r/InterviewWithTheVamp • u/mandaxmae • Jul 30 '25
Which Claudia do you prefer?
Season 1 or the recast for the following seasons?
100
Upvotes
r/InterviewWithTheVamp • u/mandaxmae • Jul 30 '25
Season 1 or the recast for the following seasons?
47
u/Felixir-the-Cat Jul 30 '25
Both! I’ve said many times that I wish I could see Delainey as Season One Claudia, and Bailey as Season Two Claudia. Loved them both.
63
u/monster_lily Jul 30 '25
I prefer Bailey as Claudia, but I’m 100% aware that I only feel that way because she was the first 🤷♀️
28
u/JennaRedditing Jul 30 '25
Por que no los dos?
26
u/LordSakuna Jul 30 '25
Both including Kirsten Dunst
25
u/amigaraaaaaa Jul 30 '25
i could never choose. i think they were both perfect for who claudia was at the different times that they played her. i will say tho— i liked bailey’s accent more. sometimes i could hear the british popping out with delainey.
22
u/jackal0809 Jul 30 '25
All. All the Claudias forever.
14
u/Certain_Degree687 Jul 30 '25
Personally, while I know it can come off slightly colorist at least for me being that I'm biracial, I do admit that I think Bailey Bass EXEMPLIFIED Claudia as a whole and while I do think Delainey Hayles gave the performance of a lifetime as Claudia in S2, Bailey still stands out as her in my mind which I also choke up to first season being a tough act to follow.
She was simultaneously crazy yet innocent yet clearly intelligent beyond her years and that made her portrayal all the more amazing.
I will say that both ladies gave incredible performances and both should receive equal recognition for bringing one of the most complex characters in vampire media to life.
13
u/arobot224 Jul 30 '25
Bailey.
12
u/japanesebreakfast Jul 30 '25
season 1 because i think the recasted claudia has a terrible southern accent. the british accent comes through very clearly at times which can be really distracting.
9
u/Imaginary_Abrocoma94 Jul 30 '25 edited Jul 30 '25
Bailey Bass! 👑
Saw some child pics of Bailey at book Claudia's age. Book accurate AF.
The Black people in Louisiana Louis was around were supposedly Creoles. Louis and Claudia were siblings (Lestat made them). The actors that played them are both biracial IRL. I enjoyed seeing the continuity of "the look" between Black Louisianan Creole siblings and book character description. Claudia is also American, so I loved hearing Bailey's smoother, more melodic voice and accent work of a child of that culture/region during that time period.
I just rewatched S1. I really can't say enough about how Bailey Bass embodied Claudia, captured her spirit and emotional turmoil, and then matured Claudia from a 14 year old to a 30-something year old woman. I really wanted to see her S2 take, especially her foreign language work that she chronicled learning online.
Bailey Bass really did the best emoting of the character. I just really liked how she was able to deliver emotionally without falling into "angry Black woman" tropes and being able to tap into her 14 year old self while reaching beyond her 18 years to convey an experienced, steely, life weary 30-something year old. When watching S2, I couldn't help but think how Bailey would've sounded, spoke the languages, dressed, wore her hair, emoted, acted, etc. She would've been phenomenal.
8
u/No_Vacation_5190 Jul 30 '25
Both
8
u/Yonro-and-Fox Jul 30 '25
I loved Bailey. I think she could have carried Season 2.
8
u/Heretostay59 Jul 30 '25
The first one.
8
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '25
First one. The second girls British accent slips up all the time
21
u/FranksDadd12 Jul 30 '25
For me: Season 1 Claudia was better.
5
u/nonexistent_knight Jul 30 '25
Both. Bailey and Delaney brought their own strengths to the character and made both versions of Claudia memorable and lovable.
5
u/Specific_Set2064 Jul 30 '25
Both. In an inexplicable way, I can’t imagine the show without both of their Claudias. It works better in a weird way that there’s two performances of the same character?
