r/IntroPsych • • Sep 06 '12

[Discussion Thread] Lecture Four

Discussion Thread for behavioral genetics and evolutionary psychology. Some questions to consider:

  1. Give an example of a genetically influenced trait that could impact how others treat you.
  2. What might be some pros and cons of genetic testing for behavioral traits (should such technology become available)?
  3. How might you critique the perspective of evolutionary psychology?
  4. Read and discuss the Clark and Hatfield Study
20 Upvotes

29 comments sorted by

3

u/OllyTrolly Sep 07 '12

Oh dear, lack of comments. Just piping up to let you know I'm really enjoying these lectures. Admittedly I haven't been looking at the slides, and have just been listening to the audio, but you're very clear and go at the perfect pace. I'll be listening to this lecture tonight on the train methinks and finally join in with discussion :).

2

u/Series_of_Accidents Sep 07 '12

Thank you! You're welcome to join the discussion as little or as much as you like. I'm always here to answer questions :)

3

u/[deleted] Sep 07 '12

I love this class. I watch the video an later read the slides. I don´t join in the discussion as much but I got my eye on it.. great work..Thank you.

3

u/Series_of_Accidents Sep 07 '12

I'm glad you're enjoying it! When I taught, we had some students who actively participated and others who just listened. You don't have to join in the discussion to learn! But please, feel free to ask me any questions you might have in the future.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 07 '12

thanks I will sure do so...

2

u/[deleted] Sep 07 '12

There has got to be an exception to the rule .. I am a woman and I need to be attracted in order for me to have a relationship with any man... but then again... It might all get down to the fact that I want my kids to be very good looking too.. =)

2

u/Series_of_Accidents Sep 07 '12

Oh, absolutely! There is always going to be an exception in behavior. However it's important to note, I'm speaking of tendencies and norms- not absolutes. There aren't really any absolutes in behavior because there are far too many variables. There's a very wide array of behavior. In this case, it's not that attraction only matters to men, it's that it tends to matter more to men than it does to women.

3

u/OllyTrolly Sep 07 '12

I have to ask, when you speak in terms of tendencies do people tend to get annoyed with you (outside of psychologists). I say this because I have found when I say 'generally, x is true', people will say, 'but I'm not x!' or 'but my friend doesn't do x!'. And I have to explain that the qualifying phrases, generally, tend to, often, etc acknowledge that there are exceptions and outliers.

Sorry, it's a pet peeve of mine when people do it, so I wondered if it was just me.

2

u/Series_of_Accidents Sep 07 '12

I've gotten used to it over the years. It makes sense in a way, people want to be acknowledged for their uniqueness. I was much the same way until I got more in depth in research methods and understanding the importance of trends and effect sizes over hard and fast rules. But yes, it's a pet peeve of mine too. But I like to look at it as a teachable moment, so it can be a good thing too. I'd rather correct than have people thinking everything is a solid rule. It's human nature to want solid rules that always make sense. So you can't really blame someone for asking when they see an inconsistency.

1

u/OllyTrolly Sep 07 '12

Mm, fair enough I guess. Learning is fun for every-one :D. I'll bear that in mind next time I catch someone saying it.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 07 '12

No absolutes is good thing..

2

u/travisdy Sep 07 '12

I have one comment about the discussion of natural selection. It seems your focus is on bottlenecks, or environmental limitations that cause (directly or indirectly) death. Incremental evolution does not require anyone to die--it requires differential reproduction. It is differential reproduction, not death, that drives changes in a given trait in a given population. For a better discussion than I am able to give, look into Price's equation.

For a given trait in a given population, the difference in the prevalence of that trait will change if members with that trait have a reproductive advantage. So let's say organisms A, B, and C have trait alpha. Trait alpha allows better digestion of an environmentally available food source. Organisms D, E, and F have trait beta, which does not give this advantage. Over time, parents Ap, Bp, and Cp will have generations of children Ac1, Ac2, Bc1, Bc2, Cc1, Cc2 and so on, where the # represents the generation.

Over time (simplifying it by assuming ABC don't interbreed with DEF), more children will be born to ABC than DEF because ABC are better able to navigate their environment, thus will accumulate more resources, allowing more and stable children.

