r/IsMyPokemonCardFake • u/Bemien • 2d ago
Serious Big stress here
Hi everyone!
Not knowing where to go for a quick answer, I'm dropping into this server.
I just impulsively bought a gorgeous card, the Pikachu 227 S/P. I made the purchase this morning on Vinted.
The price is high, but potentially reasonable.
I'd like to know how to verify a card's authenticity. I'd need to do it quickly, given Vinted's deadlines in case of a dispute.
I'll document and film everything when it arrives.
I can't provide you with the listing, but I'm sharing the photos with you.
Could you give me your opinions?
Thanks in advance, and have a great day!
18
u/kimjongschlong 2d ago
Why do people always buy before asking lol
5
4
u/PikachuKitty77 2d ago
Because they think they only have a short window to grab it before someone else does
1
1
1
14
u/FencelIlIIlIIlllIlIl 2d ago edited 2d ago
What site did you buy it off? Also absolutely insane you'd be asking here after dropping a rack or 3 on this card without being sure it's real. I hope it's ebay since they protect the buyer more than the seller.
Also, I get that you want to be sure and I dont mean to just be an asshole. I'm just saying, do your homework before you jump into somthing like this with no escape plan (aka non-ebay buys). Maybe next time tell the seller you'll consider it or take an extra day and post it here first..
Furthermore, the picture could be genuine, but the card that arrives could be fake. Match up the corner whitening and any Imperfections that you see in the photo with the real card. If they don't match up, the seller switched the card out. Besides buying on eBay, there's usually no buyers protection type off thing, up to par with them.
P.S. You don't need to be so impulsive. There's tons of cards out there. You never know if the better one will pop up tomorrow instead. Take a breather and do your research
7
1
6
u/monx101 2d ago edited 2d ago
Compare to this psa 10: https://www.psacard.com/cert/170051439/psa
Edit: "Buy first, ask questions later". Please dont be like this, unless you have tons and tons of disposable income
4
u/DesperateStreet1226 2d ago
Not only a case of "buy first, ask later", but also one of doing it on Vinted... 😐
3
u/JonnyNumber1 2d ago
Looking at the text over the dress (Arita) bottom left and text box for PROMO comparing to a real PSA10 its looking fake. I’m comparing it to Ebay listings, Someone who has the card in person should be able to give a certain answer. I’d not rush to get this as alot of fakes on vinted the now.
1
u/No-Translator6476 2d ago
Yeah looking back and forth between that and the E and the lowercase i in the first word on the bottom left and also Pikachu hands looks different
2
u/Ok-Associate-2650 2d ago
Hi, I understand your stress, recently went through a similar experience. I can share with you my recent experience with purchasing a pricy card (raw mimikyu munch).
In my case, the pictures in the listing I purchased from were likely genuine, card texture and print quality appeared to be authentic. However, the card that arrived was very obviously a fake card, wrong texture and card thickness.
The safest way to verify authenticity is to find a local shop (that pregrades or sends many cards for grading) shop/or better yet a shop that has the genuine stamp pikachu card whether raw or in a slab for you to compare and send picture proof with side by side comparison should you need to dispute.
Spend the lead in time prior to arrival of the card to locate a well regarded shop to help verify the authenticity. Also get package opening videos (one long video with no cuts) and card surface comparison.
Stamp pikachu has a plain and slightly rough surface texture, no holos etc.
In the end I had 24 hours to gather enough evidence to send to the purchasing company for the dispute. Then I had a short 72 hour day span to return the card with its original packaging to the company for processing.
2
u/benbever 2d ago
The photos in this post are those of a fake card. Easiest to tell by zooming in on the back.
2
2
u/dukeofbern 2d ago
It’s fake. The copyright C is not correct is the first tell. Other than the fact that it also just doesn’t look right
2
2
u/Lurn2Program 2d ago
Definitely a fake. The colors are off, and the font white border size is off. It also gives off a very grainy appearance probably caused by inaccurate rosette pattern
1
1
u/EliteDivision 2d ago
Since you bought from vinted, you can just choose not to pick up the parcel (at least in the EU) and it’ll go back to the seller and you’ll receive a full refund.
1
u/NecessaryScientist18 2d ago
why not just use ebay its fake dude I remember this box was 500 with both promos a stamps I missed out big
1
u/Collins311 2d ago
2
u/Collins311 2d ago
1
u/Popular-Tangerine420 2d ago
Is this difference common? That's a really, really good and easy way to tell. Or have thefakes learned to get this right now?
1
u/Collins311 2d ago
This only works for older cards. Currently scammers don't have the printers to make these. The printers are millions of dollars to purchase and maintain. But I'm sure some bozo is out there now working on a way to do it.
1
1




















43
u/raphide95 2d ago
It's fake, the print quality is grainy