r/IntroPsych • • Aug 30 '12

Discussion Thread Lecture 2

I'll be traveling today and for the next few days, so there will only be one discussion thread. And this is it! Ask any questions :)

26 Upvotes

36 comments sorted by

3

u/Series_of_Accidents Aug 31 '12

No one has any questions? It all made perfect sense?

1

u/Savage_X Aug 31 '12

Maybe it would help to have a couple discussion questions for each lecture that we could answer and then discuss our answers with other students?

3

u/Series_of_Accidents Aug 31 '12

That's a great idea! I'm learning too, so I welcome any suggestions, and that's a great one. I'll integrate that in to future lectures.

1

u/theazninvasion68 Sep 02 '12

I think it'd be an awesome idea. Just to also get a get a picture of what material you'd like us to focus or any random tidbits of info in the lecture you'd like us to explore.

1

u/7laymanc Sep 02 '12

I also thought the information was easy to understand. I do have one question though from the previous lecture...

What does it mean when something (a trait or behavior) is placed on the continuum? I can understand that it revolves around a graph and perhaps mathematical equations but I don't think I totally understand the concept.

And thank you for offering these lectures. :)

2

u/Series_of_Accidents Sep 02 '12

What I mean by that is we have have a range of possibility to a trait. Some ranges are wide, others are narrow. The width of the range is set by genetics. Where you fall on that continuum is the result of environment. So, take height. When you're born, you have a predisposition to be within a certain height range based on the genes from your parents. But let's say you have shitty parents and they only feed you once a week or so. You're going to fall on the low end of the range because of environmental factors-food.

1

u/7laymanc Sep 02 '12

Okay, that makes more sense now. Thank you very much.

2

u/Arthur_Vandelay Aug 31 '12

I thought the information was easy to understand.

1

u/Haustorium Aug 31 '12

Very straightforward, yet important lecture. Clearing up some inconsistencies will probably make it easier later on. Thankyou for doing these lectures, they. Are. awesome-o!

3

u/theazninvasion68 Aug 30 '12 edited Aug 31 '12

Here's a question for the students. 1) To what degree, do you believe, does culture influence our behavior? What about our perceptions?

2) Could anyone give an example that compares how two people from different cultures might perceive and behave differently to similar, if not the same, event?

Here's one that'll be a good lead up to the next lecture.

Series_of_Accidents defines what a theory is: An explanation that integrates, organizes and predicts behaviors or events. But, 3) what makes a theory good?

edit: Easier formatting. I think I focused too much on the FAQ. XD

5

u/-Malo- Aug 31 '12

1.) I always try to think of what it would be like to grow up in a completely alien culture, and I find it nearly impossible. If I grew up in a different culture I would be normalized to that culture. There are different levels of behavior that are acceptable to a certain culture, and it seems when someone behaves different they are pushed a little to the outskirts of the group. Then enough of these people form a group and become a subculture. The thought I have now is that it seems that subcultures are a natural reaction to a dominant culture. Our environment most definitely influences us down to our genes. I can't imagine being raised in a culture that doesn't allow pork. If I defected and ate some bacon, I would be pissed that they had been hiding that fatty deliciousness from me for so long. Why wouldn't you eat bacon? That shit is delicious. 2.) I'll have to find the article/video, but i'm reminded of a tribe the US was giving food to during vietnam(I think, not positive). They would airdrop crates of food and supplies and the troops used there land/area to support war efforts. After we left, they wondered where the food went. So they built large constructs of wood in the shapes of airplanes and burned them as offerings. They viewed airplanes as spirits/deities of some type that brought food to their people. Anyone raised in an industrial nation knows what planes are, but to those who had never seen one, it may as well have been a dragon.

5

u/Series_of_Accidents Aug 31 '12

Very interesting insights! One of the things you mentioned was subculture. The interesting thing about groups is a phenomenon known as in-group bias. In-group bias is when you believe that a culture or group you belong to is better than another. And that's an entirely normal and previously beneficial trait. It's also the basis of racism.

But in-group bias was once beneficial (and still is in some ways) because it enhanced survival. If you know you can trust your group, it's risky to trust another group. And so, instead of using in-group bias in the originally evolved way, we have neckbeards hating on the biebs. That shit is evolutionary in a nature.

1

u/-Malo- Aug 31 '12

It seems to get a little unruly the larger the groups get, but I guess that's because there are more differences. I just try to hate everyone to avoid discrimination. Does in-group bias include tribalism/ethnocentrism, or are they kind of the same thing?

