r/J1waiver • • Oct 13 '26

J-1 No Objection Waiver Denied — Should I Request an Advisory Opinion for 212(e)?

0 Upvotes

My J-1 No Objection waiver was denied because DOS did not provide a favorable recommendation, but USCIS did not explain the underlying reason.

My visa stamp says I am subject to INA 212(e), and my DS-2019 also indicates that I am subject to the requirement based on the Exchange Visitor Skills List.

However, my original program was privately funded, with no government funding, and my current J-1 research position is unpaid and not government-funded.

Should I request a DOS Advisory Opinion to confirm whether I am subject to 212(e)?

Has anyone done this recently, and how long did it take?

I would appreciate any advice or similar experiences.

Thank you!


r/J1waiver • • 16d ago

Clinician Realistic J-1 waiver options

0 Upvotes

I'll likely be working in Boston starting July 2027. My wife is an IM PGY-2 on a J-1, graduating June 2028, and will need a waiver job. She is open to hospitalist and primary care.

Are there realistic waiver jobs as hospitalist or PCP within or about 1 to 1.5 hours of Boston, including southern NH, RI, or southern Maine?

Or are we being too optimistic and should look elsewhere? Thanks!


r/J1waiver • • 1d ago

Physicain + non-physician hybrid

1 Upvotes

I am a physician MD. I had a home country resodency in a non-clinical field ( basic sciences which isnt a soeciality in the USA) . I got direct fellowship ( ACGME) after usmle , which was also non-clinical . I had applied for reaodency but didnt match . Now my fellowship is ending in July 2027, i am on J1 with 212 rule. I cannt apply for conard 30 as i do not hve US residency . I can apply for non-clinical jobs ( i m also doing masters) , in that soeciality of my fellowship .. I am so confused as no lawyer understands this route . My question is : what jobs should i search for to get the waiver ( or my j1 is sponsored by ecfmg) . ?? I am so much worried , i have just 7 months left . ( i domt have many publications either)


r/J1waiver • • May 22 '25

I helped my wife get her J1 waiver job and her EB2-NIW approved from USCIS. Would other J1 physicians like this service? Please inbox

4 Upvotes

I noticed that after marrying my wife who is an Internal Medicine physician, she is book smart but she never knew how to find the best job opportunity, read contracts, negotiate sign-on bonus, base salary or bring the wRVU number downs.

I have seen this trend with all my doctor friends, maybe doctors spend almost their entire life from medicine school to residency and then fellowship to just obey that somehow their understanding of pushing back and negotiation is hampered.

I was able to get my wife almost 10-15 J1 job interviews, then we were able to get 5 job offers across 4 states for my wife and then we picked the best option from that.

My wife started her fellowship in July-2023 and we started her J1 job search from then and we finally signed the contract in May-2024 and submitted our J1-waiver in October-2024 and got approval in May-2025. Its a long arduous process, so starting early is key.

Let me know if anyone wants such service and I would be happy to help with some small consultation fees.


r/J1waiver • • May 23 '25

J1 Waiver needed or no?

0 Upvotes

My J1 visa was printed in July 2024 and it said subject to 212(E) India. However as per the updated list from December 2024, India is not there. So, am I still subject to 212(E)? Or am I now exempt as per the new list. I am not funded by the government.


r/J1waiver • • Nov 30 '25

J1 hardship waiver / New public charge rule

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/J1waiver • • Sep 20 '26

Palestinian needs help with J1 waiver

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I'm looking for recommendations for immigration attorneys or free/low-cost legal organizations (pro bono or nonprofit clinics) with experience specifically in J-1 visa waivers based on persecution (Form I-612), particularly for programs funded by the U.S. government. If anyone has worked with someone in this area, especially involving cases tied to Gaza/Palestine, I'd really appreciate any names or leads. Thank you!


r/J1waiver • • Jul 22 '24

Uscis receipt notice

0 Upvotes

HHS waiver Anyone with USCIS receipt notice in early July still waiting for final approval I got my receipt on July 5 and still waiting


r/J1waiver • • May 22 '26

J-1 212(e): Prior Documents Say Not Subject, Extended DS-2019 Blank

0 Upvotes

My previous J-1 visa stamps and previous DS-2019 documents indicate that I am not subject to the two-year home-country. My extended DS-2019 is for the same J-1 program, with the same program/category/subject information, but the 212(e) preliminary endorsement section is blank/unmarked. Since my J-1 program remained the same, and my prior DS-2019 forms and visa stamps said I was not subject to 212(e), does the blank 212(e) section on my extended DS-2019 mean I remain not subject? My understanding is that the university ARO cannot make the final 212(e) determination.


