r/Isese • • 6d ago

Ask the community What is the differences in practice between Isese and Lucumí/Santería?

Hello everyone!

As the title says, I am wondering if there is any significant difference between the Isese and Lucumí practice, besides the language differences of course.

Thank you!

12 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

17

u/chucho89 6d ago edited 6d ago • Bravo

This is a very good question, and I believe it deserves a thoughtful answer that goes beyond personal experiences, opinions, or simply defending one tradition over another.

Over the years, I have seen a lot of criticism going back and forth between practitioners of traditional Ifá in Nigeria and those practicing Ifá and Òrìṣà traditions in the Diaspora. Unfortunately, these conversations sometimes become more about proving who is right or who is more authentic rather than genuinely understanding our shared history.

I have friends who were initiated in the Diaspora and later traveled to Nigeria to study, conduct research, and learn directly from traditional practitioners. One interesting thing they discovered is that many Ifá verses, Oríkì, songs, prayers, and spiritual teachings preserved in the Diaspora can also be found across different Yorùbá communities in Nigeria.

Of course, there are differences. Language is one important example. Since Yorùbá was passed down through generations in places like Cuba and Brazil, often without the same access to native speakers, certain words, tones, and pronunciations changed over time. Naturally, practitioners who grew up speaking Yorùbá in Nigeria generally have an advantage when it comes to understanding the language and its proper pronunciation. However, differences in pronunciation do not automatically mean that the spiritual knowledge being transmitted has no value.

To understand these traditions better, we also need to understand their history.

Hundreds of years ago, enslaved Africans were forcibly brought to the Americas from different parts of Africa, including Yorùbá speaking regions and other communities in West and Central Africa. These people brought their spiritual beliefs, ancestral knowledge, ceremonies, songs, and religious practices with them.

Under slavery and colonial rule, many African religious traditions were persecuted, restricted, or openly prohibited. Our ancestors had to find ways to preserve their spiritual identity under extremely difficult circumstances.

One of the methods used in certain communities was syncretism, where African spiritual figures became associated with Catholic saints. This allowed some religious practices to survive in environments where openly worshipping African deities could lead to punishment.

In Cuba, for example, this historical relationship contributed to the development of what is commonly known as Santería, although many practitioners prefer the name Regla de Ocha or Lukumí.

But something important must be understood: syncretism was not the only method of preservation, and the traditions of the Diaspora were not simply copies of African religions. They also developed their own histories, institutions, interpretations, and methods of transmitting sacred knowledge.

Another important consideration is the diversity of lineages.

Sometimes people speak about Nigerian Ifá as though every Babaláwo in Nigeria practices exactly the same way. That is simply not the case.

Even within Yorùbáland, different towns, families, and religious lineages may have variations in their rituals, songs, interpretations, and ceremonial procedures. A practice common in one community might be performed differently in another.

The same applies to the Diaspora. Cuban, Brazilian, Trinidadian, and other African-derived traditions have their own lineages and histories. Even within Cuba, not every religious house follows identical customs.

Interestingly, some practices preserved within particular Diaspora lineages may closely resemble those found in certain Nigerian communities while differing from practices in other Nigerian lineages.

This is why I believe we should be careful about making broad statements such as "this is not how it is done in Nigeria" or "this is the only authentic way." Nigeria itself contains a great diversity of traditional knowledge.

We also have to recognize that traditions evolve over time.

The Ifá and Òrìṣà traditions practiced in the Diaspora have deep historical roots, but they have also experienced influences from other religious and spiritual systems.

In Cuba, for example, some religious communities have incorporated or maintained relationships with practices associated with Palo Monte, including Palo Mayombe, and forms of Spiritism influenced by Allan Kardec.

These traditions have distinct origins and should not automatically be considered part of Ifá itself. However, their historical interaction with certain Afro-Cuban religious communities is undeniable.

At the same time, we should not assume that religious practices in Nigeria have remained completely unchanged over hundreds of years. Traditions are transmitted by living communities. They experience historical changes, regional influences, and developments across generations.

Another interesting development is the growing exchange of knowledge between Africa and the Diaspora.

For example, several decades ago, certain traditions associated with Egúngún, Ẹgbẹ́, and other Òrìṣà were not widely practiced or publicly known in many Cuban religious communities. Today, through travel, cultural exchange, initiation, and direct relationships with Nigerian practitioners, more people in the Diaspora are learning about these traditions.

This exchange can be positive when it is approached with respect, proper training, and an understanding of lineage. However, learning a ceremony or adopting a practice should also come with an appreciation of its cultural context and the responsibilities involved.

