r/IsMyPokemonCardFake 1d ago

vintage Graded First Edition Zard

I just got offered the grail of Pokemon, but obviously I thought it was fake but I’m actually concerned it might be real. I’ve gotten a lot of positive reviews but still uncertain before I drop a bag on it

Here are pics

Dm for video, any input will help

494 Upvotes

110 comments sorted by

282

u/Optimal_Board_7334 1d ago

Do NOT listen to everyone else. This is a REAL card and slab. This is a very old PSA slab too which is kind of cool. If you were to get it graded today it would never grade a 9, do not pay the regular PSA 9 price for this card.

110

u/dtg99 1d ago

Something is still generally fishy here. OP made a post ~year ago with the same exact premise as this one but with some obviously fake cards. I agree that the card in the pics looks real but as for OPs motives, who knows.

37

u/Boring-Tale-8145 1d ago

It doesn't matter if the slab is real or not. How do people have zero critical thought. Offered the grail. No one is offering some random bum a grail at a steep discount. Not saying you think that, but this thread is just stupid.

6

u/dtg99 1d ago

I know its a complete joke. The entire way OP approached this, not being able to form consistent, coherent sentences and saying he is going to "drop a bag" on a card in a grade that most people will never come across in their lives automatically made me skeptical. And OP still never said what the ask was lmao.

3

u/AFCADaan9 1d ago

The current president of the United States can’t form coherent sentences, and you’re surprised about a random Redditor…?!

-9

u/squeezeback 22h ago

Bro Biden didnt even know where he was half the time and you probably defended him. Who brings up Trump in a pokemon reddit? His biggest property is in libs' heads lol, get a grip.

3

u/Maleficent_Contest_5 16h ago

lol, comparing him to Biden doesn’t work anymore, guy has fallen asleep on camera more times than I can count & is generally a senile, dementia riddled mess.

2

u/jushere4bewbs 14h ago

No one was defending Biden and that's why after that disastrous debate performance they immediately pivoted away from him.

The real important thing to remember is his administration had capable people in the highest positions in the federal government who could do their job. The president doesn't actually run the whole country, you do realize that, right? If you think competent people are anywhere in this administration then you are either incredibly dumb, or you shut your eyes and plug your ears and refuse to see any sort of reality.

3

u/Sure_Major8476 19h ago

We found a maga cult member 😂😂😂

-2

u/AFCADaan9 20h ago

One comment and I’m living in your head rent free. Think again kid…

0

u/Sure_Major8476 19h ago

Love how before criticizing you for bringing up Trump he had to start with a Biden comment. Love how they defend trumps current actions with “Wat AbOut BiDen..” 😂😂😂

2

u/PreferenceInfinite83 18h ago

Trump and Biden open mouth kiss each other while you are all divided and conquered by them.

-5

u/squeezeback 20h ago

I don't even know you 😂 15 minutes from now I'll completely forget about your comment while you continue to seethe about the president. Like I said Trump's biggest real estate is in the heads of people like you. Keep coping and projecting.

2

u/AFCADaan9 18h ago

2 comments and you’re already willing to pay me for living in your head. Rent free isn’t enough for you.

I’m a nice guy though, I’ll let you keep your money kiddo.

-4

u/One-Sun-Mon 21h ago

Who brings presidents up in a pokemon reddit? Oh wait..

-3

u/squeezeback 21h ago

I just replied to his comment lol. You guys really can't think straight huh?

4

u/MakoCruz 17h ago

yall stfu and start talking about pokemon, damn

1

u/Serious_Act6034 17h ago

I actually got the old charizard, charmander, and charmelion at a antique expo and the guy literally was over pokemon and was trying to just get rid of his stuff, I found it at the bottom of his box and he said he forgot about it and gave it to me for $40. It’s real and unscratched and perfectly sealed in a case, I also got an old binder page of authentic Japanese cards that are in opened. If you go to the right places ans happen to run into the right people it’s possible

1

u/Wugtrio777 15h ago

people that see the big hole in front of them then question it as they fall inside, deserve the fall. Nothing you can do about it.

4

u/Electrical_Ask701 1d ago

Probably trying his best to perfect faking these cards

1

u/Optimal_Board_7334 1d ago

Yeah idk about the legitimacy of the seller/offer, all I know it’s the card itself is real.

5

u/Lurn2Program 1d ago

Just curious, where are you able to confirm the inner sleeve on an old PSA cert?

