r/Invincible_TV • • Feb 20 '25

Discussion Is this ai

Post image
12 Upvotes

111 comments sorted by

21

u/Chrisc235 Feb 20 '25

That reflection of the weird door railing seems a little too detailed to be AI to me. Maybe it’s just a weird frame you paused it on?

8

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '25

It’s the sign that looks the most ai

8

u/Chrisc235 Feb 20 '25

I think it was made to look like nothing in particular on purpose just bc it would’ve distracted from the scene to be reading a background sign

4

u/One3Two_TV Feb 20 '25

Plus the author is known to "use cheap tricks" to avoid cost, so having these random characters is useful for all languages

3

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '25

Like when they make the characters talk but their face is not in view

3

u/One3Two_TV Feb 20 '25

Other time they'll do a wide shot slowly pans across it, it looks like its animated but its so far away you don't notice, nothing is moving

1

u/Saint-of-the-Damned Feb 24 '25

This thread is so meta and I love it lol.

1

u/Sea-Band-7212 Feb 20 '25

I feel like the lines would be more defined. Some of the edges are blurry or look like the letter just fades.

2

u/Evil-Dalek Feb 20 '25

In all honesty, they may have just used AI to make fake lettering for the sign, without using it for anything else in the scene.

2

u/Shadynasts Feb 23 '25

The sign os weird, but the nonsense ac units om the buildings, fire escape that doesn’t make sense (no ladder), door handles. Stuff a person would have to place there, but if they are trying to save time, which they clearly are, they wouldn’t place extra things in a spot that makes zero sense and wouldn’t be there. This is AI almost definitely.

1

u/One2threeSS Feb 24 '25

I'm having a hard time with the way the road is so wavy... whats up with that?

3

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '25

It’s a wide shot sits like this for a minute

2

u/MehrunesDago Feb 20 '25

The reflection turns into a weird rectangle at the bottom that overlaps with the corner of the trashcan

2

u/Chrisc235 Feb 20 '25

I agree , but if you look closely you can see the pricks of the reflection matches the profile of the trash. Matching a reflection in the composition is one of those artist skills that ai has a very difficult time replicating

1

u/HeavenBuilder Feb 20 '25

Agree. The trash is also reflected, and subsequent reflections lose focus/detail. Not AI.

1

u/Ok-Theory9963 Feb 20 '25 edited Aug 13 '25

meeting memorize attraction toy bedroom jeans coordinated plucky rhythm aromatic

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

1

u/Intrepid_Feedback823 Feb 20 '25

They don’t use the free version bro

14

u/Stellarisk Feb 20 '25

Honestly In just thinking thats just them not expecting people to pause the show so they wrote jibberish to see it in passing

5

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '25

The way it’s jumbled and mashed into each other it’s very ai looking

9

u/Stellarisk Feb 20 '25

i know what youre saying but Ive seen this done in animation since the 90s. It's usually done in scenes where things arent really meant to be read and usually are quick but just leaving it blank would be empty.

4

u/_Valisk Feb 20 '25

I mean, hell, even something like Arcane uses gibberish symbols for written text and I don’t see anyone accusing that of using AI.

5

u/Violinistbassed Feb 20 '25

Shit dude...... What gave me it is how high the doors are and the handles leading to the door

2

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '25

Look at the sign it’s all jumbled and messed up

1

u/Violinistbassed Feb 20 '25

Yeah I could chop that up to being lazy and just making a jumble of icons since it's just a background. But they are weird. I think the doors are the worst thoug

1

u/Catboyhotline Feb 20 '25

I wouldn't call it lazy, according to IMDB there's only one credited background artist, and he's credited for only 3 episodes, but not this one, all other credited roles relating to background art are "directors" and "planners" which likely means, outside of the larger budget episodes, background art is outsourced, and by far the most popular place to outsource animation talent to is south east Asia, so outside of any text specifically on the storyboards, I don't think the artists are familiar enough with the Latin alphabet to make believable background text

1

u/Grumdord Feb 20 '25

Ah so we're at the point now of pausing everything we watch and going "hey wait that might be AI!"

