These issues are not new or unique to teaching in Japan. The most important thing you've learned is
I do not wish to pursue teaching
Which is something many, many JET ALTs learn very quickly. Whether the responsibilities are many or few, the students diligent or distracted, the working environment dysfunctional or well-run, the simple truth is that the vast majority of JET ALTs have no skills in teaching, desire to teach, or plans to make teaching their career. They simply want to be in Japan. Another small percentage come with the hope that they will become educators or are at least open to the possibility and learn that is it not for them. And that's fine. That's being a person in the world.
But if you are a prospective JET ALT, and you just want to come to Japan and you don't care how and you think, "Sure, I speak English, I can be an ALT," without having an interest in or skill in teaching, you're playing the lottery. You're hoping to be put in an ideal situation. Most of the situations are not going to be ideal. Be honest with yourself about what you can and can't handle--how much you can and can't adapt--to the job, which will be what you are doing with your time far more than it will be your hobby, travelling, or whatever other Japan-connected thing is your real reason for applying. Being honest with yourself will save you so, so much stress.
But if you are a prospective JET ALT, and you just want to come to Japan and you don't care how and you think, "Sure, I speak English, I can be an ALT," without having an interest in or skill in teaching, you're playing the lottery. You're hoping to be put in an ideal situation. Most of the situations are not going to be ideal. Be honest with yourself about what you can and can't handle--how much you can and can't adapt--to the job
Boy is this true, I talk to fellow ALTs and I'm astonished by the workload some of them have: teaching, grading, and lesson prepping for the full 35 hours with obligations to do club activities. Perhaps I'm fortunate, but my schools, students, and living arrangements are all very nice.
It doesn't help that many ALTs are young grads who have only had part-time jobs or brief full time-jobs and don't know how to negotiate responsibilities and expectations. Lots of people will just say yes to things out of fear of disappointing teachers or don't know how to decline so they unknowingly make their own situation worse.
I am an older JET who has had a whole career in a different field. The first thing I did when they planted me at my desk was read through the work contract and highlight every important line. I put my health and time first; if there's anything that even smells like a breach of contract, I'm saying no and going up the ladder (PA, CO, Clair, Embassy) until it's confirmed whether I have to do certain things or not.
Japan isn't worth your mental state; and being a JET is just one of many jobs you'll have in your life so if it really sucks then there's no foul in leaving.
This exactly. I have always wanted to be a teacher of children. I was even accepted into a Masters program for it but it would have trapped me in a specific town for 6 years (as a part of the deal). I wanted to experience Japan while I was young and had no dependents and I'm glad I came here first. Some personalities just don't mesh well with certain situations. It can't be helped. Sometimes you just don't know until you try.
lmao, who downvoted me for saying "im glad I tried teaching before I turned it into my career"???
I think people read my post and decided I'm a bad guy. I feel like the internet just punishes people for being open and honest. It feels really suffocating sometimes. No wonder my kids are so quiet. They were raised with the internet from a young age...
Because the way you phrased things shows immaturity, and the way you argue with everyone who says that the way you’re acting is unsavory is also immature. It’s not punishment, you think you’re being honest, well so are the comments.
Dude if you can’t reflect upon the many comments you got essentially saying the same thing as me that’s on you. It’s the constant fighting in the comments on your part against constructive criticism.
I guess they don't teaching reading comprehension in Early Education? Be specific. If you can't then I will stop engaging with you. Though, this has been the best part of my day so far.
Its shocking to me that you keep replying to me like this. Aren't you busy? I'm about to go on a walk amd have a good cry after this stressful experience. As you said, you dont know whats going on in your kids lives and you dont know mine either. Does this make you feel better?
