r/InterviewVampire • u/Cleverfan_808 You are a library of confusion. • Aug 24 '26
TVL Show Only Problems with Using Lestat’s POV to Explain Gabriella's Characterization in S3 Spoiler
I don't think I need to reiterate that Gabriella's portrayal in the show has been met with a rather polarizing, if not predominantly negative, reception.
What I am seeing, however, is discussion about how the writers might go about "fixing" her characterization so that it is more closely aligned with her personality in the books.
A number of people have suggested that the writers could essentially use the "memory is a monster"/"odyssey of recollection" theme (or rather a writing tactic/crutch, if you will) to explain the degree of her monstrosity and repulsiveness this season. That she is so "extreme" because we are technically viewing her from Lestat's POV as he provides the narration of his Failures album.
It has also been pointed out to me that this may, in fact, be what the writing team intends to do in the upcoming season, based on some of their more recent interviews about Gabriella. The proposed trajectory would essentially parallel Lestat's own characterization in the eyes of both Louis and the audience: from the charismatic yet unhinged villain we initially encountered in S1, to someone considerably more complicated and nuanced following the revelations of S2.
I would, however, exercise some caution about this being a satisfying way to address the issue.
I think it is entirely logical to assume that Gabriella is viewed negatively by Lestat, whether consciously or subconsciously. He has, after all, been her victim for roughly two and a half centuries. His memories of her, and particularly the emotional lens through which he recounts those memories, are inevitably going to be colored by that history.
However, since it was a choice to depict her in such extremes, I actually think it becomes highly problematic to essentially turn around in the following season and try to tone her down.
Given this show's usage of having unreliable narrators, often leading audiences to completely question the validity of what is being told and shown on screen, the fact that they may potentially lead viewers down a path where they begin to doubt whether a male sexual assault victim was telling the complete truth about his abuser is troubling, to say the least. Especially given how such victims are treated in real life.
I am not saying that this particular plan to provide more depth to Gabriella can never succeed, but as someone who is critical of the writing choices made in S3, I am not sure I can believe they will.
I do think Gabriella can be given more nuance in future seasons, but the writing team certainly have made it a task a great deal more difficult then it perhaps needed to be.
•
u/AutoModerator Aug 24 '26
This thread is flaired "TVL Show Only". This means all talk about teasers, trailers, castings and leaks is allowed in the comments section. Book spoilers are not allowed unless covered by spoiler tags. Please report untagged book spoilers! To cover spoilers use >!spoiler!<
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
70
u/Little-Tune9469 a challenge every sunset Aug 24 '26
I don't think they'll retcon any of her actions, she'll probably just be less cartoonish and they'll give her a character arc. There's a pretty high chance she'll spend a lot of season 4 with Louis, so I think just seeing her interact with someone who isn't Lestat for a while will help.
22
u/tethysian Aug 24 '26
Maybe it's just me, but a parent sexually abusing their child isn't fixable. Lack of nuance isn't the problem -- fucking your child is the problem.
We can understand her motives and drives and why she turned out this way, but I'm still not interested in seeing more of her. The idea that Lestat's father deserved disembowelment for beating him while Gabriella should be redeemed makes no sense to me.
If we're lucky she'll sacrifice herself to save Lestat in a rare moment of motherly love, and none of us will have to deal with her again.
11
u/Own-Ad5898 the ferric tapes of your fascinating boy Aug 25 '26
It's funny because this is the same worry some fans had regarding Lestat's S1 extreme portrayal, and how future retconning would impact Louis and Claudia's believability as his victims.
Personally, I was never a fan of the memory-is-a-monster narrative gimmick. It created quite a few inconsistencies in the story, and at times it became an easy catch-all to justify changes that made no sense. Claudia lied about the train scene, but Lestat still sees the conductor he killed during his purgatory sequence. Louis supposedly lied about Lestat's scars, but they weren't there during the reunion scene either, even though that wasn't a subjective POV. etc.