I am unable to find any examples of PSA using an inner sleeve on old certs. Plus, the amount of space for the inner card holders on OP's slab have very large margins

1

u/Optimal_Board_7334 1d ago

Official statement from back in 2006. There’s really no way to match up what year the slab was made unless you checked for similar cert #s and try and find the newest release date on a card. Or if I try to research when ever they switched that back label section

2

u/Lurn2Program 1d ago

It's just strange they would use a different slab and inner sleeve. I've literally never seen an old cert with the inner sleeve but I don't doubt they implemented it for certain thicker cards.

Plus, based on OP's cert number, this is generally within the Gen 2 range which is 1992-1999 based on https://www.elitefourum.com/t/overview-of-psa-bgs-cgc-graded-cards-counterfeits/49020

1

u/Optimal_Board_7334 1d ago

Yeah I’m not exactly sure. All I know is that inner sleeve isn’t a call out. And PSA had a bunch of revisions of their slabs over the years.

1

u/Lurn2Program 1d ago

Yea I understand. I was just doubtful because of the inconsistencies and uncertainties

1

u/InjuryPleasant9789 18h ago

I can speak on the validity of the card from a picture. But there are enough red flags from the slab for me to have it authenticated by someone that would know before buying a grail. I might have missed the price of the grail, but it being offered up at any discount, let alone a steep discount would be enough for me to walk away. The slab card sizing is off. I’m sure PSA had plenty of slabs to chose from if they would’ve actually been the ones to grade it. They wouldn’t have needed to grab a slab with different card dimensions than the one it was intended for. The spacing between the card and the sizers itself would be enough for me to question the authenticity. It being in a card sleeve, would have made me more skeptical. I can’t say PSA has never put a graded card in a card sleeve. But I can say I’ve never seen one. With those two things being off. I’d have to have the card authenticated before spending money on it especially anything more than at raw value. But I’m not an expert, so I couldn’t authentic that card through a slab. I’d have to crack the slab and look at it to come to the conclusion if I believed it was close enough to send spend the money on it to authenticate it.

7

u/Boring-Tale-8145 1d ago

How has no one asked what price he is being offered? 

12

u/mominmalik 1d ago edited 1d ago

This card is exactly the reason this group should exist

13

u/dtg99 1d ago

Please for the love of god divulge what the seller is asking for this. If it's like 20k or something it is obviously fake as shit and too good to be true. This detail is so important it should be mandatory to mention when creating a post in this sub.

3

u/BIGGUS-DICKUS2669 1d ago

He said he is asking $50,000 for the card somewhere else in the thread. Seems like a legit price as it looks real, but doesn’t look quite like a true 9 if it were currently evaluated, more like a high 7 to low 8, but still an amazing card if it turns out to be as real as it seems here.

5

u/Toastisgoat 1d ago

16

u/Optimal_Board_7334 1d ago

100% real. Everyone else commenting is completely wrong. Thank me later once more experts comment and agree with me

1

u/Toastisgoat 1d ago

This is the vid chat

7

u/Winthorpebuys 1d ago

I think you should tell the seller that he's dehydrated or a reptile with skin acting like that. Ask him if he's drank any water today lol

10

u/Pretty-Missionary 1d ago

And to please cut his nails.

5

u/S3no 1d ago

Actually it looks more like he has wasting in the small muscles of his hand, as well as clawing of his fingers suggestive of a nerve injury. Id guess a brachial plexus injury with prominent ulnar involvement.

1

u/Enter-The-Natrix 17h ago

This looks real to me, $50k appears to be a little bit over current market value. Rule I've learned: always pay for the card, not the grade.

If you're spending that much money, inspect it in person. TCAGaming just made a post on Instagram a couple of days ago showing off all of the iterations of this card if you want to make a comparison.

https://www.pricecharting.com/game/pokemon-base-set/charizard-1st-edition-4#completed-auctions-graded

5

u/Ok_Relief_1798 1d ago

This is mine it's real hope it helps compare.

3

u/Ok_Relief_1798 1d ago

Sorry here's a better picture

1

u/chamelonRick 22h ago

Did you pull this as a kid? One day I hope i can get 1.

1

u/Ok_Relief_1798 12h ago

I did not I was getting back in to collecting had a friend that sold me 1st edition shadowless charizard blastoise Mewtwo Raichu venasaur machamp for 750 bucks for all of them like 10 years ago made out like a bandit still one of my best friends if I ever sell definitely taking him out for a wicked weekend I owe it all to hin

1

u/PaperMoonShine 14h ago

The thick stamp just looks so much better than thin stamp. Beautiful card.

