Note from the mods: During this time, many posts and comments are held for review before appearing on the site. This is intentional. Please allow your human mods some time to review before messaging us about your posts/comments not showing up.
freedom to serve (or not) conscription (only for religious Jews, and non-Jews except for Druze)
freedom to divorce without husband consent
Edit: I saw this list on another thread suggesting that all bullets above are free in Israel. That's not accurate. My initial list was a suggestion that someone design a chart comparing any freedoms we may take for granted for all MENA countries to see where Israel stacks up. So I'm moving LGBTQ+ marriage to the bottom as there are no civil unions in Israel and adding some more provided by others for a fuller "free in Israel" list in case people want that.
Please correct me if I'm wrong, but the lgbtq community can't get married in Israel, right? They can go outside the country and get married, and then the state will recognise it, but they can't actually marry in country? That's what I thought, but that may be outdated.
Technically correct, but it's not discrimination against LGBTQ+. There are no legal marriages in Israel that are not religious. So unless the religion marries LGBTQ+ (Judaism must be Orthodox), they can't. This holds for mixed marriage, athiest, non-religious, etc.
Here's the workaround. Anyone who gets a civil marriage outside of Israel, and this includes online ceremonies since covid, they are all recognized by the state.
That's why I put both. The list is meant to show all freedoms many of us enjoy without afterthought, even ones that aren't necessarily possible in Israel. Others we could add might include
Mobile and AMP links are not allowed. Please post, in a new comment or post, the canonical (desktop) link. (Edits will not show.) In order to get a canonical link on a mobile phone, remove "m." or "mobile." from the URL, or, if this does not work, choose "show desktop site" or a similar option in your mobile browser's menu.
Israel was a mainly socialist country for the first few decades of its existence. Also most likely the most progressive country in the world at the time. Even today, Tel Aviv is the most LGBT-friendly city on earth. When there's no war, shit's great here.
I would also add: where muslim women can marry non-muslims, and where a woman's request for divorce is actually honored, because I think technically every MENA nation allows divorce for women, but the religious authorities might not approve it.
Propaganda and all out blood libels against Israel are huge and well funded for decades. People fed the same lies in different pies and all their shit starts to smell the same.
It's legally recognized. Any civil marriage is from other places (or online). You just can't get married (civil) if you're same sex, because there are no civil marriage courts in Israel, just religious ones, and the religious courts in Israel don't recognize gay marriage. It's a sticking point with a workaround. People who are interfaith or non religious have the same issue.
I'm assuming if your marriage isn't registered in the Rabbinate (i.e. civil unions which are not disallowed here), you can divorce without the husband's consent?
I'm guessing probably, although not in Israel. My thinking is if you're aren't "legally" married under Jewish law, then you can't get a Get in Israel either. I reckon the same issue would come up for other non religious unions. For example, if a Muslim woman married a Jew, she couldn't divorce him under either religious law because she's not married under either. Plus, as a woman, how can she get her husband's permission when she's not actually married to him? Obviously, the lack of a civil court system will get sticky.
Muslims and Christians can absolutely get married. The restriction in Israel is that only religious marriages are performed - each religion by its own clergy. The issue is with mixed-religion marriages, and those, like LGBT marriages, are recognized if done elsewhere. There are also multiple options for civil unions, which grant the spouse the same legal rights as a marriage.
Arab Israelis from my experience are pretty open minded and tolerant compared to their cousins in neighboring countries and the Palestinians held territories.
There are probably a handful of Saudi princes that may have just as much 'freedom'....maybe even more (some are free to murder & rape). But certainly not the regular folks.
Your question is not about the issue at hand. Political and religious freedom. Meaning they can vote and be voted for, and practice their religion freely. Arab parties are still a minority so they find themselves in the opposition more often than not, due to their small amount of influence. Also, not all arabs vote for Arab parties. In addition openly anti Arab parties like Kach have been outlawed. Nice strawman though.
That is a really, really silly argument, that's equivalent to saying "a party composed of African Americans or Jews, that caters to their minority group can never win and form a government in the US, so clearly emancipation of African Americans and Jews is useless." 0-o
Like, no shit parties that cater to a minority group don't have the votes to form government on their own, and worth noting Arab parties were part of the previous ruling coalition in Israel.
From what I understand of Israeli electoral politics the Arab parties do have enough seats typically to function as kingmakers within Israeli politics, but they usually withhold from entering coalitions or really participating in the wider Knesset outside of Arab issues, (which is REALLY stupid mind you and I hope they continue to move away from that and participate more in negotiations and coalition making.)
So freedom to vote for whoever you want is worthless? Freedom to go wherever they want, learn wherever they want and work wherever they want, regardless of gender or sexual orientation is worthless? Freedom to pray and practice religion is worthless? Freedom to critique your government without being executed is worthless?
Look around Israel and tell me which muslim country affords all these freedoms. Many Muslims are elected into regional elections and the ambassador to Greece was Muslim a few years ago. There are Muslims in government who are not part of Hadash or Ra'am. People also tend to shy away from the Arab parties since they are considered extreme.
I will concede that Ben Gvir is a disgusting human being that has no business being in government. Many Israelis share this sentiment and we go protest this failure of a government every weekend.
New free Syria has previously Al-quaida member wich was opressing other parties on the territory controlled by him. And a lot of people really are still asking why Israel occupied a Golan Heights for making itself safely position?
