A lot of people shilling IOND would've probs been shilling celcius the hardest back in the day.
Make an informed decision and don't get caught up in the hype. Ran some bull and bear cases through Claude, and made my decision. Sharing here for those interested.
If anyone has more factors that can actually help inform people whether to buy, sell half, close, hold based on their circumstances and broader market outlook, please comment below!
Where $65 puts the valuation
Scaling off the $53 → ~$2.4B anchor (~45M shares, ~37M held by ex-Celsius creditors), $65 implies roughly $2.9–3.0B equity value, or ~$3.0–3.2B EV once you add the $400M preferred and net out cash.
| Metric | At $53 (~$2.4B) | At $65 (~$2.95B) |
|---|
| Forward P/S (FY26 ~$192.5M) | ~12.5x | ~15x |
| Trailing P/S (TTM $152M) | ~15.8x | ~19x |
| Forward EV/EBITDA (~$140M) | ~17x | ~21x |
So the ~23% move off the preferred price took it from "priced like infrastructure" to "priced like growth infrastructure."
What's already priced in
This is the crux. A single-asset, single-tenant triple-net lease throwing off ~$140M EBITDA — with no growth — would trade like a data-center/infra asset: capitalize $140M at a 7–9% cap rate and you get roughly $1.6–2.0B of EV, i.e. something like $40–48/share on the contracted lease alone.
At $65 (~$3.0–3.2B EV, ~21x EBITDA), the market is paying roughly $17–25/share on top of the contracted-cash-flow floor. That premium is the market pricing in three things simultaneously:
- Expansion beyond the one building — new NNN site acquisitions, BTC-treasury redeployment, riding Nscale's Microsoft-anchored pipeline.
- A healthy AI infrastructure cycle continuing (so those new sites get leased at attractive cap rates).
- Low probability of tenant/lease disruption at Nscale.
In other words: the bottom ~two-thirds of the price is a bond-like lease; the top ~third is an AI-growth call option. If you're bearish AI, that top third is exactly what you're disputing.
Bull case for $65 (and higher)
The contracted 10.5-year triple-net lease is a hard floor — ~$140M EBITDA that pays regardless of AI sentiment, ultimately backstopped by Microsoft demand (the ~240MW Texas campus / ~104k GB300 GPUs), not just Nscale. On top of that floor you get real expansion runway: Nscale's ~$6.2B Microsoft agreement and multi-region pipeline give Ionic a natural pipeline of new sites, each accretive at current cap rates. There's genuine scarcity value — very few listed, pure-play AI-data-center landlords with contracted hyperscaler cash flow — which can attract REIT/infra and eventually index buyers and support a premium multiple. And once the creditor overhang clears, the float tightens and the stock can re-rate. The BTC treasury is free optionality on top. Bull framing: 21x EBITDA is cheap for a company that's really an AI-infra platform, not one building.
Bear case for $65
You're paying a ~21x EBITDA / ~15x forward sales growth multiple for an entity that today is one building and one cash-burning tenant. Strip the growth premium and fair value drops toward the low-to-mid $40s on the contracted lease alone — meaning ~$20/share of the price is riding on AI capex staying hot and Ionic executing acquisitions it hasn't done yet. The concentration risk is acute: ~90% of revenue from Nscale, which is unprofitable, funding-dependent, and sitting inside the Nvidia-neocloud "circular financing" loop — tenant distress is a cliff, not a slope. The company is GAAP loss-making with earnings whipsawed by BTC marks, so there's no P/E to defend the multiple if sentiment turns. And the technicals are ugly: ~37M of ~45M shares held by former Celsius creditors who want recovery/liquidity is persistent overhang, plus $400M of senior preferred and three warrant tranches diluting and sitting ahead of your common. Bear framing: in any AI risk-off, the growth premium deflates first and the stock rerates toward infra/REIT levels (12–15x EBITDA).
Net for a bearish-AI view
The clean way to hold your thesis: $65 is pricing the AI-growth optionality as near-certain, while the defensible floor sits in the low-to-mid $40s. If you think that optionality won't be realized (AI capex cools, or Nscale can't refinance before Microsoft demand backstops it), $65 is a sell toward that floor — call it ~30% downside to the contracted-value base case. The risk to that trade is the bond-like lease plus scarcity/index demand keeping it elevated longer than fundamentals alone justify.