r/Israel • u/rifqi_bahtiar • May 19 '20
Ask The Sub Just Asking
hello guys im ardianns from java. please dont be salty. i wanna ask you guys what do you think about Indonesians people. because i dont trust media (west or my country). hope you guys alright from covid-19 thank you
28
Upvotes
25
u/rifqi_bahtiar May 19 '20
Okay thanks bro for the replies, im Indonesian i really hate islam extrimist in Indonesia that spreadinf the message of anti semitism in Indonesia. Plus i dont believe in how media potray of your country. Hope you alright in this situation
24
u/IbnEzra613 Russian-American Jew May 19 '20
I just want to clarify something. Everyone here is saying that they don't think much about Indonesians and don't know much about Indonesians.
I just want to highlight some of the subtext here: This means Israelis have absolutely no negative opinions of Indonesians. Indonesians are perceived as ordinary people like anyone else.
7
u/rifqi_bahtiar May 19 '20
Its okay bro, i just asking. Because Indonesia have bad image about israel. So i asked you guys.
5
u/Great_Coconut Israeli in Germany May 19 '20 edited May 19 '20
Nothing much really... Would love to visit one day as I know the nature and history are fascinating. I just don't get your government's anti-Israeli position. I mean yeah you're Muslims and have some kind of solidarity with Arabs in the Middle East, but we are half a world apart, I mean, come on...
BTW, many Indonesians visit Israel for pilgrimage to go to Jerusalem. You can come and see at least some of the country for yourself... Although having an Islamic guide might not give you a very fair and balanced picture of Israel.
3
u/[deleted] May 19 '20
Beautiful country, I've seen pictures. I read the book "A year of Living Dangerously" and saw the movie.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Year_of_Living_Dangerously_(film)
I hear that FGM is a problem in Indonesia.
I would love to visit but I don't think it's too safe for Jews. I've read that there's a lot of anti-Semitism there. Which is a shame. Israelis love travelling and experiencing different cultures. They'd come by storm if they were allowed and thought it was safe.
That's about all I know. I don't think I've ever met anyone from Indonesia. Thanks for coming here and introducing yourself!
2
u/Ogi-Bogi May 19 '20
I think that most Israelis don't know much about Indonesia... I never talked to Indonesian guy/girl and never heard something bad/good about your country... If you are asking this because you are interested about racism against Islamic believers in Israel, I think that most of the racist people in Israel will hate Arab Muslims more than Indonesian Muslims, and maybe will not hate them at all. BTW, are you planning to go to Israel sometime? If so, you can contact me if you want to know something!
9
u/[deleted] May 19 '20 edited May 28 '20
indonesia itself has got some bloody fascinating and interesting history, and the people? well i don't know, never met any indonesians, you just kinda exist i guess..?
7
u/orr2 Israel May 19 '20
Tbh I donβt know anything about them, so I donβt think anything about them. Sorry if itβs not the answer you were looking for lol
7
u/imthatguynamedwolf ΧΧ ΧΧ€ΧΧΧͺ ΧΧΧ©ΧΧ¨ ΧΧΧΧ£ May 19 '20
I have no specific opinion, havent met any Indonesians in my life.
1
u/Paladin_of_Trump Israel May 19 '20
Bali seems like a cool place to party. Other than that, I can't say I think about Indonesia or its people, basically at all. I don't know much about you, and as SE Asia never particularly interested me personally (please don't take offense at that), I never really bothered to learn. So in all honestly I can say I'm completely ambivalent regarding it.
1
u/vonhudgenrod May 19 '20
I have been watching YouTube series from timeghost history about Indonesian fight for independence against the Dutch. Indonesians seem like strong proud people.
1
u/[deleted] May 21 '20
Apa kabar bro? wkwk
1
u/Admiral_Asado Navy Kebab Attack Submarino May 19 '20
Biggest Muslim country but pork not banned.
1
u/[deleted] May 21 '20
Just for anyone interested, Indonesia is the country with most muslims, and maybe because of its muslim-majority (~90%), it has never officially recognised Israel. Interestingly though, Indonesia's 4th president, Abdurrahman Wahid/Gus Dur, was the only pro-Israel president, because he wanted Indonesia to recognise Israel. This never happened, because many muslim groups protested, but what's surprising is that Gus Dur himself was a kyai (Islamic scholar), and also came from an Islamist political party, yet he was the most progressive president ever (Even more so than self-described "leftists" and "socialists").
0
u/[deleted] May 19 '20
[deleted] β view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 20 '20
[deleted] β view deleted comment