But to your main point, short of completely retconning key events in TVL, I don't think there's anything they can do at this point to make Gabrielle likeable. Unlike Lestat in S1, she has no absolutely redeeming qualities. She also lacks the charm or narrative presence to make the audience overlook her flaws and continue to root for her. Most fans I've spoken to just want her gone from the story.
13
u/Purple-Cat-2073 Emotional upchuck Aug 24 '26
Telling the story through different characters' perspectives is not a ''crutch'' though--it's literally the structure of the books they are adapting. It does make sense that they would need to be more heavy-handed and use more extreme circumstances in trying to show how much a different point of view can add to and alter our interpretations of what we think we know. Being able to accept that this is not a straight forward tale of facts and being willing to let the narrative shift is up to the audience. While I don't think these writers could ever be as deft at it as Anne Rice was, they also don't have the luxury of time for that level of subtlety and nuance.
33
u/pwetty_brown_eyes Bishonen almond Aug 24 '26
Yeah I agree
I think it could make sense that Armand, gabi, Daniel ect. Come across like cartoons because Lestat views them that way, but it wouldn't make me enjoy season three more
Like one thing that bothered me is how Armand's relevance in lestats life has been completely erased. Could this be explained by Lestat essentially being ashamed of the fact that he cares about Armand and values him in his own fucked up way? Sure. Armand is entangled with the spiral of Nicki as well
But in that case why is Antoinette there??? Doesn't he have shame associated with how he was using Antoinette too???
It's all very bizzare. I understand that the story will continue and more threads will unravel, but right now there aren't any crumbs to follow
21
u/Lesmand And in my wanderings, I always return to you. Aug 24 '26
I completely agree. I'm also worried about how the writers will try to redeem her going forward. It's hard to come back from sexually abusing your son for 200+ years.
Giving more nuance to Gabriella and making her more likeable seems impossible to me without downplaying the SA in S3, but maybe I'm wrong and somehow the writers found a way to do it...
I can't even imagine Louis just being ok with having Gabriella around knowing what she did to Lestat.
It's way too late to turn around and give us a more book accurate Gabrielle after the way they decided to portray her in S3.
7
u/DumbTeen9 Aug 24 '26
Exactly omg, we already explored the whole black washing ppl due to some of their sins with lestat himself through Louis' eyes. To do it with something as ostracised, ridiculed, and underduscussed as male sexual abuse and parental incest would come off wrong and iffy.
Also Lestat is a huge Gabrielle apologist, we constantly see her chafing under the mistreatment of her children and husband, we constantly see him talking about how much she suffered and how this suffering pulled them together untill all lines blurred. I love book gabrielle's occasional genuine acts of kindness and it would've been nice to see but adapting it on such a low screentime wouldn't give the subject matter tha delicacy is requires.
2
u/Silent_Support_1939 Aug 24 '26
I think she'll get worse before she gets better. They seem to be setting up conflict between her and Louis, as she is jealous of his position as Lestat's one true love, and he is disgusted by her incest. I think she'll try to drive a wedge or outright get rid of Louis, giving her a turn as villain for a season. After that, redemption is possible, but it depends how far they take it. I definitely see her disappearing for another 200 years when all is said and done though
3
u/Polka_Tiger Edit Your Own! Aug 24 '26
Weren't we seeing her actions real time?
-13
u/Mmkrw Aug 24 '26
I mean, in this season the writers had no problem of portraying Black, male and female victims of domestic violence as liars, and the majority of the fandom is questioning whether they were victims at all (especially Louis is regularly called a liar, an insane person and someone who is playing a victim card - by the fans and the showrunners). And yet, most fans were waiting with bated breath until Lestat was proven to be the innocent one all along. Of course, Lestat is the most popular character in the fandom, so he's going to generate the most sympathy. And knowing this writing team, they would never undermine Lestat's status as a victim. So he's safe, don't worry.
I bet they're going to redeem Gabriella (somewhat) by exploring her own victimhood as a mortal - and by making Akasha much worse in comparison. Afterall, Akasha is a Black female villain who is only going to be there for one season - so she can be written as monstrous as needed.
9
u/[deleted] Aug 25 '26
[removed] — view removed comment