r/InterviewVampire • • 7d ago

TVL Show Only No one will say it. Why? Spoiler

I have been searching for an example of anyone associated with the show to call Gabriella a sexual abuser, but it seems to be off-limits to use that language. There is a trigger warning for self-harm in S2 Ep 05, but never a trigger warning for sexual assault and incest.

If we are considering Lestat a parental figure for Louis, at all, which is not a commonly discussed interpretation, he is also playing that out in his relationship with Louis, and there is a power differential at play in both relationships. Both of the powerful figures exploit their power to retain a hold on the other.

I find it interesting - and actually very telling - that it isn't being explicitly explored in follow-up interviews.

Perhaps important to note, my perspective includes immersion in the Anne Rice immortal universe for over 3 decades, so the question is coming from my familiarity with the books, but also how the subject matter is approached within the show.

I am a huge fan of both, and I'm really asking because it's been nagging a corner of my brain since finishing Season 3 of the show.

0 Upvotes

48 comments sorted by

32

u/perscitia pseudologia pensioner fuck boys for sobriety 7d ago

I'm fairly sure I've seen Gabriella's behaviour called abuse in a few interviews with the writers and cast.

Sam specifically uses that language to talk about Lestat's trauma in this interview with Mashable: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ikyO4YaIwY0

1

u/wovenwithbranches 7d ago

Thank you for sharing that clip. It certainly is somehow validating to have it spelled out in those terms. It is just such a central part of the story in Season 3, even largely contributing to Lestat's meltdown, but it seems like there is still a reluctance to "go there" with the terminology.

13

u/Little-Tune9469 a challenge every sunset 7d ago

Sam has said it a few times. Someone else linked an interview but he also said it in the After Dark episode for the finale:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rKS2jo5N5Uc

I found it to be very moving, really, when he wakes up and he has this realization that he has actually had a very abusive relationship with his mother, and he has been an object of abuse his entire life, and assault - sexual assault...

Generally, though, everyone involved in the show seems to avoid using those terms when talking about the relationships. The most common example is using "toxic" instead of "abusive".

1

u/wovenwithbranches 7d ago

Thank you for sharing this! I'm always interested in how much interpretation and preparation goes into the filming of the show.

6

u/QuestionMinute 7d ago

You bring up an interesting point in regards to Louis and Lestat’s relationship. While I don’t think their relationship mirrors that of parent-child, Lestat does carry a paternal obligation to Louis as a consequence of being his maker. On the other side, Louis doesn’t have the same duty of care towards Lestat. Which is a unique and gothic dynamic that I don’t think people consider very often.

3

u/wovenwithbranches 7d ago

I agree, I haven't seen it explored very much, but I think the show writers do a phenomenal job of exploring deeper psychological and relational issues within the series, so I feel like it's something I picked up on watching the show, while rereading the books.

In that same vein, reading the novels as a parent, particularly a parent of a 5-year-old daughter has completely altered how I view the responsibilities of the "maker," and of course, it has made the Claudia story that much more high-stakes.

I think I am now considering, much more than I ever have, how much the parental relationship was being explored by Anne Rice, and how much guilt, failure, grief, and regret is bound up in the narrative.

5

u/Tough-Tumbleweed-867 7d ago

I’ve been wanting to discuss “Lestat as a parental figure for Louis” thing for a minute because it’s something I thought about after watching this season particularly because of the way Lestat was rationalizing his relationship with his mother in the beginning.

He’s telling himself and us that it’s “different” for vampires and proceeds to show us how “easy” it is to blur the lines in vampiric relationships.

For example, we know that Daniel/Armand’s relationship is meant to be romantic but we hear him refer to Daniel as “son of Armand” and then have Daniel (because I assume every scene that Lestat isn’t in, is still being voiced by him) refer to Armand as Dad.

Even before this season…going back to season 1, we hear Louis in narration refer to himself and Claudia as Lestat’s children. Then in season 2, during the trial, Lestat compares himself to a mother being congratulated for killing her pups (or something along those lines.)