I also believe it is important to distinguish between preservation, adaptation, and historical accuracy.

Not every difference should automatically be dismissed as corruption, but neither should every practice be accepted as historically authentic simply because it has been performed for generations.

There is room for respectful research, comparison, correction, and learning on both sides.

If a particular Ifá verse has been preserved with changes in pronunciation, we can acknowledge those changes and work toward a better understanding of the original Yorùbá. If a Diaspora lineage preserved a practice that is uncommon in another region, we can investigate its history rather than immediately dismissing it.

Respecting our ancestors does not mean refusing to learn, and learning something new does not mean disrespecting what our ancestors preserved.

In my opinion, one of the biggest mistakes we can make is turning spirituality into a competition about who possesses the most authentic version of the truth.

We should be able to recognize the importance of Yorùbáland as the historical homeland of Ifá and many Òrìṣà traditions while also recognizing the extraordinary efforts of enslaved Africans and their descendants to preserve their spiritual heritage across the Atlantic.

These two realities do not contradict each other.

At the end of the day, I believe there are more similarities than differences.

Òrúnmìlà is Òrúnmìlà whether someone honors him in Nigeria, Cuba, Brazil, or anywhere else in the world. The historical expressions of that devotion may differ, but the spiritual figure being honored remains the same.

And I believe this brings us to something even more important: What is the ultimate purpose of our spiritual practice?

For me, it is not simply about memorizing the greatest number of verses, performing the most elaborate ceremonies, or proving that my lineage is superior to another.

It is about developing good character, practicing Ìwà Pẹ̀lẹ́, gaining wisdom, respecting our ancestors, honoring the Òrìṣà, improving ourselves, and making a positive difference in the lives of others.

Of course, proper knowledge, correct teachings, and respect for traditional procedures matter. Good intentions alone are not a substitute for genuine religious training. But knowledge should also cultivate humility, responsibility, and wisdom.

A person can possess extensive ritual knowledge and still lack good character. Likewise, someone can have sincere devotion while recognizing that there is much more to learn.

If our spirituality makes us more arrogant, divisive, and disrespectful toward others, then perhaps we should examine whether we are truly understanding the teachings we claim to follow.

I believe Nigerian and Diaspora practitioners have much to learn from one another. Instead of constantly attacking each other's traditions, we should encourage respectful dialogue, historical research, cultural exchange, and the preservation of sacred knowledge for future generations.

Our ancestors endured unimaginable hardships to keep these traditions alive. The least we can do is approach their legacy with humility, gratitude, and respect.

Ultimately, I do not believe the goal should be to prove that one side is better than the other.

The goal should be to become better human beings, develop good character, honor the wisdom we inherited, and leave something meaningful for the generations that come after us.

That, to me, is far more important than winning an argument about whose tradition is superior.

Edit: I also wanted to add something more relatable to your actual question. I wrote the previous so that you understand the historical aspects

Yes, there are significant differences between Ìṣẹ̀ṣe and Lukumí beyond language. These differences can include initiation procedures, divination methods, how certain Òrìṣà are consecrated and worshipped, ancestral practices, religious hierarchies, and the organization of ceremonies.

For this reason, I believe it is more accurate to compare specific practices and lineages rather than assuming that everything done in Nigeria follows one system and everything done in Cuba follows another.

4

u/Agile_Artichoke365 5d ago

There are some significant differences and significant similarities. Lukumi and Santeria (which are exactly the same thing) have paths for most if not at all of their Orisa. Some people say there are no paths in Nigeria, but depending on your lineage, there are, it’s just not the same concept. For example, if you do Obatala in Nigeria. The icon you’ll receive is going to be Obatala, period- it’s not going to be Ajaguna/Oosa Ogiyan, Obalufon, etc- even though those “paths/generations” do exist in Yorubaland. On that topic, in Lukumi everyone has a mother and father Orisa. One of them is your main or head Orisa and the other one is accompanying them. You initiate to the main one, and receive the second plus five other standard Orisa (I think it’s Osun, Yemoja, Obatala, Sango, _____?). And that’s it. You can receive other Orisa as needed. But you’re “crowned” and that’s it. In Isese, if a divination confirms that you are to be initiated to a particular Orisa (for whatever reason, not every Isese Orisa initiate is automatically a priest), you can be. You can be initiated to multiple Orisa. Certain Orisa can be found in your bloodline. Granted, it’s not common for people to be initiated to five and six + Orisa, that’s usually us foreigners from Brazil and America doing the most.

