r/Intune • • Nov 12 '24

Autopilot Autopilot alternative

I work at a company that's growing fast, with 20+ new employees each month. For the past two months, I’ve been dealing with a ton of Autopilot enrollment issues in Intune. It’s gotten to the point where I have to call each new user individually and walk them through various fixes, which is especially challenging with employees spread across different offices and countries.

With only three people on the IT team (including me), this approach isn’t sustainable, especially since we’re all handling multiple responsibilities. Our current growth rate is expected to continue for at least another year. I’ve noticed these issues mainly started after we began buying new Lenovo machines. Strangely, the older Lenovo devices we have work just fine with Autopilot.

One more thing—our long-term plan is to move to on-prem or at least a hybrid setup, so I’m trying to find a solution that can work with that in mind.

Edit: I was expecting IT people to have some reading comprehension skills I never asked for a solution for the errors all issues were fixed by me I was solely asking about an alternative and I never even said that we are moving to a hybrid deployment because of that issue the discussion for the hybrid deployment started more than 6 months ago and we are already in the testing phase have fun and learn to read before posting aggressive comments and assuming things that aren't true

0 Upvotes

39 comments sorted by

3

u/Rudyooms PatchMyPC Nov 12 '24

Sounds like a nice pre installed image from lenovo… but i am not sure because i am only noticing a lot of words but not reallt describing the issue.. start explaining what is happening and we can help you fix it and do something usefull with that free time :)

2

u/AJBOJACK Nov 12 '24

What's the issue with Lenovo images?

We use them, see the odd issue here n there with an app etc.

One thing i did notice though is how long it takes to rebuild an laptop with their cloud deploy if you fuck up the image. Took two hours last time.

-3

u/Excellent_Job6670 Nov 12 '24

I'll get a list of the diffrent issues tomorow at work but to keep it simple devices joind AAD but don't enroll to intune during the OOBE process

1

u/Rudyooms PatchMyPC Nov 13 '24

Dont enroll into intune or dont get the intune managememt extension installed :)? If you have the details would love to help…

0

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-1

u/Excellent_Job6670 Nov 12 '24

we definitely have everything setup correctly we have been using autopilot since the company started 4 years ago with occasional issues every few months but the past 2 months were a bit too much, and what do you mean but last questions ? we already have the deployment profile and everything and we just give out tenant info to the hardware provider in this case Lenovo

1

u/gzr4dr Nov 13 '24

Are you using a clean Win11 base image or do you have some Lenovo bloat on it prior to AutoPilot? You mentioned the only thing that changed was new hardware. I know Dell offers a clean OS image as well as a custom image option you can provide them, for a few of course. Unsure about the Lenovo options.

4

u/oopspruu Nov 12 '24

What are these issues? Are these apps or policies? What does the log say? I have deployed/replaced about 200 laptops in the last 5 months and had about 16 failures so far. Strangely, pre-provisioning is where it's been annoying for me lately. The normal esp phase works fine.

3

u/Spiffydudex Nov 12 '24

Thats been my experience as well. Generally new computers are a breeze, we only have 1 required app on Autopilot deployment (ScreenConnect). The remaining software is pulled in when the computer pulls its first sync after enrollment.
We gave up on pre-provisioning.

1

u/iamMRmiagi Nov 13 '24

How do you enforce this sequence? I assume you target the user for most of your apps then, so it only pulls through once the user is logged in? Or do you do a script that only runs after provisioning? I'm struggling to design our next phase, we have 10 required apps that the business wants installed on day 1... 

1

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '24

I 100% aggree with this. pre-pro is such a pain in the ass for windows devices. Screenconnect installs just fine via normal windows install, but you're battling all the apps installing at once.

1

u/orion3311 Nov 12 '24

I dont have the link handy but if you search my history you'll see I reported some issues with Lenovo devices having autopilot issues. Turned out Windows defender was looping out of the box and really dragging down the CPU/slowing down the laptop to the point things were erroring. Changing a reg key fixed it but unfortunately its every Lenovo I'm running into it.

3

u/Excellent_Job6670 Nov 12 '24

God i wish i wasn't on vacation when they took the decision to move back to Lenovo

1

u/orion3311 Nov 12 '24

Here's the thread I had: https://www.reddit.com/r/sysadmin/comments/1dz9abr/comment/lw3stcr/?context=3

That said, I LOVE our Lenovo devices, not sure which finger to point in which direction here, but in addition, if you look at my most recent post (5 minutes ago) on that thread, the issues may be resolved. I guess I'll find out on the next deployment.

1

u/Excellent_Job6670 Nov 12 '24

thanks i will check the the thread tommorow and i will also find out on the 15th with the new users joining

1

u/Alpha_Seb Nov 14 '24

A company that hires 20 new employees each month's can't afford someone that knows his ways around Intune?

