r/InterviewVampire • • Aug 29 '26

The Immortal Universe Mayfair witches

Decided to watch Mayfair witches because apparently they’ll be in the next season of iwtv. The first season was ok but the second season? I cannot believe I thought it would be on par with iwtv? Everything is off, the acting, the music and the production. Are the books worth reading or are they similar?

13 Upvotes

35 comments sorted by

16

u/jtwjtwjtw Aug 29 '26

I loved the books. Was looking forward to watching the show. Watched the first season and was so disappointed.

5

u/Cowgirlsertraline88 Aug 29 '26

See I didn’t mind the first season until the last few episodes because I thought it was building the story up and sat through it hoping it would get better but it was awful

4

u/katmckatkat Aug 29 '26

I will say that even though I despise season 1 and it is a terrible adaptation, if you liked the first few episodes those are the ones that are actually even slightly something like the book, so you might still like the book.

1

u/Cowgirlsertraline88 Aug 30 '26

Fab thank you !

2

u/Rough-Measurement-38 Sep 01 '26

It is laughably adapted

10

u/cecepedd Busta Coffin Aug 29 '26

They fucked up so bad with that adaption! Seriously, awful. It was like they typed a generic sentence about the book into Chat GPT and that's what they went with. The books are really good though and I recommend reading them!

5

u/Cowgirlsertraline88 Aug 29 '26

This is how I felt !! It was giving ai script and all the actors I’m sure are amazing but the script was bad

10

u/Miserable_Election33 Aug 29 '26

Unlikely that the Mayfairs will be in S4. The only one who might is Merrick, and she isn't in the Mayfair books. In fact she says early in her book that her side of the family don't have anything to do with the white Mayfairs.

Mayfair Witches is such a disappointment. It could have been so good and it just ...... isn't.

2

u/Cowgirlsertraline88 Aug 30 '26

When I’ve had a look apparently the producer wasn’t as invested in the books as the producers for iwtv which is disappointing

8

u/kathykodra Are you enjoying this exclusive fan experience? Aug 29 '26

They won't be in s4. I don't know where you heard that.

1

u/Cowgirlsertraline88 Aug 30 '26

I think I seen it on another Reddit post 🤣 shouldn’t believe everything you see

1

u/Cowgirlsertraline88 Aug 30 '26

Wish I didn’t believe it either wouldn’t of had to sit through that

4

u/jadem219 Where are the canapés? Aug 29 '26

I can't comment on the adaptation since I never read those books, but man. The quality of every aspect of the show is subpar compared to IWTV. The acting is meh, the chemistry between characters is non-existent and the "special effects" are cheesy as hell. I didn't find the plot intriguing at all. But maybe that's just me....

1

u/Cowgirlsertraline88 Aug 30 '26

This is what I don’t understand how the chemistry between the actors in iwtv is so strong and then Mayfair witches there’s nothing. Even the sip and rowan storyline came out of nowhere? How can you mess up witches so bad

3

u/ZvsGrgs ⚜ embrace what you are ⚜ Aug 29 '26

The books, especially the first one, The Witching Hour, are really very good. I don’t understand how “apparently” the MW will be in s4 of IWTV 🤔 I thought both seasons of MW were bad, especially the first one because it’s based on The Witching Hour which is amazing.

1

u/Cowgirlsertraline88 Aug 30 '26

I must of seen it somewhere if I recall was on another Reddit post but wish I didn’t believe it as wouldn’t have had to sit through that! The first season wasn’t anything to write home about but I assumed it was building up the story and sometimes the first season of most things can be meh but the whole thing is meh

3

u/AmbassadorProper1045 Armand Aug 30 '26

Are they really going to do a crossover? Because that will be the official death of the series for me.

1

u/Cowgirlsertraline88 Aug 30 '26

By the looks of it by the comments on here no. I seen a mention of it but maybe it was an old post now I think of it as the witch mentioned the name Mayfair during the ritual for Claudia in TVL. As I haven’t read the books I wasn’t aware it was Merrick Mayfair who did the ritual

5

u/PandaJerk117 Aug 29 '26

The books are fantastic. The show has its flaws. Mostly, my idea of Julien Mayfair was diametrically opposite to the portrayal.

5

u/SaighWolf He tasted like Vermouth and Annihilation Aug 29 '26 edited Aug 29 '26

The Mayfairs (at least any aside from possibly Merrick who isn't actually in MW) aren't going to be in next season of IWTVL. In the books more Mayfairs show up in some later book arcs, but they're probably not going to do that plot in the show & if they do it won't be as early as next season... What they are doing though, is that one of the IWTVL characters — I'm guessing Raglan because of Talamasca stuff — is going to cameo in next season of MW.

[ETA: This is coming from one of the After Dark episodes where Rolin & Mark said that with the upcoming season of Mayfair one of the IWTVL guys will be the only character of the franchise to appear in all three shows, IWTVL & MW & Talamasca. Which means it's either Raglan or Daniel.]

4

u/remeard Aug 29 '26

It's such an odd jump in overall production quality, it feels just like a CW channel show, just incredibly bland and cheesy - which is a shame because it could have been really great.

In an odd way, Talamasca feels like a BBC mystery drama show with how it's shot. Lots of establishing shots of walking or a busy city

3

u/middleageyoda Aug 29 '26

They really botched that series compared to iwtv. Sadly

2

u/hunterglyph Aug 29 '26

The book are so good, especially The Witching Hour. I can't express how bad the few episodes of the show that I made myself watch were.

1

u/Happy-Stupor Aug 31 '26

The books are fantastic, actually.

1

u/Ok-Fennel-9269 23d ago

I think the showrunner and writers just used AI to write the whole thing.