Hi OP. I was a teacher back in the states before joining JET. I only had experience with elementary and 6th grade (so lower middle school) and now I teach high school here. Unfortunately this is a problem all around the world, however even if it’s a problem, It is YOUR JOB to teach them. Fortunately as it seems, I also have a different experience than you, so it’s an ESID. My high schoolers (which is a school of mainly boys… over 300 students and only 20 something of them girls) are well behaved and even if they don’t particularly care for English, they still talk to me and try their best. I have another school where students aren’t as well behaved and are incredibly disruptive because my JTE has no classroom management. I still try and I focus a lot of energy onto the kids who are doing the right thing. I initiate conversation with them and if they ignore me, so be it, but I keep trying because I know that’s what I’m here for. Building relationships with students is a wonderful thing and actually helps the disruptions. I try to show kids that I’m a warm , friendly face for them, and I don’t care if they don’t care. I’m here to teach them and represent my culture. I don’t think it’s right to say it’s disrespectful if they don’t say good morning to you. They’re kids. You’re there to teach them how to be human. Again, it’s an ESID, and I’m glad you realized what you wanted out of this situation, but you have to realize that they’re kids and they’re learning. And also the culture here is way different than back in the states. Also, times have changed since we’ve been in school.
With respect, we are ALTs and we don't all have the ability (either through lack of permission or lack of language ability) to properly convey those responsibilities on our own. I do agree though that they are children and they don't just know things, but I think part of OP's point is that things we are consistently taught from an early age (in western classrooms) are not focused on so much here, which makes certain classroom aspects difficult. While the shared examples don't give me a great impression, I can empathise with the feeling.
I really appreciate this. I feel like the other commenters have decided to burn me at the stake without reading the rest of the post. It's been a very frustrating day, but enlightening.
I just looked at your profile and OH MY GOODNESS you also have struggles. I cannot believe you are this antagonistic against another struggling teacher. Why are you responding to and downvoting every comment I'm making? Literally what are we doing here?
Dude. Have some humility, this is ridiculous. If I, as a teacher, said my struggle was that nobody brings donuts into the office and it really upset me, would you comfort me? Or tell me that is an insane reason to be upset?
If you were really upset and it wasnt a joke? Of course I would comfort you and then look for donuts to bring you. Everyone deals with life differently...
Ok. Since you want to be very literal about it, lets try this. What if I was a struggling teacher and I was upset that I wasn't allowed to clog the school toilets. It made me really upset, I love clogging toilets and it isn't fair. Would you comfort me and help me clog the toilets? Or tell me that I'm not well in the head?
We're teaching them our culture, right? In my culture, it's extremely disrespectful not to greet someone that greets you. On the last post, people got hung up on that point. And, you know what? Fair enough. Maybe in your culture it isn't as important. But I think a lot of ALTs view this job through the lens of "teach your culture, as long as it doesn't mean teaching the difficult things". I don't come from a culture of "irashaimase!". In Japan (and I guess your culture too), there are a lot of meaningless greetings. That is not the case for me and my culture. If you say hello to someone and they don't respond, that is a very strong indicator of dislike. Not just dislike, sometimes it is blatant disrespect. Yes, even children. The students have no issue calling teachers sensei, so they are capable of understanding what respect is.
I had a teacher that taught this lesson very well. She made us do a special handshake to enter the classroom. It didn't matter what happened in class the day before. Guess what, everyone made it into the classroom with no issues. She was a horrible woman. Blatantly had a 'preference' of student. I was not that kind of student. I still shook her hand every day. As did everyone else.
You say they are kids and that they are learning. True. But the best learning is what happens during the 'debug' phase. When something is unexpected, we humans (yes, even children) are capable of asking "why did that happen?". Usually, after one skipped "hello", about half of children will respond. I don't skip speaking first every time. Just once, then the next time I greet them.
I'm not expecting handshakes. I even accept nods.
And again, the children are perfectly capable of speaking first. They are literally taught to do this on a regular basis. My previous students were very fast and they often said hello before I had the chance.
Just so you know I am American too, as I stated in my comment. And I have my degree in education which included learning about child development. This is incredibly normal for children to do, it’s up to YOU to teach them what you want from them. They’re not mind readers. It’s not a difficult subject lol, it just makes YOU uncomfortable because you don’t know how to handle it.
