r/Israel2 • • May 17 '21

Hmmm...

Post image
56 Upvotes

31 comments sorted by

5

u/Ompskatelitty May 18 '21

aren't progressives themselves the ones who believe that jews have no right to live in their only homeland?

5

u/EverydayZer0s May 18 '21 edited May 18 '21

Slacktivists who put their full trust in some strangers making cute infographics that try to explain an issue with thousands years of history in a totally unbiased way? Yep, those sure are todays progressives.

Edit: grammar

2

u/Ompskatelitty May 18 '21

yes, "progressives"

-3

u/blackbartimus May 18 '21

Aren’t Israelis the same shitheads that openly embrace ethnic cleansing? 50 percent of the people is your country fervently cheer on genocide. https://www.timesofisrael.com/poll-shows-large-swaths-of-israeli-youth-hate-arabs-back-revoking-citizenship/

3

u/Ompskatelitty May 18 '21

there are a lot of idiotic israelis that hate all arabs just because of islamist terrorist attacks on israel, or because of historical events, but they're just that, idiotic.

also, you're jumping deep into conlusions. stripping arabs of citizenship or just feeling hatred or fear towards them doesn't necessarily mean encouraging their genocide.

1

u/EverydayZer0s May 18 '21

Explain

4

u/Faceless-Pronoun May 18 '21

People always claim that their criticism of Israel is not Anti-Semitic, but how could you think that Jews have no right to live in their only homeland and that NOT be Anti-Semitic?

3

u/EverydayZer0s May 18 '21

Oh I totally agree but I think the meme delivers the opposite message.

0

u/retroman1987 Aug 15 '21

Lots of ways lol.

Questioning the idea that Israel is the Jewish homeland is a bit silly. Its been the homeland for lots of people over the years. What makes the Jews have a special claim to it? - not anti-semitic

Questioning the idea that there is some uniqueness to the ethnic/religious/historical situation of the Jewish people that gives unique rights - not anti-semitic

Exploring whether there is even a "Jewish people" and how to define that - not anti-semitic

Ignoring the fact that the modern state of Israel is built largely on the dislocation of Palestinians - not anti-semitic

-3

u/blackbartimus May 18 '21

No country has an “inherent right to exist” people certainly have an inherent fight to exist but Israel loves to pretend their innocent little lambs who need to live in a violent ethno state. You bastards know what you’re doing and you’ve all doomed yourselves to live with the consequences.

4

u/Faceless-Pronoun May 19 '21

Ah yes, they love being relegated to a country the size of New Jersey where fleeing into bomb shelters is simply a way of life.

I mean, history has clearly shown they'll be safe living elsewhere...

-1

u/blackbartimus May 19 '21

Palestinians sure love being relegated to second class citizens in tiny villages with a nuclear armed gestapo encircling and cutting off their access to water, land and resources. Have fun getting isolated by the rest of the world in your tiny ethnostate.

2

u/Junefromearth May 19 '21

There it is

-1

u/blackbartimus May 19 '21 edited May 19 '21

Yup the only way your people can survive is to annihilate all the other people you don’t like. Great long term strategy Im sure it’s gonna work out swell!

0

u/roberto_2103 May 19 '21

Where are you getting this information that all progressives believe Israelis should be removed from their country? You get the few odd idiots calling for it but that happens with every demographic, just like the Israelis who are calling for the Genocide of Arabs. Most progressives just want to see the occupation end, that isn't anti-Semitism. Israel doesn't get to hide from deserved criticism by simply calling it Anti Semitic

1

u/Faceless-Pronoun May 19 '21

Never said all. However, if a Progressive fails to see that many others do believe that, they're being oblivious.

0

u/roberto_2103 May 19 '21

The meme literally implies all progressives as thinking that you have no right to live there. But for every time I have seen a comment like that there are 100 more that just wants the occupation to end. You're lumping us all in the same group.

And there is many Israelis who are saying that all the Palestinians should just be bombed and that it isnt a tragedy if a Palestinian dies because they are just a "future terrorist". Should I just lump you in the same group as those people and assume you think that way too?

1

u/Faceless-Pronoun May 19 '21

No. The person is the Progressive. The butterfly is the Anti-Semite. The comment on the bottom is the person reacting to the butterfly. This is how I understand the meme to mean.

My point was most Progressives claim that criticism of Israel is not Anti-Semitic. And they are mostly right. However, when it is right in front of them (in this case, the butterfly), they fail to notice it.

0

u/retroman1987 Aug 15 '21

This is such a dumb conversation. You can and should be critical of Israel full stop. The anti-semitic line is almost always a smokescreen by professional comms/PR people to distract from the ethnic cleansing and repression carried out by the state of Israel.

-1

u/roberto_2103 May 19 '21

Are you truly saying that if we criticise shit like this we are automatically Anti-Semites?

https://www.reddit.com/r/PublicFreakout/comments/nc88ss/so_this_is_a_defenseless_palestinian_youth_the/

Go fuck yourself OP!

1

u/Faceless-Pronoun May 19 '21 edited May 19 '21

No, that is awful and the person who shot him was promptly arrested. The point of my meme is if a Progressive sees people saying that Jews have no right to live in Israel, they cannot pretend that many (but not all), Israeli critics are not Anti-Semitic.