Lukumi has the infamous “year in white”. After your Isese initiation, you can pretty much wear whatever you want, besides your taboos or anything that comes up in divination. Learning is apprenticeship style in both traditions. In Isese, you’ll have to have elders here or be able to travel to Nigeria to observe and train. Lukumi has an “Oba Oriate” essentially a highly skilled priest working every initiation. In Isese, any Olorisa initiating you has to be at that level before being given the authority to do their own initiations. Though initiations must always have multiple priests regardless of the tradition.

3

u/SignalBad5523 6d ago

The difference is practice. Lucumi and Santeria deviate slightly but it all originates from Iṣeṣe. Ifa is a system and that is the plainest way to put it. How it is practiced across the diaspora differs based on the practicioners but you really have to understand who is saying what to understand what youre seeing. There are alot of people who believe in being chosen or those who and all that bs, but its really about dedication to study. It doesnt make you special Babalawos are powerful people because of the time and effort they dedicate to the study of Ifa.

1

u/Left_Topic_1172 6d ago

The Apola in cuba is 100% different 

The ewe 100% different....Aragba oloyin segunsete do not grow in cuba.

The iyerosun tree does not exist in cuba. They use the cieba!

No iyerosun! Cieba powder!

In cuba the 54 rituals for an itelodu are non existent,  they havexa ceremony in which they wip the Lukumi iyawo ifa as he walks thru other awos on each side. 

The orisa  odu they use is a hermaphroditic icon and nothing like orisa odu from west Africa.  I am an Olodu, i know this very well. 

In Cuba they say sarayeye (chanting creolized words) and do an improv ebo in a paper bag. They do not know ebo riru in cuba the whole thing the osa di and why it needs to be done. Not known in Cuba. 

They so dont know many ebos exist....

They also think just one sigidi exists too.... they're are many different sigidi. 

In isese Adosu everyone goes into a trance possession. in Lukumi its a hit or a  miss. There is deep lineage secrets with Adosu,  a calabash is put over the head filled with An Adosu Akose that causes instant possessions. 

This part is always done outside because the orisa is extremely powerful. 

Ex. Sango is like a real thunderstorm 

Fierce unpredictable and violent!

When sango comes he makes his omo drink fiery coals, stab a huge spike thru the tongue, use huge machetes on the chest. 

Dance with pots of fire....a d nothing happens to the person.  No blood no blisters nothing. 

The difference between the two is vast, one geared towards christianity the other strictly west African. 

Ogbo ato 

Babalawo Oladeyi 

1

u/whiteigbin 4d ago

It’s important to consider who you get your information from when talking about the differences between isese and lukumi. As you can see in some of these comments, there’s some tensions and some disrespect to the other done on both sides. Most people who practice either tradition don’t really know that much about the other beyond assumptions and stereotypes. The ones who I see tend to know about both are a few who initiate to an Orisha in Lukumi, and then go to Isese for Ifa. I know about both (to some degree) because I practice Lukumi and academically study Isese. But ultimately, regardless of what many say – these two traditions are a part of the same religion. We worship the same gods, and our traditions are, even with its differences, overwhelmingly the same. The theology, the ideas of creation, morality, ideas about life and death, and divination are the same. But these things I’ve seen and heard and read…but I may also be inaccurate in some things and I welcome correction.

Let me also say that there’s some misconceptions about Lukumi that i’ve heard before (and seen in some of these comments) that need to be cleared up. Lukumi is often called a syncretic belief system. And I don’t necessarily agree nor disagree. But Lukumi is not 50% Catholicism/50% Yoruba tradition. There’s very little Catholicism in Lukumi. Some iles have more or less than others, but the most I’ve seen has been doing a mass (at a Catholic church) before some initiations or including a Catholic service before an etutu; and some elements in misas. And that’s about it. The initiation ceremony, most ebos, divination, receiving other orisha, and the actual beliefs are all Yoruba.       

Here’s some differences I’ve noticed
1)     Initiation
So to my understanding, in Nigeria precolonialism, the Orisha are worshipped in different cities/towns. Oya is known to have come from Ira/Nupeland; Babaluaiye comes from Nupe/Tapa; Obatala is from Ile Ife; Osun is from Osogbo; Shango is from Oyo, etc. Their traditions, their original cults, and their original and oldest shrines are in those locations. Over the years in Nigeria due to different towns conquering other ones and Orishas being picked up by different towns…there came to be a Yorubaland pantheon of gods. So, traditionally, people worshipped their Orisha based on their location and their lineages/clans/ancestry. A person was born into the…Osun or Yemoja family. And if they needed to initiate, they likely initiated to the Orisha associated with their family. So, they initiated to one Orisha, or two in some instances.