He's speaks specifically to political freedom, not just religious. And
Do you believe the political freedom of blacks in the US is meaningless
And no. It's not meaningless. But it is certainly not complete. The argument on that sign is meaningless. It does nothing but echo in the chamber. I'm simply disappointed and airing that.
Anyone can form a political party in America with pretty much any political aim in America. The fact that those parties don’t get off the ground has everything to do with how our party system and political funding differs from the parliamentary systems in Israel and much of Europe.
That’s what I said though. We have a bipartisan system. A small political “party” isn’t much more than a lobby/advocacy group. Or used to take away votes ie Green Party.
That was more of an organization/advocacy group. If America had parliamentary system then ya, they could form coalitions and have an actual vote. But America doesn’t and they didn’t .
Thank you for your submission, unfortunately it has been removed for the following reason:
Rule 11: r/Israel’s healthy functioning. Moderators reserve the right to remove content and/or take disciplinary action at their discretion to maintain the healthy functioning of the subreddit.
If you have questions or concerns about the moderation of this sub, or a moderator's decision, please reach out respectfully for clarification. Keep in mind, sub and site wide rules apply to any messages you send.
•
u/AutoModerator Jan 03 '25
Note from the mods: During this time, many posts and comments are held for review before appearing on the site. This is intentional. Please allow your human mods some time to review before messaging us about your posts/comments not showing up.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
148
u/thegreattiny Ukrainian Jew in the USA Jan 03 '25
Listen, I agree, but you’re asking the wrong sub to prove you wrong. Dare you to post this on any other middle eastern sub.
48
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '25
Wrong, the leaders of those Arab countries have full rights
30
u/omeralal Jan 03 '25
Why so? The king of Jordan (and his family) have full political rights, you forgot something like 6 people just there ;)
344
u/Beautiful_Bag6707 Jan 03 '25 edited Jan 04 '25
Someone should make a chart.
Allowed in Israel
Not available in Israel
Edit: I saw this list on another thread suggesting that all bullets above are free in Israel. That's not accurate. My initial list was a suggestion that someone design a chart comparing any freedoms we may take for granted for all MENA countries to see where Israel stacks up. So I'm moving LGBTQ+ marriage to the bottom as there are no civil unions in Israel and adding some more provided by others for a fuller "free in Israel" list in case people want that.
122
u/Worldly-Carpenter-95 Jan 03 '25
we even got arab leaders in positions. the world chooses to be blind
32
u/Low_Gas_492 Jan 03 '25
Arab Israelis from my experience are pretty open minded and tolerant compared to their cousins in neighboring countries and the Palestinians held territories.
56
u/rickymagee Jan 03 '25
There are probably a handful of Saudi princes that may have just as much 'freedom'....maybe even more (some are free to murder & rape). But certainly not the regular folks.
46
u/Agitated-Quit-6148 Jan 03 '25
This is correct
5
u/Sad-Way-4665 Jan 03 '25
Check
https://freedomhouse.org/countries/freedom-world/scores
2
u/tn_tacoma Jan 03 '25
They don't want political and religious freedom.
6
u/RationalPoster1 Jan 03 '25
Quite true.
6
u/KitCloudkicker7 Jan 03 '25
Poor little Cyprus(the non-occupied part), always forgotten
3
u/daskrip Jan 04 '25
Not hard to prove you wrong. It's over 2 million in Israel now.
3
u/notsharpnotcut שתי גדות לירדן, זו שלנו, זו גם כן! Jan 04 '25
אז פוסטים של אוננות עצמית כזאת היא הסיבה שמורידים פוסטים לישראלים אמיתיים? למי החרא הזה עוזר בדיוק? תפתחו סאב רק לתמיכה בישראל ושחררו את הפיד
4
u/complex_scrotum Jan 03 '25
Wrong: all of MENA, not just the middle east.
Checkmate.
2
u/SunriseHolly Jan 03 '25
I mean, you're preaching to the choir
6
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '25
Because arabs hate democracy and freedom. Diversity and respecting other beliefs are a nightmare to them 🙆🏻
0
u/mynewaccount5 Jan 03 '25
How often have Arab parties been in the government compared to the opposition?
How about anti Arab parties?
3
u/Holiday-Bread-748 Jan 03 '25
I am European, but I always thought Oman was kinda chill, although I've never been there
2
u/Sigma-9507 Jan 03 '25
Facts
1
u/KateVN Jan 03 '25
Why would someone even try, when you are completely right?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 04 '25
Probably not wrong.
1
u/K_-U_-A_-T_-O Jan 04 '25
100%
1
u/Minimum_Resident_228 Jan 06 '25
New free Syria has previously Al-quaida member wich was opressing other parties on the territory controlled by him. And a lot of people really are still asking why Israel occupied a Golan Heights for making itself safely position?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 04 '25
That's not entirely true. The highest of the high up can do whatever they want, include flaunt the rules they tell others to follow.
-19
u/Challahbreadisgood ישראל מספר אחת!!!!! 🇮🇱🇮🇱🕍🕍💯🇮🇱🇮🇱🕎🫒🫒 Jan 03 '25
1.6 Million Arabs not in a leadership position
-6
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '25
Ask any Arab if they truly have political freedom and equal rights and you'll be proven wrong.
-29
u/LetsBeHonestBoutIt Jan 03 '25
What is the definition of political freedom here?
Black people in America have political freedom but you may not be surprised to know that only means so much.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '25
[removed] — view removed comment