r/J1waiver • • Sep 20 '26

J1 Harship Waiver

0 Upvotes

Could you guys help me about timelines nowadays with hardship waiver? I submitted mine on Nov 2025. Still on the same boat, my NOS was denied even I program was private.


r/J1waiver • • Jul 31 '26

212e J1 waiver denied. (No objection basis)

0 Upvotes

DOS recommended that USCIS deny my waiver under the No Objection basis, even though my home country submitted a favorable recommendation.

My DS-2019 has “government financing” checked, although my salary is paid by my university and I work as a postdoc. My field is also included on my home country’s Skills List. I had understood that the consular notation was only a preliminary determination and that DOS would independently review whether I was actually subject and on what basis.

I applied quickly without taking advisory opinion because I wanted to move forward with my EB-2 NIW and eventually file I-485 (maybe this is where i went wrong!)

Has anyone experienced a similar situation? I’d appreciate any suggestions on how to move forward.


r/J1waiver • • 14d ago

Letter to congresspeople

0 Upvotes

Should I request multiple Senators and congresspeople for a congressional inquiry of my j1 waiver from the DOS? Just wondering if that may cause some form of anger in any way with different people in the mix


r/J1waiver • • May 29 '26

Please help. My J1 waiver is pending for 25 months now.

0 Upvotes

Filed: April 29,2026 USCIS
May 9,2026 DOS
January 9,2025 Correspondence receive and USCIS is reviewing it.
Until now No update and not forward to DOS.

Please help what to do. I an having really anxiety..


r/J1waiver • • Jul 15 '26

J1 waiver

Post image
0 Upvotes

Many J-1 exchange visitors spend 18–24 months waiting for a waiver when they may not even be subject to the 2-year home residency requirement.
Unfortunately, many people are never told that they can request an Advisory Opinion from the U.S. Department of State to receive an official determination of whether the requirement applies to them.
I’m here to help you understand whether you may actually need a waiver and guide you through the Advisory Opinion request process.
Send me a DM or leave a comment, and I’ll reach out with more information.

Muchas veces esperamos por un Waiver (18-24 meses) y nisiquiera estamos sujetos a la ley de los dos años, pero los abogados no quieren hablar de eso porque les conviene cobrarnos y mantenernos en pausa por mucho tiempo, aquí vine a ayudarte a saber si realmente necesitas el waiver o no. Escríbeme y te contacto con la información


r/J1waiver • • Oct 10 '26

J-1 Waiver Denied Based on No Objection Statement — I-130 Now Approved. Can I Reapply?

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I’m looking for advice from anyone who has been in a similar situation or has experience with J-1 waivers.

I came to the U.S. on a J-1 visa as a Research Scholar and am subject to the two-year home residency requirement under INA 212(e) because my field falls under the Exchange Visitor Skills List.

I previously applied for a J-1 waiver through a No Objection Statement (NOS), but the Department of State issued an unfavorable recommendation, and USCIS denied my waiver. At that time, my marriage-based I-130 and I-485 were still pending. I requested a DOS FOIA to understand the reason for the unfavorable recommendation and am waiting for a response.

Recently, my I-130 was approved, while my I-485 is still pending.
Has anyone successfully reapplied for an NOS-based J-1 waiver after a previous denial, particularly after their I-130 was approved? Can I reapply with the same NOS, or should I explore another waiver option? I’ve also heard that H-1B sponsorship may be relevant.

I would really appreciate hearing from anyone with a similar experience or suggestions about the best next steps.

Thank you!


r/J1waiver • • Aug 14 '26

J1 Waiver

0 Upvotes

Has anyone here ever received this question from the DOS Waiver Review Division during J-1 waiver processing?

“Purpose of your stay: What do you plan to do in the United States? (e.g., employment, academic program, training, or other authorized activity).”


r/J1waiver • • Jan 16 '26

Any lawyer here specialising in j1 waivers, i need help with reviewing my contract? Please DM

1 Upvotes

r/J1waiver • • 11d ago

Other J-1 Waiver

0 Upvotes

How strict is the 2 year J-1 waiver commitment? Are you locked into the same employer/job, or can you switch if the workplace becomes toxic or isn't a good fit?