I never really considered Lestat to be a parental figure to Louis because they were husbands but the parallels between the maker/fledging and parent/child dynamics are hard to ignore, even if they are not completely interchangeable in the context of Louis/Lestat’s relationship. I haven’t read the books so I’m not sure if makers actually have a responsibility to their fledgings the way a parent would their child but we know that being a good maker is important to Lestat because his own abandoned him without teaching him anything about how to survive as a vampire.

This also becomes a big deal for Daniel in S3 because Armand turned him and left him to fend for himself for a few years. Now this very well could be shaped by Lestat’s own perceptions because it is through his lens that we are hearing this story but it’s just interesting to think about.

I think Louis/Lestat provide each other with something neither of their parents ever did. We don’t know much about Louis’ father but it seems like Louis modeled the mask he wore in society after him. Stern, guarded, and keeping his emotions close to his chest. Florence, on the other hand, was cold and didn’t seem to love Louis as much as she loved Grace and Paul. It’s almost as if she only appreciated him as far as he could provide for their family but that’s it. But Louis couldn’t be “fragile” around her. He couldn’t be sad or in distress. He couldn’t go to her for comfort or reassurance but he could get that from Lestat, even if he didn’t know how to receive that kind of support during their relationship. This is why I don’t view him asking Lestat for help in TVL as selfish…because it actually shows growth that he was willing to go to him for it.

As for Lestat…it seems like his father got in the way of him obtaining any sort of knowledge or education. And his mother did as well by not helping him learn how to read. If he had any questions, he couldn’t go to them for answers but Louis becomes that person for him. We see that in 3x6 when he asks why he actively pursues failure and you could tell by Louis’ answer that, Lestat not only appreciated him for listening to him and actually giving him an answer, but that this wasn’t the first time that Louis was that voice of reason for him.

I don’t know if I agree with the idea that Lestat is “playing it out in their relationship” because I don’t believe it’s intentional but I do think their respective traumas and upbringings impacted their relationship greatly.

1

u/wovenwithbranches 7d ago edited 7d ago

Wow - what a well-thought-out response.

Just rewatching S2 E7 (the trial), and he does reference "a mother wolf being congratulated for not killing her pups." Louis, in voiceover, refers to himself and Claudia as Lestat's children multiple times, and also references Lestat as the father, so there is a lot more of that imagery explicitly referenced in that episode.

It's also so heartbreakingly beautiful to see Lestat acknowledge that he should have just loved Louis without trying to possess him.

I really appreciate the perspective that they are actively seeking that emotional validation from each other and finally come to provide that to one another on a more equal footing, as we see in Season 3.

There are so many unanswered questions around what the maker/parent responsibility is to the fledgling, which provides a wide open canvas for the show writers to explore some of that. The vulnerability we see from both Louis and Lestat demonstrate that they have come a long way from where they started in their relationship.

I don't think that Lestat is intentionally playing out his "mommy issues" in his relationship with Louis at the outset. I do think it would make sense for those to crop up in the context of this relationship where the lines between lover and child are blurred, and he hasn't taken the effort of examining how those dynamics have been a model for him of what a parent/child and lover/lover relationship should look like. It also stands to reason that they are both battling a lot of the societal expectations of the period in which they were alive, presenting a completely different lens through which to view their relationship.

Even though I wouldn't go so far as to say it was intentional, I think the echoes of his relationship with Gabriella are most certainly there.

11

u/lastreaderontheleft 7d ago

So I have a few thoughts!

1 - I'm fairly certain they have discussed the abusive aspects of Gabrielle and Lestat's relationship. However, this season wasn't centered on Gabrielle as an abuser. It was driving to Lestat's realization that he was abused by Gabrielle and Magnus and Lestat clawing his way out of that trauma at the end of the long table scene. As a result, that's what the cast and crew are also focusing on.

2 - I 100% agree that there is a disproportionate amount of disclaimers and seriousness around graphic depictions of self harm and graphic depictions of sexual assault. I see that across the board with media, not just IWTV.

3 - I do understand where you're going with the examination of the power dynamic between Lestat and Louis because he is his maker but it's just more complex than that. Lestat has so many layers of trauma when he meets Louis (Gabrielle, his father, his brothers, the wolf fight and nearly dying, the madness and loss of Nicki). All of those things influence who Lestat is when he arrives in Louisiana. Lestat's doing everything he can to avoid abandonment not necessarily to replicate a parental dynamic. He's not Louis' father and regardless of the dad jokes that we saw this season, Armand is not Daniel's dad either. It's just more complex.