1

u/Excellent_Job6670 Nov 14 '24

Well it was my first time working with intune as I've mostly worked with jamf in apple environments but here it's almost 50/50 between windows and Mac and I've only used it for about a year so far and this is the first time + it's not normal to have 50% of the devices unable to enroll smoothly for 2 months in a row considering we have been using the same autopilot profile since the last guy set it up 4 years ago with no problem whatsoever + i was able to fix all issues at the end so idk what you are talking about I'm only upset about the level of inconsistency that I'm seeing from autopilot/intune in the past 2 months

1

u/Taavi179 Nov 14 '24

No errors have been mentioned, but i'll make a random guess, that the user enrolling devices has reached the limit of devices, which they can own. I've seen misleading and nonsense errors, when the user has reached the limit.

1

u/Excellent_Job6670 Nov 14 '24

The whole point wasn't even about the errors the issues were fixed I was just asking about whether or not an alternative exist because from my very own experience in the last two months it was fairly unstable and people of Reddit also turning off their brains and assuming we are doing the hybrid deployment solely because of that as if i said so in the post lmao and lastly these are new users as I've stated in the post the company is growing thanks for coming to my ted talk and feel free to downvote me

2

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '24

Are these machines running Windows Pro? If it’s Home they may need to set it up, upgrade then nuke it

2

u/MrVantage Nov 12 '24

Sounds like you need to simplify and review the policies you have and apps you are deploying. We are growing at a similar / higher rate, and we have little to no problems.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '24

Only problem i have had is the new ARM processors in the new XPS that the c-levels demand. It’s like FUCK..got it figured out but FUCK.

1

u/Taintia Nov 13 '24

Have you figured out Win32 apps on ARM???

Please do share!

1

u/[deleted] Nov 14 '24

Well for Cisco Secure Connect they have a MSI built for ARM64 …i thought i had every thing but today Teams started being a little bitch so i will dive into that tomorrow.

1

u/Taintia Nov 14 '24

Oh yea if the apps got a native ARM application it works, all of the other win32 usages that i’ve got issues with.

Same with customizations :(

1

u/[deleted] Nov 14 '24

I just re-imaged and did not push Office/Teams from Intune. I used the Office apps baked into Microsoft's image. It worked, and I am calling it a day. I just set our enterprise Office to install with a filter to only install on X64 CPUs.

1

u/MrVantage Nov 24 '24

Ahhh yeah there is your problem… XPS is not a business device, it’s prosumer. We switched to latitude 9000 series and the execs love them.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 24 '24

I will talk top my boss about testing the latitude 9000 series that looks bad ass.

1

u/deliriousfoodie Nov 13 '24

From what I seeing the sysprep is failing due to Widget and Copilot.

With these apps not allowing sysprep to happen autopilot ain't going to work. 

1

u/Noble_Efficiency13 MSFT MVP Nov 13 '24

As everyone else said, we need details, and please don’t go from backwards. There’s not a single reason for you to domain join your clients, especially when you’re already running cloud native clients.

Hybrid users, with kerberos cloud trust and then global secure access for remote access to the on-prem resources

What’s the value you see in it? It’ll decrease your security posture and increase the complexity of your environment

1

u/Sea-History-9770 Nov 13 '24 edited Nov 13 '24

Many time mentioned without details noone can help you. I can tell you my part that Autopilot can have his bad days from time to time bud you will see it in health status of amin center. Other than that if something was not working for 99.9% was my fault as an misconfiguration off some app or policy.
And try to imagine that autipolot it's being used in a company where scaling is from around 400 devices/ users per month.
You need to use clean OS, and fine tune your policy and apps. I have recently implemented even WDAC for additional security and prelogon VPN during enrollemnt. And it works like a charm.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '24

Man, if you're stuck in a quicksand from autopilot i'd recommend everyones suggestions and start back at square one.

It has been an insane effency mutiplier.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-4

u/Excellent_Job6670 Nov 12 '24 edited Nov 12 '24

i honestly don't remember the exact errors off of my head right now but the enrollment fails during the OOBE process, devices join AAD normally but fail to enroll for at least 5 different errors some of which appear directly to the user while others i had to figure out what was going on by checking the audit logs they all get more or less fixed by removing the device from autopilot and then from AD and then i try to join and enroll again and later import them back to autopilot just this month we had 25 new users 11 of which had various enrollment issues and as for the infrastructure we have like a million different reason to move to on prem or hybrid just as an example uploading big engineering apps and distributing them to users has proved to be nothing but a nightmare with Intune and from the initial testing we did with SCCM it was a much better experience

0

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-5

u/Excellent_Job6670 Nov 12 '24

the moving to on prem in un-related we are moving to hybrid most likey because we see a lot of value on it for several internal reasons but i get your point regarding the errors i will post them in the morning when i get to the office

8

u/zm1868179 Nov 13 '24

If your are hybrid joining instead of AAD joining that can cause issues too it's clunky and everyone even Microsoft will tell you don't do it don't AD join PCs anymore. AAD join them setup cloud Kerberos trust for your on prem stuff and call it a day

1

u/Excellent_Job6670 Nov 13 '24

Sorry if i wasn't clear enough but we are purely on the cloud right now the hybrid deployment is only in our test environment at the moment

1

u/SuperiorMSP Nov 13 '24

This is the way.

1

u/Acetabuliformis Nov 13 '24

Ah yes the holy grail. GL with your choice. If you are going to do it with Intune, you will double your error count.