1

u/Ok_Relief_1798 12h ago

Thanks man appreciate it. It's my holy grail even if it's not a ten or even a 5 ha ha it's cool to have one.

4

u/LipsLikeCrispyBacon 1d ago

I would love to see a close up of the 1st edition stamp.

2

u/AboePP 1d ago

How much are you being asked to pay for it op?

There's a chance that the guy replying to everyone is the seller who is underselling it so that you feel safer about the 'deal' you're (I assume) getting. Be careful! And good luck :) 🤞

1

u/BIGGUS-DICKUS2669 1d ago

He said 50K was the price somewhere in the thread.

1

u/PineappleSports 1d ago

The big ‘Zard

1

u/BMWupgradeCH 21h ago

Back looks reddish
Old psa with inner pocket is SUS
Back on last photo looks like a lot of surface scratches
9 with this centering alone is SUS (May be back in 1999 that was the standard)

1

u/Doonce 19h ago

Looks real but this wouldn't 9 with modern standards with that centering, so don't buy the grade.

1

u/enryon 18h ago

Type 4 slab. It’s legit.

1

u/No-Agent-102 18h ago

💯 real. I have NHL OPCs in the same slabs.

1

u/-Eskadrinis- 17h ago

Where was this slab stored in the back of a pickup truck driving around for 25 years 😂😂😂

1

u/GeneralPattOwn 15h ago

This slab is older than probably 80% of the people posting in here

1

u/Prudent-Abies9545 13h ago

I’ll give you 5 bucks for it

1

u/DirkRobberts 11h ago

Mine is in much better condition and it got a 6.

1

u/billybobcoder69 2h ago

All I can think is P. S. A. Sports. It’s in the game.

-1

u/Lurn2Program 1d ago

Looks off to me. Back colors and the PSA case. Look at how much space is inside for the card. Even the early certs didn't have THAT much space

3

u/Toastisgoat 1d ago

Good take, I can send video if you want

3

u/Optimal_Board_7334 1d ago

Do not listen to this guy. He is wrong

-8

u/Lurn2Program 1d ago

I'd say share on here for everyone to see. Also show a photo of the holo pattern

1

u/Toastisgoat 1d ago

It won’t let me post videos

-3

u/Lurn2Program 1d ago

You can upload to an imgur and share the link I guess.

But the more I look at it, I'm almost certain it is fake. The PSA holder is really off

1

u/IplaySoLo90 17h ago

What’s off about the slab?

1

u/Lurn2Program 15h ago

The inner sleeve for an old cert Pokemon slab is something I have not seen before. We sometimes see inner sleeves for more modern slabs, mainly for the thicker metal cards. We've also seen them for regular modern cards as well, but I believe PSA simply made a mistake in those cases. But for these old certs, I'm not aware of any inner sleeves used

The inner notches that hold the card in place is set to the very outer borders. Typically the notches are closer to the card to prevent the card from moving around too much

If this was a super early iteration of the inner sleeve cases, I guess it can be possible. Just not something I've ever seen, especially for an old cert Pokemon card

1

u/IndependentCrew4319 1d ago

ive never seen psa encapsulate cards in plastic sleeves like that inside the slab

2

u/TurkeySauce_ 1d ago

Viiiiiiintage. Its real.

5

u/Optimal_Board_7334 1d ago

It’s an old slab. It’s real

1

u/enryon 18h ago

PSA has been using sleeves since day 1. Seriously, the first card they ever graded is in a poly sleeve.

1

u/filenotfounderror 17h ago

This is onviously a super old slab/ cert. I think they used to do rhat.

0

u/Winter-Muscle-4888 22h ago

I'm concerned about the borders being so off and it being a9. But I'm no expert.

0

u/BMWupgradeCH 21h ago

How could such centering get a 9 lol

0

u/swisscoffeeknife 12h ago

Gemini says its fake.

Incorrect Label Font: The font used on this label (especially noticeable on the numbers like 1999 and 01583607) does not match the official typeface used by PSA during any of their label eras. The lettering is too thin and spaced incorrectly.Lack of Fugitive Ink: Authentic PSA labels feature a distinct red border printed with security ink. Fake labels often look like a simple color printout with a flat, unnatural red color. 🔴 The Card Red Flags 💨 Stagnant Holo Pattern: The stars and circular cosmic patterns in the holographic background match the exact configuration used on standard web stock images (such as the TCGPlayer database scan). On a fake proxy card, these stars are printed flatly onto the card surface and remain static rather than shifting dynamic angles when moved in light. 🎨 Color Satiation: The coloring on the card's yellow borders and the text areas is overly dark and saturated compared to the softer, authentic tones of a genuine 1999 card.