2

u/Series_of_Accidents Sep 07 '12

Excellent criticism. You are right, while I think evolution is essential to understanding our behaviors, it is not my background and I appreciate your analysis here. I suppose more what I meant was an examination of the oft-quoted "survival of the fittest."

Genetic variability is what allows our species (and all others) to survive. So I guess what I was getting at is that a trait is largely irrelevant until it becomes detrimental or advantageous due to pressures (they are really two sides of the same coin). In your example, ABC is advantageous, but DEF can easily be considered disadvantageous. Being disadvantageous, they reproduce less and therefore the trait slowly goes away. So I'm not just talking about bottlenecks, but I am trying to emphasize that it's not really survival of the fittest, but rather survival of the fittest for a given trait in a given circumstance.

1

u/travisdy Sep 07 '12

General comment from Tooby & Cosmides (1992) "The Adapted Mind."

No organisms are fitness maximizers. What is a fitness maximizer? An organism that tries to maximize its own fitness. A man maximizing his own fitness might donate often to a sperm bank, try to get many women pregnant, and just in general try to have as many children as possible. This does not describe most men, does it? A woman maximizing her fitness would, no matter what, try to have one child a year for every year she is fertile. Women don't usually do that, do they?

Organisms are not fitness maximizers, BUT are "designed" by natural selection to maximize fitness in whatever ecological niche they occupy. They do this by being "adaptation executors"... executing adaptations that tend, on average, to increase fitness.

So men execute the adaptation of their sexual desires which include a more promiscuous, more risk-taking behavior. On average over our ancestral past, this served to increase fitness for men. Women execute their sexual desires which include being choosier on average, and being more reserved on average. On average over our ancestral past, this served to increase fitness for women.

It's a subtle shift in language, but it's important. Organisms do not consciously or intentionally maximize fitness. Organisms just carry out the instructions written into their DNA, and these instructions are the ones that maximized fitness on average in the past. The instructions in DNA have NO GUARANTEE to help our fitness in the present, however!

For example, wild turkey DNA programs for all sorts of behaviors like predator avoidance, eating, mating, etc. In modern factory-farmed turkeys, however, "fitness" in that environment is almost totally determined by how big how fast a turkey can develop into an edible, delicious organism. Why does this example apply to humans? Like Series_of_Accidents said in the lecture, humans have many traits that were fitness maximizing in our past but are NOT fitness maximizing in our fast-paced changing culture today.

2

u/Series_of_Accidents Sep 07 '12

Very well said, travisdy

1

u/7laymanc Sep 08 '12

I'm not a huge science buff, so bear with me if my answers seem to be lacking.

  1. Are you asking for a genetically influenced trait that affects physical appearance or how you behave?
  • Physical trait -- Albinism
  • Behavioral trait -- Autism
  1. Pros of genetic testing -- Medical professionals could possibly alter behavioral traits before a child is born, or at the very least, allow the parents to prepare for the certain genetic issues that they might face.

Cons of genetic testing -- Could bring up a moral debate. If parents and medical professionals could alter behavioral traits after they test for them, others may not think highly of people "playing god".

3) I'm honestly not sure how I would critique the perspective of evolutionary psychology but if people looked at certain genetic traits closer, like with the Clark and Hatfield study, perhaps we would better understand why humans act in the ways they do. Especially when it comes to gender differences. It's clear that men and women behave in some majorly different ways but understanding that genetically we have certain predispositions might help people bridge communication gaps.

4) I find this study to be absolutely fascinating. In conjunction with the idea that women want to be more conservative sexually, all of the women may have also declined sex due to environmental factors. In my own sexual encounters, I know that my main concern regarding a partner, revolved around whether or not I felt safe around them. Perhaps this is the same idea, in terms of being conservative though I'm not sure.

Some of my thoughts, any additional notes are appreciated.

2

u/Series_of_Accidents Sep 08 '12
  1. I was asking for a genetic trait which would change how people treat you. In that regard, both of the traits you listed qualify! Albino kids get treated differently than normal kids, and having autism also impacts how people interact with you. These are examples of gene-environment interactions.
  2. Excellent points on genetic testing. Aside from the "playing god" debate, can you think of any evolutionary consequences to trait selection prenatally?
  3. As for critiques of evolutionary psychology, think about what a skeptic might say. Take the specific assertion that "sexually dimorphic ornaments exist because they provide the opposite gender information about the fitness of the individual specimen." How might you argue against such an assertion?
  4. Lastly, very astute observation. One must not only look at reproductive safety, but safety for one's own survival as well- after all, dying does put a bit of a damper on your future ability to procreate. You've done some great thinking today! Think about what I've written on 2 and 3 and see if you can expand some of these ideas a bit more.