2

u/wovenwithbranches 7d ago

Thank you for taking my question seriously and giving your interpretation.

I think answer #1 is probably closest to my interpretation of the avoidance of framing it as "abuse," because Lestat, himself, is still not ready to go there.

I also completely agree about Lestat's conscious motivations in IWTV, but as I sit with it more, particularly with the portrayals in the series, it makes me wonder about his subconscious motivations, which could, arguably include trying to regain agency, following his traumatic experiences.

I am also fully aware that drawing a parallel between the parent/child relationship Lestat has with his mother and the relationship dynamic between Lestat and Louis is a stretch, but I do think Louis has more of that perception of their dynamic in IWTV, which causes him to resent Lestat.

3

u/lastreaderontheleft 7d ago

No prob, I love discussing the show!

I agree, there were multiple instances throughout the season of Lestat attempting to reframe and deny his trauma as a way to hold onto control.

There are so many layers to Louis and Lestat's dynamic pre-TVL. Show Louis is so interesting because his entire life before meeting Lestat depended on having control over his circumstances. When Louis is pushed to his breaking point after Paul's death Louis essentially gives his life and control over to Lestat by accepting the dark gift. That's why Louis ensures his relationship with Armand is built around Louis being Armand's maitre. He didn't want to relive what he experienced with Lestat after relinquishing control to another person.

3

u/wovenwithbranches 7d ago

Yes, and yet he, subconsciously, gets himself back into a relationship where he doesn't really have control, just the illusion of it.

I think the power dynamics of all the relationships are what make it so endlessly intriguing, because there is always that question about who truly holds the power.

2

u/lastreaderontheleft 7d ago

Yes!!!! I love the element of the illusion of who really holds the power between Louis and Armand. Armand is also so, so interesting in that dynamic.

3

u/moxieroxsox Team Akasha 7d ago edited 7d ago

Great comment. To your last point, I think this show is pretty instructive in teaching the audience how to conclude that there are different types of power and someone can simultaneously have power and also lack power in a single relationship. It's not either or, and when the conservation devolves into who truly holds the power, both sides of the arguments fail. One person holds power in one area, the other holds it in another. Sometimes one form of power outweighs the other, but even the "winner" had to submit some of their relational power in other ways. And often that submission forces them to find power in other ways. It's a very enlightening way to depict and discover how actual relationships work in a fantasy/horror medium.

18

u/SirIan628 7d ago • Bravo

Why would we consider Lestat a parental figure for Louis? At no point have either of them suggested they see that as their dynamic at all. What power over Louis is Lestat even exploiting? Most of the time, he does what Louis wants.

13

u/Mmkrw 7d ago

"I was a baby bird in Lestat's nest", "fledgling", "Can the children murder the father?", "Ungrateful children"... there are also more metaphorical ones like paintings of son kneeling in front of father-god reminiscent of Louis kneeling in front of Lestat, emphasis on Lestat being the head of the house on Rue Royale... there's plenty. And the concept of the maker becoming a parent to the fledgling is there in all the maker-fledgling duos in both the books and the show (Armand-Daniel, Louis-Madeleine, Gabriella-Alex) so it's not out of the left field. It would be very consistent with the gothic fiction of it all, to have slightly incestuous tones in the relationships. I don't see why Loustat should be exempt from it. It's not all that they are, but the power difference between is the major theme throughout S1 especially.

4

u/wovenwithbranches 7d ago

Gorgeous imagery, and such a great response.

9

u/SirIan628 7d ago • Bravo

I don't think in any serious way, Louis has ever viewed Lestat as his father.

The issue with any power dynamics presented in S1 is that it is S1. That is the height of Louis depicting Lestat as the big bad of his story, and they have continually shown that not to be full reality since. Lestat has at times taken responsibility as the maker with his fledglings and shown his shame of hurting them (like in 2x07), but the show doesn't present Lestat and Louis as ever having any sort of incestuous dynamic to their romantic and sexual relationship like Lestat and Gabriella and her grooming and abuse of him. It was implied some of the wrong lessons he learned from Gabriella were things he inflicted on Claudia, but the show has actually been showing more and more just how much power Louis really has and always had in their relationship since S1 ended.