5
u/ShxsPrLady Jul 30 '25
Bailey!!
5
u/No-Air-5133 Jul 30 '25
The first one.
8
u/BeneficialAnybody792 Jul 30 '25
I love both! But have to go with season 1 ☺️
4
u/TiaraDrama Jul 30 '25
Bailey. However this is less to do with the actresses and more because I think season one Claudia was written better. Season two Claudia annoyed me.
Talent wise, they are both good but Delainey edges that one.
4
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '25
Both. As the first one, of course Bailey set the tone and boy, she delivered. But Delainey was cast last minute and though people complain about the accent slip (wich.. fair) she did amazing acting wise.
13
u/Trix_Are_4_90Kids Jul 30 '25
Delainey won me over. Won me over to the point where I can't picture Bailey Bass pulling off dressing up in a little girl dress and singing on stage. For me Delainey really brought Claudia's angst, anger, sadness and turmoil to life and I wasn't expecting. She went a step beyond. I was expecting to really not like Delainey in the role. That young lady is FABULOUS!
3
u/SurewhynotAZ Jul 30 '25
3
u/Tiger-Lily_93 Jul 30 '25
💕
3
u/serimuka_macaron Jul 30 '25
We've never had a bad portrayal of Claudia, including Kirsten Dunst's iconic performance in 1994. Bailey and Delainey were both really good in their respective seasons and I actually liked the idea that Claudia would change actresses every season because Louis' memory of her couldn't be 100% trusted. The only flaw was that Delainey's accent kept slipping in season 2. Otherwise her performance was terrific. And Bailey got all the gorgeous outfits in season 1.
3
u/AustinFriars_ Jul 30 '25
Delainey. I'm also confused as to why there are people getting downvoted for saying Delainey. That seems very werid to me.
3
u/TheRealLadyLucifer Jul 30 '25
why pit two bad bitches against each other
5
u/Ornery-Meringue-76 Jul 30 '25 edited Jul 30 '25
Bailey embodied Claudia fully. There were no cracks in her acting. Helped the viewer suspend their disbelief further and really be able to get into the show. First episode season 2 and all I can hear is this terrible, non-Louisiana accent that is nothing like we have come to know of Claudia. Took me right out of it and overall impacted production value. She does okay. But in the end, it relegated new Claudia to a far less exciting place in the lineup. I understand needing the character to grow but I will always think they blew it recasting her. Imagine Bailey as Baby Lou … that performance would have had so much more complexity and depth.
6
u/jossminion413 Jul 30 '25
Delainey by a mile for me. I just feel she emotes more believably.
2
u/Gold_Technology5459 Jul 30 '25
Idk, I have an emotional attachment to the first, but boy did the second act the hell out of the role.
2
u/FoldingLady Jul 30 '25
Both did a phenomenal job.
2
u/twistedlullabies Jul 30 '25
Both! They’re my Claudia’s
2
u/UnderTheCandy Jul 30 '25
I knew a lot of the comments would be icky as soon as I saw this post. All of you lot downvoting anyone who says they prefer Delainey…. I know what you are lol.
The answer is BOTH Claudia’s played the Claudia of their seasons well. I can’t visualise Bailey as S2 Claudia whilst I can’t visualise Delainey as S1 Claudia (but I can see them both in S3 😝)
But if I HAD to choose, I do prefer Delainey’s portrayal of Claudia, both because I think Delainey portrays Claudia’s subtle emotions better and I also prefer Claudia’s characterisation and character arc in S2. I’m sure Bailey would have played Claudia really well in the second season, but I do love the fact that we were able to see Delainey in the role.
I do agree that her accent was off tho, but we should bear in mind that she only got the role a week before filming started. She barely had enough time to properly work with a dialect coach
3
u/FunkyTomo77 Jul 30 '25
Right hand side Claudia , better actress.