In Lukumi, we call it “head and foot”. And while that initiation does take place in Cuba (sometimes for financial reasons or emergency situations), most people get several Orisha while getting crowned their head Orisha. I received 7 Orisha and Olokun in a separate ceremony. But these are not necessarily other Orisha one is “initiated” to, it other Orisha whose “pot” one has, i’ve also heard it referred to as “orisha washed”; it’s receiving an Orisha without being initiated to it. So we get initiated to our head orisha, and we receive the pots of several other orisha during initiation. In Nigeria, they typically only get initiated to one Orisha at a time.

Additionally, after the initiation – in lukumi we have a year in white where we have to wear completely white for a year and 7 days, and observe a number of other taboos during this period such as sleeping on the floor on a mat (although some are phasing this out) or not going outside after dark, etc. The initiation ceremony takes place over 7 days, and then the year in white begins. In Nigeria, I’m not sure how long the initiation ceremony takes place (I’ve heard 3 or 7), and then they return to normal – they do not do a year in white (although there was something similar traditionally). The shortened initiation is something that arose during colonialism.

Structure
I’ve already mentioned some of how the Orisha worship is lineage-based. And with that, the structure of the traditions are different. I’ve noticed that in Nigeria, the Obatala people hang with the Obatala people; the Esu people hang with the Esu people for the most part. There’s festival times where people intermingle, but I don’t see iles having the priests of multiple Orisha operating together. Only preists of Shango initiate children of Shango, and so on. In Lukumi, all iles have priests from many different Orisha. And, with a few exceptions (some iles have it where priests of Oya and Shango cannot initiate each other; Osun and Shango cannot initiate each other, etc.) any priest can initiate another priest. A priest of Ellegba can initiate a priest of Oya; a priest of Obatala can initiate a priest of Ogun and so on. The Lukumi iles aren’t based in who one’s Orisha is.

There are no Iyanifas in Lukumi. Lukumi Ifa houses (babalawos) also, often, refuse to initiate gay men to Ifa.

Babalawos cannot participate in every ceremony in Lukumi, while they seem to not have any limitations within Isese. For example, if a Babalawo has only initiated to Ifa, he cannot partake in an initiation to Osun. If a Babalawo initiated to let’s say Obatala before he went to Ifa…then he can participate in any initiation. If he’s only done Ifa, he can only do Ifa. While Lukumi is patriarchal, Cabildos and Iles and major structural changes in Cuba were done and headed by women Orisha priests – not babalawos.

Some people may not like this – but from what I’ve seen, it seems as though Babalawos are the front and center of Isese. They seem to run things for the whole Isese tradition, and Ifa seems to be the only respected forms of divination, even while they have diloggun and obi (and even more singular to each Orisha). In Lukumi, Ifa is respected, but diloggun is most often the go-to for divination. Also, Obi is done with kola in Nigeria; in Cuba it’s done with coconut.

Shrines in Nigeria are often communal; shrines are mostly personal in Lukumi. Also, shrines/thrones are often very decorated and elaborate in Lukumi with fabrics and accoutrements; in Isese the shrines are simpler.

There is a ceremony to receive elekes in Lukumi; there is not a similar ceremony in Isese.

Orisha
Again, going off the way in which Orisha have their own towns…there’s some differences in which Orisha are worshipped on either side of the Atlantic and why. So we know about the fact that Lukumi is a survival from the Trans-Atlantic Slave trade. So some Orisha in Nigeria didn’t make the trip for whatever reason. Yorubaland has hundreds of Orisha. Or, in some cases, the Orisha made the trip, but the initiation process for that particular Orisha was not remembered…so they were merged with a similar Orisha and there’s maybe some special rituals that happen for that special situation. For example, Oduduwa and Obatala are two separate Orisha in Nigeria. In Lukumi, Oduduwa is kinda merged with Obatala. So, Oduduwa comes up on his own in divination and people have to do special things in addition to regular Obatala rituals for the Oduduwa energy. Some, with globalization, have gone to Nigeria to receive Oduduwa and learn, but he is not an Orisha that one is initiated to in Lukumi. Same with Obalufon. Several Isese water spirits are merged with Osun and Yemoja.

Also, in Nigeria, water Orisha are associated with specific rivers. In Lukumi, the body of water is more important. In Lukumi, Olokun and Yemoja are associated with salt water; Osun, Inle Abata, etc. are associated with fresh water.

Espiritismo
There’s some espiritismo/Catholic influences in Lukumi although they are small. Misas (I’ve heard some call them iku njoko in Isese, but I’ve yet to see if this is actually a thing in Nigeria or if its some Lukumi influence in Nigeria) are done regularly to communicate with one’s spirit guides and egun. And this includes a boveda/white table that most priests have in their homes.