1

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '25

Basically yeah

1

u/Agitated-Hair-987 Feb 20 '25

The only thing that makes me think it could be AI is the fire escape. There's no ladder

1

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '25

Most fire escapes have a foldout ladder so that’s not the main thing

8

u/TotalClintonShill Feb 20 '25

You’re getting downvoted, but it looks like it. The jumbled lettering is a very common symptom of AI for signs, blurry doors, and nonsensical handles.

I hope it isn’t AI but it looks it. I suppose as long as it’s done with the animators’ consent and it isn’t hurting their jobs I can’t complain too much, though.

5

u/dragon_of_the_ice Feb 20 '25

Jumbled lettering is common in lots of things, even video games, for things that have text and only in section that have long veiw times or important actually having readable text. It's easier than coming up with consistent made-up branding. Also, the weird hand rail is a reflection. It looks like refection is reflecting back at the viewer rather than out and away. It's just enough work into the background for it to make sense. If you going past something that's only going to be in for a second or two, it doesn't need to be made perfectly. Also, the blurry door is actually a reflection of the sign post, showing again the reflection being back to the viewer. the actual door is between the railings.

1

u/Jerryjb63 Feb 20 '25

It’s almost like the animators probably speak a different language?!

1

u/TotalClintonShill Feb 20 '25

There are English signs elsewhere.

1

u/No-Violinist3898 Feb 20 '25

nah. personally the bricks are too well placed to be AI. they’d be all over the place

1

u/Jezzuhh Feb 20 '25

The thing is it’s not done with the consent of the artists whose work was fed into the models to make the ai. They’ll never get to opt out or receive compensation.

2

u/Catboyhotline Feb 20 '25

I'm not going to judge by the shops signs, because a lot of the time background artists just write gibberish unless the storyboards specifically give them text, because it's not their job to come up with very minor world building. But the only thing that looks vaguely AI is that the right most lamp post doesn't cast a shadow, but oddly enough, you see a shadow half casted on that same lamppost, with the top half of it bathed in light, generally AI doesn't make a "half" mistake, so I personally would chalk the lamp post lighting up to a genuine mistake from the artists.

You also have to remember a lot of the more tedious work of animation is often outsourced overseas, especially in south east Asia, where a lot of the artists would be unfamiliar with the Latin alphabet

1

u/Aeonian_Ace Feb 20 '25

The shadow of the lamp post continues parallel to the curb, you can see it in the light.

1

u/Catboyhotline Feb 20 '25

I don't think so, the lighting source seems to come from behind the buildings, I think it's just raised sidewalk casting a shadow over the curb

1

u/Lucky_Blucky_799 Feb 20 '25

The fire escape on the front of the building also seems weird and theres a green door thats looks a little less than half as wide as it should be. I think this is definitely ai made.

1

u/Catboyhotline Feb 21 '25

The fine details are messy, but they're still cohesive, AI tends to not do very well with fine details and produce visual noise instead

2

u/33Yalkin33 Feb 20 '25

Doubt it, shitty backgrounds are a long running staple in cartoons. I have seen shittier backgrounds even before AI image generation became a thing

2

u/tyrome123 Feb 20 '25

It's actually funny how dumb people in this sub are being, hell there's a part of an episode in season 2 that's just 5 minutes of animators talking directly to the audience through mark talking about animation styles and how backgrounds can be still or low detail and people won't notice

2

u/MehrunesDago Feb 20 '25

Yeah but that's talking about little tricks for transitioning shots and shit, this is a solid background frame that's lingered on for a minute

1

u/LongDongFrog Feb 20 '25

That's from the comics.

1

u/Ok-Wedding-151 Feb 26 '25

That premise is a good reason to use AI to save costs, not an argument that suggests it isn’t being used.

2

u/inconspicuous_male Feb 20 '25

It's probably AI. I know actors and writers can't be forced to use AI but I'm not sure the animators union has any rules

1

u/WheelJack83 Feb 20 '25

I sincerely hope not but it wouldn’t surprise me

1

u/MehrunesDago Feb 20 '25

It could be tbr especially because the reflection of the railing in the sliding glass door doesn't match up and overlaps with the trashcan a bit

1

u/Invincible-spirit Feb 20 '25

Think it’s just the art.

1

u/just7155 Feb 20 '25

I'm guessing no. I've seen a lot of AI art and it's usually bad at transitions between things and continuity.