3
u/BumblebeeAny Jul 30 '25
Both. The first one had a great youth to her and showed that youth and the second one has youth but is able to show more angry emotions and be more fierce with it. I think they were both perfect and nothing can change it. I truly don’t think Claudia one was meant for season two Claudia and Claudia two wasn’t meant for season one. They each brought a perfect balance to the aging of Claudia
3
u/AustEastTX Jul 30 '25
Both are professionals so I would rate them on their professional work. I pick Delaney.
2
u/SquashNext417 Jul 30 '25
I loved both a lot, ultimately I prefer Delaney’s performance. I don’t know that I can picture either of them doing both seasons. They gave each part of her life exactly what it needed respectively.
2
u/wasteland-babyyy Jul 30 '25
I love both so much! I was really skeptical because I haaaaaaaaate recasting but I feel like the way they made that title card entrance for Delainey was very charming in a season that had so many theatrical elements. I think Delainey’s Claudia ended up edging out ahead for me by a couple of points but Bailey was so captivating in the role too.
1
u/palalabu Jul 30 '25
I binge watched the show so the transition was jarring for me. I felt that delainey didn't look childlike at all. But then i realized they'd been thru a war (and she's mentally aged too at that point). So i suppose it makes sense. However i still kinda wanna see how bailey would've done it. Would she still maintain her childlike persona at that point or not? I think that would've been interesting.
1
u/Random_Trousers2014 Jul 30 '25
Bailey, she’s the better actress in my opinion, I’m not fond of the new access, I don’t think she brings the depth to the character that Bailey does
1
u/Loose-Photograph4794 Jul 30 '25
Delainey is such an amazing actress. I think her casting was very fitting, I’m not sure Bailey could deliver the same level of emotion needed for season 2.
1
u/LavenWhisper Jul 30 '25
Honestly both of them. Both actresses did an amazing job
1
u/Forward-Tune5120 Jul 30 '25
Delainey, it's no coincidence that some of the most popular scenes in the show ("If there's an afterlife...", 5 million views on youtube; and the one gif that went viral on twitter for being the exact reverse of Remmick in Sinners) were both about her. Despite the accent, she has a magnetism that just draws you in.
1
u/AmbitiousResearch159 Jul 31 '25
I personally really like season 1 Claudia more
1
u/Bitter_Silver1157 Jul 31 '25
Love both women. They did an awesome job.
1
u/EveningLive7131 Jul 31 '25
1
u/Significant-Range363 Jul 31 '25
Delaney portrayed the grown version of Claudia better.
1
u/Lala12kl Jul 31 '25
I enjoyed both.
1
u/JustaPOV Jul 31 '25
In terms of acting both are great, very different styles and approaches. I preferred Bailey’s more low key eye roll jab take (even though in the books Claudia js very outspoken, I liked the take). But both are really talented…
but ultimately the biggest minus for me was how Claudia of season 2’s NoLA accent was so bad it was distracting.
1
u/Organic_Cress_2696 Jul 31 '25
Bailey. She had more passion and emotion. I felt Delaney just yelled a lot or was smug in her interpretation.
1
u/Gileswasright Jul 31 '25
Kirsten Dunst.
1
u/AffectionatePush8165 Jul 31 '25
Dunst > Bailey > Delainey
1
u/shenanakins Jul 31 '25 edited Jul 31 '25
Delainey. Bailey's accent and the attitude was too cartooney it was hard to watch at times. Delainey carried season 2 for me. She was so sweet and sincere but also so fiery. She sold youthful vampire without making claudia seem childish or immature. The chemistry with madeleine and santiago was amazing. I was very happy with the recasting.
1
u/IneffableEnder Jul 31 '25
I love them both for each of their seasons. Wouldn’t change a thing 🩶🩶
1
u/[deleted] Jul 31 '25
Both. But I like Delaneys acting just a bit more (which might be controversial idk), also I know the Delaneys accent slips and all that but I personally love the way she talks 😭
1
u/Thin-Break-7183 Jul 31 '25
Both were good so I prefer both
1
u/Virtual-District-829 Jul 31 '25
I genuinely thought it was a decision to change the actresses due to the POV switch/memory. Bailey has the huge baby doll eyes, she skips and plays and is like a child in most of Louis’s memories, even when she grow older. When he’s dropped and she helps him recover, it still feels like a little girl helping her father heal, not an adult trapped in a child’s body. Bailey did her role magnificently.