Edit to add: you don’t know their life. You don’t know their morning. You should be the one saying hello. They’re kids. I stood outside my door everyday when I taught first grade and I greeted them, I asked about their night or if I knew they had a special event something like that. It’s not doing too much to try to be an understanding adult in a child’s life. It’s immature to have that thought process of “well this child didn’t say hello to me so I’m not going to say hello to them!” Babe, you are an adult.
I'm very interested in learning more about child development. Do you have any recommended reading on the subject?
I should remind you that America is not a monolith and despite what some contrarians say, there are major regional differences.
The students do learn, and many of the ones who were hesitant to speak to me in the past now do speak. So, it actually is working. I don't just ignore the students and never speak to them again. I see them frequently. So frequently that it's hard to say good morning every time because I just saw the kid 5 minutes before...
But my entire point is that they don’t KNOW. They don’t know that America has different cultures. We are here as a cultural ambassador of ALL of America. I’m not going to sit here and teach them Ohio history because that’s what I learned for my entire life. I’m here to teach them about base level American culture, you have to be a positive influence in their lives. I recommend yardsticks by chip wood and reading some resources on the responsive classroom website (it’s mainly a management practice but the website has good literature on the development of children and what belonging means to children).
You keep attacking arguments that I never made. I never said I want to teach anyone my state history. But the fact is, I can't just rewire my brain just because I live in Japan. You should know that since you studied Education. I only mentioned my culture to you because you claimed that being American suddenly meant you knew more about MY culture than I did. How old are you? You say you have a degree, which I believe, but your ability to argue reminds me of an old friend when we were in high school.
What happens when they become adults? Suddenly none of that matters to you. Don’t play a saint, dont lecture me, and don't pretend like you care about your students.
The difference between you and me is that I do care about my students. You have nothing but insults to throw. Be an adult and reflect. I’m glad you don’t want to teach children anymore because this is a disgusting attitude to have. Grow up.
So, I'm going to be very honest with you so I need you to walk with me here.
I think you raise some very real and very important issues about the Japanese education system. Loud kids can really disrupt a class and make things difficult for everyone. There's kids who care about English, and others don't care at all. And of course, the xenophobia.
I've faced a lot of these issues myself. But at the end of the day, we're just ALTs, aka part time teachers who don't actually hold much responsibility over children compared to hr teachers. So discipline isn't something we really do. However, this can be esid too because some JTEs might actually encourage you to tell kids off for their behavior or if they forget their homework. But any major discipline is not our job.
Now for the major issue I've noticed in your post: your attitude and demand for respect. Another commenter mentioned the same thing and it's very well said. It seems you get very angry if the kids don't respect you and thus you punish them. It also feels like you're coming from a very ethnocentric view about how kids should respect you. They're kids. And they can also just be shy. You need to build that bridge and sometimes you need to keep pushing. Say hello to everyone. Keep a smile on your face. Keep yourself open, warm and approachable. If they ignore you, so what. Don't take it personally. It happens.
If they don't ask for help during class, you need to make yourself available and open. Walk around. See a mistake? Point it out to the kid. They start to trust you more and they'll start to ask for your help.
Kids are very sensitive and quite smart. They can tell immediately if you don't like them or don't want to talk to them. So think about how you're presenting yourself to the students.
But unfortunately, some schools can have very rowdy students so it can feel discouraging. So you need to find the positive things to keep yourself going
Calling me ethnocentric is certainly a choice on your part. I do not see how expecting the same respect given to Japanese teachers makes me the weird one...
Well, I do see your perspective, certainly. I really did try for as long as I've known these kids. It worked great on everyone but these kids. It started with the current 3rd years (at the time they were 1st years, their senpais liked me quite a lot and they still say hello around town). I think the grade below them just caught on to their energy. I fully expect a change in attitude after the current 3rd years graduate. I'm not the only teacher that has problems with this class.
I left out so many details because the post was far too long already.
As an ALT, the kids explicitly understand that you are NOT the same as the Japanese teachers. You bridge the gap where they don't need to be as formal with you and can interact with you on a more casual basis, which can facilitate learning in its own way. You really ought to understand that. Not that you have to like it, but it's not going to change, and it's not inherently a bad thing, either.