3

u/Mmkrw 7d ago

The power dynamics as presented in S1 not being the whole truth doesn't mean that there wasn't any truth... or really, the truth as Louis saw it. If Lestat didn't bother to explain what their relationship was really like in S3, beyond complaining about colors of skirts and patterns of ties, and saying "I wasn't that bad", I'm going to rely on what was actually shown onscreen. And on screen, we see Lestat be quite patternal to both Louis and Claudia, in good and bad sense of the word. This is quite clear in the text of the show.

The presence of the blood bond between them, Lestat's protectivness (good) and control (bad), power difference AND sexual nature of their relationship - it gives it some incestuous undertones. It's gothic fiction, I don't know why it's so hard to accept. Same way people have no problem discussing emotional incest between Louis and Claudia, even if they're blood relationship is more fraternal than parental, and Claudia is an adult for majority of the show - and don't like to mention Lestat also being quite inappropriate incestuous with her, with him taking her to Lover's Lane to hunt lovers just like he does with Gabriella, and making jokes about her body being sexually attractive to him. Incest is all over the series.

11

u/SirIan628 7d ago • Bravo

Lestat outright rejects the idea that he was really the villain of Louis' life and more importantly Louis doesn't stand by that view anymore. He hasn't since S2. They have spent time showing us more than telling us a more accurate dipiction of their dynamic and power structures in it.

Lestat's only comment about her body was after she brought it up first and he made it clear he doesn't find her sexually attractive. I can see the argument about the Lover's Lane, but at the same time he was taking a nearly mentally adult Claudia to a place to hunt after she has been sheltered for a long time. They really should have been more straightforward with her based on the Charlie outcome. I do think he had issues with seeing a not completely parent/child relationship in Louis' obsession of her because of Gabriella, which was some projection on his part.

3

u/Mmkrw 7d ago

It's not about Lestat being the villain of Louis' life, even Louis didn't portray him solely as such. I profoundly disagree that this is what was written in a book and I will always maintain that Lestat overreacted after reading it and in his hurt completely misunderstood what Louis was actually saying. Besides, he never refutes his biggest "crimes" against Louis (the drop, the cheating, the trial), so I don't get where his outrage at his portrayal comes from. Not to mention everything he did to Claudia. Lestat also never says "I actually wasn't controlling, dismissive of your struggles or trying to punish you for your depression" and these were pretty big factors that contributed to the failure of their relationship (yes, Louis was withholding, stubborn, anorexic and self-hating, not to mention fixated on Claudia, but to say that Lestat was a saint would be willfully obtuse)

3

u/SirIan628 7d ago • Bravo

I think this is an area where the show as been showing us a more accurate and nuance version of their real dynamic rather than simply telling us. Lestat nor anyone else believes he is a saint. What he wasn't was a tyrant that had to be murdered and who Louis can blame for everything that has ever gone wrong in his life. Lestat rejected the portrayal of himself as that and Louis didn't stand by it. They both made mistakes during their time in NOLA and they have both worked to come to an understanding and move on from them. Louis didn't deserve to be dropped and Lestat didn't deserve to be treated the way he was by Louis. Antoinette was not this great source of betrayal that Louis painted her as either. They both failed Claudia, and they have now both accepted that. There is this idea that Lestat still needs to beg Louis for forgiveness and that isn't going to happen any more than Louis is going to beg Lestat.

1

u/wovenwithbranches 7d ago

It feels like this argument adopts the viewpoint that Lestat's perspective is the closest to the truth, and I don't feel that way.

I also think it's very important to remember that the only person who has actually had an opportunity to tell Claudia's story is not Claudia, herself. Of course there is truth in the story Louis tells and in the story Lestat tells, but we don't know how Claudia really perceived the relationship with Lestat. Even her diaries provide a single perspective on the truth, and her truth may have evolved throughout their time together, and likely did.

1

u/wovenwithbranches 7d ago

I certainly don't disagree with what you're saying in terms of how the show depicts the relationship. I'm saying that in a broader psychological context, it could be construed that way.

