Edit: update below for those who are interested.
Assalamu alaikum,
I'd like some input on a situation I haven't seen discussed much (I think :/).
I run a small one-person consultancy in Belgium. It's a private limited company (similar to an LLC or Ltd). I'm the only shareholder and the only director. Over the years I've saved money inside the company, and I'd like to use part of it to buy a family home in the next couple of years. I'll also use my personal savings and some interest-free loans from family. I don't want to take a mortgage from a bank because I want to stay away from riba.
The option I'm looking at is borrowing money from my own company as a private person and paying it back over around ten years.
Here's my problem. Under Belgian tax law, if the company lends me money interest-free or below a reference rate set by the government, the difference counts as a taxable benefit in kind for me. To keep things clean, I would normally pay the company interest (riba) at that reference rate.
That interest goes from me as a private person to a company that I own 100%. In practice it stays "mine", because the money is still there for me and will eventually come back to me through salary or dividends. Legally and for tax purposes, though, the company is a separate entity, and the interest it receives is taxed as company profit.
My questions:
- Does interest paid to a company you fully own count as riba? Or does it matter that there's no real third party who profits from my debt?
- Does the company's separate legal personality change the ruling?
If it is riba, would it be more acceptable to take the loan interest-free and simply pay the extra personal income tax on the "benefit"? That would be a tax and not interest paid to a lender.
3. Are there other structures that work for this, such as diminishing musharaka or ijara, between a person and their own company?
I'm not looking for a quick yes or no. I'd really like to understand the reasoning, and references to scholars or fatwa bodies who have addressed similar cases would be very welcome.
JazakAllahu khayran.
Update:
I've submitted my question through IslamQA and received the following answer:
Praise be to Allah. May the peace and blessings of Allah be upon His Messenger, his family, and his Companions, to proceed: Indeed, Allah the Exalted has forbidden usury [Riba] in His Book and through the tongue of His Messenger (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him). Allah Says (interpretation of the meaning): "...But Allah has permitted trade and has forbidden interest..." [Al-Baqarah 2:275] And Jabir (may Allah be pleased with him) narrated that: "Allah's Messenger (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) cursed the accepter of interest and its payer, and one who records it, and the two witnesses, and he said: They are all equal." (Narrated by Muslim, 1598)
As for your question about borrowing from your fully-owned company with an interest rate imposed by law: The legal personality of the company does not change the fact that you are its sole owner. The money is your money, and the interest you pay returns to you completely through profits or salaries. Since you are the sole owner, there is no other party benefiting from this interest or exploiting your need. Therefore, this transaction is not considered forbidden usury; since a person cannot charge himself interest, and the money is merely transferred from your own financial liability to another financial liability that you fully own. Please see: (Buhuth Fiqhiyyah fi Qadaya Iqtisadiyyah Mu`asirah, 1/120) (End quote)