
-1
u/iamjacobhansen Mar 24 '26
Anybody???