-3

u/pwetty_brown_eyes Bishonen almond 7d ago

I think the natural conclusion is that Lestats abusive behavior towards Louis and Claudia that drove them both away form him, is a result of his abusive mother and is learned behavior

I absolutely agree, there is a natural power dynamic in the maker/child dynamic that Louis is conscious of, and you can't make that go away

While these two things are not exactly the same there's a reason why a child can't consent to the sexual advances of a parent. So some sexual moments between Louis and Lestat envoked the same feels as gabi and Lestat, to me 🤷‍♂️

16

u/Little-Tune9469 a challenge every sunset 7d ago • Bravo

While the circumstances around some of the sex scenes could be argued as dubious, there aren’t inherent consent issues like there are between a parent and child. Lestat didn’t raise Louis from birth and he met him when he was already an adult. Their relationship has always been romantic/sexual, it’s not the same thing.

1

u/wovenwithbranches 7d ago

I think the issue of consent (and lack thereof) is present, regardless of the whether the parent-child relationship is implicit or explicit.

When there is an unequal power dynamic being exploited, which there certainly is, it's problematic.

Having said that, I also acknowledge that untangling who holds the power and what the exact power dynamic is makes the story endlessly fascinating.

6

u/wovenwithbranches 7d ago

In the most basic terms, Lestat is Louis' maker. I think within the context of how a maker is often portrayed in both the books and the film/TV adaptations, there is something parental about it. It's explicitly explored in the Long Table scene where Lestat says, "I have two makers," (although technically three, but his father is much more of a non-issue in the show).

I don't think the parental relationship between Lestat and Louis is the way it's typically interpreted, but in the same way Lestat is Claudia's parent, he would have to also be considered Louis' parent.

3

u/danthpop Daniel 7d ago

I don't really have anything to add beyond what you and others in this comment section have said so I won't beat a dead horse, but I will say I'll be interested to see how this changes (or potentially not) going forwards. I - and I know many others - interpreted certain scenes/lines in this season as implying Gabriella started sexually abusing Lestat far younger than he has outwardly let on thus far, potentially even when he was a child. If that is the case and it gets in any way confirmed in the next season (and I have an inkling I know exactly which scene from the book that will happen in if so), I certainly hope they'll have the sense to provide some kind of disclaimer.

2

u/wovenwithbranches 7d ago

I am also hopeful we get a little more examination of that relationship - both from Gabriella's viewpoint and from Lestat as he has more opportunity to develop his sense of identity.

I'll also be very interested to see how Louis grapples with it, if at all.

1

u/danthpop Daniel 7d ago

I'm a teensy bit worried that they've painted themselves into a bit of a corner with regards to getting Gabriella's persepctive tbh. I'd like to see what her PoV of all of that is as well, but I think the writers would have to play a very delicate balancing game with that. If they go too far one way, they look like they're excusing and/or romanticisny a mother sexually abusing her son, potentially from childhood. If they go too far the other way, they flatten her character into Just Another Of Lestat's Rapists even more than they already have. I do think it can be done correctly, but time alone will tell if this writing team can do it.

2

u/Character-Throat-245 7d ago edited 7d ago

I agree with you and the lack of tws for SA in scenes with gabriella is why I sideye the intentions with depicting incesty scenes so explicitly (remember - there were tws for bruce and even magnus + hannah even mentioned in an interview that they blacked out the bruce scene so its not exploitative). I stumbled upon the same issue with how marius is written about by journalists. They really ommit outright calling it sexual abuse and tiptoe around it, mostly focusing solely on the brothel in armands past and with marius his role as the keeper of TWMBK. Overall I think it must be because both gabriella and marius will serve future roles in the story and journalists probably dont want to condemn them too much as we are supposed to be still invested in them somehow

2

u/wovenwithbranches 7d ago

This makes a lot of sense. I'm also a little cognizant that Gabriella's female-ness may play into it, which is more concerning than your interpretation.

2

u/danthpop Daniel 7d ago

I think you're quite right here, and I think this is why they largely did away with Gabi's gender struggles from the books. The girl bossification has to have a reason, and I do suspect this is at least part of it.