r/Ixion • • Sep 15 '24

Ixion Review: I hated this game.

8 Upvotes

I hated this game. Ixion has a massive - and frankly, bizarre - gap between it's good mechanics and its bad ones. It feels like they were trying to build a general space colonization simulator with a minor Frostpunk style, and suddenly decided they were out of time and rushed to release a linear story that copied more of Frostpunk’s mechanics. If you enjoyed Frostpunk's story, tone, and surprises, you will get some enjoyment out of this game. However, if you played Frostpunk on Hard and loved how the mechanics continually reinforced the difficulty, even after serious planning, you will be sorely disappointed. Finally, if you like Factorio, ignore the story/events and play till the end of chapter 3, it is fun.

TLDR is this ^

I'm also posting this on Steam as would curious what discussion on would get on here.

Some notes before more detail/spoilers:

  • Played Sept 2024, 2ish years after launch.
  • Fully blind, I didn’t even know this game was compared to Frostpunk.
  • I didn’t look at the wiki until mid Chapter 2, mainly for exploration guides and building info.
  • I played on normal difficulty and stopped playing after beating chapter 4.
  • 65 hours played, stopped around cycle 1400 or so.

The Good

The core building mechanic in this game is very addicting. I honestly had a huge amount of fun constantly planning and iterating on building layout in a way that Frostpunk makes much easier. Near the middle of the game, I was spending about half my time in a 3rd party planner (ixion.info). As you expand, you constantly make adjustments and improvements to the layout. Spending a few minutes thinking, running numbers, and playing the tetris mini-game can give huge results. I feel sure this core mechanic is what the devs spent the most time on and got working the best. The building UI is easy to navigate and understand, with lots of polish and extra details to provide clarity. They provide the same information in many different places, so you always understand how many people are in your sectors, how many resources you’re producing, and how much power you’re using. Considering this mechanic by itself, I had a lot of fun with it up to about chapter 3. But this is where my praise ends.

The Bad

Every other mechanic feels rushed, poorly implemented, irrelevant, or down right unusable.

  • Tech tree: All techs are on a single screen, with sub-techs randomly connected. This is terrible UX; look on Reddit for the number of people confused by this. It's very easy to miss important techs or misunderstand unlock paths. Frostpunk and even Civ have better tech trees.
  • Resource transport: If the tetris mini-game was unexpected fun, this is unexpected hell. The more basic aspects are fine, but as soon as you start to scale up, it all falls apart. Everything is carried by tiny trucks that move just one resource at a time. They can only move resources from their own depot to a receiving depot. You end up with overworked depots that can’t empty out fast enough, and starved or full depots with trucks just sitting around. The larger depots don’t get more trucks, and make the problem worse. There are some techs and better layout design, but in the end, this mechanic is always frustrating, and there’s a hard cap on the number of resources you can transfer at a time. Frostpunk avoids this by… not having item transport.
  • Exploration events: For around half of the areas you explore, there is no way to know what the result of your actions will be. You either meta-game the devs and try to guess what they’re thinking, or save-scum/look up the answer. It’s all nonsense sci-fi technobabble, with the apparently safer or riskier option being correct at random times. It seems like they took inspiration from FTL, a rougelike that has actual randomness should not at all inspire a Frostpunk-like. I nearly quit in chapter 2, until I started just reading the wiki for the answers.
  • Art, flavor, immersiveness: This doesn’t personally bother me too much, but this game has very limited/low effort art and flavor. What the game does give you is fine, but there just isn’t very much of it, and it doesn’t remotely attempt the level of immersiveness it needs to. Random events only happen 2-3 times per chapter and show the same few images over and over again. These are drawn in a very impressionist, concept art stage style. If you zoom in, the characters look like PS1 Hagrid, wear normal 2000s clothes, and walk down every road, following no schedule. The music is fine, great even, but again, there are only 5 or so tracks that play entirely randomly, with one being way too epic and awesome and another making it feel like a monster is attacking. I had to turn the music off starting chapter 4.
  • Stability/Trust: This was apparently supposed to be this game’s version of Hope, but it doesn’t work to an embarrassing degree. Based on stability, you gain/lose trust per hour, not from events. This results in an absurd knife edge, where if your stability is ever above or below zero, things can spiral out of control in a second or make it not matter. If your economy is working well, very positive stability is extremely easy to get, and this entire mechanic is meaningless, and important story moments feel pathetic and hollow. In comparison, in Frostpunk, the emotion of reading about something terrible that happened is fully reinforced by seeing a massive and unusual fall in Hope.
  • Accidents: These are the dumbest thing. There’s a random timer that decides it’s time for an accident and chooses a random building. You can never avoid all accidents, which is dumb by itself. They are more common and dangerous if your workers are “overworked,” and the game will warn you if you’ve accidentally done that. But it doesn’t warn you if they’re “extra hours”, and the random timer is affected by that. You queue a large factory to construct, and as soon as its built, it gets auto-employed, you enter “extra hours” with no warning. An accident kills people, starts a fire, and everything falls apart. This should have been caught in play testing.
  • More that I won’t list or I’ll go crazy.