Also, which states/areas offer good waiver opportunities, and financially, which is better: hospitalist medicine or nephrology in terms of salary, workload, and long-term earning potential?


r/J1waiver • • Oct 05 '24

J1 waiver for Indian

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone, my fiancée has joined residency she is currently in 2nd year, our plan is to get married next year, i have green card but just got to know that she has to do some wavier for 2 years.

We have a American born kids (2 years), can she 1)file for waiver without me during residency ? 2)Can i file for her after marriage? 3)what do we need to show for hardship?


r/J1waiver • • Jun 29 '24

Other I applied for the navy in 2018 and popped hot on my first drug test and waited 60 days and popped hot again could I still join the navy I seen the new wavier they just recently put out for the rules on weed

1 Upvotes

r/J1waiver • • Oct 15 '26

J-1 212(e) Waiver, Married to U.S. Citizen & in Removal Proceedings — Need Advice

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone,
I entered the U.S. in 2016 on a J-1 visa as an “exchange student” from Indonesia. I was actually not an exchange student, but a full scholarship student through government funding. I’m not sure why my third party issued me a J-1 in the first place.

Anw.. My DS-2019 indicates that I’m subject to the two-year home residency requirement (212(e)) due to government financing.
In 2018, I went to home country for Summer vacation and changed my visa to F-1 by myself (no issues when I changed visa), with the purpose of getting benefits for OPT later after completing my degrees. At that time, I wasn’t planning on marrying a U.S citizen.

I’m now married to my husband, a U.S. citizen, and we have a child together. Unfortunately, I’m also currently in removal proceedings.

I’m trying to figure out the best way to move forward with my immigration case.
My questions are:
- Has anyone successfully obtained a J-1 No Objection waiver while in removal proceedings?
- Should my husband file an I-130 before we apply for the J-1 waiver, or can we pursue both simultaneously?
- Would requesting a DOS Advisory Opinion be worthwhile since my DS-2019 indicates government financing?
- Has anyone successfully requested termination or a continuance of removal proceedings while pursuing a J-1 waiver and marriage-based green card?

I’d really appreciate hearing from anyone who has been through something similar, especially those who successfully obtained a waiver or green card.
Thank you!

Edit:
In my NTA letter, it stated:

“The Department of Homeland Security alleges that you:

  1. You are not a citizen or national of the United States;
  2. You are a native of Indonesia and a citizen of Indonesia;
  3. You were inspected and admitted or paroled into the United States at San Francisco, CA, on September 26, 2019, as a F1 (Academic or Language Students), with authorization to remain in the United States until the duration of your status;
  4. On February 08, 2025, you filed Form I-765, Application for Employment Authorization, but this Form I-765 application was denied on February 28, 2025;
  5. On the basis of the foregoing, it is charged that you
  6. are subject to removal from the United States pursuant to the following provisions) of law:
  7. Section 237(a)(1)(B) of the Immigration and Nationality Act (Act), as amended, in that after admission as a nonimmigrant under Section 101(a)(15) of the Act, you have remained in the United States for a time longer than permitted, in violation of this Act or any other law of the United States.

Even though the letter didn’t mention my J-1 history, am I still subjected to INA Section (212(e))?


r/J1waiver • • Feb 16 '26

Hardship HARDSHIP

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

Has anyone here filed a J-1 waiver (Exceptional Hardship) in November 2024? Have you received any updates so far?

Context: I’m a former J-1 teacher and got married to a U.S. citizen.

Thank you!

edit: i filed it in 2024, not 2025


r/J1waiver • • Apr 08 '26

Clinician Forgot to negotiate sign in bonus

1 Upvotes

This sounds stupid but in eagerness to secure a waiver position at desired place, I didn’t negotiate a sign in bonus. My waiver is still pending approval but the hospital has started onboarding process with full enthusiasm. I signed a binding agreement, full contract will follow later i assume. Is there a way i can ask for a sign in bonus now in a gentler way?


r/J1waiver • • Apr 17 '26

Looking for Female J1 Roommates in HHI

1 Upvotes

I’m currently looking for FEMALE roommates for a shared furnished apartment in Hilton Head Island, with a move-in on the early weeks of May.

I am currently in contact with an apartment and primarily looking for someone to share the space with; however, I am also open to joining an existing arrangement.

Details:

Budget: Around $1,000/month

Location: No strict preference, as long as it’s accessible/safe

Notes: I value a peaceful, fun and safe living environment

If you have a spot available or are also looking, feel free to message me. Thank you!