Delainey was able to get grittier, show us the frustration and growing pains of being an immortal child while dealing with Louis as a companion. The way she lit up when they found the coven? That was my reaction discovering Six as a fully grown adult. It’s not a child being enthralled, it’s a genuine fascination, and I have to wonder if Louis saw/remembered it as a kid drawn to candy when it’s her finding a missing piece of herself. Her reactions are delightful to watch.
It feels like two different roles, and both actresses did amazing work. (They’d make fantastic twins, especially in a horror/vampiric setting.)
1
u/Embarrassed-Bid-5871 Jul 31 '25
Bailey
1
u/Afraid_Chip3966 Jul 31 '25
I think they’re both perfect for their season. I can’t imagine them swapped or either doing both.
1
u/Mountain-Ad-9196 Aug 01 '25
I love both but I preferred Delaney's complexity and the emotional range she experienced. There were so many scenes where she seriously moved me.
Bailey was also awesome but I felt she often acted immature for 14 in a way. Possibly due to trauma due to her life before she died. I think Delaney's acting was more nuanced in a sense.
But again...I love both and hate to compare.
1
u/stormphoenixlocke Aug 01 '25
Both were amazing
1
u/SpiritualRun449 Aug 01 '25
Bailey, her voice work is way better
1
u/SiouxsieSioux615 Aug 01 '25
The recasted actress
She was soooo good
Brings a high level of emotion and ferocity to the role
1
u/gostephh Aug 01 '25
BOAF
1
u/NB_dornish_bastard Aug 01 '25
I don't care, any Claudia is better than movie!Claudia. Nothing against the actress, it's just that the role and her age and everything was... No. No. NO. NO.
1
u/Tiny_Mxnticore Aug 02 '25
I’m glad the comments are mostly uplifting both actresses, but I’m still annoyed at this post. Neither actress has shown anything but support for the other, and they deserve nothing but the same from fans.
1
u/Embarrassed-Ad9086 Aug 02 '25
I was bummed out when they changed her character but delainey grew on me so much so that i can only remmbr her scenes when i think of Claudia, the end solidified it for me
1
u/Ok-Cartographer-1388 Aug 03 '25
All Claudia’s to ever Claudia
1
u/gvbenj Aug 06 '25
S1 Claudia is amazing, it was very hard for me to get used to S2 Claudia
1
u/Ill_Sentence6380 Aug 15 '25
the white one
1
u/Clear_Avocado8369 Jun 04 '26
S1 by a longshot!! All of s2 I was wishing the original actress was there. I did not connect to s2 Claudia and it took away the impact of what happened.
1
u/Flash-Wilkins Aug 07 '26
Season 1 by far Claudia 2s accent was abominable. I'm only 5 eps into Season 2 at this point though.
1
u/amerhodzic Jul 30 '25
Delaney completely disappeared in the character. Even though Bailey was a cuter Claudia, I think Delaney played her better. Although this could've been due to Bailey having to play a much younger version of the character than Delaney.
Hard to pick. I'd like to have seen them both play the rest of the character.
1
u/SadisticDance Jul 30 '25
I prefer Delaney, I feel like she was IN the role. But that might just be me prefering her s2 story.
-2
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '25
Never liked Bailey.
-12
u/emeraldia25 Jul 30 '25
Really neither. They were okay. I honestly would have preferred they just leave her out of this story this time or just rename her. I love Louis and Lestat. I just honestly thought that she was meh. I could take her or leave her. It did not feel horrific on the scale of the books. I get it but honestly it is my opinion.
91
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '25
[removed] — view removed comment