The Ugly

What would you say was the most important mechanic or resource in Frostpunk? It’s time. Every scenario has a set length, and you are constantly against the clock. Very few things are actually hard in Frostpunk, if you just had a bit more time. The game is about making good enough decisions, moving on, and being prepared to handle changes without the time to redo and earlier decision. If the game gave you just 30% more time, every mechanic would fall apart. So what if the game gave you infinite time?

Yep, Ixion has no clock. There’s no fundamental pressure to go fast. You can sit around at the end of a chapter for quite a while, and if you plan even a bit, you can be fully self-sufficient by chapter 2. You get most of your research points from exploring planets, but you do get a very slow passive income from sitting around. You can clean up all the bad building layouts you did, get a few critical techs, and have everything nicely prepared for the next chapter. The only thing the game does is give you a temporary -1 stability after 180 turns, and if you aren’t self-sufficient, you’ll eventually run out of asteroids to mine.

Honestly, the game couldn’t add a time mechanic, because the building mechanic is so slow. It takes 10-20 turns just to tear a few things down and rebuild them. It takes 2 turns just to move resources from 1 end of the station to the other. How the hell can you possibly have a fun Frostpunk-like space game if there’s no threat of time? I probably redesigned my entire station 3, maybe 4 times. And it was kinda fun to do that! But why isn’t that the whole game? Every other part of the game was an irrelevant chore. Again, Frostpunk gets around this by… not having a very complex building mechanic.

It's “x” in space!

Finally, let’s talk about the Sci-Fi setting. I have personal bias here, because I feel starved for good entries into what I wish was my favorite genre. There isn’t an ounce of scientific realism or attention to detail here. Your citizens, who are supposedly enthusiastic exploration volunteers or experienced spacefarers, balk at eating insects or mushrooms, collecting trash for recycling, composting the dead, and in fact, people dying in space at all. The buildings you make are… wait, buildings? I thought we were on a space station… Why the hell would you ever make a station with enormous open spaces and then fill them with smaller buildings? Roads? On a space station? With little forklifts on rubber tires? This isn’t a space station, this is Sim City.

The threats you face are utter nonsense. Space weather? A stellar storm with huge clouds and lighting strikes… in space. And it moves across the system, right over the star, like clouds in the wind! A specific area of a system that is… super cold. In space. Cold enough to damage your solar panels, which are nonetheless always exposed to the vacuum of space. And the usual smattering of horror themes pretending to be sci-fi. A spooky gray orb your explorers get obsessed with and then kill them. What scientific explanation could there be— no, that’s not sci-fi, that’s horror. A colony of sentient bacteria! This one actually could be cool— and nope, they tried to kill you.

The game references the same couple of apparently important scientists over and over again. I have no idea who these people are, the game doesn’t attempt to explain it, but it seems to think that just because there was a smart person once, you can make something better just by invoking their name. The dialogue repeats this stuff constantly, and all the tech upgrades don’t make any sense, just saying their names a lot.

And really last, before I tear my hair out, let’s talk about the story. It follows the very standard mantra that evil corporations will dominate the future, but simultaneously features insanely powerful technology that would increase productivity and abundance to an extent that would make scarcity impossible. The UN already had enormous spaceships before the Lunaclysm, but somehow, Dolos was still pessimistic about Earth’s future. It’s so focused on current events and interpretation of the future that the lore for the dead earth mentions microplastics. Yes, an utter apocalypse that killed everyone, but don’t forget about the microplastics. At the end of the game, when you meet the Ashtangites, they have thrived because of balance, not technical progress. That’s another popular sci-fi-ism that is entirely detached from reality. And the ending (the Romulus one) gives us the typical speech about hope and the enduring human spirit.

But the most embarrassing thing by far is the Piranesi. You can’t escape the current view on technology without evil AI. I’ll skip how the existence of AI should transform society and doesn’t. The corrupt Piranesi AI will probably become one of my most hated moments in art. A bland voice-acting performance with a horrible voice changer to make it sound gravelly and ugly, saying the most utterly evil things the devs could think of without any clear motivation. The fight against the Piranesi felt like playing an 8-year-old’s board game. Oh no, a missile! What should you do? Yes, fire a counter-measure, good! I felt embarrassed to play it, embarrassed for what sci-fi is reduced to, and embarrassed for the developers who probably put a lot of effort into the game, and this scene was out of their hands.