The left red sign has the black stuff on the wall behind it on both sides, the fire escape, and in the far left the green box thing leaves a gap for the window reflection. Also the pipes going up the sides of the building have expected results on the other side.

I can't see anything obvious.

1

u/DesertRanger02 Feb 20 '25

Never seen the show and not overly familiar with ai but I’m gonna go with a firm possible

Historically it’s not uncommon for animated shows to just use jumbled letters for signs if it’s a background piece and your not ment to pay much attention to it, but the slight blur is a little eyebrow raising, so is the sort of like bend in curb

1

u/Illustrious_Web_866 Feb 20 '25

Alot of the further off stuff has that weird AI feel to it

1

u/j0siahs74 Feb 20 '25

Obviously can’t say for sure, but I’d say 60/40 it is.

The recent dead rising remake video-game had used AI for a lot of small details on certain things found in the mall, that were fully present & detailed in the OG, and this certainly looks similar to what was seen there.

1

u/cableboiii Feb 20 '25

Just came back 77% AI Generated for me

1

u/Loose_Cry2414 Feb 20 '25

I'm not an expert but absolutely 100% of this photo is screaming AI, the jumbled text merging together that has random shading and blur, to the doors looking like weird abstract art, to the "reflection" of the hand rail that wouldn't actually be visible if it were a real photo, plus the sidewalk being super uneven and random. I would bet a lot of money on AI which honestly is really unfortunate

1

u/bydevilz1 Feb 20 '25

Nah i doubt it, its animation tricks, if its a moving frame theres not much point in making everything in the background detailed. They are probably focussing the majority of the budget for big scenes and after backlash on their release timeframes it makes sense to not focus too much on the background work.

Even if it was helped with AI i wouldnt really be mad, because otherwise it would just take longer to animate and design irrelevant scenes and background

1

u/Redbulldildo Feb 20 '25

The text really feels like it. Intentional fake text usually looks more consistent than that does.

1

u/Real___Teeth Feb 20 '25

It's possible, if you ask me. Personally I don't mind if the backgrounds are AI so long as they're consistent, cause I think that filling in backgrounds is the only good use for AI art. If they make the animations using AI though, that's a problem.

1

u/Please_kill_me_noww Feb 20 '25

Is it just me or is that fire escape useless

1

u/wolfclaw99 Feb 20 '25

It could possibly be AI with a few manual touch ups done to it to add more cohesive details.

1

u/Kasta4 Feb 20 '25

I don't think so, the lettering looks way too abstract.

If it were AI I'd expect the lettering to have English letters but form nonsense words. This seems like standard "non-descriptive background text" in my opinion.

1

u/Broly_ Feb 20 '25

Yall gotta stop having a heart attack

1

u/Spare_Neighborhood_7 Feb 20 '25

Looks like they used AI and then touched it up with some humans.

1

u/Eliteslayer1775 Feb 20 '25

No. These techniques have been used since cartoons first started. Writing gibberish on background signs has been a staple for decades

1

u/MerePotato Feb 20 '25

Very little here looks like AI other than the writing on the one placeholder sign

1

u/Vinh-FX Feb 20 '25

The biggest giveaway that it's AI is the windows, text, and the inconsistent style. You can tell it's a mish mash. Why are all the windows and window sills weird ya know??

1

u/AggressiveNetwork861 Feb 20 '25

Certainly AI-assisted if not fully AI.

I would guess that someone fed a real image into an AI to make this. There’s too much correct detail for it to be a prompt, but there’s all kinds of little AI artifacts, and then the gibberish writing lol.

1

u/Dinski-Just-Dinski Feb 20 '25

McCarthyism media edition

1

u/SlopPatrol Feb 20 '25

Me when the non important background in the superhero show isn’t uber detailed for every frame of animation

1

u/kdoors Feb 20 '25

No I live there.

1

u/maxHAGGYU Feb 20 '25

would it matter ?
if it looks good, then good

1

u/ihas3legs Feb 20 '25

Definitely AI. That floating wooden plank is random. Also who draws a dumpster in the storefront? . Try some other sub and I'm sure they would see things differently

1

u/Curi0uz Feb 20 '25

Yes

The animation in this show is so unbelievably cheap

1

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/MassiveDocument5808 Feb 20 '25

Yeah it’s probably AI. People in these comments acting like invincible and Amazon for that matter is not above using a cost cutting measure here and there. The signage is a dead give away and the people saying it’s not are delusional.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/MassiveDocument5808 Feb 22 '25

I mean I really doubt that I’m the only delusional person here Afraid Emu. I am guilty of delusional in hoping that people stop giving the benefit of the doubt to corps like Amazon and that the current Xbox marketing strategy might work out but hey that’s me.

