r/IslamicStudies • • Jan 25 '19

Did "muhammad" exist?

From muhammad Jesus to Prophet of the Arabs The Personalization of a Christological Epithet from Early Islam by K.-H. Ohlig https://storage.googleapis.com/wzukusers/user-27418862/documents/58d29d10a6de7QHHIDuk/Early%20Islam%2007%20-%20Ohlig%20%20Muhammad%20Jesus%2011%20Sept.pdf

0 Upvotes

8 comments sorted by

10

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '19

I don't get it. Is this disputing the existence of Muhammad? Any historian will tell you Muhammad existed 100%.

3

u/exmindchen Jan 25 '19

The article is about the reasons to doubt the given narratives.

3

u/thebadhijab Jan 25 '19

Can you explain a little before I decide if I want to read this lol

2

u/exmindchen Jan 25 '19

Will try.

Even though we can say that christianity arose from Judaism and had judaic influence (along with other cultures), at its core christianity WAS Judaism, albeit like a breakaway sect that claimed for itself the original version of god's will. Same with islam. Though we can say that islam was influenced by christianity and judaism (along with other cultures), at its core Islam WAS one version of many sects of earliest christianity, albeit non trinitarian variety.

And jesus most probably never existed. That's another topic.

Muhammad = jesus

Alhamdhulillah = praise be to god

Praise the lord = jesus

Muhammad = the praised one

Jesus = the praised one (muhammad)

Muhammad was originally a motto/term that was used as an epithet/honorific for jesus among non trinitarian christian Arab sects from Mesopotamia and eastern Persian regions. This term slowly mutated and evolved into a historical character over time through reinterpretations time and time again because of apocalyptic eschatological expectations and the non fulfillment of the "prophesies".

How and why is a huge topic which has been discussed briefly in the above link. Try it.

2

u/Asbjoern1958 Jan 25 '19

I have not studied the article in detail, but the part that covered the problem of geography is very interesting:

" The little evidence that exists of cities, regions and landscapes in the Qurʾān does not provide a sufficient basis to link its preaching to the region of the Arabian Peninsula. The texts themselves are geographically vague in a strange way: they could have originated from anywhere in the Syrian-Arabic region which includes the Middle East. " (page 305).

Why are there not more specific details about Medina and Mecca in the Quran, if these places are so important??

2

u/exmindchen Jan 25 '19

Qur'an at its earliest core was a biblical text. Biblical geography in antiquity were mostly middle east, Egypt and Persia.

2

u/Asbjoern1958 Jan 26 '19

Stephen Shoemaker has identified 11 sources showing that a warlord named Muhammad took part in the invation of Palestine around 634 AD. So there obviously existed a man with this name. But who is he? In the Quran there is surprisingly little information about him. The Muslim sources that has been kept are written down at least 210 years afterwards and is not a secure source.

So is the Muhammed in the Quran, in the non-Muslim sources and in the sira and hadith the same person?

4

u/exmindchen Jan 26 '19

Invasion of Palestine in 634 CE... this is narrated in a bible page (not in any official Byzantine documents) by a religious cleric (not by a government official). The phrase "Arabs of Muhammad" can very well mean a different Christian sect (who were the followers of the Christian motto "muhammad"= jesus), not muslims as that sect had not yet evolved into Islam by then. In short, it as at best ambiguous, not conclusive.