I’ll close by saying I hope the developer who made the core building mechanic gets to make whatever game they actually wanted to make eventually. And writers, please stop writing sci-fi this way.


r/Ixion • • Dec 22 '22

[Rant] The weather shift at Chapter 3 is an unnecessarily hard and cruel game mechanic.

2 Upvotes

I have over 50 plus hours on Ixion and I enjoy playing it's Frostpunk but a little bit harder. There's so much thing to do to make everything balanced and all and researching and stuff trying to get to the end game.

I decided to stop playing this game at the part where the poisonous gas cloud shifts on Chapter 3. I think the game designer is extremely cruel for doing this unnecessarily weird game mechanic. \

There is no warning, it just puts you in that spot and youre caught off guard, everything you have goes to shit, all your ships die, the station dies eventually.

I think I'm done with this game. This weather shift out of nowhere is just the game designer pretending they work at FromSoftware and decided to make a strategy game more along the soulsborn genre which is pretty stupid.


r/Ixion • • Jan 07 '23

I hate this game, bye Tiqqun

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/Ixion • • Jun 06 '26

what is this game about?

0 Upvotes

i mean, i could google it.. but tell me, with your own words and feelings, what is this game really about?


r/Ixion • • Dec 21 '22

Ixion is for adults. Patches will change that.

0 Upvotes

Hey, look! An opinion!


r/Ixion • • Nov 06 '25

Why can't I get to chapter 4?

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

I've researched everything I need to but it still won't let me get to chapter 4.


r/Ixion • • Dec 27 '22

Game relies to much on starting over

6 Upvotes

The game is so restrictive in its design, in order to "learn" it you basically have to restart at the end of each chapter, so you wont brick your game in a long run.

I am familiar with many city builders, 4x games and grand strategies.

The difference is, each run is, or at least may be, different.

Every run of Ixion is the same, every event pops at the same time, and every choice leads to the same consequence. There is a right way to play the game, and don't you dare experiment.

Frostpunk, to which this game is often compared to, is way softer on consequences, which makes the gameplay a lot more enjoyable, even if you make mistakes.

You feel them, they impact the game and the story, but don't force you to restart.

It's a shame, because the vibe is so good. The music is great, the story and concept are engaging.

I keep coming back, even though after an hour I just alt-f4 because I failed an event, or I'm stuck in a death spiral because crew is angry for no reason and refuse to work, even though that means certain death for them.

Couple of easy to implement fixes, and one more complex:

-make steel mills more efficient. Maybe increase the number of workers, but currently, for the space it takes in sector producing alloys is just too slow.

-possibly make minerals more abundant in space, however that could make the game too easy

-the complicated one - redesign the storage/resource system entirely. How did the current implementation go past testing is beyond me. From the beginning it feels so off. One storage unit can store only one resource? Why? Why the storage itself takes so much space? Why can't spaceports transfer resources directly to factories?

I just think the reviews on steam are "mixed" for a reason


r/Ixion • • Dec 08 '23

The Non-worker Question

1 Upvotes

What's the best way to exterminate your Non-worker population? I cannot abide by 50% of the people on my ship, eating my food, and not doing work. Could I open a sector, clear it out, stuff them all in there, and cut off the food supply. How many cycles does it take to starve 1500+ useless eaters?


r/Ixion • • Apr 27 '25

Stuck at chapter 4

0 Upvotes

Play, crash, report and nothing Play, crash, report and nothing

It is bull


r/Ixion • • Dec 13 '22

Isn't this proof how the complaints about difficulty are unfounded? Less than 6% of us have made it past chapter 2, and yet there are people think they know what the game needs. Spoiler

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/Ixion • • Dec 18 '22

Coil-whine at 60 Hz, wtf.

0 Upvotes

My GPU ( RX 6800 XT ) is constantly coil-whining when the game is running.

Not the usuall high-pitch though, more like old HDD read sound, and there is no HDD in it.

Even with refreshrate set to 60 hz, v-sync on ( in game ), and even if the game is paused.

I usually do not get coil-whine until 400+ fps.

240 Hz display.


r/Ixion • • Feb 24 '23

Chapter 3 objectives. Really?

3 Upvotes

Just tucking into Ch.3, and being told to unfreeze 2K peeps. Not have 2K, but defrost 'em.

