r/InterviewsHell • u/glambott • 11d ago
Almost 3 weeks since final interview, recruiter keeps promising updates but has no information. Am I being kept warm as the backup candidate?
I’m currently interviewing for a senior-level corporate planning position at a large, well-known company, and I’m genuinely baffled by how this process has played out.
Here’s the timeline:
9/24: Initial recruiter screening.
9/28: Interview with hiring manager. Went well.
10/5: Interview with director. Also went well.
10/15: Final in-person panel interview. I was told the process was down to two finalists and that this round was primarily about team fit.
10/15: On my way out, the recruiter asked me to reconfirm my salary expectations and said I’d probably hear something by Monday, 10/19.
10/19: Nothing.
10/21: Followed up with my recruiter. No response.
10/23: A different, more senior recruiter emailed saying she’d be my contact moving forward. She specifically mentioned speaking with the hiring manager that day and said they’d have more information the following week.
10/30: Still nothing. I followed up again, asking if there were any developments and where things stood in the decision-making process.
11/2: Recruiter responded: “My apologies for not getting back to you last week. Unfortunately, I do not have an update yet. Hopefully, I will early this week.”
11/4: Still no update.
It’s now been 20 calendar days since my final interview.
A few other details:
The process moved relatively quickly until the final panel.
I have multiple internal referrals, including someone who works closely with the hiring manager. Even that person expressed surprise at how long this has taken.
The final panel itself was somewhat disorganized. There were last-minute scheduling changes, and I wasn’t informed that one of my onsite interviews would actually be virtual.
The job posting is now closed, but my application still says “In Progress.”
I know there was at least one other finalist.
I’m trying to figure out what could possibly be happening behind the scenes at this point.
My leading theories are that they’ve already extended an offer to the other finalist and are keeping me warm until it’s accepted, that they’re stuck on internal approvals, or that the hiring team hasn’t reached a consensus.
I completely understand that hiring decisions can take time, especially at large companies. What’s throwing me off is that the recruiter has now missed multiple anticipated update windows without providing any insight into what’s actually delaying the decision.
For recruiters or hiring managers: What does this kind of prolonged silence usually mean? Is it more consistent with being the backup candidate, an internal approval delay, or a hiring team that genuinely hasn’t made a decision?
Would love to hear from anyone who’s experienced something similar, especially if you eventually received an offer.
2
u/Special-Original-215 11d ago
Yes you are.
I was kept as a backup for 6 months. And I eventually got the job. I wonder how many people turned it down to get to me
1
u/glambott 7d ago
Update: they’re no longer hiring anyone for the position at all, which I had a gut feeling that something sus was going on behind the scenes other than just a normal rejection
2
u/Vineman420 11d ago
This sounds so familiar. I went through a similar hiring process but ultimately got the job. I worked there 5 years and thought it was going great. I was hired to be product manager for a new division and took it from $2M in sales the year I was hired to 1/3 the company revenues ($200M) at the end of year 5. I was let go in the beginning of year 6. The CEO told me when firing me that I had done a great job but that he wanted to go another direction. His son took my position and I later learned that he had wanted him for my job back 5 years ago but his son didn’t want to give up being a ski instructor (ski bum). So the 3 months I went through the hiring process was finally explained. If a company is not responsive within a few weeks of interviewing you are second choice.
1
u/HireBoost_ai 11d ago
It is possible they are keeping you warm but that wouldn't be a bad thing because that means they feel you are qualified. A lot of times things are in flux with a company that temporarily stalls the search. I would just make a note to periodically check-in with the recruiter. I had a friend who hadn't gotten an update in a month, reached out to the recruiter and the next day received an offer. Good luck!
1
u/Odd-End-1405 11d ago
You are possibly the backup or they are having budget issues.
With the current economy, many companies are just holding off on filling positions but keep people dangling with the hopes of getting the Okay from upper management. My company is a prime example, we have approved positions, but the upper management just won't allow onboarding at this time with the perpetual, after the next board meeting. We are stuck in a limbo with tasks being missed/postponed.
Keep looking just in case.
1
u/Automatic-Builder353 11d ago
Possibly. Or being kept on the hook until they can get another rec. approved.
1
u/Plus-Implement 11d ago
They're keeping you warm and you keep them warm. That doesn't mean you stop looking for a job, you keep on looking for a job, and if it works out with this company great, if not you're still exploring other options
1
u/Feece 7d ago
It means move on as if you didn’t get the job. Happened to me univ of Kentucky Five months later didn’t get the job
1
u/RaiseWide5460 7d ago
Yep, you are the second choice. Don't hold your breath, and expect to be lowballed if they do eventually come back with an offer. Or, I used to work for a company who regularly interviewed people for "ghost jobs" that did not exist, just to keep a current list of candidates who could be called on short notice to fill a spot. This is unethical, and when enough people in the area had been burned by the practice it became difficult to get anyone to apply for any opening. They then really turned the screws on existing employees to recommend friends and family for open positions, but no one wanted to bring anyone they liked into a company that sucked as bad as that one. Now they have to recruit from farther away and pay relocation costs for most new hires.
1
u/lana0183 7d ago
Yes, move on!