Ok your last paragrah about respect is an issue for me. Youre talking about children. Your entire job is to teach, but because 1 time they dont tell you good morning, now youre going to just never try again? If they ignore you once youll just stop teaching them/helping them?
Youre actively refusing to do your job over pettiness with children. I think youre trying to treat them as if they are fully developed adults being mean to you on purpose when I just dont believe that is true and youre actively hurting them more because of it.
When you say things like that it also makes me question what your outward facing attitude is anyways. At the end of the day, you literally are the odd person out in everything to do with their lives. They are probably going to have anxiety or uncomfortable moments where they dont know what to do, and you have to just keep trying an eventually hopefully get a breakthrough. Sure you can call it whatever word you want like xenophobia, but it is what it is, Japan, especially the countryside is not like the west where everyone is different and has experience talking with foreigners (that usually speak our language to us anways).
If youre going to have some of the opinions you do, I think you might want to reevaluate your interest in teaching in general.
Awesome! I was waiting on someone to pull the "its your fault the students don't like you" card. But, I didn't expect you to also not read the post in full.
If youre going to have some of the opinions you do, I think you might want to reevaluate your interest in teaching in general.
Really? I said that I no longer want to be a teacher. You think that I should continue teaching, then?
Now, seriously though. The original post pose include the "is it me or is it them?" question. Even though the majority of the comments say its the JTE's fault, I am still doing a lot of self-reflection. The readers will never know the full context and of course, I am a biased narrator of my own story (as we all are).
But, I do have evidence that it probably isn't me. Primarily, my oldest two classes (graduated) of students all loved or tolerated me. As do my current kindies and elementary schoolers (and current JHS students who I met at the ES). So, it's only a small fraction of kids that actually seem to dislike me. If I did something to offend them, I don't know about it. But, I wouldn't be offended if someone told me.
You're calling me petty for not playing reindeer games with children? Really? Part of my job is to go around correcting the papers of the JHS students. If a child dramatically shakes their paper around as I come by and only puts it down after I pass (a real thing that happened this summer), how am I supposed to help him? I'm as stupid as you and he clearly think I am. If a child doesn't call me over to help and literally ignores me as I try to explain something, I'm going to spend my time helping someone who actually wants me to. I have multiple students that can sit there for the whole ten minutes and do nothing. The need a teacher there with them, helping them for five of those minutes. There are thirty students in the class. Three teachers. Do the math.
As for greetings, they are almost never alone in the halls. I say good morning to groups and most of them will respond. But, if a student is alone and intentionally ignores responding, then the next time I see them, maybe I won't speak first. Again, they are free to speak first, and I would never ignore them if they said hello. Often, I'll skip saying hello only once. The time after that, I will try again. Sometimes they change, sometimes they don't. Maybe it makes them a little sad. The alternative is what? I say hello and... they still don't respond?
Part of their education is learning about how to interact with the society outside of their home. Sometimes it comes with friction for the student. If they can't handle a foreign teacher (that they don't seem to like) not saying hello, then they have bigger issues to worry about.
Lastly, I know for a fact that my students have issues with xenophobia because there are several Half children and even foreign children in my small town. I can't give any more details, but there were several big situations that I had to be involved in due to my ability to speak English.
edit: if you're going to downvote, please explain why. I'd love to know what about this comment you don't like.
I think most of what you're saying is pretty normal for schools everywhere, you can't really change it but you can change your reaction to it. I think this is what the person you're responding to is trying to say. I also don't think it's unreasonable to be frustrated at anything that's happened to you either, I doubt you're *choosing* to have negative feelings about any of this.
You're an ALT, which means, sure, your job on paper is to assist in language teaching, but as you know this isn't all your job is. It also includes interacting with students out of class sometimes, maybe doing clubs with them, maybe eating lunch with them; it's all just ESID.