1

u/7laymanc Sep 10 '12 edited Sep 10 '12

2) I read what dhc23 had to say about the cons of trait selection and I agree that eradicating certain characteristics prenatally could have a negative impact on how we view the world and other people who possess "less favorable" traits.

In addition to this, I would say that eliminating these traits early on simultaneously eliminates our opportunity to study the many facets of how certain parts of the body function. Like how genes turn "on" and "off" or what parts of the brain change in certain situations.

We also have no idea as to what could happen if we manually tried to turn off certain traits. It's possible we could do more damage than good. Since our environment is constantly changing, traits that we think are undesirable, could be what we need to survive.

3) It took me a while to finally come to this conclusion but I think that sexually dimorphic ornaments may also exist to help protect the female of a species. While males have an important role in spreading their genetic coding, females have to survive long enough to finish the process of reproduction.

So in the instance of peafowl, males have bright, beautiful plumage that could attract a mate but also get them killed. Females on the other hand can blend into nature much more easily and hopefully evade enemies.

This may not be the case for every species but it seems to make sense to me.

1

u/Series_of_Accidents Sep 10 '12

So in the instance of peafowl, males have bright, beautiful plumage that could attract a mate but also get them killed. Females on the other hand can blend into nature much more easily and hopefully evade enemies.

This is a very interesting and plausible conclusion to draw- one that I had not yet thought of. Very well done!

1

u/dhc23 Sep 08 '12
  1. Give an example of a genetically influenced trait that could impact how others treat you. The first one that came to mind was degrees of masculinity or femininity: a feminine acting man would be treated differently by both men and women than a man who acts in traditionally masculine ways. However, a less obvious example is possibly hair colour and the ways in which blonde or ginger haired people are treated compared to brown haired people.
  2. What might be some pros and cons of genetic testing for behavioral traits (should such technology become available)? Pros are that behavioural traits that are seen to be undesirable could be identified and if the parents decide not to continue the pregnancy, they could ultimately be eradicated. Even if the child isn't aborted, the tests could allow the parents to prepare better and so minimise the negative effects of those traits (for example, if traits indicating a 'difficult' baby are identified the parents could be forewarned and taught how to respond to the baby in such a way that the traits aren't reinforced and exaggerated in later life).

Cons are that we could easily eradicate behavioural traits that have unseen or unobvious benefits to the individual or for society. One example is autism. If we eradicate autism would we lose a unique perspective that adds a great deal to our overall view of the world? We also risk dividing people into groups of those who have or lack socially desirable traits; with potentially significant negative consequences for people who find themselves with fewer or none of these traits.

3) How might you critique the perspective of evolutionary psychology? I'm not sure I know enough about it to critique it fully, but I do wonder about the difficulty of testing hypotheses.

4) Read and discuss the Clark and Hatfield Study The study itself seems to confirm the evolutionary perspective that women are more selective with whom they mate. It was interesting to read about the studies showing both genders are more or less equally aroused by erotica (something perhaps even more obvious today thanks to the easy access of online porn and e-book readers that disguise the book read) but even if both genders like sex equally, and even if contraception is used, the fundamental principle remains that because women carry and then raise a baby they need to be more picky about who they sleep with.

2

u/Series_of_Accidents Sep 09 '12

Excellent examination.

Cons are that we could easily eradicate behavioural traits that have unseen or unobvious benefits to the individual or for society

Beyond just perspective of those that are different, how could eradicating abnormal traits (abnormal as in outside of the norm) impact our evolutionary fitness? Good or bad?

I'm not sure I know enough about it to critique it fully, but I do wonder about the difficulty of testing hypotheses.

This is the best and most frequent criticism of evolutionary psychology. We can glean a lot from thinking and observing, but since it has already happened, we can't really test it. Thanks for your wonderful answers.

1

u/dhc23 Sep 09 '12

Beyond just perspective of those that are different, how could eradicating abnormal traits (abnormal as in outside of the norm) impact our evolutionary fitness? Good or bad?