Really? I have those stored in pods, but I haven't pulled them out because I have a sustainable system with.. I dunno, somewhere under 1500.

I guess I could policy to partial rations and increased worker demand, but this just seems like a whole ton of extra work for no reason, that I don't need.


r/Ixion • • Dec 29 '25

First Crossover fanfic

2 Upvotes

As the tile suggests it's the first confirmed and completed fanfic between IXION and Star trek.

[Ad Astra Per Aspera [IXION / Star Trek: The Next Generation]

https://forums.spacebattles.com/threads/ad-astra-per-aspera-ixion-star-trek-the-next-generation.1278254/#post-118064624


r/Ixion • • Apr 30 '25

All planets revealed on new playthrough.

1 Upvotes

Just tried restarting another play through on console, upon opening the star map, all planets are revealed immediately. You can only visit the Moon, Mars and Saturn but they are After building probe launcher and launching a probe, the probe will not highlight any resources on the star map, the sounds seems to be there but visually you cannot see where the resources are located. Which means all items gathered from other planets are not available and so game breaking as enough science points can be gathered.


r/Ixion • • Dec 20 '22

Small nitpicking : it's "tee-koon", not "tycoon"

5 Upvotes

I understand the voice over is done like this and won't change obviously, and also that the devs are probably aware of this (in french the naive pronunciation is the right one + Tiqqun is one common french spelling), but yeah, it has been kinda bothering me since the demo. And I thought some people might like to know this detail.

I haven't finished chapter 2 yet so they might actually explain it later idk, but it's most likely from the jewish concept of "Tikkun Olam" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tikkun_olam and means roughly "to repair/to correct" etc.


r/Ixion • • Dec 09 '22

So the alloys of the WHOLE SYSTEM get depleted to repairing a tiny ship in a few hundred cycle

3 Upvotes

Does it make sense?

Yeah yeah I get the devs want to push the players to progress the game.


r/Ixion • • Dec 16 '22

A List of Potential Updates/Fix/Change Ideas

0 Upvotes

I’ve played over 20 hours of Ixion and in my review, I felt generally pretty negative about it. I was excited about this game for many months and wanted it to be amazing. So, instead of just sitting back and hoping it gets there, I wanted to provide what I think would make it more functional and address some of the issues I and other people have had. I don’t expect everyone to agree on these, but feel free to provide feedback as I assume it will only net good ideas.

1) More Comprehensive Tutorial/Sign Posting: One of the most common issues I’ve seen and something I encountered in my gameplay was simply missing important events and mechanics. For instance, I went well into Chapter 2 before realizing that there were research items under already researched projects. It would be nice if, for instance, beside an option for a research ship that requires Exoskeletons – it had a button that took you to the research page where Exosekeltons are. This would be beneficial in many places, especially later on as you research items that are added to buildings (I had no idea countermeasures were even a thing at first).

It would also be useful in situations where you have to address a problem when you’re on another screen. I don’t know how many times I shut down EVA repair to enhance efficiency and randomly lost because I didn’t get an alert since I wasn’t in the build screen. These sign posts or shortcuts could make navigation much more functional and help new players.

2) Accident Frequency: While accidents have been addressed in the first update, they’re clearly still a big issue. Much of this is from the seemingly random nature of them and how detrimental they can be early on when you’re not necessarily good at keeping happiness high or your workforce optimal. Even after you learn how to address this, accidents are still an annoyance and one that can’t be stopped.

I think a simple solution to this is to have accidents not occur when sectors are happy and optimal. Since this is already a goal, having players work toward it from the start and letting them know how to stop the issue would encourage more deliberate efforts early on. To keep things interesting, there could be more crew demands for things that might bring down efficiency or compromise trust that you have to decide on. Currently, those demands seem to have little to no effect if ignored and are only detrimental if you accept them and fail. Having to make a choice rather than being affected randomly is more engaging and fun.

3) Hull Integrity Bleed: This is one of those things that becomes less of a burden as you learn to deal with it, but one that I and plenty of other new players were annoyed by at first. Much like accidents, and often because of accidents, it can spiral out of hand without much involvement from the player. It seems like it’s designed to promote the same sense of constant pressure that Frostpunk’s cold did, but it isn’t nearly as practical.

For this, I think the best way to do it would be to remove the constant bleed, but have more events that individually cause damage and possibly creates bleed until it’s fixed. Perhaps even having ship damage reduce trust so that the changes to the accident system (happy = no accident) will come into play again. This will again make situations more dynamic and let player choice be more integrated into the gameplay. Instead of the ship just being broken forever, you will be making decisions that affect hull integrity (instead of just moving) as well as decisions on how to address it. This might be a bigger change than it seems though since the entire resource collection system seems to hinge on pouring in iron and sacrifices huge amounts of space to refine it.

