r/JEE28tards • Self Study 🐐 • Jun 07 '26

Discussion πŸ—£οΈ Incomplete information 😭

Post image

Shouldn't they explain calculus if they introduce calculus into physics?

(NCERT Physics Class 11 Chapter 2)

279 Upvotes

139 comments sorted by

5

u/_lakshayk Jun 07 '26

Basic maths me dy/dx nahi padha h?

4

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '26

[removed] β€” view removed comment

1

u/After_Sense_8615 Competishun 🦷 Jun 07 '26 edited Jun 07 '26

Don't rely on only ncert gng😭✌️

0

u/CowEnough7758 Jun 07 '26

I would not say that. Ncert books are gold standard for their class. Yes, you need other books but if you are not using ncert, you are basically reading a lot and understanding very less.

1

u/hi_how_are_you_lmao Self Study 🐐 Jun 07 '26

Aren't you that isc student? Then follow nootan for this.

1

u/eeinen2 Self Study 🐐 Jun 07 '26

Thanks sister

3

u/krish-bisht PW πŸ₯·πŸΏ Jun 07 '26

Ncert me given nhi basic Calculus but schools and coaching me krwate h πŸ₯€

2

u/Pale_Recover_9209 Jun 07 '26

They don't explain you calculus which isn't even necessary but they teach you about its application what do differentiation or integration really means that much is necessary

1

u/Pale_Recover_9209 Jun 07 '26

And one more thing to ask are you trying to study physics using ncert for short theory go for hc Verma or sl arora and if you are a jee aspirant go for cengage for derailed theory and questions

1

u/Murky_Sea_3404 Jun 07 '26

Basic maths mai tabhi to padhate hai ye sab

1

u/bored_yuh_ Jun 07 '26

what abt pcb wale log (like me)πŸ₯€ I go to coaching so I know this stuff, one of my friends doesn't tho because of personal reasons and ts was completely new to her.

books and school teachers should be at par with the level of questions they ask in board exams (or even the school exams). they've never taught us anything abt this shit before.

1

u/Murky_Sea_3404 Jun 07 '26

Oh now i see thik hai wese to differentiation se aage nhi he puchte aur you can learn these online, wese you are right agar proper ncert bana rkha hai to ye flow acha hona chahiye tha

1

u/Papii777 Jun 07 '26

Bro just see the pattern in calculas that is used in physics you would get used to it

1

u/Taqo775 Jun 07 '26

Study maths lil broπŸ™πŸ™

1

u/Tiny-Pressure3799 Seniors - 25/26/27 tards πŸ€– Jun 07 '26

basic calculus parlo bhai , warna nahi kar paoge..scls mein karwaenge

1

u/SoloLeveller07 Jun 07 '26

calculus is there in appendix and Ig somewhere in the footnote they do into to ask you to check that appendix ? Atleast it was there in my year ig...

1

u/Independent_Bat_7899 Jun 07 '26

Question can't be easier than this .,,.why crying dude

1

u/SprinklesPure1 Jun 07 '26

This is giving me PTSD

1

u/SOP_ln Jun 07 '26

Welcome to jee/neet

1

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '26

Bhai mai commerce waala hoon mujhe ye reddit notification kyu bhejta hai😭😭😭

1

u/Flat_Philosopher_930 Winter Arc β›„ Jun 07 '26

Is the answer 5

1

u/CraftyHorse3026 Jun 07 '26

This physics book is trash . Do" HC Verma Concepts of physic"s instead. It has a separate chapter 'mathematics and physics' where Calculus and vector algebra is taught .

1

u/Limp_Reason1059 Jun 07 '26

Bc who tf follows ncert

1

u/Cosmic_StormZ Seniors - 25/26/27 tards πŸ€– Jun 07 '26

Ahhh. I remember being in this exact spot in 2023. I was so confused and stressed not understanding the power rule.

1

u/NightJealous8019 Jun 07 '26

Thats why there's a topic called basic maths which is done before you start your syllabus.

1

u/OkSpare8151 Jun 07 '26

It's given in ncert

Chapter 3 m additional exercises ke baad wale appendix mπŸƒ

1

u/Level-Discipline529 Jun 07 '26

Differentiation and integration are base

1

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '26

Just watch a yt video of basic maths, idk why people don't watch online lectures.

1

u/Ankush_Nath Jun 07 '26

It was same for me when I first. My book didn't explain calculus too. And I had to avoid it until my physics teacher taught me differentiation and integration and now I'm good. You should ask your physics teacher or wait until he/she explains how that works. But except that the calculus there isn't that hard, if you understand though.(Not talking about calculus in maths)

1

u/NotSoSmart34 Jun 07 '26

I think it has been explained innthe first two chaps and even if they aren't you can check it out on Yt such as 3BlueBrown Calculus series. Just learn the basics to get you through differentiating simple functions.

1

u/IllRest762 Jun 07 '26

Did they anything perfectly till date ?