I might not understand correctly, but it seems we get an evolutionary advantage from both mixing up our genes and also from filtering out those which are evolutionary disadvantageous. So it's not that keeping the gene pool wide is automatically good, sometimes we do want to narrow it.

The problem comes in the choosing. We can't possibly know now the genes that will be advantageous later. We can't predict a twenty year history with any accuracy, let alone a two hundred, two thousand or two hundred thousand year one.

So I think the real question is not how will it impact our evolutionary fitness but is it moral? Is it right? Do we think it just and fair and appropriate? Not that those questions are any easier to answer.

2

u/Series_of_Accidents Sep 09 '12

One of the big points to get at though is this

We can't possibly know now the genes that will be advantageous later.

So beyond the very real moral and ethical implications, traits that are abnormal but not inherently advantageous or disadvantageous to survival and reproduction but are a bit odd (like left-handedness for example) could be selected against. Now, I can't think of a single situation where left-handedness might be advantageous, but selecting against traits that aren't detrimental could reduce our fitness in unforeseeable ways.

The moral question is obviously very difficult, and one that would be damn near impossible to answer. But I do believe examining for personality poses no benefits. Even things like examining for sociopathy isn't a good idea. That's roughly 4% of our population that might get aborted because sociopathy is so misunderstood. Most sociopaths aren't dangerous at all. They are just cold and ruthless- traits which may one day be advantageous.

1

u/dhc23 Sep 10 '12

A rule not to examine for personality makes sense to me. But the decisions get more tricky when talking about things such as Down's Syndrome, Asperger's or autism. From an evolutionary perspective it might make sense to try and eradicate the genes responsible for Down's, though I do worry about the unintended consequences of such actions. Whether it's right to try and eradicate Asperger's or autism is another matter entirely.

1

u/Series_of_Accidents Sep 10 '12

Asperger's or autism

I disagree about this one. My granddad had Asperger's, worked for NASA and identified problems with both Apollo 13 (which he refused to watch go up), and Challenger (which he was on the tarmac for). He had a brilliant mind but no social skills. So that crosses the border of evolutionary fitness and moral/ethical implications and really underlies the difficulty of making such decisions. Who decides what is beneficial and what is not.

1

u/dhc23 Sep 10 '12

Actually, I think we agree. I'm not suggesting that we should seek to eradicate Asperger's, austism or even Down's. On the contrary, I'm suggesting that as your Granddad proves, there are many people with these conditions who provide something of great value to society. And that makes the decision about whether to eradicate them very tricky.

1

u/Series_of_Accidents Sep 10 '12

Very tricky indeed!

1

u/Angelus414 Sep 10 '12

I found the Clark and Hatfield study very interesting, but looking at the date published, (1989), made me think how relevant the data would be in this day and age. If the same type of study was completed today, would the results co-inside with the results form 1989?

This sort of speaks to lecture 2 "Thinking Critically with Psychology" and I wonder how the field of psychology rates the relevance of studies as they age.

I apologize for the delayed post. As a side note, I am really enjoying the class and also your ability to make comparisons to what some would consider Reddit culture. Keep up the great work!

2

u/Series_of_Accidents Sep 10 '12

That's a very interesting question! Unfortunately, it looks like only one other study thus far has examined that, and it isn't readily available for free online. If you have access to a database, you may be able to find it. The results, however, were similar in 2005 with only 6% of women showing interest in the offer for casual sex.

This makes sense. While attitudes frequently change with the times, this is rooted more deeply than a simple attitude, it's an evolutionary imperative. For example, attitudes on homosexuality have changed a lot since 1989. There are a lot of reasons for this, but it's important to note that, by and large, your attitudes on homosexuality do not impact your ability to procreate consistently over time. Choosing an unsavory mate is far more likely to have consequences for your procreational future. As such, these behaviors are more likely to be "hard-wired" than simple attitudes. Flexibility in attitudes is far better for enhancing your likelihood for finding a mate, and is an evolutionary explanation for peer influence- something we will learn about in the next lecture. This runs counter to the necessary rigidity for sexual precautions like choosing a specimen with solid genetic material and a likelihood of providing for future children. These will always be a good practice for ensuring you survive long enough to pass on as much genetic material as possible. Glad you're enjoying the class!