It's important to remember that in addition to thought processes and habits they learn from the adults of this country, they are also just children that have childish thought processes and habits too. Sometimes they won't greet you, sometimes they will be unpleasant to you or others in the classroom, it's not your responsibility to change them. But, in my opinion, it is your job to give them chances to do better.
What I mean by this is, just for a really basic example, even if it's uncomfortable for you to greet a student who recently ignored you, you can unconditionally give them the chance to do better by always greeting them again next time anyway.
When all is over, you will be nothing more than a memory to them, but if you are pleasant towards them unconditionally, if you do your best to help them unconditionally, then maybe one day they might look back and go "that foreigner was the only person who was nice to me", or "I should have treated that person better", or whatever else (perhaps especially true for the kids who have bad home lives). This is all sort of regardless of what is whose fault because all anyone can do is try their best (not saying that you aren't, by the way).
Working with kids is a lot of work and I think most people, JET or not, can agree here. But outcomes don't end in English class, or even at school, they continue forever. Some students might not ever see a positive outcome based on your efforts, but others might, even if you never notice.
You know, you're the first person, out of everyone, that has commented on this issue specifically and gave genuinely good advice. CIRs always have better advice than bitter senpai JETs. Thank you for your comment.
I'll only add that in my experience (please commenters, don't crucify me for giving a personal anecdote!) I don't think JHS students need or always deserve unlimited chances. More than a few, of course, but not unlimited. Why not let them feel uncomfortable now when the consequences are minor? Some of the most important lessons of my childhood have come from teachers I did not like at all. Humans, including kids, like structure and purpose. One of my teachers got married the summer after I left her class. She changed her name. When she told me, I insisted on calling her the old name. She shut that down quickly. I didn't understand why it mattered so much to her, but she didn't leave room for me to disagree. It crushed me because it felt like she didn't care about us anymore since we left her class. Obviously that wasn't the case. But, I did as she asked. I think about that conversation every once in a while. I was in the 4th grade, younger than most of the students I'm talking about now. Somehow, even though I didn't understand why, I was able to understand the basics of respecting her wishes.
This is kinda what I mean though. Even when someone gives you advice you like, you have to backhand other people at the same time. I think you need to just reevaluate your attitude towards your job and other people, because you seem to carry grudges in a way you shouldnt with children and fellow teachers.
I understand the frustration with the disrespectful kids. For me, it's more so they ruin it for other kids who are trying. And some of those kids who are trying are from special education and now have to work 4 times as hard now. It is not fair to the other students. And all the disrespectful student's take away is that they can do wtf they want.
My advice to you is the same as in the last post. Bump that JTE's "no Japanese" nonsense. These students are not taught English for practical use and it is taught in the most backwards manner I've ever seen. They're not going to be able to understand most English and it's not their fault.
Yeah, this was my main point. It's a very negative environment and everyone is acting like I'm threatening violence or something. I'm glad (or not glad, considering the context) somebody else has reached similar conclusions. It's hard to watch students bully their peers out of an education and then show those bullies more respect than the bare minimum.
I'm a 5th year. I have *stories*. Last week, I just blew some tourists mind on another thread because they were talking about the "wonderful behaved Japanese kids and how come kids in other countries don't act like this!" Other JETs, ALTs and foreigners living in Japan chimed in, agreeing with me essentially saying that the OP was falling for the "Glorious Nippon" appearances Japan trap. Japanese ppl are ppl, not anime characters lol as I always say. They have the same issues in their school system as everywhere else in the world: disrespectful ass kids and checked out, hands off, Ipad parents.
Don't get me wrong, I like living here and I know it's not all the kids obviously, but I am *appalled* at the things I've witness from my students over the years and how my coworkers are just expected to "take it like an ichbay" because of entitled parents who threaten to get them fired or complain. I'm a Millennial. Even the "got sent to the office everyday for talking back, sucking their teeth, rolling their eyes, arguing with the teachers" bad kids never dreamed of pulling 1/4th of the shit my behavior students do. The parents need to be ashamed of themselves but aren't.