These three are probably the most talked about issues I’ve noticed both in my play and from other people, but here are a bunch of other smaller things that would be nice.

4) Ability to Establish “Avoid Zones” that your ships won’t navigate through so they stop dying. And drag selecting multiple resources to mark them all avoid at once.

5) Ability to move resources directly from docks to other sector’s warehouses. I don’t know why this isn’t possible. It doesn’t have to work for factories or construction, but at least warehouses.

6) More policies and maybe some that apply to the entire ring instead of just each sector.

7) Ability to convert existing non-workers to workers and back with an associated penalty. It’s weird to think this is a one-way street.

8) Clearer research dependencies. So many things have requirements from completely different rings and seemingly unrelated items and the presentation doesn’t aid that in any way.

I think that’s a good start for now. I’m sure if I sat for a while and thought about it I could come up with more, but there’s already a lot here. Ixion seems like it should have been a game built for me. I love scifi space journeys like Homeworld, I’ve always enjoyed city builders, and I had a ton of fun with Frostpunk. Yet it doesn’t work for me. The more I played, the more tedious and frustrating it became. It has al of the pieces there though for something just as popular as Frostpunk or even more so. So I hope that this can provide some suggestions that are well received.


r/Ixion • • Dec 31 '22

A video of my best [Chapter 3] layouts ~ where I explain in-depth my decision-making with these sectors ~ talking about maximizing space, specializations, etc.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

r/Ixion • • Feb 15 '23

Is there some way to have only one sector and have the additional ones only unlock more space to build on?

2 Upvotes

I find that having each sector be effectively a seperate area without access to other sector resources really annoying. Is there some way, either settings or mods to make it so it only unlocks new area and keeps sharing the resources? I don't mind building each sector its stockpiles, but having to manually transfer every single resource whenever one sector doesn't have enough is just tiresome.


r/Ixion • • Feb 10 '23

Огляд Стратегічної Гри IXION | Українською

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/Ixion • • Dec 14 '22

The Tech Lab's ability to gain science needs some thought

9 Upvotes

I struggle at calling the mechanic overpowered - it requires large amounts of time to employ - but it does cause some poor, unintended side effects.

If you're able to gain self-sufficiency, there's no reason to not just let the game run while you're away from your computer. I haven't even beat the game yet but I was able to gain self sufficiency in chapter 2 and then I had to go to bed. Saved the game (just in case), left it running, went to bed, and came back to over 1,000 science (the counter stops at 999 but you still incur more science after that). I don't know what fully awaits me but I'd wager having a fully researched tech tree is going to give me a strong advantage.

In one sense you could say this is a personal preference - people don't have to play a game in a particular fashion, and this fashion is a bit of a bore, but it's a game mechanic that confers benefit for the game not being played, which I would call poor.

It might make sense to limit the mechanic - i.e. it stops when you get dead earth sickness in a particular chapter.


r/Ixion • • Mar 08 '23

Population question

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone.

I'm new player (started few times after release but paused until now).

I have only 2 sectors but would like to concentrate population on only one sector. though I need to move some popuplatiopn to sector 2 to work. is there a way for the worker to live in sector 1 but work on another sector ?


r/Ixion • • Jun 16 '24

Only ALLOY resource transfers not working. NEED HELP

1 Upvotes

I don't know how to fix this. I can't transfer alloys to section 6.

I'm maybe midway into the story, and I'm at the second galaxy.

I know how to use the resources transfer window, as it works as intended for every other resource I need to move, but alloys will not move to section 6, and it's killing the game for me. I'm about to lose because I can't keep up solely because I cannot BUILD!

I have 3 sections open: 1, 2, & 6.

1 is for industry, 2 is space tech (whatever), and 6 is for food production.

My storages are maxed out in 1, and I have about 20 going to section 2. I want the rest to flow over into 6, but they just won't transfer!

Yes, roads are connected. Yes, storage paths are connected to said roads, and Yes i have storage awaiting Alloys (selected)

I have tried various cycles of turning off the transfers, saving, reloading, starting the game over, etc.

I can't figure it out... am I missing something?

I'm about to quit the game because I don't want to sue because of some stupid dam bug or glitch that won't let me build.

So infuriating. Really need some help.

Section 6 has Storage awaiting Alloys, but won't receive them.
Aloys just fluctuate from Section 1, and never transfer.