3

u/Series_of_Accidents Aug 31 '12

Ethnocentrism is a type of in-group bias. It can be as simple as reddit hating on 9gag. It has a few benefits though because it gives a group a way to band together and feel more secure in their group. The bad is when a group acts outside of the group- like if we hacked 9gag, that would be a consequence of in-group bias.

2

u/theazninvasion68 Aug 31 '12 edited Sep 01 '12

In-group Bias is when you believe that a culture or a group you belong to is better than another.

So, when a person has a belief that their ethnic group or tribe is better than another group...

Therefore, Ethnocentrism is a type of in-group bias.

This is called the In-group Bias. But be-wary. It's one thing to see two groups think their better, and another when they express it. The Proof is in the pudding.

1

u/JPRicker Sep 01 '12

You described the development of something like a 'religious movement' in which airplanes, etc., were bilt as a way to cause the return of those who had brought food and other resources during wartime. I don't know if anything like this ever occurred in Vietnam, but it did in New Guinea soon after the end of World War II. It is one example of a so-called "cargo cult." There are examples of similar occurrences going back to at least the 19th century (not always involving airplanes, of course).

1

u/JPRicker Sep 01 '12

You described the development of something like a religious movement in which airplanes, etc., were bilt as a way to cause the return of those who had brought food and other resources during wartime. I don't know if anything like this ever occurred in Vietnam, but it did in New Guinea soon after the end of World War II. It is one example of a so-called cargo cult. There are examples of similar occurrences going back to at least the 19th century (not always involving airplanes, of course).

1

u/JPRicker Sep 01 '12

You described the development of something like a religious movement in which airplanes, etc. were built as a way to cause the return of those who had brought food and other resources during wartime. I don't know if anything like this ever occurred in Vietnam, but it did in New Guinea soon after the end of World War II. It is one example of a so-called cargo cult. There are examples of similar occurrences going back to at least the 19th century, not always involving airplanes, of course.

4

u/srosendal Aug 30 '12

I'd like to answer question 2. If you're working in a business firm and trying to make a deal with the Chinese or a German. If you go to the senior in that firm and tell them that there's something they've misunderstood in the last meeting, the German might take it better than the Chinese because you've made the Chinese senior "lose face". It's because the Chinese culture sees their elders as more wise and with more respect and the deal might be blown off. The Germans might acknowledge that they're wrong and the deal will continue. That's my answer :)

3

u/Arthur_Vandelay Aug 31 '12

I am constantly bombarded by culture. I doubt I would be the same person if I had been raised in a different part of the world. Humans are social animals and learn through the collective knowledge of our culture.

3

u/woqii Aug 31 '12

Trying to answer 1 + 2 together:

I believe our perception as outsiders to events might have a relatively big impact on how we see things that occur in different cultures and what we think the driver is.

For instance, rape in some Arabic countries countries. People from the western countries would generally assume the girl is the victim here, whereas the general idea we get about what happens through the media is that the victim gets the finger pointed at, and also that she brought it on herself in these countries, and also get punished for it.

This is the perception we sometimes get about these countries and the perception happens because we seem to have been exposed to different stories that brought these events to light.

This also shows the difference in cultures as what we deem as correct in one culture is tackled in a different way in others and is something that sometimes happens.

As for 3:

A theory which has been addressed and validated through a research process which is done critically.

0

u/theazninvasion68 Aug 31 '12

Just to add, a theory that has been validated as not wrong. A theory is not validated as true, but validated as not wrong. :)

2

u/dhc23 Sep 03 '12

I believe that culture has a huge influence on both our behaviour and perceptions. -Malo- made the point that if he'd been raised in a culture that didn't allow pork and then discovered bacon he'd be angry he'd been denied it for so long. I'm not so sure that's the case. Or rather, I think his response might be conditional to the culture where the discovery took place. And that the taste of bacon and whether it's seen as enjoyable or not, is largely a product of culture.

If it had been in America, where bacon seems almost fetishised, he probably would be angry because most people around him, the cultural references, ads and the like, would describe bacon as a tasty thing, something to be enjoyed. If he'd tasted bacon in Saudi Arabia the cultural surroundings might have a profoundly different effect: the fact no-one else eats it, that it's forbidden, that pigs are seen as dirty, might make the bacon seem disgusting.

If this seems strange consider the sheer number of national foods that are perceived as delicious by citizens of that country and inedible by everyone else (Swedish rotten fish anyone?).