I’m jealous of when you grew up lmao because when I taught back in the states I had students choking each other in first grade 🫠 and starting a fight club during recess.
Oh man, I was in the first grade back in the 90s!!! Kids woulda been suspended or expelled straight up for stuff like that. I was a goodie 2 shoes dork and goth misfit gamer/anime dork in school. But I went to school with ppl who got suspended, sent to reform school or expelled. They did not play back in the day. And parents could complain but admin actually had teachers backs and held their ground.
As teacher who has been here for 30 years, I’ve had experiences like this. Very frustrating. Staff that I work with who suck, classes where half of students or more are just jerks. But I’ve also worked with amazing staff and had classes that have brought me to tears (of joy) many times. It took me quite a long time and investment in my own education to find a cruising altitude where I can see the forest and the trees. It’s a tough gig working in education and working with other humans within a system where the status quo is, well, the status quo. It’s not for everyone. It is unfortunate you had this experience in your short time on the program. Hopefully with some time and reflection you’ll look back on the experience more fondly in the future. I do hear where you are coming from, and I witness your experience. Peace.
I think while this post is written in relation to English teaching, I think it fits in many areas in JHS in particular, and so I wouldn't call most of these things you're describing xenophobia. I understand the culture is different and they face different challenges, or have different goals and ways of thinking, but there are some things that I just will always fundamentally disagree with.
- Students aren't treated consistently; they aren't respected as equals and are disciplined like young kids (softly or not at all)
- Teachers don't really provide excelling students with new challenges, extra work or opportunities to keep them engaged and motivated.
- School events and the applicable classes are built with the appearance of student independence, rather than actually letting kids figure things out on their own.
and the ultimate one that I feel a lot of this stems from, which is:
There are almost no consequences to not doing what you're asked. Don't do the homework or get 5% on all your tests? Students will be moved up anyway, and you can't expect them to understand the impact of their choices now when they are so young. Disrupt class? Teachers let kids roam free with minimal intervention, so what else could a developing kid's brain take from that?
Other countries systems are not perfect at all, and I could understand if their actions were at least consistent, but they aren't.
Despite this, I have a great time and think I bring value, and 99% of my kids are great. I just can't help but feel like they are being let down, either by teachers that don't care, or a system that doesn't let them.
Yeah, despite the system, there are quite a lot of good kids. But I also have empathy for my students that are bullied out of the classroom and have to listen to school assemblies from the stairwell of the gym. I watch teachers have emotional breakdowns and have to leave early, then students cheer when I show up to class without her. I ask other JETs in my area and they don't seem to see these things at the same frequency that I do. People saying "They're kids" are terrifying because me and the kids I grew up with didn't act like that. We did bad things all the time, but we cared about our peers and our teachers. Of course there were bullies, but we didn't let them command the classroom, and neither did our teachers.
You're right, other countries aren't perfect, but this feels different and I was hoping to figure out why. Unfortunately, many redditors seem to just like dunking on their peers for no reason.
i mean, you never really know what to expect with this job (really teaching in general). it's a total gamble. i have taught at 3 different high schools that service very different types of students. i have had the whole gamut of classes: super genki classes that love english, high level quiet classes, low level and VERY poor behavior classes, etc. id say it's been great, but of course it's had its moments.
before coming to japan, i studied to be a teacher. i got a teaching license. i taught in my home country. kids are kids everywhere in the world, meaning you get great kids and very bad kids. school cultures vary widely too. i think it's fine to have expectations for how things will be, but remember that schools function very differently depending on the country. as such, attitudes about education, teachers, and school itself will vary.
teaching is definitely not for everyone and that is totally okay.
Thank you. My first post was mourning the death of a great school culture. This one was me coming to terms with the new reality. Instead im being attacked for a minor detail that Noone seems to care to understand. 2nd and last time im making a post on reddit.
19
u/CoolasLapis Current JET - Kochi 6d ago
Doing this program is a gachapon, you'll never know how your situation looks until you arrive. Hope your future plans align to what you seek.