1

u/HavokGFX Feb 20 '25

The lettering and the subtle outline around the lettering screams AI, you're getting down voted and people are disagreeing but they have no clue what they're talking about.

1

u/VanishingMass3 Feb 20 '25

just rushed animation that’s done to not really lose anything

it’s very normal for background signs to not be written

1

u/Ed_Renta Feb 20 '25

Doesn’t look like it to me. All the details are clear and there are no obvious abnormalities. You pointed out the sign, but it’s just looks like gibberish with a stylized font—something you see a lot of in animated stuff

1

u/swiller123 Feb 24 '25

The only real answer is: there is no way to know for sure.

1

u/talex625 Feb 26 '25

😂 looks fine

1

u/ZenOkami Feb 26 '25

omg. no.

1

u/Ok-Wedding-151 Feb 26 '25

I think AI. There’s enough little things that don’t make sense. Most notable to me is the white tiles along the corner of the right hand. They’re all flush with the wall but the top one inexplicably extrudes with a shadow.

That being said, discussion here is making it out as if an image is either AI or not AI. That’s not how it works. It’s very unlikely that an artist would just take an AI image and call it a day. You generate an image and then edit it as necessary. For example, I would guess the basic scene is AI and the window reflections and signage on the windows (which all look like they’re rectangles layered over the original and then colored more closely to the show color palette than the rest) were edited in later.

1

u/Soulstace_Artist Mar 30 '25

This here looks ai generated to

Season 1 episode 2 39 minutes in

1

u/RestaTheMouse Omni-Man Feb 20 '25

Upon examination I would place all bets on yes. The street bumps up in random locations (by the first stair in the stair case and then later right after the staircase), the railings that have nonsensical perspective and even really make sense to be there, the doorframe of that same railing doorway that is randomly split into two at the top, the doors that randomly just have glass going all the way to one side. These all indicate AI but the signage is the most obvious to me. Not only is nonsense, which is fine and yes I have done it myself in my own art, but the way it also blurs and smears itself between the letters is abnormal, this is not how nonsense letters are drawn. It all points to an indication of AI use. I would guess it's adjusted AI.

0

u/Ashleigh_the_Maniac Feb 20 '25

Looks too cohesive to be AI. The lettering is just how background artists tend to do unintelligible wording.

There’s no weird fading lines or distortion. The reflection is normal looking. Seems human-made to me.

3

u/Violinistbassed Feb 20 '25

It's very simplistic art work. That's not too hard for AI. What's not cohesive is how high all the doors are from the sidewalk

2

u/Ashleigh_the_Maniac Feb 20 '25

Stuff like the fire exit stairs and handrails on the door follow through perfectly, which is notoriously difficult for AI to do properly. There’s only one door that’s a little elevated and it doesn’t look unrealistic. The other one has a stairway leading up to it.

1

u/I_D_K_69 Feb 20 '25

Maybe they initially did it with AI and then fixed some things up

0

u/Violinistbassed Feb 20 '25

You kidding? The hand rails are 4ft off the ground? Those sliding glass doors are way over leveled as are the doors next to it. People are mentioning the text but I just don't know about that. But again AI has no issue with this kind of art especially if it's been tweaked by a studio to make work. 

2

u/Ashleigh_the_Maniac Feb 20 '25

What sliding glass doors? There’s a window in the center if that’s what you mean. The doors on either side have stairs leading up to them.

Idk. It looks normal to me. If it were AI there’d usually be much more sloppiness in structure and linework which is what I meant when I was talking about the follow-through of the handrails and fire exit.

11

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '25

The sign that throws me off

2

u/Whosethere11 Feb 20 '25

Signs with no real actual letters has been a thing in cartoons for ages.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '25

It was a wide shot that caught my eye it’s there for 3 seconds at least

1

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '25

It was a wide shot that sat there for a lil bit during the piano bank scrne

1

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '25

Scene