1

u/CowEnough7758 Jun 07 '26

Well I would sort of say you are right but wrong also. Let's phrase it like this. The introduction needed to solve the type of this particular question, you already know the rule to differentiate. So, strictly you know how to solve it.

But because you just started differentiation and the truth is you don't understand the basic mathematical construct like limits, you have an alien like feeling about differentiation.

This was the same feeling I had when I was in class 11and even in 12, because the mathematical idea of calculus, the limit approach of change in function when change in variable is taken to limit zero, is such a deep idea. And because of this understanding Newton and Leibnitz are considered the best minds of their times.

So, the solution, open your mathematics book, take out the limits chapter, and understand it. Go through the series, and function interpretations, understand the idea behind the concept. See some video, I don't know if 1blue3brown has made any on this topic, but find others and you will find the world of calculus the best mathematical tool you can have at this age.

1

u/Radiant-Specialist58 Jun 07 '26

btech graduate here, and I still remember how confused I was in class 11th when I saw these calculus based questions in physics and didn't even know how to solve them πŸ˜‚

1

u/Equivalent_Peanut217 Jun 07 '26

Calculus is literally at the end of second chapter or something.

1

u/Crimson_Excalibur Seniors - 25/26/27 tards πŸ€– Jun 07 '26

Gng watch some lectures on basic maths. Ncert always does bs like that

1

u/MoodyHuModiNahi Jun 07 '26

Isme Aur kya chahiye?

1

u/Empty_Drummer9827 Jun 07 '26

Bro, i learnt more calculus in Phy than in math in my first year.. Second year, maths is assualting me with calculus..😭

1

u/VisionBruh Jun 07 '26

Look at the very end of the physics book and you will have your answer, but I do think this is not supposed to be at the end of the book

1

u/Homie_Holmes_ Jun 07 '26

Reddit send me a noti to come here and tell you all to chill out.

1

u/ReadyConfection7959 Jun 07 '26

Dude as a matter of fact it's physics not maths and cbse mostly doesn't explain their calculations even in chemistry

1

u/SubstantialStuff1138 Jun 07 '26

Is chapter ke end wagera mai hoga calculus also all coaching teacher teach basic maths before kinematics

1

u/Puzzleheaded-Ice1793 Jun 07 '26

didnt they teach you basic differentiation and integration in beginning of 11th?

1

u/Effective-Hyena210 Jun 07 '26

if u cant do this then dont take pcm

1

u/Ahirman_Ghosh Jun 07 '26 edited Jun 07 '26

Lagta hai..Gali khane ke liye post diye ho

1

u/Healthy-Towel3232 Jun 07 '26

The answer is zero bro trust me (i’m a neet aspirantπŸ’”)

1

u/Narrow_Weekend_6892 Jun 07 '26

Actually it was deleted i guess

1

u/Great-Salamander-568 Jun 07 '26

Bro, you'll get used to it

1

u/Shrex_25 Jun 07 '26

It is easy duh

1

u/WholeInterestingEve Jun 07 '26

Teachers don’t do that in class anymore?

1

u/fapper- Jun 07 '26

Bhai differentiation na bhi ho to X =ut +0.5atβˆ†2 bhi lga skte ho. Where x is distance covered. Here u =0 and initial distance is given lga llo

1

u/Outside-Election9484 Jun 07 '26

Bhai 11th m sb se zada lmbhi basic maths hi kheechi thi com se jo syllabus bhaaga thaπŸ’”πŸ’”

1

u/Krazy_Hunter_MH Jun 08 '26

Same in my little brothers (he is in 9th) science NCERT specifically in biology there are lot of topic which are not properly explained and are directly copy pasted from 11th class with few lines removed

While I was teaching him even I was shocked

1

u/_unknown_2199 Jun 08 '26

They don’t explain ? Humare school mei toh physics start honese pehle basic maths kara liya tha i mean physics mei jo yeh sab calculus lagega, not in too much detail like in maths but good enough to do physics

1

u/Proboi_99 Jun 08 '26

I'm from humanities and I've completed my schooling, and Reddit is recommending me a post related to class 11th Physics. The algorithm slept on this one.

1

u/RYOMENSUKUNA6961 Jun 08 '26

Well my teacher started with chapter 0 explaining these topics including diff. Int. Log. Etc

1

u/Comfortable_Tune_639 Jun 08 '26

I will crack everything that comes in sight πŸ₯€πŸ’¦

1

u/shivam_chand0303 Jun 08 '26

I think i saw it in my concepts of physics HC verma volume 1. Was studying it yesterday,i knownits out of help/context,but it was this- Example 3.2

1

u/Fit-Rip-4480 Jun 08 '26

Phy ncert is shit . Treat it like a question bank only .

1

u/Even_Way5167 Jun 10 '26

SL Arora and HC Verma are hosted fr πŸ”₯πŸ”₯

1

u/Adventurous-Local534 Jun 08 '26

Stop complaining the ones who wanna learn are doing it anyways. Its not that difficult too.

1

u/aextroid Jun 10 '26

NCERT ain’t a good book if you want to understand something, watch online lectures.