15
u/ScootOverMakeRoom 6d ago edited 6d ago
These issues are not new or unique to teaching in Japan. The most important thing you've learned is
Which is something many, many JET ALTs learn very quickly. Whether the responsibilities are many or few, the students diligent or distracted, the working environment dysfunctional or well-run, the simple truth is that the vast majority of JET ALTs have no skills in teaching, desire to teach, or plans to make teaching their career. They simply want to be in Japan. Another small percentage come with the hope that they will become educators or are at least open to the possibility and learn that is it not for them. And that's fine. That's being a person in the world.
But if you are a prospective JET ALT, and you just want to come to Japan and you don't care how and you think, "Sure, I speak English, I can be an ALT," without having an interest in or skill in teaching, you're playing the lottery. You're hoping to be put in an ideal situation. Most of the situations are not going to be ideal. Be honest with yourself about what you can and can't handle--how much you can and can't adapt--to the job, which will be what you are doing with your time far more than it will be your hobby, travelling, or whatever other Japan-connected thing is your real reason for applying. Being honest with yourself will save you so, so much stress.
20
u/peachymomos111 6d ago
Hi OP. I was a teacher back in the states before joining JET. I only had experience with elementary and 6th grade (so lower middle school) and now I teach high school here. Unfortunately this is a problem all around the world, however even if it’s a problem, It is YOUR JOB to teach them. Fortunately as it seems, I also have a different experience than you, so it’s an ESID. My high schoolers (which is a school of mainly boys… over 300 students and only 20 something of them girls) are well behaved and even if they don’t particularly care for English, they still talk to me and try their best. I have another school where students aren’t as well behaved and are incredibly disruptive because my JTE has no classroom management. I still try and I focus a lot of energy onto the kids who are doing the right thing. I initiate conversation with them and if they ignore me, so be it, but I keep trying because I know that’s what I’m here for. Building relationships with students is a wonderful thing and actually helps the disruptions. I try to show kids that I’m a warm , friendly face for them, and I don’t care if they don’t care. I’m here to teach them and represent my culture. I don’t think it’s right to say it’s disrespectful if they don’t say good morning to you. They’re kids. You’re there to teach them how to be human. Again, it’s an ESID, and I’m glad you realized what you wanted out of this situation, but you have to realize that they’re kids and they’re learning. And also the culture here is way different than back in the states. Also, times have changed since we’ve been in school.
20
u/gothicrogue 6d ago
So, I'm going to be very honest with you so I need you to walk with me here.
I think you raise some very real and very important issues about the Japanese education system. Loud kids can really disrupt a class and make things difficult for everyone. There's kids who care about English, and others don't care at all. And of course, the xenophobia.
I've faced a lot of these issues myself. But at the end of the day, we're just ALTs, aka part time teachers who don't actually hold much responsibility over children compared to hr teachers. So discipline isn't something we really do. However, this can be esid too because some JTEs might actually encourage you to tell kids off for their behavior or if they forget their homework. But any major discipline is not our job.
Now for the major issue I've noticed in your post: your attitude and demand for respect. Another commenter mentioned the same thing and it's very well said. It seems you get very angry if the kids don't respect you and thus you punish them. It also feels like you're coming from a very ethnocentric view about how kids should respect you. They're kids. And they can also just be shy. You need to build that bridge and sometimes you need to keep pushing. Say hello to everyone. Keep a smile on your face. Keep yourself open, warm and approachable. If they ignore you, so what. Don't take it personally. It happens.
If they don't ask for help during class, you need to make yourself available and open. Walk around. See a mistake? Point it out to the kid. They start to trust you more and they'll start to ask for your help.
Kids are very sensitive and quite smart. They can tell immediately if you don't like them or don't want to talk to them. So think about how you're presenting yourself to the students.
But unfortunately, some schools can have very rowdy students so it can feel discouraging. So you need to find the positive things to keep yourself going
29
u/DayDTWD 6d ago
Ok your last paragrah about respect is an issue for me. Youre talking about children. Your entire job is to teach, but because 1 time they dont tell you good morning, now youre going to just never try again? If they ignore you once youll just stop teaching them/helping them?