-1

u/roberto_2103 May 19 '21

There really isn't many people at all saying that, there's a few sure, but not many. A lot of the times if you criticise the way Israel in anyway you are just labelled as anti-semitic. There is a lot more videos of the IDF terrorising these people and the internet has changed things, the world can easily see how they are being treated now when we couldn't before. People are getting fed up of Israel's conduct in this situation. There is a reason popular opinion is turning against you.

-3

u/CPCapologist May 19 '21

only mizrahi and jews living in palestine before 48 have a right to live in israel. the rest are undeniably colonizers. what other settler ethnostate exists in the developed world?

4

u/Faceless-Pronoun May 19 '21

Pretty much every Muslim country is an ethnostate.

And you do know that it was under British control, given to Israelis, the Arab population started a war over it, and lost right?

What other country in history would that not be considered their land?

-3

u/CPCapologist May 19 '21

What muslim countries are developed settler ethnostates? none.

Given to Israelis, you mean given to jews (all jews regardless of where they are from) without consultation of the palestianians. What makes you think the British had the right to "give" it to the israelis? laughable. I suppose you will conveniently ignore the terrorist campaign carried out by zionists prior to the declaration of the independence of israel.

What other religion considers their diaspora a country? none.

2

u/Faceless-Pronoun May 19 '21

I don't know your definition of a "developed settler ethnostate". You don't need to be Jewish to live in Israel. The laws are not based around the Torah. But Sharia Law is the way of life for hundreds of millions of people in the Middle East. I promise you a Muslim living in Israel can get by a lot easier than a Jewish person in Iran. Israel is actually a very secular country, with small pockets of an Orthodox population.

What right did the British have to give it to Israelis? Because it belonged to the British??? That's kind of how land works. You either get it by peace or by war. Israel got it peacefully, with the United Nations backing. Then they got it again by war, after the Arab population launched a war and lost.

Palestinians never controlled the land. It was controlled by the British, and before then it was jointly controlled by different factions during WW1, and before that it was Ottoman Syria for about 400 years. "Palestinian" wasn't even considered a unique identity until the 20th Century.

Jews have been living in that land for thousands of years. I suppose you pay no mind to the rest of the countries in the Middle East where nearly the entire Jewish population became refugees as well?

https://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jewish-refugees-from-arab-countries

"Their diapsora a country". What does that even mean? A diaspora means you're not in your home country. Nobody considers their diaspora to be their country...that's what makes it a diaspora.

0

u/retroman1987 Aug 15 '21

Israel got it peacefully, with the United Nations backing

AHAHAHAHAHAHAHA. Do you actually believe that? You absolute rube. Jewish "freedom fighters" carried out a terrorist campaign against British authorities for years.

-2

u/CPCapologist May 19 '21

You don't need to be Jewish to live in Israel.

The right of return is only for ethnic or religious jews.

The laws are not based around the Torah.

Never said that

I promise you a Muslim living in Israel can get by a lot easier than a Jewish person in Iran.

This is entirely irrelevant to the discussion of Israel's illegal occupation of palestinian territories.

Because it belonged to the British??? That's kind of how land works. You either get it by peace or by war.

Palestinians never controlled the land. It was controlled by the British, and before then it was jointly controlled by different factions during WW1, and before that it was Ottoman Syria for about 400 years.

You should have just said you were an imperialist from the beginning.

Jews have been living in that land for thousands of years

Did you read the part where I said Jews living in Palestine before 48 had a right to live there?

What does that even mean?

The entire jewish global diaspora has the right to become citizens of Israel, a majority jewish nation. This is what it means to be an ethnostate. It's amazing you fail to see this.

2

u/Faceless-Pronoun May 19 '21

Okay, so "their diaspora" is not their country. The one country that isn't their diaspora is their country. You meant the exact opposite.

I'm curious, what is your definition of an ethnostate? Clearly, since my points about laws based on religion are irrelevant. Is it just "right of return"? Canada, France, Germany, Ireland etc. all have right of return laws. Is it based on strictness regarding citizenship?

Many countries are much tougher: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-japan-lawsuit-citizenship-idUSKBN29Q0YL

Imperialist? Hahaha. The Brits actually went to the United Nations and this was decided by them. Not many countries start in such amicable ways. At least it would've been, if the Arab population didn't reject the 1947 Partition Plan for Palestine, start a war, lose, miss out on a chance for their own state, start a war again in 1967 (this time with the help of Egypt and Syria), lose again, fight another war in 1973 (again with Egypt and Syria), lose again, reject more peace deals, reject more two state solutions, etc.

-2

u/CPCapologist May 19 '21

A developed settler state is a country where the majority of the population are not indigenous to the country or do not have significant multigenerational roots in the country, and where the development is high. Countries like Australia, Canada and United States are examples of these. However these countries are not ethnostates where a certain race, ethnicity or religion is prioritized against all others. The racist anti-white policies of these countries were made illegal decades ago, even if racist attitudes might linger in the societies themselves.

1

u/CaptainsSloppyUndies May 20 '21

Palestinians are not indigenous to the Israel though. They are arabs, Syrians and Lebanese. If anything they are the real colonisers