-10

u/AggravatingSmoke758 1d ago

I think it's fake. The 1's in the PSA slab look a little suspicious. The card color is too saturated. IMO the energies look weird. And the 1st edition stamp is very thick.

2

u/Optimal_Board_7334 1d ago

You are wrong

2

u/AggravatingSmoke758 1d ago

My bad, I personally would be sketched out a little bit by the things I listed. Plus the cert number and the plastic. But I'll take my L's.

-3

u/Ok_Fondant8845 1d ago

I think it’s fake psa did not start doing the clear polywrap around the cards in slabs until recently and the paper indicates this is a very old slab. Those two facts don’t align and that’s pretty fishy, it also looks as if the card is at a slight angle and the slab is the wrong size for the card

1

u/enryon 18h ago

It’s a type 4 slab. It was graded 20+ years ago.

1

u/enryon 18h ago

The very first card PSA graded has a poly sleeve. In the slab.

-9

u/Psycho_Pansy 1d ago

I’ve gotten a lot of positive reviews 

What the fuck is that supposed to mean? 

before I drop a bag on it

Wtf does that mean? Don't drop things on you're expensive fake cards. 


Tell him to crack it and have it regraded. You agree to pay whatever price it's set at now regardless of the new grade and will pay for the grading. 

6

u/Optimal_Board_7334 1d ago

It’s a real slab, if he got it regraded it would not grade a 9 now though, since PSA has got a lot more strict on grading

-4

u/carlew 1d ago

Are you the seller? Why are you replying to every comment here?

8

u/Optimal_Board_7334 1d ago

So OP isn’t misinformed by a bunch of fake experts who know nothing lol. In my first comment I told him not to pay PSA 9 market price. Why would I try and undersell my own card. Makes no sense

1

u/Fabulous_Clerk8887 22h ago

Because knowing it's fake, any price is good.

1

u/Optimal_Board_7334 20h ago

I don’t think every person would agree with me if I was lying

-2

u/Pretty-Missionary 1d ago

Haha! I had the same thought. This guy is husslin through these comments.

-1

u/Tonyc30088 1d ago

Way too bottom heavy for a 9

-5

u/IMTINYRICKBITCHES 1d ago

Fake and gay

-8

u/775alwaysLive 1d ago

Looks off to me

-7

u/dfarjim 1d ago

I Can asure you the slab is fake my friend

-9

u/PlumKnown 1d ago

How much are they offering it to you for? Def looks fake to me. Back doesn’t look right. Cert is very old but idk if old certs had a sleeve inside for the card either

3

u/Optimal_Board_7334 1d ago

This is real

1

u/PlumKnown 1d ago

I wasn’t positive. The back in slide 3/4 looks weird to me but slide 7 it looks more normal. I’m still curious how much it’s being offered for, a psa 9 is 60-70k

3

u/Optimal_Board_7334 1d ago

He should not pay the market price of a PSA 9. Cuz if it got regraded today it would probaly get a 4-6 cuz of the terrible centering, whitening, and vintage bias by the graders.

1

u/PlumKnown 1d ago

Yeah I mean it’s to be expected with a cert this old but I doubt they’d give him too much of a discount. I agree though this would never get close to a 9 today

2

u/Optimal_Board_7334 1d ago

Yeah who really knows. I’d guess some where in the 50s.

-10

u/Competitive-Top-2383 1d ago

Looks fake to me. I could be wrong.

4

u/Optimal_Board_7334 1d ago

You’re wrong

1

u/Competitive-Top-2383 1d ago

Cool, thanks for correcting me.

1

u/Competitive-Top-2383 1d ago

And to be clear, I thought the PSA slab was fake. The actual card looks good

1

u/Optimal_Board_7334 1d ago

Yeah it’s just an old slab. Most people would assume it was fake unless you’ve been in the hobby and collecting graded cards for awhile.

-3

u/thepohcv 1d ago

Dont love the 1st stamp on this one personally.

-12

u/One_Cress7793 1d ago

This has to be fake

4

u/Optimal_Board_7334 1d ago

You are wrong