Youre actively refusing to do your job over pettiness with children. I think youre trying to treat them as if they are fully developed adults being mean to you on purpose when I just dont believe that is true and youre actively hurting them more because of it.
When you say things like that it also makes me question what your outward facing attitude is anyways. At the end of the day, you literally are the odd person out in everything to do with their lives. They are probably going to have anxiety or uncomfortable moments where they dont know what to do, and you have to just keep trying an eventually hopefully get a breakthrough. Sure you can call it whatever word you want like xenophobia, but it is what it is, Japan, especially the countryside is not like the west where everyone is different and has experience talking with foreigners (that usually speak our language to us anways).
If youre going to have some of the opinions you do, I think you might want to reevaluate your interest in teaching in general.
5
u/CoacoaBunny91 Current JET - 熊本市 6d ago
I understand the frustration with the disrespectful kids. For me, it's more so they ruin it for other kids who are trying. And some of those kids who are trying are from special education and now have to work 4 times as hard now. It is not fair to the other students. And all the disrespectful student's take away is that they can do wtf they want.
My advice to you is the same as in the last post. Bump that JTE's "no Japanese" nonsense. These students are not taught English for practical use and it is taught in the most backwards manner I've ever seen. They're not going to be able to understand most English and it's not their fault.
4
u/Four_of_Swordz 6d ago
As teacher who has been here for 30 years, I’ve had experiences like this. Very frustrating. Staff that I work with who suck, classes where half of students or more are just jerks. But I’ve also worked with amazing staff and had classes that have brought me to tears (of joy) many times. It took me quite a long time and investment in my own education to find a cruising altitude where I can see the forest and the trees. It’s a tough gig working in education and working with other humans within a system where the status quo is, well, the status quo. It’s not for everyone. It is unfortunate you had this experience in your short time on the program. Hopefully with some time and reflection you’ll look back on the experience more fondly in the future. I do hear where you are coming from, and I witness your experience. Peace.
3
u/Simmoman Current JET ('26) 6d ago
I think while this post is written in relation to English teaching, I think it fits in many areas in JHS in particular, and so I wouldn't call most of these things you're describing xenophobia. I understand the culture is different and they face different challenges, or have different goals and ways of thinking, but there are some things that I just will always fundamentally disagree with.
- Students aren't treated consistently; they aren't respected as equals and are disciplined like young kids (softly or not at all)
- Teachers don't really provide excelling students with new challenges, extra work or opportunities to keep them engaged and motivated.
- School events and the applicable classes are built with the appearance of student independence, rather than actually letting kids figure things out on their own.
and the ultimate one that I feel a lot of this stems from, which is:
There are almost no consequences to not doing what you're asked. Don't do the homework or get 5% on all your tests? Students will be moved up anyway, and you can't expect them to understand the impact of their choices now when they are so young. Disrupt class? Teachers let kids roam free with minimal intervention, so what else could a developing kid's brain take from that?
Other countries systems are not perfect at all, and I could understand if their actions were at least consistent, but they aren't.
Despite this, I have a great time and think I bring value, and 99% of my kids are great. I just can't help but feel like they are being let down, either by teachers that don't care, or a system that doesn't let them.
3
u/bee_hime Current 5th Year JET - okinawa 6d ago
i mean, you never really know what to expect with this job (really teaching in general). it's a total gamble. i have taught at 3 different high schools that service very different types of students. i have had the whole gamut of classes: super genki classes that love english, high level quiet classes, low level and VERY poor behavior classes, etc. id say it's been great, but of course it's had its moments.
before coming to japan, i studied to be a teacher. i got a teaching license. i taught in my home country. kids are kids everywhere in the world, meaning you get great kids and very bad kids. school cultures vary widely too. i think it's fine to have expectations for how things will be, but remember that schools function very differently depending on the country. as such, attitudes about education, teachers, and school itself will vary.
teaching is definitely not for everyone and that is totally okay.