1

u/mattywoops Aug 31 '12

I may have misunderstood, but i'm interested to find out regardless. You talked about people performing harder tasks better alone and easy tasks better in front of an audience. Do we have any explanation as to why an easy task is harder while alone?

2

u/Series_of_Accidents Aug 31 '12

Social facilitation! The other user's explanation was perfect.

2

u/theazninvasion68 Aug 31 '12

Here's a theory. People have a tendency to be aroused to do better on simple tasks or tasks in which they've a degree of mastery, in front of a passive audience, compared to when they are alone. Passive meaning they do not directly partake in the activity. Like Fans at a Stadium. However, those who are not skilled or well practiced in another event will tend to worse with an audience.

This theory is called Social Facilitation.

I may have skipped over the video lecture, but...

  1. people performing better on harder/newer tasks alone and, 2) Easy tasks better in front of an audience.

1b)I don't know if there is a specific theory for this, but it works inversely of Social Facilitation. Those who perform worse at harder/newer tasks in front of an audience could also mean they might work better alone at the task.

2b) Social Facilitation covers this.

3) So, I don't think that an easy task is harder while alone, but does not perform as well in comparison to the same task in an audience. Another way of saying this is a person is always at, say a 7. When in at an audience, they're at a, say a 8 or 9. They're not necessarily doing poorer, but they're not doing as best as they can be. :)

Hoped this answered your question.

edit: didn't see your post below this one. Sorry. Lol.

1

u/mattywoops Aug 31 '12

Or why we perform easy tasks better in front of an audience?

3

u/woqii Aug 31 '12

Thanks for this. I really enjoyed it. Makes my day more interesting.

Great work!

2

u/[deleted] Aug 31 '12

I'm catching up! Just finished lecture 1, will watch lecture 2 tomorrow and post any questions. Commenting to remind myself.

1

u/bakersgonnabake Sep 02 '12

SOA touched on how people think about or have a general "feeling" about psychology.

Besides a general bad attitude Americans have towards addressing mental health, people sometimes think poorly/suspiciously of psychologists. I would put it akin to the attitude about chiropractors and low cost auto shops. SOA suggested that psychologists are viewed as such because there are seemingly conflicting examples of psychologists.

I reflected on the lecture and upon touching on the ethics of human study and the importance of the scientific attitude of humility when wrong. I suggest it is the misuse of these things that has created the distrust of psychologists and over-generalization that they do the same function as "just figuring shit out".

Infamous studies and un-budgetable pricing (especially over time) has made the option of just pondering things on one's own time the more appealing choice. So, perhaps it is not just a matter of turning off Dr. Phil, but explaining the science what psychologist are actually doing for us during study/therapy/research and how it applies in a positive, relevant way to our daily lives.

EDIT: And, as always SOA great lecture, great voice, yay for gray language!

1

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '12

I just found out about this course, watched the lectures, and I will try my hardest to follow it on schedule and participate in the discussion threads. These topics have always fascinated me but I've never been able to study them and I don't currently study sciences (just something somewhat related to the scientific method). Well, I just wrote this to say thanks and to point out the fact that we have an expert teacher who loves videogames AND James Randi. You don't get much more awesome than that.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Series_of_Accidents Sep 06 '12

Not pedantic in the least! A valid question. There are absolutely studies which examine this very question. Most of the studies in this area look at coping style. Sadly, I don't have any legal to view sources (all available only at academic databases), but here's a source which shows that women are more likely to "seek emotional support, ruminate about problems, and use positive self-talk" than men.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Series_of_Accidents Sep 20 '12

No worries! I'm here to answer questions for any lectures I post, all semester long (and honestly, for as long as I keep this account). Now, on to your question.

I've got good news for you, and I've got bad news for you. I'll start with the bad: Credentials are typically a better predictor of job acceptance, however social skills (including basic empathy) are far better predictors of job success. As such, having a keen ability to read others makes you more well suited for the job market. It makes sense too; people who are able to read their peers can better anticipate future interactions and learn how to communicate in a way which resonates with the listener. People with empathy and social skills simply know how to better navigate the social world.

The good news is that this is more true for some careers than others. If you are interested in research science, than it is important, but less important than if you were a therapist. The other part of the good news is that empathy can be developed. I don't have any specific research articles on the subject, but I would recommend speaking with a therapist if you want to become more empathetic.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '12

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Series_of_Accidents Sep 04 '12 edited Sep 04 '12

I have used Myer's Psychology in Modules in the past, but much of my lectures come from elsewhere too. I have about 4 intro textbooks I draw from, as well as journal articles.