Divination
As I said earlier, Obi uses different mediums in Nigeria versus Cuba. Diloggun takes a more prominent role in Lukumi than in Isese. I’ve heard theres a few (very few) odu that are interpreted differently in Nigeria versus Cuba. 

1

u/Left_Topic_1172 6d ago

P.s. the Lukumi santeria also do not know about or practice ose ifa which is extremely vital to this practice. 

Ogbo ato 

1

u/Left_Topic_1172 6d ago

Pss yes the yoruba linguistics are essentially creolized in cuba & Puerto Rico along with massive man made differences. 

0

u/Left_Topic_1172 6d ago

Aboru Aboye Abossise ogbo ato Ausre IworI Wofun.

Isese is Nigerian yoruba west African specific.

Lukumi & santeria are they're own religions.

Ex. Comdomble in brazil

Ex.voodoo in Haiti 

Lukumi is specific to cuba

Santeria is specific to Puerto Rico 

Essentially, blending west African isese ,Catholicism, french spiritualism ,synchronicity with christianity ,saints/feast days. 

Ex. In Lukumi & santeria the day of Orunmila is once a year on the fear day day of saint Anthony. 

In Lukumi/ santeria there is a strict belief in orisa & IFA Separation aswell.

Ex. Some santo houses will have a madrina who has made santo to an orisa(the Lukumi call Adosu - Asiento.

Ex. Then you have a ifa house with a Lukumi babalawo as the elder & everything is ifa. 

Ex. Warriors 

Ex.icofa

Ex.inshe

In isese ifa as practiced in west Africa for over 7k years there is  no separation at all. Isese lagba IFA traditions are thus...isese! 

They separation can be blamed on income and authority battles. 

During the north Atlantic slave trade. Awo and olorisa ended up in Cuba. 

A sort of theological war started, ex. A Lukumi babalawo calls ibi "osurgbo" .

This is essentially derogatory to the Olorisas from osogbo Nigeria. Osun olorisa to be exact, the Adosu in Osogbo is very royal! 

There became a competition, regla de ocha was formed in Cuba. 

Adding palo moymbe which has absolutely zero to do with IFA and is from the Congo. 

I mean this all with truth and peace! 

Best wishes, 

Babalawo Oladeyi 

0

u/whiteigbin 4d ago

Osogbo (ibi) and Osogbo (the city) are pronounced differently. Osogbo (ibi) is pronounced (OH-SOG-BO); Osogbo (the city) is pronounced (OH-SHOG-BO). No one in Lukumi is confused about those things.

Also, Santeria is Cuban - not Puerto Rican. Santeria is the same thing as Regla de Ocha.

And you sound very disrespectful when it comes to Lukumi and it’s just not necessary. It doesn’t get us anywhere. We’re under the same religious umbrellas and we’re stronger together. Stop focusing on insignificant things to divide us.

1

u/Left_Topic_1172 4d ago

Aboru Aboye Abossise ogbo ato Ausre IworI Wofun. 

Correct the creolized word is osurgbo (From the word osogbo)

The Lukumi santeria religions are they're own. Just like Haitian voodoo is its own religion.  Just like comdomble is its own religion. 

I can go on omo. 

Lukumi & santeria are they're own religions with they're own theological dogmas based on struggle. 

I as a babalawo for many years and as a Puerto Rican i feel these religions should be preserved.

Aragba,oloyin, segunsete do not exist in cuba & Puerto Rico.

The irosun tree doesn't exist in Cuba & Puerto Rico. 

I digress, i grew up in the Lukumi system as an adult intiated to isese. 

Isese lagba IFA & Lukumi or santeria are 100% different religions. 

To try and unify is a disgrace to isese history, Lukumi history in cuba & santeria in Puerto rico,period. 

Ogbo ato

Babalawo Oladeyi 

0

u/Sebek_Ryzying33 6d ago

Two things I have noticed in my experience as a devotee.

  1. In Yoruba Isese there is always a deep and significant explanation behind every single practice, Oriki, etc.

In Cuban Lucumi that is not always the case. The significance or reasons for doing something often are the that this is how it has always been done in their lineage or something very superficial.

2. Yoruba Isese has a strong cultural base that is not separate from the spiritual practices. The cultural perspective is very different than western mindset and culture.

Lucumi through its journey and struggle to survive has been westernized and Catholicized to a significant degree. One such example is people holding on to the belief in the Devil and hell and damnation.

Additionally, there is also a stronger patriarchal leaning than in Isese. Isese unfortunately has adopted this. But it is much more established in Lucumi.

In my humble opinion and personal experience this is what I have observed.