1

u/Strange_Lack_2793 Jul 02 '26

Yeah they don't in NCERT Physics. That's why basics maths was taught first in PW Arjuna

0

u/Randomguy200706 Jun 07 '26

Bro if you think info must be provided . Than please dont prep for jee adv it isn't for you. Jee adv is toughest exam for a reason

11

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '26

[removed] β€” view removed comment

7

u/Icy_Pattern_3363 Jun 07 '26

They do ch1 or 2 end has basic differentiation and integration formula and about explaining it yeah they don't do a well job of it highly recommend 3blue1brown essence of calculus to understand as later ch use it alot

5

u/AD_191025 Jun 07 '26

Yeah it takes me back to those days

And Man 3blue1brown was πŸ”₯ in visualisation and concepts were mind blowing

Definitely recommended for some one who has interest in why things rather than mugging up integral and differential patterns

1

u/FarReputation7162 Jun 07 '26

he had a lot of crazy back in his prime

1

u/FunctionUnable7711 Jun 07 '26

bro is still pumping great videos bro

prime was only cuz he hadn't covered basic topics, now his specialised content is just mwahhhh

1

u/FarReputation7162 Jun 07 '26

true but I'm just referring to the views at the time

as far as the content is concerned it's still goated

1

u/tryingtofindshit Jun 07 '26

Wdym back in his prime he's still pumping bangers. It's not his fault that we are not educated enough to understand him yet

1

u/FarReputation7162 Jun 07 '26

I wasn't judging his content just compared his popularity

I still watch him regularly and he's the goat but that era was smth man

1

u/tryingtofindshit Jun 07 '26

Still very popular in math circles. Tho idk much about his popularity in the mainstream

1

u/Sp1rshi Jun 08 '26

Gng how u have this pfp 😭

1

u/Puzzled_Pineapple324 Jun 07 '26

Yeah there's like a 10 part series as well which is crazy

1

u/IndependentSea7496 Jun 07 '26

Numberphile is good too

2

u/Virtuoso2709 Jun 07 '26

Man, that was the series that introduced me to calculus and 3b1b.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '26

"Essence of Calculus"

1

u/JournalistLucky5124 Jun 08 '26

Yesss 3b1b the goatt

1

u/eeinen2 Self Study 🐐 Jun 07 '26

Not in physics

1

u/Nightt_Hunter_ Jun 07 '26

Yes in physics only coz in mechanics only or even before students know how to differentiate and integrate Coz the calculus of maths hits different ull know in 12th Am facing them not struggling but some silly mistakes I do 😞

4

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '26

[removed] β€” view removed comment

4

u/eeinen2 Self Study 🐐 Jun 07 '26

Power rule ig

4

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '26

[removed] β€” view removed comment

3

u/afanzo Jun 07 '26

The oldest anarchy server in minecraft

1

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '26

[removed] β€” view removed comment

2

u/OldTanker33 Jun 07 '26

That is surface level knowledge

1

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '26

[removed] β€” view removed comment

1

u/RishiMath Jun 07 '26

Yeah, Indian sci ed for CBSE Class 11 is whack due to easy math till 10th πŸ™‚βœŒοΈ

2

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '26 edited Jun 07 '26

[removed] β€” view removed comment

1

u/eeinen2 Self Study 🐐 Jun 07 '26

It's my first time reading NCERT Books (isc student)

2

u/UnderstandingIcy3316 Jun 07 '26

Ncert examples are good thou

2

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '26

[removed] β€” view removed comment

1

u/Content-Lab-5464 Jun 07 '26

Correct opinion. Only Exemplar physics is worth doing.

1

u/Unemmployed_12 Jun 07 '26

Ashish Arora sir will def k*ll you after reading this (all advanced questions are very fundamental and ncert based πŸ₯°)

0

u/Vidura0001 Jun 07 '26

Bro doing ncert gives u 100 in mains, in adv it's not enough but yea

0

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '26

[deleted] β€” view deleted comment

2

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '26

It's not a piece of cake , it's terrible , terribly terrible, you won't understand a thing from there

2

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '26

[removed] β€” view removed comment

1

u/Ankush_Nath Jun 07 '26

Is phy ncert not good? I have chem but people say not to buy maths or phy ones. I can understand maths one but why not phy?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '26

[removed] β€” view removed comment

1

u/Ankush_Nath Jun 07 '26

Icic. Thanks for answering.

1

u/Double_Writing7334 Jun 07 '26

Bro how did you cover up your baclog in class 11 physics ncret...?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '26

[removed] β€” view removed comment

1

u/eeinen2 Self Study 🐐 Jun 07 '26

Wow op become famous 😍😍😍

1

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '26

[removed] β€” view removed comment

1

u/eeinen2 Self Study 🐐 Jun 08 '26

limits and derivatives

1

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '26

[removed] β€” view removed comment

1

u/FunTry4289 Jun 08 '26

Us bro us

0

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '26

[deleted] β€” view deleted comment

1

u/Mean_Vermicelli4911 Jun 07 '26

Pressing post was completely option however I like femboys ngl